Student Loan Forgiveness

abomination
Posts
708
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
SLC, UT, USA
8/31/2022 12:55am
It's a rare occurrence of politicians giving their constituents something the party campaigned on, and the constituents largely want.

I can be empathetic to some complaints of it, but what a piss poor argument against it.
17
jchek779
Posts
533
Joined
3/19/2009
Location
Kannapolis, NC, USA
8/31/2022 9:30am
It's a rare occurrence of politicians giving their constituents something the party campaigned on, and the constituents largely want. I can be empathetic to some complaints...
It's a rare occurrence of politicians giving their constituents something the party campaigned on, and the constituents largely want.

I can be empathetic to some complaints of it, but what a piss poor argument against it.
Thats a slippery slope that ends with tyranny.

A democracy fails when the majority realize they can vote themselves largess of the Treasury.
4
1
abomination
Posts
708
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
SLC, UT, USA
8/31/2022 10:59am
Don't hurt your arm stretching that far.
11
jchek779
Posts
533
Joined
3/19/2009
Location
Kannapolis, NC, USA
8/31/2022 11:34am
Don't hurt your arm stretching that far.
We'd be a much stronger nation if women stopped fucking guys that think like you.





14
4

The Shop

JM485
Posts
5817
Joined
10/1/2013
Location
Davis, CA, USA
8/31/2022 12:36pm
It's a rare occurrence of politicians giving their constituents something the party campaigned on, and the constituents largely want. I can be empathetic to some complaints...
It's a rare occurrence of politicians giving their constituents something the party campaigned on, and the constituents largely want.

I can be empathetic to some complaints of it, but what a piss poor argument against it.
And what is the argument for it? Maybe I'm missing that part. . .
abomination
Posts
708
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
SLC, UT, USA
8/31/2022 2:23pm
That it’s what Biden said he would do, and that people that voted for him wanted him to do.

I know politicians doing what their constituents want is weird, but that is absolutely a positive thing and as a representative government is supposed to do.
1
15
JM485
Posts
5817
Joined
10/1/2013
Location
Davis, CA, USA
8/31/2022 6:37pm
That it’s what Biden said he would do, and that people that voted for him wanted him to do. I know politicians doing what their constituents...
That it’s what Biden said he would do, and that people that voted for him wanted him to do.

I know politicians doing what their constituents want is weird, but that is absolutely a positive thing and as a representative government is supposed to do.
That’s your argument? Seriously, that’s the best you can come up with to spin this colossally asinine plea for votes into something positive? So as long as you say you’re going to do something completely unfair and damaging, it’s always a good thing to follow through with it because you kept your word instead of digging up at least a shred of logic and determine your original idea was terrible and indefensible? That’s got to be one of, if not the worst, spin on this to date.

Representative government is supposed to be just that, the people represented by a governing body. This asshole went around all of that, including the check and balances within them, to go out on his own and write a blank check regardless of what the representatives we elected had to say about it. We don’t elect a monarch, so trying to paint this notion of following through on a promise is flawed at the very core.
18
1
Searights
Posts
328
Joined
8/26/2022
Location
Temecula, CA, USA
8/31/2022 6:56pm
jchek779 wrote:
We'd be a much stronger nation if women stopped fucking guys that think like you.





😂😂😂👍👍👍
7
3
abomination
Posts
708
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
SLC, UT, USA
8/31/2022 9:03pm
JM485 wrote:
That’s your argument? Seriously, that’s the best you can come up with to spin this colossally asinine plea for votes into something positive? So as long...
That’s your argument? Seriously, that’s the best you can come up with to spin this colossally asinine plea for votes into something positive? So as long as you say you’re going to do something completely unfair and damaging, it’s always a good thing to follow through with it because you kept your word instead of digging up at least a shred of logic and determine your original idea was terrible and indefensible? That’s got to be one of, if not the worst, spin on this to date.

