I created a Motocross Incident Database

hillbilly
Posts
9079
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Afton, TN, USA
4/11/2015 1:04pm
Who is going to look at this data and make moto safer?


The Rock
Posts
8758
Joined
3/21/2007
Location
HAIKU, HI, USA
4/12/2015 1:15am
I must have missed that hillbilly where anyone said they were going to make moto safe.
ocscottie
Posts
69092
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Redding, CA, USA
4/12/2015 1:18am
FYI: to the OP, that long title was bugging me (its a pet peeve) so i did a little editing of it. Cool
hillbilly
Posts
9079
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Afton, TN, USA
4/12/2015 6:38am
The Rock wrote:
I must have missed that hillbilly where anyone said they were going to make moto safe.
It would be safe when you're local track is closed because someone got pissed at the owner and thru a bunch of fake data at the base nd lost his lease or such.

Be real safe when you can only stare at your bike in the garage.

The Shop

oldman125
Posts
30
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Grand Junction, CO, USA
4/12/2015 7:26am
Oh boy....retard helmets and safety cages for everyone.

MX is dangerous...plain and simple. Get over it.
Falcon
Posts
12602
Joined
11/16/2011
Location
Menifee, CA, USA
4/12/2015 7:38am
I want to point out that some insurance policies may not cover you for motorcycle crashes. Or, we motorcyclists have to pay higher premiums. If you post up about your crash, it may be akin to an admission that you were riding.
I always say I fell down in the driveway, or had gardening accident, or my wife beat me up, but never that I was on a motorcycle if I can avoid it.
APLMAN99
Posts
12921
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
Fantasy
4/12/2015 9:06am
The Rock wrote:
I must have missed that hillbilly where anyone said they were going to make moto safe.
What were you thinking "improvement" was referencing when you said that about summing up your feelings?
The Rock
Posts
8758
Joined
3/21/2007
Location
HAIKU, HI, USA
4/12/2015 1:47pm Edited Date/Time 4/12/2015 1:48pm
At this point I would define improvement as doing more than starting threads when people get hurt with everyone saying "prayers sent etc." and the annual "we need to improve flagging" threads. SSDD or up until recently SSDY.

Doing something even if it isn't the best thing to do is better than doing nothing in my book. Step 1 we need to mellow out MX courses and return them to their roots. Not flatten them but change the outdoor SX tracks that exist a lot in the US into actual MX tracks.

Alternatively we can do nothing and just keep lying to ourselves that it is the Internet making us more aware of injuries and really nothing needs to be done. MX is dangerous so people running into each other head on, riders hitting equipment on the track, riders getting landed on because of poor flagging is all just part of the sport.....besides you can't make MX safe so why even bother? (insert sarcasm emoticon)
The Rock
Posts
8758
Joined
3/21/2007
Location
HAIKU, HI, USA
4/12/2015 1:52pm
Falcon wrote:
I want to point out that some insurance policies may not cover you for motorcycle crashes. Or, we motorcyclists have to pay higher premiums. If you...
I want to point out that some insurance policies may not cover you for motorcycle crashes. Or, we motorcyclists have to pay higher premiums. If you post up about your crash, it may be akin to an admission that you were riding.
I always say I fell down in the driveway, or had gardening accident, or my wife beat me up, but never that I was on a motorcycle if I can avoid it.
Unless you arrive via ambulance still in your ridig gear ANY reason for the injury is better than admitting you were on a motorcycle. I learned at 15 after hearing the anti motorcycle rap once from a doctor that was the last time I wanted to hear it.
The Rock
Posts
8758
Joined
3/21/2007
Location
HAIKU, HI, USA
4/12/2015 1:54pm
oldman125 wrote:
Oh boy....retard helmets and safety cages for everyone.

MX is dangerous...plain and simple. Get over it.
Yeah we hear that a lot. May I ask how old you are please, what is your injury collection to date and if you have any children? Thank you.
The Rock
Posts
8758
Joined
3/21/2007
Location
HAIKU, HI, USA
4/12/2015 2:19pm Edited Date/Time 4/12/2015 2:27pm
The Rock wrote:
I must have missed that hillbilly where anyone said they were going to make moto safe.
hillbilly wrote:
It would be safe when you're local track is closed because someone got pissed at the owner and thru a bunch of fake data at the...
It would be safe when you're local track is closed because someone got pissed at the owner and thru a bunch of fake data at the base nd lost his lease or such.

Be real safe when you can only stare at your bike in the garage.
You can have any opinion you want on the subject and that's fine with me but PLEASE don't fabricate when trying to make your point. Right out of the gate I call BS on your hypothetical track being closed. Too many assumptions in your scenario and in my world this information wouldn't be on a public access server.

