A plea to the media asking riders questions

stremme12
Posts
1219
Joined
3/10/2015
Location
HA, HI US
3/8/2020 3:12pm
The post-race press conference isn't the place to be asking what some of you might call the "hard hitting" questions. No rider wants to be put...
The post-race press conference isn't the place to be asking what some of you might call the "hard hitting" questions. No rider wants to be put on the spot with those questions after a race. Save those questions for media day, or at a better time when the riders have time to give a fair response. Last week is a good example of why. Barcia and Tomac were both heated and running on emotion, but I'm sure as the week went on, those emotions cooled down a bit and it was back to business as usual. What they might have said post-race (and did to each other as we all saw) might be a lot different from what they would say now having stepped back a bit from the emotions.

I've always seen the post-race interviews to ask questions about how the race went, good or bad. What can be done, if anything to improve for the following week? What were thoughts about the track and track conditions? Etc. And while some of those questions are vanilla, it's not the right time to ask riders about internal team conflicts, "beefs" with other riders, etc.
I believe there's a bit of a lapse from when the race is over and when the press conference starts. It's not like they're coming right off the track.

Watch any other main stream sport and you'll see people being interviewed right after the heat of the moment. It's what builds stories and keeps fans interested. It makes things interesting and right now our sport could use as many interested fans as it can get.
Alex.434
Posts
451
Joined
12/12/2016
Location
Warner Springs, CA US
3/8/2020 3:24pm
I think the way they do the post race press conferences is whack. They need to bring the riders out one by one and let them...
I think the way they do the post race press conferences is whack. They need to bring the riders out one by one and let them talk about their race on their own and then field questions on their own like they do in the UFC or even the NFL.

Having them all sit at the table right next to each other and having some dude standing up there on a podium with them fielding generic questions to get generic responses just isn't worth watching.
Works in MotoGP just fine. The 3 podium finishers are all up there together and the press ask real questions. It makes for some funny/interesting moments.

Mainly US MX press is pretty softball. Most of the guys are barely making a living so if you get blacklisted, you're out.
1
brlatm
Posts
1775
Joined
2/14/2009
Location
Brock, TX US
3/8/2020 3:26pm
stremme12 wrote:
I believe there's a bit of a lapse from when the race is over and when the press conference starts. It's not like they're coming right...
I believe there's a bit of a lapse from when the race is over and when the press conference starts. It's not like they're coming right off the track.

Watch any other main stream sport and you'll see people being interviewed right after the heat of the moment. It's what builds stories and keeps fans interested. It makes things interesting and right now our sport could use as many interested fans as it can get.
Supercross could take a clue from F1, those guys say what is actually on their mind.

Cooksey is the only one not tossing softball questions up, you guys love you some Matthes, but he has alienated himself from a lot of the riders now with him trying to be the show, instead of the riders, who are the show.
3/8/2020 7:14pm Edited Date/Time 3/8/2020 7:20pm
scott_nz wrote:
both Eli and Barcia did interviews about the incident at Atlanta before the race, and then nothing happened during the race, why on earth would you...
both Eli and Barcia did interviews about the incident at Atlanta before the race, and then nothing happened during the race, why on earth would you expect anything to be asked about something that happened the week before,

although, the press conferences are pretty lame, its not really a good place to ask in depth questions,
Because it was the biggest topic of the week, and then bam at the start of the race Eli is sitting in behind Barcia.

If anyone says they were not watching to see how, when and where Tomac was going to pass Barcia and how it would play out, they are full of shit.

SurleyTomac would be thinking differently about passing Barcia compared to any other rider in front of him on Saturday night.

It was a situation that played out big time last week, a situation that has big championship involvement between two of the guys inside the top 3-4 in points.

In any other sport, it would have been one of the first questions asked, the athlete in any sport probably would not want to answer it, or not give a full answer, but it would be the first one asked.
2

The Shop

JeremyK
Posts
510
Joined
12/19/2019
Location
North Tonawanda, NY US
3/8/2020 7:21pm
aaryn #234 wrote:
Because it was the biggest topic of the week, and then bam at the start of the race Eli is sitting in behind Barcia. If anyone...
Because it was the biggest topic of the week, and then bam at the start of the race Eli is sitting in behind Barcia.