Representative government is supposed to be just that, the people represented by a governing body. This asshole went around all of that, including the check and balances within them, to go out on his own and write a blank check regardless of what the representatives we elected had to say about it. We don’t elect a monarch, so trying to paint this notion of following through on a promise is flawed at the very core.
No.
7
abomination
Posts
708
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
SLC, UT, USA
8/31/2022 9:04pm
jchek779 wrote:
We'd be a much stronger nation if women stopped fucking guys that think like you.





You'll have to take that up with your mom.
1
10
dmm698
Posts
955
Joined
6/24/2015
Location
USA
9/1/2022 6:06am
jchek779 wrote:
We'd be a much stronger nation if women stopped fucking guys that think like you.





You'll have to take that up with your mom.
Can you outline, from your prospective, how this helps to fix the problem? We're in a similar geographic location here, so i'm seriously interested in your response.

-How does this fix college education costs? Or do you just forsee the government paying for university for everybody moving forward?
IE- Government announces tax rebate on EV's. Ford in turn raises MSRP to be inline with the new tax rebate.

-Do you feel forgiving (transferring debt to others who didnt attend university , or were responsible and put themselves/sacrificed in order to pay them off) teaches any self responsibility / accountability?

-What message is this delivering to people who have some fiscal intelligence, and refinanced their high interest fed loans into private for a lower rate, and thus now dont qualify for any forgiveness? Seems like you're penalizing the intelligent and providing for the unintelligent, no?

-Do you think many people who complain about how "predatory" compounding interest is, have been making payments the past two years, while it would of been straight principal, no interest, helping them get ahead? Most folks I know in this situation, have not made any payments through the pause/freeze.

-How does this fix people taking out loans, with zero idea of what their median starting salary would be?

-How would you feel about the following proposal
-Current loans continue to be interest free for the next 2 years. After that, they go to 1/2 the prime rate.
-Starting in grade 9, instead of some mandatory fluff course in high school, there is a requirement for a financial course.
- Basic understanding of how to budget, how to understand / research starting median salaries, living expenses, ect. With the internet there is zero excuse for being surprised that a degree is going to put you into a position that starts at 40k, and at that point with a basic understanding of finance/budget, you can make an educated decision on weather accruing 100k in debt is something you think is wise or not.
-Allow student loans to be removed when declaring bankruptcy, however, your degree is revoked along with it, just as your car/home would be if you defaulted.

-Why is it the tax payers responsibility, to help fund somebody to attend a 4 year university for a degree that society values at XYZ Pay, that doesnt allow the person to pay back the borrowed money?

-Do you find it comical, that whenever the government gets involved things dont make sense? Their arbitrary income cut off for this "program", is over 1.5x (last I checked) the income limit for deducting student loan interest. Not to mention the deduction is capped well below the 10k. These may of changed recently, its been a few years since i've had to deal with student loans.





10
1
SCR
Posts
1107
Joined
12/10/2009
Location
USA
9/1/2022 8:17am
That it’s what Biden said he would do, and that people that voted for him wanted him to do. I know politicians doing what their constituents...
That it’s what Biden said he would do, and that people that voted for him wanted him to do.

I know politicians doing what their constituents want is weird, but that is absolutely a positive thing and as a representative government is supposed to do.
JM485 wrote:
That’s your argument? Seriously, that’s the best you can come up with to spin this colossally asinine plea for votes into something positive? So as long...
That’s your argument? Seriously, that’s the best you can come up with to spin this colossally asinine plea for votes into something positive? So as long as you say you’re going to do something completely unfair and damaging, it’s always a good thing to follow through with it because you kept your word instead of digging up at least a shred of logic and determine your original idea was terrible and indefensible? That’s got to be one of, if not the worst, spin on this to date.

Representative government is supposed to be just that, the people represented by a governing body. This asshole went around all of that, including the check and balances within them, to go out on his own and write a blank check regardless of what the representatives we elected had to say about it. We don’t elect a monarch, so trying to paint this notion of following through on a promise is flawed at the very core.
Sometimes there just aren't enough thumbs up.
Once in a while there is a gem of a post like this that hopefully makes people stop and consider the recklessness of what's going on.
Thank you.
7
1
abomination
Posts
708
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
SLC, UT, USA
9/1/2022 9:25am
dmm698 wrote:
Can you outline, from your prospective, how this helps to fix the problem? We're in a similar geographic location here, so i'm seriously interested in your...
Can you outline, from your prospective, how this helps to fix the problem? We're in a similar geographic location here, so i'm seriously interested in your response.