If we are smart about this we get this form to the Asterik Medical Lab and they keep it on a PC or Mac and collect data throughout the season for professional racers as a starting point. Not sure if DC has chimed in on this yet but both MX Sports and Youthstream need to see what the OP has put together.

Where I am coming from now is the same place I was coming from almost 10 years ago regarding being an advocate of sound limits back when the majority of people still thought loud was cool. How well did the booming four strokes work out for tracks and riding areas? Same thing as I see it for safety and unfortunately we are behind just like we were in trying to deal with sound ten years ago. I am hoping with K-Dub speaking up and the subsequent discussions safety will become our number one priority. Time will tell if we can do a safety reset in order to reduce the carnage.

No one is trying to make it safe nor does anyone think MX will ever be safe.

It is my opinion (not saying I am right) that it IS possible to reduce the amount and degree of severity of accidents by just using our heads and using more COMMON SENSE when it comes to our sport.

To everyone: If it was your kid and if his life was saved by because he didn't take a footpeg into his spine because of his his spine was covered by padding (or air) and plastic might your opinion be a bit different on mandatory spinal protection? To clarify I am NOT talking about neck braces.

BTW Chad Reed stated what safety equipment he uses is his decision and I respect his position. My only response is NASCAR would not agree with him.

EDIT: We are not alone. Look at the concussion issues in football and all sports for that matter. The masses are waking up to the importance of our lives outside the sport. I hate change...I don't even like surprises for the most part because I am a planner but in this case I fully embrace change. I would rather embrace change and wind up with different version of what we have today (Scramblecross is on the right track) than see us wind up with a sport where we have dwindling Vet and Senior classes. Last time I looked these are the people that are buying most of the gear and bikes. We are talking our long term survival here.

The digital age is robbing us of recruits......think about it.
motogrady
Posts
3931
Joined
1/27/2008
Location
USA
4/12/2015 2:54pm
The Rock wrote:
I must have missed that hillbilly where anyone said they were going to make moto safe.
hillbilly wrote:
It would be safe when you're local track is closed because someone got pissed at the owner and thru a bunch of fake data at the...
It would be safe when you're local track is closed because someone got pissed at the owner and thru a bunch of fake data at the base nd lost his lease or such.

Be real safe when you can only stare at your bike in the garage.
The Rock wrote:
You can have any opinion you want on the subject and that's fine with me but PLEASE don't fabricate when trying to make your point. Right...
You can have any opinion you want on the subject and that's fine with me but PLEASE don't fabricate when trying to make your point. Right out of the gate I call BS on your hypothetical track being closed. Too many assumptions in your scenario and in my world this information wouldn't be on a public access server.

If we are smart about this we get this form to the Asterik Medical Lab and they keep it on a PC or Mac and collect data throughout the season for professional racers as a starting point. Not sure if DC has chimed in on this yet but both MX Sports and Youthstream need to see what the OP has put together.

Where I am coming from now is the same place I was coming from almost 10 years ago regarding being an advocate of sound limits back when the majority of people still thought loud was cool. How well did the booming four strokes work out for tracks and riding areas? Same thing as I see it for safety and unfortunately we are behind just like we were in trying to deal with sound ten years ago. I am hoping with K-Dub speaking up and the subsequent discussions safety will become our number one priority. Time will tell if we can do a safety reset in order to reduce the carnage.

No one is trying to make it safe nor does anyone think MX will ever be safe.

It is my opinion (not saying I am right) that it IS possible to reduce the amount and degree of severity of accidents by just using our heads and using more COMMON SENSE when it comes to our sport.

To everyone: If it was your kid and if his life was saved by because he didn't take a footpeg into his spine because of his his spine was covered by padding (or air) and plastic might your opinion be a bit different on mandatory spinal protection? To clarify I am NOT talking about neck braces.

BTW Chad Reed stated what safety equipment he uses is his decision and I respect his position. My only response is NASCAR would not agree with him.

EDIT: We are not alone. Look at the concussion issues in football and all sports for that matter. The masses are waking up to the importance of our lives outside the sport. I hate change...I don't even like surprises for the most part because I am a planner but in this case I fully embrace change. I would rather embrace change and wind up with different version of what we have today (Scramblecross is on the right track) than see us wind up with a sport where we have dwindling Vet and Senior classes. Last time I looked these are the people that are buying most of the gear and bikes. We are talking our long term survival here.

The digital age is robbing us of recruits......think about it.
Yea, that's great. Get Asterik involved. Perfect example. Start off keeping track of injuries until the next do gooder
Or govt agency want s to throw their suggestion in. Poof, half the people are yanked up for smoking a joint 3 weeks prior.