If anyone says they were not watching to see how, when and where Tomac was going to pass Barcia and how it would play out, they are full of shit.

SurleyTomac would be thinking differently about passing Barcia compared to any other rider in front of him on Saturday night.

It was a situation that played out big time last week, a situation that has big championship involvement between two of the guys inside the top 3-4 in points.

In any other sport, it would have been one of the first questions asked, the athlete in any sport probably would not want to answer it, or not give a full answer, but it would be the first one asked.
Believe it or not but not everybody cares about the drama that goes on .
2
1
burnside
Posts
4095
Joined
6/17/2009
Location
London US
3/8/2020 7:43pm
Ask compelling questions and watch the riders but their hands behind their backs as the sponsors reach from behind and cover their mouth. Can’t get cancelled...
Ask compelling questions and watch the riders but their hands behind their backs as the sponsors reach from behind and cover their mouth.

Can’t get cancelled if you say nothing. It sucks for the fans because personality is celebrated until it’s personality you don’t care for.

Me? I love Justin Barcia. I also love Eli Tomac. I am a huge Dungey fan too. My man Chad Reed? Super fan right here. Wanna know why? Cus they’re GDMF super heroes on a dirt bike. I already get it that they aren’t going to just open up a can of worms so I don’t complain about something that will never happen.

The presser is a formality for that big ass M logo to be displayed more often. Not for any other reason.
We don't have to set our expectations so low. We're trying to grow our sport and understand the narrative of the season better. This is a valid platform to do this.

Like, some iconic moments in F1 history came from the post race press conferences, just search 'Aarton Senna press conference' on YT... same with UFC and many other sports I assume.

I get this is a cottage industry but we can do better.

3/8/2020 7:59pm
scott_nz wrote:
both Eli and Barcia did interviews about the incident at Atlanta before the race, and then nothing happened during the race, why on earth would you...
both Eli and Barcia did interviews about the incident at Atlanta before the race, and then nothing happened during the race, why on earth would you expect anything to be asked about something that happened the week before,

although, the press conferences are pretty lame, its not really a good place to ask in depth questions,
TxGuy wrote:
not a good place? After winning a race in front of 50k fans, this is not a good place to ask questions? 1. talk about setup...
not a good place? After winning a race in front of 50k fans, this is not a good place to ask questions?

1. talk about setup specifically
2. specific sections of the track - what worked and what didn't?
3. Beef with riders, block passes, rough riding, etc
4. Team issues - how a teammate is doing, a manager is doing, a trainer is doing
5. The industry as a whole and issues related to pro motorcycling
6. goals, struggles, assistance
7. looking toward the next round, what's on the table, how they're approaching the next week


off the top of my head. YES, this would be a great time to ask REAL questions. And yes, I know this industry is very tight-lipped but the old saying "That's how it's always been done...." comes to mind.
No rider ever gonna discuss bike set up. No point in asking that question.

Press conferences for football suck too...nobody wants to give anyone info to lose that edge....
BS12
Posts
1060
Joined
1/13/2014
Location
AU
3/8/2020 11:53pm
Genuine question. Do any outside media attend the press conferences or just all the usuals?

If its essentially all of the usuals only, is there any point even holding press conferences when each media outlet corners them right afterward for their own exclusive content anyway? Assuming most outlets hold back asking the majority of their questions at the press conference itself, saving it for their own exclusive interviews.
1
1
3/9/2020 1:16am
aaryn #234 wrote:
Because it was the biggest topic of the week, and then bam at the start of the race Eli is sitting in behind Barcia. If anyone...
Because it was the biggest topic of the week, and then bam at the start of the race Eli is sitting in behind Barcia.

If anyone says they were not watching to see how, when and where Tomac was going to pass Barcia and how it would play out, they are full of shit.