-How does this fix college education costs? Or do you just forsee the government paying for university for everybody moving forward?
IE- Government announces tax rebate on EV's. Ford in turn raises MSRP to be inline with the new tax rebate.

-Do you feel forgiving (transferring debt to others who didnt attend university , or were responsible and put themselves/sacrificed in order to pay them off) teaches any self responsibility / accountability?

-What message is this delivering to people who have some fiscal intelligence, and refinanced their high interest fed loans into private for a lower rate, and thus now dont qualify for any forgiveness? Seems like you're penalizing the intelligent and providing for the unintelligent, no?

-Do you think many people who complain about how "predatory" compounding interest is, have been making payments the past two years, while it would of been straight principal, no interest, helping them get ahead? Most folks I know in this situation, have not made any payments through the pause/freeze.

-How does this fix people taking out loans, with zero idea of what their median starting salary would be?

-How would you feel about the following proposal
-Current loans continue to be interest free for the next 2 years. After that, they go to 1/2 the prime rate.
-Starting in grade 9, instead of some mandatory fluff course in high school, there is a requirement for a financial course.
- Basic understanding of how to budget, how to understand / research starting median salaries, living expenses, ect. With the internet there is zero excuse for being surprised that a degree is going to put you into a position that starts at 40k, and at that point with a basic understanding of finance/budget, you can make an educated decision on weather accruing 100k in debt is something you think is wise or not.
-Allow student loans to be removed when declaring bankruptcy, however, your degree is revoked along with it, just as your car/home would be if you defaulted.

-Why is it the tax payers responsibility, to help fund somebody to attend a 4 year university for a degree that society values at XYZ Pay, that doesnt allow the person to pay back the borrowed money?

-Do you find it comical, that whenever the government gets involved things dont make sense? Their arbitrary income cut off for this "program", is over 1.5x (last I checked) the income limit for deducting student loan interest. Not to mention the deduction is capped well below the 10k. These may of changed recently, its been a few years since i've had to deal with student loans.





> how this helps to fix the problem?

I think we'd have to agree first on what 'the problem' is. There's a lot of them. But I think reducing the number of people under somewhat predatory loans, while trying to better themselves and their outcome, is likely a net good.

I think you bring up some fine, decently thought out, non-purely-reactionary points. I like your proposal—anything to try to help people is a great place to start in my opinion. I don't have the answers, I trust economists and people a lot smarter than I to at least have thought them all through. I'm about as leftist as it gets, and this wasn't anywhere near the top of my personal political priorities, which makes sense—I'm a leftist, they're centrist. And this doesn't better my personal situation in anyway, but that's not my goal with policy.

But I'll reiterate again why I think overall this is a good idea—they campaigned on it, constituents want it, and it's happening. That's the process actually working. And it's not to take away personal rights, or to benefit the wealthy. That's progress.
1
8
Zycki11
Posts
7856
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edwardsville, IL, USA
9/1/2022 9:51am
dmm698 wrote:
Can you outline, from your prospective, how this helps to fix the problem? We're in a similar geographic location here, so i'm seriously interested in your...
Can you outline, from your prospective, how this helps to fix the problem? We're in a similar geographic location here, so i'm seriously interested in your response.

-How does this fix college education costs? Or do you just forsee the government paying for university for everybody moving forward?
IE- Government announces tax rebate on EV's. Ford in turn raises MSRP to be inline with the new tax rebate.

-Do you feel forgiving (transferring debt to others who didnt attend university , or were responsible and put themselves/sacrificed in order to pay them off) teaches any self responsibility / accountability?

-What message is this delivering to people who have some fiscal intelligence, and refinanced their high interest fed loans into private for a lower rate, and thus now dont qualify for any forgiveness? Seems like you're penalizing the intelligent and providing for the unintelligent, no?

