US cars junk?

musmanni
Posts
282
Joined
1/2/2012
Location
CR
Edited Date/Time 11/2/2013 10:56pm
6 of the ten least reliable cars are US companies. 5 of which are Ford.

http://autos.yahoo.com/news/the-10-least-reliable-cars-181031192.html
|
lostboy819
Posts
12809
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Blk Forest, CO, USA
10/29/2013 10:38pm
I was going to get either a new Ford F150 FX4 or a new Toyota Tacoma. The Ford was my first choice but could not find one with everything I wanted so I got a new Toyota. I think I would have been happy with either one of them but kind of glad I got the Tacoma.
vet323
Posts
3654
Joined
7/31/2010
Location
Lead, SD, USA
10/30/2013 7:05am
Why call out "US cars" in the title? 6 out of 10 on the list are US cars, that means 40% are not US cars. If this poll was done by a European magazine, 6 of 10 would be European cars.
motoracer633
Posts
427
Joined
11/14/2011
Location
North Charleston, SC, USA
10/30/2013 7:27am
Based on the asterisks 4 of the US cars are first year models which consumer reports doesn'tfind that a long enough time to make reliability reports.
newmann
Posts
24437
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
10/30/2013 7:47am
Remember when Consumer Reports put one of these on the steering wheel of the Acura MDX (Isuzu Trooper) in an attempt to get it to roll over. Fuck them.

The Shop

motoracer633
Posts
427
Joined
11/14/2011
Location
North Charleston, SC, USA
10/30/2013 7:51am
They should have let an MX'er do it. We can tear some shite up!
RocketLab
Posts
604
Joined
11/18/2009
Location
San Antonio, TX, USA
10/30/2013 1:32pm
Seems it's mostly all Hybrid or turbo Fords. Ford I'm sure is working on this. I've got a 2004 F150 that's been completely reliable to date. Oh wait, I had to replace the lighter.
Griff.747
Posts
139
Joined
10/25/2013
Location
Idaho Falls, ID, USA
10/30/2013 6:24pm Edited Date/Time 10/30/2013 7:25pm
With my experience ford cars.... Well they kinda suck ass. Unless it's a mustang then ford actually has some pride in it and builds it right. But their trucks on the other hand are just as good as any other manufacturer out there. I had an old 94 f 150 that I restored and honesty there wasn't a whole lot to restore on it haha mostly just interior. It was my daily driver for 5 years and I only had one problems with it. The starter quit on me (still factory). But after turning over that truck after a week and a half of the high being -15 I'm not surprised. (Gotta love idaho winters).
MR. X
Posts
6913
Joined
6/24/2010
Location
North Tonawanda, NY, USA
10/30/2013 7:08pm
All cars are junk , they all break down ,not if but when.
Mr. G
Posts
4225
Joined
12/23/2009
Location
Riverside, CA, USA
10/30/2013 10:37pm
Ford has an interesting truck history as far as reliability. The 385 series engines were pretty reliable. I had a 351M that had almost no oil pressure at idle and I could never kill that thing. Of course the 460 was also reliable. When they went to the Mod motors they had 6 bolt mains (upgrade) but they suddenly had a problem spitting out spark plugs (too few threads). It was so bad that a company called Timesert created a fix for it. Later they added threads but went to a 2 piece plug that would come apart! Geez. Now onto the diesels. When they came out with the 6.0 it was a nightmare. I had an 05 and had two EGR coolers replaced in the 40K miles I owned it. Otherwise it was built like a tank. I sold it and bought a 98 Chevy 3/4 with a 350 with throttle body injection. Hey you can actually see the spark plugs which is good but it can't haul that much weight and the brakes are so weak that I consider it dangerous. Here is what I would do: build a bare bones truck, no electric windows no throttle by wire, manual trans and a low tech motor. They could make them cheap.
kongols
Posts
24231
Joined
9/22/2009
Location
Riga, LV
10/30/2013 11:04pm
Yup
ehr400
Posts
2630
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Britton, MI, USA
10/31/2013 4:09am
Lol, I love when these "consumers reports" rags nominate this shit. Follow the money trails for advertising and so forth. Ever here of Fiat, Peugot, Opel, Jaguar? JC those are great cars! Lol. Point is every manufacturer has built a shit model or two over the 100+ years of their existences.