SurleyTomac would be thinking differently about passing Barcia compared to any other rider in front of him on Saturday night.

It was a situation that played out big time last week, a situation that has big championship involvement between two of the guys inside the top 3-4 in points.

In any other sport, it would have been one of the first questions asked, the athlete in any sport probably would not want to answer it, or not give a full answer, but it would be the first one asked.
JeremyK wrote:
Believe it or not but not everybody cares about the drama that goes on .
Believe it or not some do Smile

Going by the number of posts, reposts, shares, likes and comments after last weekend, and the fact that every outlet posted the drama last week would suggest the majority enjoy the drama a championship battle between four riders can bring.

The racing this year is great, the off-track drama is helping build the hype, the personal battles are adding to the excitement.

Walk into a bike shop or when riding on the weekend, everyone wants to talk AMA Supercross, this year's series is being talked about and discussed more than any I can remember for a long time where I live. I would guess it would be the same in most places.

Over halfway through the series, two riders separated by just 3 points, two more guys with an outside chance ofa title run, both the 250 series have more than one title contender.

Its a good year, with some great drama adding to some awesome racing.
1
Dougy1
Posts
473
Joined
4/14/2017
Location
AU
3/9/2020 3:22am
"How good does it feel?", "How deep did you have to dig?", "How much does this mean to you?" are NOT compelling questions. Please stop doing...
"How good does it feel?", "How deep did you have to dig?", "How much does this mean to you?" are NOT compelling questions. Please stop doing this. I'm watching the press conference for Daytona right now and there have already been various iterations of these types of questions asked halfway through it.

For some reason I see Chris Cooksey getting a ton of hate on here, but at least the guy asks what we all want to hear and/or asks something that will get an interesting response! What is it with the softball questions from the media?
Haven't heard this brought up before, but 100% agree—feel like Blair is really guilty of this and given how much he pats himself on the back...
Haven't heard this brought up before, but 100% agree—feel like Blair is really guilty of this and given how much he pats himself on the back for his performance on his podcast, I don't see it changing.
I’d have to agree and he’s coming across as bit arrogant or maybe just a little too cocky on his podcast ..
1
reded
Posts
3682
Joined
3/26/2011
Location
KS US
3/9/2020 4:18am
aaryn #234 wrote:
Because it was the biggest topic of the week, and then bam at the start of the race Eli is sitting in behind Barcia. If anyone...
Because it was the biggest topic of the week, and then bam at the start of the race Eli is sitting in behind Barcia.

If anyone says they were not watching to see how, when and where Tomac was going to pass Barcia and how it would play out, they are full of shit.

SurleyTomac would be thinking differently about passing Barcia compared to any other rider in front of him on Saturday night.

It was a situation that played out big time last week, a situation that has big championship involvement between two of the guys inside the top 3-4 in points.

In any other sport, it would have been one of the first questions asked, the athlete in any sport probably would not want to answer it, or not give a full answer, but it would be the first one asked.
JeremyK wrote:
Believe it or not but not everybody cares about the drama that goes on .
Agreed. Why do you guys seriously give a fuck what any rider thinks of the other, the track or how deep they dug? From what I’ve seen, most of these home schooled speedsters are lucky to be able to spit out a canned answer, let alone a coherent answer to your “riveting” questions.
2
1
walleyeguy
Posts
463
Joined
5/9/2011
Location
Centerville, PA US
3/9/2020 5:04am
scott_nz wrote:
both Eli and Barcia did interviews about the incident at Atlanta before the race, and then nothing happened during the race, why on earth would you...
both Eli and Barcia did interviews about the incident at Atlanta before the race, and then nothing happened during the race, why on earth would you expect anything to be asked about something that happened the week before,

