Upgrade to enjoy this feature!
Vital MX fantasy is free to play, but Premium users receive great benefits. Premium benefits include:
- View and download rider stats
- Pick trends
- Create a private league
- And more!
Only $10 for all 2026 SX, MX, and SMX series.
Allowing equal displacement doesn't affect any of the OEM's. They can still race the bikes they have now, it just allows smaller OEM's/teams a chance to compete. It's not like 1997/98, when every other OEM had to suddenly pay for research and development, tooling and manufacturing of a totally different engine just to remain competitive. The four-strokes are already competitive with equal displacement two-strokes, they can race whichever they want.
Who knows, if a few pros start doing well on two-strokes, maybe someone can sell a bike for a change.
I don't think anyone on this board is an actual 16 to 19-year-old prospect who would participate...
Devin Davis just took his shirt off.
The Shop
Free shipping: VITALMX
Luxon 4-Post Bar Mounts
$189.95 - $239.95
Are you saying that an OEM or PC can't put together a 250 4stroke that can hang with a privateer on a 250 2stroke in this day and age.
Look at the old Honda Road racers of the 60's. They had to mad things (6 cylinder 250's FFS) just to keep up with simple 2 strokes from Yamaha.
1. First, as far as any factory rider being put on a 250 2 stroke, it hasn’t happened anywhere there is cc vs cc rules. That is in countries even that have OEM’s like Suzuki’s and Kawasaki’s that still sell in those countries like Australia etc. There has been no factory riders put on KTM’s or Yamaha’s either. Even in the LL national, the riders who are sponsored by big teams rode 4 stroke 250s. So it shows that OEM’s will not do as you state.
2. Second, you have stated multiple times that a 250 2 stroke would run 2-3 second a faster lap times. If we take a look at lap times, between the 250 and 450 class, again, we see that they are very similar lap times. In many cases the 250F’s run faster lap times. If the 250 2 stroke was running 2-3 second a lap faster, than they would still be winning races against 450’s.
3. Third, 450F’s have never really been part of the argument on the 2 stroke side. We have always talked about the 250F’s being the problem. The 450F’s are most likely not going anywhere. Their motors are used in 4 wheelers and other things that make it a crossover motor. And we do know they are pretty reliable. But the 4 stroke guys aways use the 450F reliability when comparing. I have yet to see an argument that the 250F is more reliable than the 250 2 stroke. So what really would be wrong with letting the 250F fall away, for a cheaper, cheaper to maintain, and pretty equal bike? It would help our sport.
4. Finally, if we did have 125, 250 and open classes again, what really would be in danger as far as 4 strokes? If anything the 250F, but as we’ve seen the factory and factory backed teams will run the 250F, so what’s left is the privateer. That rider isn’t going to win against a PC Kawasaki. The Open bikes, really, does anyone think a big 500AF is going to be able to run motos at 450F’s pace? Sure a lot of power, but just not going to happen due to the fact they just plain wear the rider out faster. So in closing, although on paper, it may seem like things like you say will happen. In reality, we know that it will not. There will be no factory riders put on 250 2 strokes. The 4 stroke will remain the dominate bike. But you will hear no more crap from the 2 stroke side, and life will go on with less stress."
I propose a compromise, lets make the manufacturers develop a 3-stroke so everyone is happy.
Imagine what a 2-stroke would be like today if the factory's continued with their development? I'm sure they could make them track better by altering power delivery or maybe chassis changes. They're already light, nimble, fast and affordable and I'm sure people would buy and race them. I certainly would but for now I'm buying 2005 and newer YZ125/250 Yamaha's since they haven't changed much.
I think someday we will see a mix of different engine technologies in racing and who knows, maybe there will be a hybrid electic vehicle? What class would you place a 10 Kilowatt electric bike? I guess that will be a post for a date far in the future.
Speaking of give and take...so far, it's been pretty lopsided in that the the pro rules have done nothing but take from the less costly 2 stroke and handed the unfair advantage over to the more costly 4 stroke.
The YZ80 may not have taken over., but wasn't it cheap racing those thing?
Pit Row
And, again, as far as the cost of racing, this is an issue for pro guys, which is a small population of riders.
As far as long term, what would be interesting is some real insight into the OEM management on their decision-making and what they are taking into consideration and what they have to do to compete for resources in their organizations. Folks might not agree with or like what they hear, but at least it would be transparent.
The OEMS would continue to race the 250F in the 250 class and it would not cost them anything.
If privateers wanted to run a 2 stroke they would then have the option to race a YZ or KTM and they'd then be on a more level playing field with the factory and PC 250f's. Why would that scenario be bad for the sport?
The question that I ran past you earlier in the thread that I didn't hear back on was...
"Are you saying that an OEM or PC can't put together a 250 4stroke that can hang with a privateer on a 250 2stroke in this day and age."
and then all us will be able to bitch about missing gas powered motorbikes.
The ongoing question is...WHY allow an old displacement rule to continue that was meant to put 4 strokes on the same footing as 2strokes when it's no longer healthy for the sport? In my opinion there have not been any good answers to why the rule can't be changed. It's all about somebody making a buck is what it all comes down to.
Edit: Ha! You changed your post while I was typing this. Hello Burn1986.
And I'll qualify that statement for everyone by saying I don't know wtf I'm talking about. But talking to guys at Honda etc that do is what my comment is based on.
Post a reply to: Jody, MXA, Two Strokes and Matthes