BTW when someone owns a German car that is out of warranty tell me how much it will cost to replace some of the simplest wear items and then they can claim "superior" engineering. I have seen them all and been to most of their factories. All I have to say people would be shocked how there is NO difference between the way a premium manfacturer and a entry level manufacturer builds their cars. None. And the amount of rework that happens between the 2 is exactly the same.
10/31/2013 8:24am
I have a 2002 Tundra and it still purrs like a kitten. Both my neighbors have 2002 Ford F150. No issues with them except for rust. No rust on mine so far.
That said, if I had 45 g's to drop, I would get a 2014 Ford F150.
Sandberm
Posts
5845
Joined
3/27/2009
Location
Pasco, WA, USA
10/31/2013 8:30am
#5 Nissan Pathfinder

I love my Pathfinder....now that Ive got all the problems fixedLaughing
jtomasik
Posts
12895
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Golden, CO, USA
10/31/2013 8:34am
I had a 1999 F250 with a Banks-juiced 7.3. The only good thing about that truck was the engine and its looks. Otherwise....POS. Owned tons of Japanese vehicles over the past 3 decades, and aside from one Isuzu Trooper, every single one have been fantastic. Owned 3 American vehicles, one Volvo, and one BMW, and each one has had multiple problems. A big deal to a Japanese vehicle within 150K+ miles is having to replace a starter. In that same timeframe on the American-made vehicles, I've had to replace trannies, ball joints, multiple other suspension components, glow plugs, electronics, repaired body issues....shit....so many other issues as well. In my experience, there's no comparison.
newmann
Posts
24437
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
10/31/2013 9:55am
A Phillips screwdriver and a 10mm socket will damn near disassemble a complete Japanese vehicle. They seem to simplify many things. Which probably explains why they can build a vehicle here in the US. The 80 piece front bumper on the Tundra puzzles me though. Guess they are trying to Americanize things.

You need a shopping cart full of tolls to detrim a door on a domestic car. Why does Ford insist on having a Phillips head , torx head, 5.5mm , 6 mm and 8mm plus an assortment of plastic clips just to hold an interior trim panel on? I think I counted 13 - 15 tools involved on removing a fender from a F series truck in the mid to late 90's. They seem to overly complicate many simple things. No doubt it has to be the union involvement, otherwise I can't imagine any company doing shit in such a haphazard manner as the domestic, uh...ummmm I mean Mexican and Canadian mfgs. Do we actually build anything here anymore.....LOL

Europeans over engineer everything. Once you figure it out you have one of those "ah-ha" moments. Better keep an assembly manual close by or you will break something expensive in a hurry...Whistling

The Korean mfgs. that are going big lately seem to have a lot of Japanese influence in their vehicles.
Spartacus
Posts
2269
Joined
5/20/2011
Location
USA
10/31/2013 10:02am
The best thing about current diesel trucks is having to take the cab off to do any serious motor work.

Brilliant!
jtomasik
Posts
12895
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Golden, CO, USA
10/31/2013 10:15am Edited Date/Time 10/31/2013 10:23am
newmann wrote:
A Phillips screwdriver and a 10mm socket will damn near disassemble a complete Japanese vehicle. They seem to simplify many things. Which probably explains why they...
A Phillips screwdriver and a 10mm socket will damn near disassemble a complete Japanese vehicle. They seem to simplify many things. Which probably explains why they can build a vehicle here in the US. The 80 piece front bumper on the Tundra puzzles me though. Guess they are trying to Americanize things.