although, the press conferences are pretty lame, its not really a good place to ask in depth questions,
You don't believe that it was on Eli's mind as he was drawing up on Barcia? I good question would have been "Was making the pass on Barcia on your mind? Did it cause any hesitation as to where you would make your move? Was it hard to concentrate on hitting your lines thinking about how this pass was going to shake down?"
2
philG
Posts
10858
Joined
5/12/2012
Location
GB
3/9/2020 5:28am
I havent watched a press conference pre or post race for ages. Serves no purpose . Only thing i do every round is Pit Bits.
2
TxGuy
Posts
46
Joined
2/12/2020
Location
San Antonio, TX US
3/9/2020 12:32pm
philG wrote:
I havent watched a press conference pre or post race for ages. Serves no purpose . Only thing i do every round is Pit Bits.
agreed. But the reclusive nature of this sport is not helped by scripted stiff press events like this. Honestly, it comes off so cringey...if they won't change it....they should just dump it altogether.
245MX
Posts
93
Joined
4/3/2018
Location
GB
3/10/2020 7:08am
BS12 wrote:
Genuine question. Do any outside media attend the press conferences or just all the usuals? If its essentially all of the usuals only, is there any...
Genuine question. Do any outside media attend the press conferences or just all the usuals?

If its essentially all of the usuals only, is there any point even holding press conferences when each media outlet corners them right afterward for their own exclusive content anyway? Assuming most outlets hold back asking the majority of their questions at the press conference itself, saving it for their own exclusive interviews.
That's a really good question, I'd like to know the answer too.

I agree with most people here that the press conferences have just become the usual "white noise going through the motions" question & answer sessions.
TxGuy
Posts
46
Joined
2/12/2020
Location
San Antonio, TX US
3/10/2020 10:05am
BS12 wrote:
Genuine question. Do any outside media attend the press conferences or just all the usuals? If its essentially all of the usuals only, is there any...
Genuine question. Do any outside media attend the press conferences or just all the usuals?

If its essentially all of the usuals only, is there any point even holding press conferences when each media outlet corners them right afterward for their own exclusive content anyway? Assuming most outlets hold back asking the majority of their questions at the press conference itself, saving it for their own exclusive interviews.
245MX wrote:
That's a really good question, I'd like to know the answer too. I agree with most people here that the press conferences have just become the...
That's a really good question, I'd like to know the answer too.

I agree with most people here that the press conferences have just become the usual "white noise going through the motions" question & answer sessions.
x2
GuyB
Posts
35722
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA US
3/10/2020 10:32am
Still waiting on an answer for this, but I suspect I won't get one.
I think you guys are fairly confused about my relationship with the riders. Do I have a professional (but generally friendly) working relationship with most of them? Yes.

Do I consider them friends or buddies? Probably a whole lot less than you'd think. It's more like a co-worker relationship We don't hang out away from the races. We're not blowing each other up on the phone during the week...though I do check in with some of them when I have a particular question. Generally, they live in their world. I live in mine.

I do check in with lots of riders (from privateer to points leaders) nearly every week in pre-race and one-on-one post-race interviews. I generally have questions that I ask in a press conference setting, and others that I ask in a one-on-one setting.

This week's 450 press conference in Daytona started out with a reporter from a local newspaper in the Daytona area. Then it went to Weege, the weekly stats guy, and then me. A lot of the questions that I would have asked were already off the table by the time it got to me.

Sometimes questions are based on what I think I can get a productive answer out of. Sometimes they're designed to let them vent on a particular topic.

Asking Eli about Barcia would have probably elicited not much more than an eye-roll from Eli. It also proved to be a non-factor. I did ask Eli in our pre-race video if we'd hit the grumpy part of the season. He laughed.

During the season, I've also asked things like whether Plessinger is headed to off-road next year (he said no), and Cooper about his back injury (both before and after the race). I think he's tired of talking about it, and after two straight podiums, it's also a non-factor. I also asked them about the back-to-back dragonback to triple section in Arlington, and got a lot of good answers from the riders about track design, construction, and safety.