-Do you think many people who complain about how "predatory" compounding interest is, have been making payments the past two years, while it would of been straight principal, no interest, helping them get ahead? Most folks I know in this situation, have not made any payments through the pause/freeze.

-How does this fix people taking out loans, with zero idea of what their median starting salary would be?

-How would you feel about the following proposal
-Current loans continue to be interest free for the next 2 years. After that, they go to 1/2 the prime rate.
-Starting in grade 9, instead of some mandatory fluff course in high school, there is a requirement for a financial course.
- Basic understanding of how to budget, how to understand / research starting median salaries, living expenses, ect. With the internet there is zero excuse for being surprised that a degree is going to put you into a position that starts at 40k, and at that point with a basic understanding of finance/budget, you can make an educated decision on weather accruing 100k in debt is something you think is wise or not.
-Allow student loans to be removed when declaring bankruptcy, however, your degree is revoked along with it, just as your car/home would be if you defaulted.

-Why is it the tax payers responsibility, to help fund somebody to attend a 4 year university for a degree that society values at XYZ Pay, that doesnt allow the person to pay back the borrowed money?

-Do you find it comical, that whenever the government gets involved things dont make sense? Their arbitrary income cut off for this "program", is over 1.5x (last I checked) the income limit for deducting student loan interest. Not to mention the deduction is capped well below the 10k. These may of changed recently, its been a few years since i've had to deal with student loans.





> how this helps to fix the problem? I think we'd have to agree first on what 'the problem' is. There's a lot of them. But...
> how this helps to fix the problem?

I think we'd have to agree first on what 'the problem' is. There's a lot of them. But I think reducing the number of people under somewhat predatory loans, while trying to better themselves and their outcome, is likely a net good.

I think you bring up some fine, decently thought out, non-purely-reactionary points. I like your proposal—anything to try to help people is a great place to start in my opinion. I don't have the answers, I trust economists and people a lot smarter than I to at least have thought them all through. I'm about as leftist as it gets, and this wasn't anywhere near the top of my personal political priorities, which makes sense—I'm a leftist, they're centrist. And this doesn't better my personal situation in anyway, but that's not my goal with policy.

But I'll reiterate again why I think overall this is a good idea—they campaigned on it, constituents want it, and it's happening. That's the process actually working. And it's not to take away personal rights, or to benefit the wealthy. That's progress.
That is not progress.... You are alienating so many people by doing this. Why should others pay for someone who not only chose to go to school but signed an agreement to pay back the loans? They went into the situation with intentions to go to school, get a job, and payback the loans. This is not progress, this is strong arming the american people into paying for something they shouldn't be paying for and collecting votes simultaneously. The money "saved" by those going to college will not be a benefit for the economy
7
1
abomination
Posts
708
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
SLC, UT, USA
9/1/2022 10:40am
I don't have kids so am I 'alienated' by tax cuts for those with kids? No. Having kids is also a choice.
3
Searights
Posts
328
Joined
8/26/2022
Location
Temecula, CA, USA
9/1/2022 10:46am
Thank you for saying you don’t have kids.😉
4
abomination
Posts
708
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
SLC, UT, USA
9/1/2022 10:50am
All good, I can understand why your mom didn't want to have another you. 😉
6
Searights
Posts
328
Joined
8/26/2022
Location
Temecula, CA, USA
9/1/2022 11:09am
Lmao touché
Zycki11
Posts
7856
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Edwardsville, IL, USA
9/1/2022 11:56am Edited Date/Time 9/1/2022 11:57am
I don't have kids so am I 'alienated' by tax cuts for those with kids? No. Having kids is also a choice.
How is that the same concept?.
9/1/2022 7:30pm
Zycki11 wrote:
You are completely missing the point. When you inject money it doesn’t just affect the economy, it hurts it. You are devaluing your own dollar which...
You are completely missing the point. When you inject money it doesn’t just affect the economy, it hurts it. You are devaluing your own dollar which at the moment is the most stable globally.

By injecting the money into the market they essentially told the banks to give out loan after loan and “hopped” that would stimulate the economy. Why on earth would the fed want to stimulate the economy? I thought the labor market was strong?