You need a shopping cart full of tolls to detrim a door on a domestic car. Why does Ford insist on having a Phillips head , torx head, 5.5mm , 6 mm and 8mm plus an assortment of plastic clips just to hold an interior trim panel on? I think I counted 13 - 15 tools involved on removing a fender from a F series truck in the mid to late 90's. They seem to overly complicate many simple things. No doubt it has to be the union involvement, otherwise I can't imagine any company doing shit in such a haphazard manner as the domestic, uh...ummmm I mean Mexican and Canadian mfgs. Do we actually build anything here anymore.....LOL

Europeans over engineer everything. Once you figure it out you have one of those "ah-ha" moments. Better keep an assembly manual close by or you will break something expensive in a hurry...Whistling

The Korean mfgs. that are going big lately seem to have a lot of Japanese influence in their vehicles.
That over-complication is evident everywhere. Seems to me that American cars are designed to try to do too much....all the bells and whistles on the planet....whereas the Japanese cars I have, even the more luxurious ones (like my Infiniti), still seem simplified.

Personally, I suspect a lot of the problems start in management and marketing with those American companies. American culture is fantastic and individualism and innovation...but the problem arises when they can't stop to solidify a design and move into production. Feature creep affects so many projects, and it appears to be the same with our cars. You keep adding features late in the program, it causes cost overruns and adds risk to a tested, stable design.

A lot of the simplification theory in design manufacturing exists in the American design environment (DFA, DFM, top-down, poka yoke), as does the analysis methods for continuous improvement (DFMEA, etc.). If you keep adding features, you fuck up the benefits delivered by those practices. Oh, half-ass marketing and overblown profit projections don't help, either.


There's a chart that plots dollars/resource against schedule in the product development cycle. The ones I've seen of good design show a huge investment/effort early in the development cycle, then it tapers off to almost nothing on product release and after manufacturing introduction. American charts are often the opposite, with little work up front, but a ton of corrections and redesign at/after production. That translates to HUGE bucks, shit quality, and pissed off customers.
Racer92
Posts
17965
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Central, TX, USA
10/31/2013 10:47am
MR. X wrote:
All cars are junk , they all break down ,not if but when.
Dude whether anyone likes the Japs or not, the Camry is an incredibly reliable vehicle that will go hundreds of thousands of miles with no issues other than routine wear-maintenance.
newmann
Posts
24437
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
10/31/2013 11:26am
MR. X wrote:
All cars are junk , they all break down ,not if but when.
Racer92 wrote:
Dude whether anyone likes the Japs or not, the Camry is an incredibly reliable vehicle that will go hundreds of thousands of miles with no issues...
Dude whether anyone likes the Japs or not, the Camry is an incredibly reliable vehicle that will go hundreds of thousands of miles with no issues other than routine wear-maintenance.
Yep, unless you are my neighbor who likes to pressure wash his engine, fill the air resonator box full of water, crank and rev it to six grand to dry everything off and ventilate the engine block! Dude keeps his driveway spotless.....that five quarts took a while to clean up! LOL
sgthubbard#60
Posts
765
Joined
12/15/2010
Location
Millers Falls, MA, USA
10/31/2013 11:38am
My 99 E350 has 190k on it and I haven't changed the oil in the last 40k, thing just keeps on going. Almost done restoring a 1971 Econoline right now so I'm kind of trying to see if I can kill the 99 just for the fun of it. I've always owned Fords and Chevys, never had any serious problems with any of them.
newmann
Posts
24437
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
10/31/2013 11:46am
My 99 E350 has 190k on it and I haven't changed the oil in the last 40k, thing just keeps on going. Almost done restoring a...
My 99 E350 has 190k on it and I haven't changed the oil in the last 40k, thing just keeps on going. Almost done restoring a 1971 Econoline right now so I'm kind of trying to see if I can kill the 99 just for the fun of it. I've always owned Fords and Chevys, never had any serious problems with any of them.
Damn thing burns so much that you just keep filling it up? Update pics on the 71 are needed.