In closing, I can say that there was a recent post-press conference video that may have proven to be a one-hit wonder with fans, but it wasn't all that popular with the rider who was being quizzed. He felt a bit put on the spot, and told me last week that future interviews likely wouldn't be nearly as productive for the person who asked the questions.
2
GuyB
Posts
35722
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA US
3/10/2020 10:34am
BS12 wrote:
Genuine question. Do any outside media attend the press conferences or just all the usuals? If its essentially all of the usuals only, is there any...
Genuine question. Do any outside media attend the press conferences or just all the usuals?

If its essentially all of the usuals only, is there any point even holding press conferences when each media outlet corners them right afterward for their own exclusive content anyway? Assuming most outlets hold back asking the majority of their questions at the press conference itself, saving it for their own exclusive interviews.
It depends on the race. Sometimes they're in there, but just monitoring. I think a lot of them aren't familiar enough with the riders or sport that they're comfortable asking questions in a press conference setting.
1
3/10/2020 10:43am
walleyeguy wrote:
You don't believe that it was on Eli's mind as he was drawing up on Barcia? I good question would have been "Was making the pass...
You don't believe that it was on Eli's mind as he was drawing up on Barcia? I good question would have been "Was making the pass on Barcia on your mind? Did it cause any hesitation as to where you would make your move? Was it hard to concentrate on hitting your lines thinking about how this pass was going to shake down?"
do you think that Eli answers that question in any other way than an eye roll like Guy said above?
3/10/2020 11:20am
walleyeguy wrote:
You don't believe that it was on Eli's mind as he was drawing up on Barcia? I good question would have been "Was making the pass...
You don't believe that it was on Eli's mind as he was drawing up on Barcia? I good question would have been "Was making the pass on Barcia on your mind? Did it cause any hesitation as to where you would make your move? Was it hard to concentrate on hitting your lines thinking about how this pass was going to shake down?"
scott_nz wrote:
do you think that Eli answers that question in any other way than an eye roll like Guy said above?
IF a rider responded with an eye-roll (as if to say you're wasting my time) then he ought to be reminded that its the fans that pay his wages. He really should be giving the fans what they want, to stay interested. Even if its not true. Give the fans something to excite them.
3
snackfedbear
Posts
1060
Joined
10/18/2016
Location
Southern, CA US
3/10/2020 11:36am
I just think some more specific technical bike set up questions would be nice for the gear heads. We get they want to be secretive but if you ask a question that is generally specific in nature it would require to be answered in a way that they would at the least be generally specific.

The, “what kind of changes to your bike did you do this week” Wouldn’t get much of an answer as like a “you mentioned you went to work during the week at the test track and found some good changes, what were those changes to the bike and how did the feedback transfer to speed during the race” might get something a little more specific, even though you’re basically asking the same question. And when they try to round about the question, keep the mic to dig deeper.
1
GuyB
Posts
35722
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA US
3/10/2020 1:19pm
I just think some more specific technical bike set up questions would be nice for the gear heads. We get they want to be secretive but...
I just think some more specific technical bike set up questions would be nice for the gear heads. We get they want to be secretive but if you ask a question that is generally specific in nature it would require to be answered in a way that they would at the least be generally specific.

The, “what kind of changes to your bike did you do this week” Wouldn’t get much of an answer as like a “you mentioned you went to work during the week at the test track and found some good changes, what were those changes to the bike and how did the feedback transfer to speed during the race” might get something a little more specific, even though you’re basically asking the same question. And when they try to round about the question, keep the mic to dig deeper.
Speaking from experience, you generally do not get specific answers to those kinds of questions. I try occasionally, and find that once again, the juice is not worth the squeeze.
TDeath21
Posts
6515
Joined
2/22/2011
Location
Somewhere, MO US
3/10/2020 4:14pm
I honestly don’t even know why the 2nd and 3rd place guys are there when Eli wins. 95% of the questions are directed at him.
1
Helda3
Posts
85
Joined
2/20/2020
Location
AU
3/10/2020 5:40pm
I thought I'd get flamed if I made this topic, listening to this press conference made me want to pop my ear drums with a number 2 phillips.

They are flat out articulating the question.

Post a reply to: A plea to the media asking riders questions

The Latest