The thing I can’t wrap my head around is that individuals blindly continue forward without doing research and understanding exactly what is happening. The US is in a world of pain right now and these idiots in office just keep spending money like it is nothing. Ask yourself the question why this is happening and get back with me
What question you said a bunch of nothing
3
9/1/2022 7:51pm
There's no benefit to the injection of the stock market. That money evaporated. Lifting crushing debt off of millions of everyday Americans has real benefit.
Zycki11 wrote:
You are completely missing the point. When you inject money it doesn’t just affect the economy, it hurts it. You are devaluing your own dollar which...
You are completely missing the point. When you inject money it doesn’t just affect the economy, it hurts it. You are devaluing your own dollar which at the moment is the most stable globally.

By injecting the money into the market they essentially told the banks to give out loan after loan and “hopped” that would stimulate the economy. Why on earth would the fed want to stimulate the economy? I thought the labor market was strong?

The thing I can’t wrap my head around is that individuals blindly continue forward without doing research and understanding exactly what is happening. The US is in a world of pain right now and these idiots in office just keep spending money like it is nothing. Ask yourself the question why this is happening and get back with me
Yeti831 wrote:
[img]https://p.vitalmx.com/photos/forums/2022/08/29/566118/s1200_67E617C1_70FA_482C_B872_FC8FC599B8B5.jpg[/img]

That's a false comparison. People are forced to go through the education system if they want to get ahead in life. They're forced to bet their future on thousands in debt right out of the gate. We could just fund public education like we do with K-12, it's not even expensive. People wonder why young people can't buy homes, they have a mortgage the second they graduate from college. This article says it's only 58 billion. Sell some extra F-18's to the Saudi's to make up for the loss, it's not like the US wasn't going to anyway.

https://educationdata.org/how-much-would-free-college-cost
7
Titan1
Posts
9443
Joined
2/3/2010
Location
Lehi, UT, USA
9/1/2022 8:47pm
Zycki11 wrote:
You are completely missing the point. When you inject money it doesn’t just affect the economy, it hurts it. You are devaluing your own dollar which...
You are completely missing the point. When you inject money it doesn’t just affect the economy, it hurts it. You are devaluing your own dollar which at the moment is the most stable globally.

By injecting the money into the market they essentially told the banks to give out loan after loan and “hopped” that would stimulate the economy. Why on earth would the fed want to stimulate the economy? I thought the labor market was strong?

The thing I can’t wrap my head around is that individuals blindly continue forward without doing research and understanding exactly what is happening. The US is in a world of pain right now and these idiots in office just keep spending money like it is nothing. Ask yourself the question why this is happening and get back with me
Yeti831 wrote:
[img]https://p.vitalmx.com/photos/forums/2022/08/29/566118/s1200_67E617C1_70FA_482C_B872_FC8FC599B8B5.jpg[/img]

That's a false comparison. People are forced to go through the education system if they want to get ahead in life. They're forced to bet their...
That's a false comparison. People are forced to go through the education system if they want to get ahead in life. They're forced to bet their future on thousands in debt right out of the gate. We could just fund public education like we do with K-12, it's not even expensive. People wonder why young people can't buy homes, they have a mortgage the second they graduate from college. This article says it's only 58 billion. Sell some extra F-18's to the Saudi's to make up for the loss, it's not like the US wasn't going to anyway.

https://educationdata.org/how-much-would-free-college-cost
You don’t HAVE to go to college to get ahead in life…that is part of the lie that is driving up college tuition rates.

I know plenty of people who never went to college who make more money than college graduates (my family are all coal miners…they make $60k-$70k per year…more than the medium income of someone with a bachelors degree in your major). One of the wealthiest people I know dropped out of high school…and he’s been working for himself since he was 17…built and sold multiple tech companies…No college…

Plus I know MANY people who do go to college and graduate with no debt…but they don’t get then”college experience” (since they work full time while in school-ME!) so many debt riddled college grads want, and is the real motivation for so many for going to college.