You don't need to be a rocket scientist or bean counter to realize its the young age and size of jumps out there.
4/12/2015 5:24pm
ocscottie wrote:
FYI: to the OP, that long title was bugging me (its a pet peeve) so i did a little editing of it. Cool
No problem scottie.

BTW: I am MMS_BoNalls from MCM2. Smile
vschaik141
Posts
1166
Joined
1/25/2010
Location
Soest, NL
4/12/2015 10:06pm
I have a few concerns on rider safety. Sometimes it's just small things can easily be prevented.
there's prolly a lot of other points i don't think about but that's the problem I guess before something gets done it needs to go horribly wrong 1st.

flaggers must always be visible, waving the flag, sometimes a rider can't see the flag because of the sun. it doesn't take long to find out you can hardly see a flagger between 2 and 4 pm because of the sun. do something about it.

flaggers must know what to do sometimes its a friend of you with no experience around motocross that ends up flagging for you a couple of classes. they must get proper instructions.

this big speed difference on practice days. 65cc with the big guys.
or even when they let some classes race together because there isn't a lot of entries in those classes and they struggle with the limited time they have for all classes to practice and ride 2 moto's.
And whatsupp with doing big jumps when there's a inexperienced rider in front of you? I seen that go wrong too many times.

strict rules around jumping and passing when there's a yellow flag. on every level of racing. if its amateurs hobby or pro.

Always have flaggers even on practice days on some tracks there is no policy for this. luckily there's concerned family members and spectators that will stand there. but sometimes there's no one standing on a jump you can't look behind as a rider until you in the air and find out someone went down behind it.

pay attention where you leave and enter the track. 2 years ago someone in front of me left the track near his RV without looking behind him. maybe have 1 save low speed corner to enter and leave the track.

I had a big crash once, broke a lot of bones + multiple surgeries as a 14 year old. so get put in this way to small first aid loft, bed against the wall and limited room to move around me the medical staff had to flip me over on the bed a couple of times to get most of the clothing and protection off. I don't remember anything of this day but still.

and protection of course I don't think it should be riders choice to wear or not to wear knee caps a body protector ect.

GuyB
Posts
35722
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA, USA
4/12/2015 10:14pm Edited Date/Time 4/12/2015 10:15pm
The Rock wrote:
You can have any opinion you want on the subject and that's fine with me but PLEASE don't fabricate when trying to make your point. Right...
You can have any opinion you want on the subject and that's fine with me but PLEASE don't fabricate when trying to make your point. Right out of the gate I call BS on your hypothetical track being closed. Too many assumptions in your scenario and in my world this information wouldn't be on a public access server.

If we are smart about this we get this form to the Asterik Medical Lab and they keep it on a PC or Mac and collect data throughout the season for professional racers as a starting point. Not sure if DC has chimed in on this yet but both MX Sports and Youthstream need to see what the OP has put together.

Where I am coming from now is the same place I was coming from almost 10 years ago regarding being an advocate of sound limits back when the majority of people still thought loud was cool. How well did the booming four strokes work out for tracks and riding areas? Same thing as I see it for safety and unfortunately we are behind just like we were in trying to deal with sound ten years ago. I am hoping with K-Dub speaking up and the subsequent discussions safety will become our number one priority. Time will tell if we can do a safety reset in order to reduce the carnage.

No one is trying to make it safe nor does anyone think MX will ever be safe.

It is my opinion (not saying I am right) that it IS possible to reduce the amount and degree of severity of accidents by just using our heads and using more COMMON SENSE when it comes to our sport.

To everyone: If it was your kid and if his life was saved by because he didn't take a footpeg into his spine because of his his spine was covered by padding (or air) and plastic might your opinion be a bit different on mandatory spinal protection? To clarify I am NOT talking about neck braces.

BTW Chad Reed stated what safety equipment he uses is his decision and I respect his position. My only response is NASCAR would not agree with him.

EDIT: We are not alone. Look at the concussion issues in football and all sports for that matter. The masses are waking up to the importance of our lives outside the sport. I hate change...I don't even like surprises for the most part because I am a planner but in this case I fully embrace change. I would rather embrace change and wind up with different version of what we have today (Scramblecross is on the right track) than see us wind up with a sport where we have dwindling Vet and Senior classes. Last time I looked these are the people that are buying most of the gear and bikes. We are talking our long term survival here.

The digital age is robbing us of recruits......think about it.
Both the AMA and Asterisk already track crash data in the pro ranks.

