Ok so in Seattle they got their $15hr minimum wage but wait....

Jakes Dad
Posts
1865
Joined
6/22/2009
Location
Brooksville, FL US
Edited Date/Time 8/1/2015 5:57pm
Now they are asking to have their hours cut because they're making too much and might lose their welfare checks! Yep forgot the new American way.Huh
|
Tpog496
Posts
1282
Joined
9/16/2014
Location
MN US
7/23/2015 4:39pm
That's fucked.
Brad460
Posts
4388
Joined
5/15/2012
Location
Richfield, WI US
Fantasy
7/23/2015 6:46pm
My wife has a friend she grew up with who's husband intentionally cuts back on his hours the weeks leading up to the state checking his pay stubs...all so they can retain their state assistance.
newmann
Posts
24438
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
US
7/23/2015 7:09pm
So if waiters and waitresses are now getting a "living wage" tipping is no longer expected?
MR. X
Posts
6913
Joined
6/24/2010
Location
North Tonawanda, NY US
7/23/2015 7:15pm
They just passed 15 an hour in NY but its only for fast food workers , they should be the last people making 15 an hour.

The Shop

TailSoHard
Posts
1656
Joined
10/18/2014
Location
Beer City, MI US
7/24/2015 11:55am
MR. X wrote:
They just passed 15 an hour in NY but its only for fast food workers , they should be the last people making 15 an hour.
I agree, but if they must raise the min wage, then maybe now they'll get some people working there that don't screw up my order every goddamn time. Get some people that actually give a shit about doing well at their job and I have no problem paying them a fair wage...(even though $15/hr is pretty ridiculous IMO)
7/24/2015 12:53pm
newmann wrote:
So if waiters and waitresses are now getting a "living wage" tipping is no longer expected?
I doubt it applies to waiters and waitresses. When I waited tables in college in the 90s my wage was $2-some an hour.
mattmatt300
Posts
1457
Joined
3/30/2009
Location
Rockmart, GA US
7/24/2015 1:29pm
newmann wrote:
So if waiters and waitresses are now getting a "living wage" tipping is no longer expected?
No no no. The tip will be even more now because the cost of food will go up. Your $40 meal will now be $50 so that $8 tip is now $10. Gotta love it.
Sandberm
Posts
5845
Joined
3/27/2009
Location
Pasco, WA US
7/24/2015 3:17pm
Seattle is so liberal its rediculous. Those people wouldnt know a hard days work if it bit em in the ass. Pot smoking, tweeker, hippy hipster wannabes.

Socialism over there.Pinch
Uncle Tony
Posts
4149
Joined
6/30/2014
Location
New York, NY US
7/24/2015 3:22pm
MR. X wrote:
They just passed 15 an hour in NY but its only for fast food workers , they should be the last people making 15 an hour.
But I don't think that kicks in till 2017 our great governor said today, or was it yesterday?
71Fish
Posts
1794
Joined
11/29/2011
Location
Ogden, UT US
7/24/2015 4:55pm
The very people this is designed to help will end up hurting them. There are plenty of new college grads who can't get a decent job in their field of study, so they will gladly take a $15 per hour fast food job over not working. So, now who has the better chance of getting that burger flipper job, a college grad or a single working mom?

An like Green said above, what about the McD's manager now making $15 an hour? Or even if they make $18-20, how much will their raise need to be to make it worth it now?