You don’t HAVE to go to college to get ahead in life…and if you do go to college you don’t HAVE to take on a ton of debt to graduate.
11
rc51
Posts
59
Joined
4/29/2021
Location
Somewhere, MN, USA
Fantasy
9/1/2022 9:14pm
Zycki11 wrote:
You are completely missing the point. When you inject money it doesn’t just affect the economy, it hurts it. You are devaluing your own dollar which...
You are completely missing the point. When you inject money it doesn’t just affect the economy, it hurts it. You are devaluing your own dollar which at the moment is the most stable globally.

By injecting the money into the market they essentially told the banks to give out loan after loan and “hopped” that would stimulate the economy. Why on earth would the fed want to stimulate the economy? I thought the labor market was strong?

The thing I can’t wrap my head around is that individuals blindly continue forward without doing research and understanding exactly what is happening. The US is in a world of pain right now and these idiots in office just keep spending money like it is nothing. Ask yourself the question why this is happening and get back with me
Yeti831 wrote:
[img]https://p.vitalmx.com/photos/forums/2022/08/29/566118/s1200_67E617C1_70FA_482C_B872_FC8FC599B8B5.jpg[/img]

That's a false comparison. People are forced to go through the education system if they want to get ahead in life. They're forced to bet their...
That's a false comparison. People are forced to go through the education system if they want to get ahead in life. They're forced to bet their future on thousands in debt right out of the gate. We could just fund public education like we do with K-12, it's not even expensive. People wonder why young people can't buy homes, they have a mortgage the second they graduate from college. This article says it's only 58 billion. Sell some extra F-18's to the Saudi's to make up for the loss, it's not like the US wasn't going to anyway.

https://educationdata.org/how-much-would-free-college-cost
"Sell some extra F-18's to the Saudi's to make up for the loss, it's not like the US wasn't going to anyway."

I do not understand when people say comments like this. There is no making up for the loss.... tax payers already bought and paid for those F-18s or anything else the government or military has including their salaries. So whatever the government or military builds, buys, sells or gives away it is at the direct expense of the tax payers period. New bridge gets built we as tax payers pay for it... Stimulus money gets tossed around we as tax payers pay for it. There is no money in the government or military, the only money they have is directly generated from us as tax payers.


5
TeamGreen
Posts
37312
Joined
11/25/2008
Location
Thru-out, CA, USA
9/1/2022 9:22pm
Zycki11 wrote:
You are completely missing the point. When you inject money it doesn’t just affect the economy, it hurts it. You are devaluing your own dollar which...
You are completely missing the point. When you inject money it doesn’t just affect the economy, it hurts it. You are devaluing your own dollar which at the moment is the most stable globally.

By injecting the money into the market they essentially told the banks to give out loan after loan and “hopped” that would stimulate the economy. Why on earth would the fed want to stimulate the economy? I thought the labor market was strong?

The thing I can’t wrap my head around is that individuals blindly continue forward without doing research and understanding exactly what is happening. The US is in a world of pain right now and these idiots in office just keep spending money like it is nothing. Ask yourself the question why this is happening and get back with me
Yeti831 wrote:
[img]https://p.vitalmx.com/photos/forums/2022/08/29/566118/s1200_67E617C1_70FA_482C_B872_FC8FC599B8B5.jpg[/img]

That's a false comparison. People are forced to go through the education system if they want to get ahead in life. They're forced to bet their...
That's a false comparison. People are forced to go through the education system if they want to get ahead in life. They're forced to bet their future on thousands in debt right out of the gate. We could just fund public education like we do with K-12, it's not even expensive. People wonder why young people can't buy homes, they have a mortgage the second they graduate from college. This article says it's only 58 billion. Sell some extra F-18's to the Saudi's to make up for the loss, it's not like the US wasn't going to anyway.

https://educationdata.org/how-much-would-free-college-cost
Bwahahahahahahaaa

And now we all see how logic doesn’t work for the ohhhhhh sooooo victimized left

“People are forced to go through the education system …”