I like some of what this is intended to do, but I did talk to some folks this weekend who said it's obvious that this was created by someone who's never had to deal with litigation. They also had some concerns about the subjectivity about how some of the questions are worded. As an example, if there's a crash, why would it necessarily be a bad design of a track feature? Isn't it possible that the rider ran out of talent?
APLMAN99
Posts
12921
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
Fantasy
4/12/2015 11:48pm
The Rock wrote:
At this point I would define improvement as doing more than starting threads when people get hurt with everyone saying "prayers sent etc." and the annual...
At this point I would define improvement as doing more than starting threads when people get hurt with everyone saying "prayers sent etc." and the annual "we need to improve flagging" threads. SSDD or up until recently SSDY.

Doing something even if it isn't the best thing to do is better than doing nothing in my book. Step 1 we need to mellow out MX courses and return them to their roots. Not flatten them but change the outdoor SX tracks that exist a lot in the US into actual MX tracks.

Alternatively we can do nothing and just keep lying to ourselves that it is the Internet making us more aware of injuries and really nothing needs to be done. MX is dangerous so people running into each other head on, riders hitting equipment on the track, riders getting landed on because of poor flagging is all just part of the sport.....besides you can't make MX safe so why even bother? (insert sarcasm emoticon)
So despite your reply to hillbilly, you were thinking that "improvement" was related to making the sport safer. Got it. Just not sure why you'd try to basically deny that at first.......

As a thought, how exactly will keeping this list of injuries make the sport safer?
APLMAN99
Posts
12921
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Tualatin, OR, USA
Fantasy
4/12/2015 11:57pm
GuyB wrote:
Both the AMA and Asterisk already track crash data in the pro ranks. I like some of what this is intended to do, but I did...
Both the AMA and Asterisk already track crash data in the pro ranks.

I like some of what this is intended to do, but I did talk to some folks this weekend who said it's obvious that this was created by someone who's never had to deal with litigation. They also had some concerns about the subjectivity about how some of the questions are worded. As an example, if there's a crash, why would it necessarily be a bad design of a track feature? Isn't it possible that the rider ran out of talent?
I definitely think the intentions are good, but who is responsible when some folks who want kids banned from riding start reporting all these fake injuries at tracks and it affects the attendance enough that it shuts down?

If we really want numbers, the NIH and the CPSC would probably love to compile some numbers for the sport, but I doubt most would like the end result.........
yzfjere
Posts
73
Joined
1/4/2007
Location
Anniston, AL, USA
4/13/2015 12:26am
This is still the USA! If your track is dangerous, let the owner know or go elsewhere. Litigation is part of what closes our riding areas and this can only help the attorneys. This is NOT going to improve protection or track conditions! B freaking S! Talk to your track owners and managers if you have issues..... PLEASE!
The Rock
Posts
8758
Joined
3/21/2007
Location
HAIKU, HI, USA
4/13/2015 9:49am Edited Date/Time 4/13/2015 10:28am
EDIT: Are some of you really saying and thinking we can't do anything to make the sport safer so why even try?

GuyB-How long have pro injuries been tracked?
The Rock
Posts
8758
Joined
3/21/2007
Location
HAIKU, HI, USA
4/13/2015 9:52am
yzfjere wrote:
This is still the USA! If your track is dangerous, let the owner know or go elsewhere. Litigation is part of what closes our riding areas...
This is still the USA! If your track is dangerous, let the owner know or go elsewhere. Litigation is part of what closes our riding areas and this can only help the attorneys. This is NOT going to improve protection or track conditions! B freaking S! Talk to your track owners and managers if you have issues..... PLEASE!
A track that just closed due to a fataility told someone (as reported here) who complained about the jump in the past "just hold it on mate!"

Do you have any other suggestions (besides go somewhere else) since not everyone has an open ear that manages a track?
The Rock
Posts
8758
Joined
3/21/2007
Location
HAIKU, HI, USA
4/13/2015 9:59am Edited Date/Time 4/13/2015 10:29am
APLMAN99 wrote:
So despite your reply to hillbilly, you were thinking that "improvement" was related to making the sport safer. Got it. Just not sure why you'd try...
So despite your reply to hillbilly, you were thinking that "improvement" was related to making the sport safer. Got it. Just not sure why you'd try to basically deny that at first.......

As a thought, how exactly will keeping this list of injuries make the sport safer?
Please claify the last sentence in your first paragraph.

Like motogrady said you don't have to me a rocket scientist to realize the size of the jumps today are the leading cause of injuries. Regarding the list if a lot of people weren't so hard headed we wouldn't need to compile historical data to prove what is apparent to most of us that don't subscribe to the "racing is dangerous get used to it" mentality.

Post a reply to: I created a Motocross Incident Database

The Latest