Minimum wage isn't supposed to be a living wage. It's a wage where you start and work your way up as you develop skills and experience. Why stop at $15? Why not make MW $25 an hour?
7/25/2015 8:52am
I dont think these people realize they will quickly be replaced with the thousands of unemployed college graduates who cant find work in their field. Well then again, people who work at Micky Dees arent hired for being intelligent anyway
MR. X
Posts
6913
Joined
6/24/2010
Location
North Tonawanda, NY US
7/25/2015 9:03am
I dont think these people realize they will quickly be replaced with the thousands of unemployed college graduates who cant find work in their field. Well...
I dont think these people realize they will quickly be replaced with the thousands of unemployed college graduates who cant find work in their field. Well then again, people who work at Micky Dees arent hired for being intelligent anyway
No ,but if you are forced to pay them 15 an hour ,you might as well take the one with some kind of smarts.
7/25/2015 9:31am
I dont think these people realize they will quickly be replaced with the thousands of unemployed college graduates who cant find work in their field. Well...
I dont think these people realize they will quickly be replaced with the thousands of unemployed college graduates who cant find work in their field. Well then again, people who work at Micky Dees arent hired for being intelligent anyway
MR. X wrote:
No ,but if you are forced to pay them 15 an hour ,you might as well take the one with some kind of smarts.
This is a great point!^^^
starting at $15 bucks an hour MC Ds can hold out for "better" more mature employees knowing that there will likely be a better field of potential candidates to choose from.
People working in hot and dirty manufacturing type jobs will leave their $12-13 per hour job to work for more pay and better conditions.
Tiki
Posts
10575
Joined
8/1/2006
Location
Corona, CA US
Fantasy
7/25/2015 12:34pm
Brad460 wrote:
My wife has a friend she grew up with who's husband intentionally cuts back on his hours the weeks leading up to the state checking his...
My wife has a friend she grew up with who's husband intentionally cuts back on his hours the weeks leading up to the state checking his pay stubs...all so they can retain their state assistance.
I worked with this peach of a person. She dated this man for 10 years who was in a wheel chair since birth. I asked why don't you two get married? It's been 10 years? She said if I do that, we lose out on state funds that pays her to be a hospice worker. She was getting an hourly wage with OT after 8 hours each day. Plus she claimed him as a dependent and He was getting Social Security. They made their landlord install new wheel chair ramp into the house to be ADA.Then they called HUD on the landlord every time he said pay your rent. It was never enough for those two. Wheel chair boy got free education and went to work at CalTrans where the taxpayers had to pay to make everything in the office ADA.

A piano couldn't fall on these two soon enough.
7/25/2015 6:33pm Edited Date/Time 7/25/2015 6:34pm
MR. X wrote:
No ,but if you are forced to pay them 15 an hour ,you might as well take the one with some kind of smarts.
sooo.... Yes?

you basically just said what I said in a different way
APLMAN99
Posts
12190
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR US
Fantasy
7/25/2015 8:26pm
Currently Seattle's minimum wage is $11 per hour........
APLMAN99
Posts
12190
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR US
Fantasy
7/25/2015 8:28pm
Brad460 wrote:
My wife has a friend she grew up with who's husband intentionally cuts back on his hours the weeks leading up to the state checking his...
My wife has a friend she grew up with who's husband intentionally cuts back on his hours the weeks leading up to the state checking his pay stubs...all so they can retain their state assistance.
Tiki wrote:
I worked with this peach of a person. She dated this man for 10 years who was in a wheel chair since birth. I asked why...
I worked with this peach of a person. She dated this man for 10 years who was in a wheel chair since birth. I asked why don't you two get married? It's been 10 years? She said if I do that, we lose out on state funds that pays her to be a hospice worker. She was getting an hourly wage with OT after 8 hours each day. Plus she claimed him as a dependent and He was getting Social Security. They made their landlord install new wheel chair ramp into the house to be ADA.Then they called HUD on the landlord every time he said pay your rent. It was never enough for those two. Wheel chair boy got free education and went to work at CalTrans where the taxpayers had to pay to make everything in the office ADA.

A piano couldn't fall on these two soon enough.
10 years of hospice care might be some sort of record......
imoto34
Posts
3780
Joined
1/28/2010
Location
TN US
7/25/2015 11:47pm
newmann wrote:
So if waiters and waitresses are now getting a "living wage" tipping is no longer expected?
well that always depends on the ass and tits. also not having a empty glass helps
bronwynrayne
Posts
930
Joined
11/23/2014
Location
Harrisburg, OR US
7/26/2015 8:10pm
Jakes Dad wrote:
Here is some other related issues, they were told it would happen. $15hr to $0hr.
https://www.washingtonpolicy.org/blog/post/seattles-15-wage-law-factor-…
7/26/2015 10:52pm
One of the points of the original article was that the owners arent saying it was specifically the min wage hike, because that would put them on the city government official's bad side.

The merit of the claim? IDK, but it seems logical
bronwynrayne
Posts
930
Joined
11/23/2014
Location
Harrisburg, OR US
7/26/2015 11:35pm
One of the points of the original article was that the owners arent saying it was specifically the min wage hike, because that would put them...
One of the points of the original article was that the owners arent saying it was specifically the min wage hike, because that would put them on the city government official's bad side.