And you posted that silliness in response to an ON POINT quote from Thomas Sowell. That’s an amazingly hi-level of “fail” on your part.
7
3
Searights
Posts
328
Joined
8/26/2022
Location
Temecula, CA, USA
9/1/2022 9:30pm

ns503
Posts
4606
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
NS Toolies, CA
9/2/2022 5:36am
Yeti831 wrote:
[img]https://p.vitalmx.com/photos/forums/2022/08/29/566118/s1200_67E617C1_70FA_482C_B872_FC8FC599B8B5.jpg[/img]

That's a false comparison. People are forced to go through the education system if they want to get ahead in life. They're forced to bet their...
That's a false comparison. People are forced to go through the education system if they want to get ahead in life. They're forced to bet their future on thousands in debt right out of the gate. We could just fund public education like we do with K-12, it's not even expensive. People wonder why young people can't buy homes, they have a mortgage the second they graduate from college. This article says it's only 58 billion. Sell some extra F-18's to the Saudi's to make up for the loss, it's not like the US wasn't going to anyway.

https://educationdata.org/how-much-would-free-college-cost
Titan1 wrote:
You don’t HAVE to go to college to get ahead in life…that is part of the lie that is driving up college tuition rates. I know...
You don’t HAVE to go to college to get ahead in life…that is part of the lie that is driving up college tuition rates.

I know plenty of people who never went to college who make more money than college graduates (my family are all coal miners…they make $60k-$70k per year…more than the medium income of someone with a bachelors degree in your major). One of the wealthiest people I know dropped out of high school…and he’s been working for himself since he was 17…built and sold multiple tech companies…No college…

Plus I know MANY people who do go to college and graduate with no debt…but they don’t get then”college experience” (since they work full time while in school-ME!) so many debt riddled college grads want, and is the real motivation for so many for going to college.

You don’t HAVE to go to college to get ahead in life…and if you do go to college you don’t HAVE to take on a ton of debt to graduate.
That's all 100% true.

But there are also those in society we need, who have to go to college, and have to take on a ton of debt to get there. (Unless they come from a boat load of money).

I have a semi-wonky heart valve, and when the time comes that it needs attention, I want the guy on the other end of the knife to be highly educated.

There are no doubt money issues with higher education. My 3 kids went that route. They are freshly into new occupations in health care nutrition, teaching, and business/accounting. All are paying off loans. The cost of all that is way more than it needs to be. Universities are big business and a big dollar thing.
1
3
LOOnatic
Posts
731
Joined
5/20/2019
Location
New Orleans, LA, USA
9/2/2022 6:14am
Student loan forgiveness is a boondoggle give away for votes well timed to help a floundering Sleepy Joe before the mid terms.
If it was actually Student loan reformation that addressed the outlandish cost of higher education I and many others would give him due credit.
But alas it does nothing of the sort.

Come to think of it I can't recall any area that the government has tried to make more affordable that actually became more affordable (long term versus short lived credits).

12
2
LoudLove
Posts
2938
Joined
7/16/2010
Location
USA
9/2/2022 7:19am Edited Date/Time 9/2/2022 7:24am
LOOnatic wrote:
Student loan forgiveness is a boondoggle give away for votes well timed to help a floundering Sleepy Joe before the mid terms. If it was actually...
Student loan forgiveness is a boondoggle give away for votes well timed to help a floundering Sleepy Joe before the mid terms.
If it was actually Student loan reformation that addressed the outlandish cost of higher education I and many others would give him due credit.
But alas it does nothing of the sort.

Come to think of it I can't recall any area that the government has tried to make more affordable that actually became more affordable (long term versus short lived credits).

BAM! The student loan crisis is the result of an unregulated industry able to set its own prices. The cost of a college education has significantly outpaced overall cost-of-living increases, resulting in higher debt loads. Sure, universities today offer a better overall experience, but I’m not sure that justifies an environment where even in-state costs can exceed $30K/yr (I’m talking to you, University of Texas!).

Edit: state-funded colleges and universities are “regulated” by respective legislatures, but the pushback is nominal. Not saying it’s a rubber-stamp approval, but not not saying it, either. Man, I need to drop a hook in the water and go into the zone…
2
2
ns503
Posts
4606
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
NS Toolies, CA
9/2/2022 8:02am
LOOnatic wrote:
Student loan forgiveness is a boondoggle give away for votes well timed to help a floundering Sleepy Joe before the mid terms. If it was actually...
Student loan forgiveness is a boondoggle give away for votes well timed to help a floundering Sleepy Joe before the mid terms.
If it was actually Student loan reformation that addressed the outlandish cost of higher education I and many others would give him due credit.
But alas it does nothing of the sort.

Come to think of it I can't recall any area that the government has tried to make more affordable that actually became more affordable (long term versus short lived credits).

Ya I don't know about that.

Seems this would have more people to vote against him, than for. There are lots out there who don't like it. Just read thru this thread. Not much if any in support.
1
Titan1
Posts
9443
Joined
2/3/2010
Location
Lehi, UT, USA
9/2/2022 8:02am
That's a false comparison. People are forced to go through the education system if they want to get ahead in life. They're forced to bet their...
That's a false comparison. People are forced to go through the education system if they want to get ahead in life. They're forced to bet their future on thousands in debt right out of the gate. We could just fund public education like we do with K-12, it's not even expensive. People wonder why young people can't buy homes, they have a mortgage the second they graduate from college. This article says it's only 58 billion. Sell some extra F-18's to the Saudi's to make up for the loss, it's not like the US wasn't going to anyway.

https://educationdata.org/how-much-would-free-college-cost
Titan1 wrote:
You don’t HAVE to go to college to get ahead in life…that is part of the lie that is driving up college tuition rates. I know...
You don’t HAVE to go to college to get ahead in life…that is part of the lie that is driving up college tuition rates.

I know plenty of people who never went to college who make more money than college graduates (my family are all coal miners…they make $60k-$70k per year…more than the medium income of someone with a bachelors degree in your major). One of the wealthiest people I know dropped out of high school…and he’s been working for himself since he was 17…built and sold multiple tech companies…No college…

Plus I know MANY people who do go to college and graduate with no debt…but they don’t get then”college experience” (since they work full time while in school-ME!) so many debt riddled college grads want, and is the real motivation for so many for going to college.

You don’t HAVE to go to college to get ahead in life…and if you do go to college you don’t HAVE to take on a ton of debt to graduate.
ns503 wrote:
That's all 100% true. But there are also those in society we need, who have to go to college, and have to take on a ton...
That's all 100% true.

But there are also those in society we need, who have to go to college, and have to take on a ton of debt to get there. (Unless they come from a boat load of money).

I have a semi-wonky heart valve, and when the time comes that it needs attention, I want the guy on the other end of the knife to be highly educated.

There are no doubt money issues with higher education. My 3 kids went that route. They are freshly into new occupations in health care nutrition, teaching, and business/accounting. All are paying off loans. The cost of all that is way more than it needs to be. Universities are big business and a big dollar thing.
I'm not saying that nobody should go to college...and certainly doctors, attorneys, scientists, STEM fields, business etc. etc. all require formal education. So certainly there is a need for college...

But think about this: nearly 50% of college grads-talking about bachelors degrees-don't even use their degree in their career (and nearly 15% of people who enroll in college never even graduate).

What would happen to college tuition rates with a 65% drop in enrollment (if their potential customers stopped using them)? They went right into the work force, went to a trade school, started their own business, etc. etc.

With a 65% drop in enrollment could colleges maintain their current tuition rates? How much less student loan debt would their be in America?

College is a "cultural requirement" not about "not an absolute requirement" for all people, nor is it required for "getting ahead" in life...kids go for the "college experience", not for the education...

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-04-18/is-college-worth-it-…

"Here’s a statistic that may give some pause: More than half of college graduates over the age of 25 don’t work in their field of study, according to a new survey from Intelligent.com."

"he survey also found that 25% of respondents earn less than $30,000 a year, while approximately one out of seven earned less than $15,000 per year. An individual annual income of $14,097 is considered below the federal poverty threshold."


2
1

Post a reply to: Student Loan Forgiveness

The Latest