The merit of the claim? IDK, but it seems logical
Some people like cold hard cash (well I do too), but I also value cold hard facts. Regardless of whether a claim seems logical or not, it's actual legitimacy hangs in the proof.
APLMAN99
Posts
12190
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR US
Fantasy
7/27/2015 6:43am
One of the points of the original article was that the owners arent saying it was specifically the min wage hike, because that would put them...
One of the points of the original article was that the owners arent saying it was specifically the min wage hike, because that would put them on the city government official's bad side.

The merit of the claim? IDK, but it seems logical
It only seems logical because you want it to.

Restaurants and other businesses have been closing in Seattle forever, and new businesses have been opening in Seattle forever. To suddenly blame all of the closings on a minimum wage increase that likely didn't even affect every employee is completely illogical.

Since every nearby competitor is affected the same, the playing field between Seattle restaurants is still level. If I'm going out to dinner in Seattle, I'm not going to drive across Lake Washington just because Pesos raised their Carne Asada price by $1 (if they even had to do that).

This isn't a "story", it's merely a piece of propaganda that infers cause and effect despite a lack of any conclusive evidence.
borg
Posts
6656
Joined
12/7/2009
Location
Long Beach, CA US
7/27/2015 8:12am Edited Date/Time 7/27/2015 8:16am
It's too early to tell what the forced wage increase is doing. If I were really interested I would wait for data in about a year. Then I would want to see the subsector breakouts.

Local youth unemployment rates and month over month changes.
Employment in the leisure and hospitality subsector.
Local revenue reports from the subsector.

If there were going to be effects caused by the increase they would likely be reflected by a change in these subsectors.
What ideology driven people want to extract from the data will be anyone's guess.



borg
Posts
6656
Joined
12/7/2009
Location
Long Beach, CA US
7/27/2015 8:31am
Some of that information is HERE.
The rest would have to come from local information.
7/27/2015 8:53am
Jakes Dad wrote:
Now they are asking to have their hours cut because they're making too much and might lose their welfare checks! Yep forgot the new American way.Huh
A few points:

1) Who is they? I would imagine that these types of things are not representative of most hard working people who make minimum wage and is rather an exception to the rule. But it could really be such that hard working people and families will struggle if their benefits get cut.

2) This points to an unhealthy economic system in our country because $15.00 an hr is still not enough to live in Seattle. Minimum wages should be increased but the welfare system is also going to have to be overhauled to account for the oncoming increases in minimum wage (yes they are coming as more and more states and cities will follow) so that minimum wage workers can still receive benefits if needed.

3) To comments that think that flipping burgers is not worth $15.00 an hr; it's not up to you to decide what a job is worth. Our local animal control officer makes nearly $80,000.00 a year and I don't think his job is worth that much, but that is just my opinion. What a entry level job is worth is highly dependent, not on specific skill sets, but on the demands of the economy.
7/27/2015 8:55am
No no no. The tip will be even more now because the cost of food will go up. Your $40 meal will now be $50 so...
No no no. The tip will be even more now because the cost of food will go up. Your $40 meal will now be $50 so that $8 tip is now $10. Gotta love it.
This has already been proved to be incorrect, there will not be increases that large.
Titan1
Posts
9406
Joined
2/3/2010
Location
Lehi, UT US
7/27/2015 2:56pm
Jakes Dad wrote:
Now they are asking to have their hours cut because they're making too much and might lose their welfare checks! Yep forgot the new American way.Huh
A few points: 1) Who is they? I would imagine that these types of things are not representative of most hard working people who make minimum...
A few points:

1) Who is they? I would imagine that these types of things are not representative of most hard working people who make minimum wage and is rather an exception to the rule. But it could really be such that hard working people and families will struggle if their benefits get cut.

2) This points to an unhealthy economic system in our country because $15.00 an hr is still not enough to live in Seattle. Minimum wages should be increased but the welfare system is also going to have to be overhauled to account for the oncoming increases in minimum wage (yes they are coming as more and more states and cities will follow) so that minimum wage workers can still receive benefits if needed.

3) To comments that think that flipping burgers is not worth $15.00 an hr; it's not up to you to decide what a job is worth. Our local animal control officer makes nearly $80,000.00 a year and I don't think his job is worth that much, but that is just my opinion. What a entry level job is worth is highly dependent, not on specific skill sets, but on the demands of the economy.
I thought one of the arguments FOR increasing the minimum wage was that the tax payers are subsidizing these companies low salaries (because all their minimum wage employees are still collecting welfare)...so you're saying that the welfare system needs to be overhauled so that all the minimum wage workers will still qualify for welfare? That defeats one of the main points of increasing the minimum wage.

Good grief...

Minimum wage jobs aren't meant to be living wage jobs...never have been, never will be. They are jobs to get ones foot in the door, to start getting experience, to build a resume, to support while working on education etc. The minimum wage isn't set to be the minimum amount that one can live. Its there as a minimum amount one might earn, until they can improve themselves to justify a larger wage.

In fact, you talk about how subjective what a job is worth is...well, living wage is also very subjective. One persons living wage, is another persons poverty. Really. And if the government is going to start pushing a "living wage" rather than a "minimum wage"...then the government is going to have to define exactly what a "living wage" actually is. And the problem is, is that its not the governments job to tell employers what their jobs are worth. That is up to what the local economy will justify. When jobs are scarce, its a higher wage...when jobs are plentiful its a lower wage. If an employer gets sick of crappy workers, then he'll pay more to get better qualified employees. The government doesn't need to be involved in this beyond making sure that companies aren't exploiting their workers (and working for even the current minimum wage isn't exploitation).

T
borg
Posts
6656
Joined
12/7/2009
Location
Long Beach, CA US
7/27/2015 3:47pm
Jakes Dad wrote:
Now they are asking to have their hours cut because they're making too much and might lose their welfare checks! Yep forgot the new American way.Huh
A few points: 1) Who is they? I would imagine that these types of things are not representative of most hard working people who make minimum...
A few points:

1) Who is they? I would imagine that these types of things are not representative of most hard working people who make minimum wage and is rather an exception to the rule. But it could really be such that hard working people and families will struggle if their benefits get cut.

2) This points to an unhealthy economic system in our country because $15.00 an hr is still not enough to live in Seattle. Minimum wages should be increased but the welfare system is also going to have to be overhauled to account for the oncoming increases in minimum wage (yes they are coming as more and more states and cities will follow) so that minimum wage workers can still receive benefits if needed.

3) To comments that think that flipping burgers is not worth $15.00 an hr; it's not up to you to decide what a job is worth. Our local animal control officer makes nearly $80,000.00 a year and I don't think his job is worth that much, but that is just my opinion. What a entry level job is worth is highly dependent, not on specific skill sets, but on the demands of the economy.
Titan1 wrote:
I thought one of the arguments FOR increasing the minimum wage was that the tax payers are subsidizing these companies low salaries (because all their minimum...
I thought one of the arguments FOR increasing the minimum wage was that the tax payers are subsidizing these companies low salaries (because all their minimum wage employees are still collecting welfare)...so you're saying that the welfare system needs to be overhauled so that all the minimum wage workers will still qualify for welfare? That defeats one of the main points of increasing the minimum wage.

Good grief...

Minimum wage jobs aren't meant to be living wage jobs...never have been, never will be. They are jobs to get ones foot in the door, to start getting experience, to build a resume, to support while working on education etc. The minimum wage isn't set to be the minimum amount that one can live. Its there as a minimum amount one might earn, until they can improve themselves to justify a larger wage.

In fact, you talk about how subjective what a job is worth is...well, living wage is also very subjective. One persons living wage, is another persons poverty. Really. And if the government is going to start pushing a "living wage" rather than a "minimum wage"...then the government is going to have to define exactly what a "living wage" actually is. And the problem is, is that its not the governments job to tell employers what their jobs are worth. That is up to what the local economy will justify. When jobs are scarce, its a higher wage...when jobs are plentiful its a lower wage. If an employer gets sick of crappy workers, then he'll pay more to get better qualified employees. The government doesn't need to be involved in this beyond making sure that companies aren't exploiting their workers (and working for even the current minimum wage isn't exploitation).

T
The whole idea the minimum wage should be a living wage is an ideological argument not an economic one. It's a bad idea for all the reasons you gave. As far as there being a minimum wage at all, it would certainly be something that only a local government would have any chance at getting right. A federal minimum wage is basically Congressional silliness.
newmann
Posts
24438
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
US
7/27/2015 5:19pm
If you are 40 years old and working at McDonalds for minimum wage....newsflash....McDonalds is not the problem.

Post a reply to: Ok so in Seattle they got their $15hr minimum wage but wait....

The Latest