Had Ford and Chevy relied on car sales, they would have been toast a long time ago. Their trucks, big SUV's and commercial vehicles have been their savior.
B DUB 333
Posts
772
Joined
9/9/2010
Location
New Richland, MN, USA
10/31/2013 11:49am
got a 07 ram with a cummins, just hit 330000 last night, I did the trans at 260 because it was starting to shutter at take off and I had a goereand trans installed, for 7k, but it's all built right now and I swear the truck runs just like it did new. I think the US builds great trucks at least. I tow 10-15k all the time, and it just keeps coming back for more. I honestly believe the dodge rigs with cummins are the best vehicles ever made. I have six in my company that get used by idiots day in and day out and have yet to have a engine failure, and kids these days dont take care of shit, they beat them hard
sgthubbard#60
Posts
765
Joined
12/15/2010
Location
Millers Falls, MA, USA
10/31/2013 12:07pm
newmann wrote:
Damn thing burns so much that you just keep filling it up? Update pics on the 71 are needed. Had Ford and Chevy relied on car...
Damn thing burns so much that you just keep filling it up? Update pics on the 71 are needed.

Had Ford and Chevy relied on car sales, they would have been toast a long time ago. Their trucks, big SUV's and commercial vehicles have been their savior.
HaHA, Honestly the thing doesn't burn a drop of oil, it leaks just enough that I throw a fresh quart in it about every 1500 miles. Guess that keeps it fresh enough to keep her going.

I will get some update pics of the 71 this weekend. Thing is gonna be pretty sweet with a handfull of Elsinores in the back!
ToolMaker
Posts
10516
Joined
11/19/2011
Location
Escondido, CA, USA
10/31/2013 12:16pm
Racer92 wrote:
Dude whether anyone likes the Japs or not, the Camry is an incredibly reliable vehicle that will go hundreds of thousands of miles with no issues...
Dude whether anyone likes the Japs or not, the Camry is an incredibly reliable vehicle that will go hundreds of thousands of miles with no issues other than routine wear-maintenance.
I like Japs, I married one Smile but I don't think I'll buy a camry.
TM
Mr. G
Posts
4225
Joined
12/23/2009
Location
Riverside, CA, USA
10/31/2013 6:10pm
B DUB 333 wrote:
got a 07 ram with a cummins, just hit 330000 last night, I did the trans at 260 because it was starting to shutter at take...
got a 07 ram with a cummins, just hit 330000 last night, I did the trans at 260 because it was starting to shutter at take off and I had a goereand trans installed, for 7k, but it's all built right now and I swear the truck runs just like it did new. I think the US builds great trucks at least. I tow 10-15k all the time, and it just keeps coming back for more. I honestly believe the dodge rigs with cummins are the best vehicles ever made. I have six in my company that get used by idiots day in and day out and have yet to have a engine failure, and kids these days dont take care of shit, they beat them hard
That is both incredible and good to hear.
Sandberm
Posts
5845
Joined
3/27/2009
Location
Pasco, WA, USA
10/31/2013 6:44pm
B DUB 333 wrote:
got a 07 ram with a cummins, just hit 330000 last night, I did the trans at 260 because it was starting to shutter at take...
got a 07 ram with a cummins, just hit 330000 last night, I did the trans at 260 because it was starting to shutter at take off and I had a goereand trans installed, for 7k, but it's all built right now and I swear the truck runs just like it did new. I think the US builds great trucks at least. I tow 10-15k all the time, and it just keeps coming back for more. I honestly believe the dodge rigs with cummins are the best vehicles ever made. I have six in my company that get used by idiots day in and day out and have yet to have a engine failure, and kids these days dont take care of shit, they beat them hard
50,000 miles a year. You get around

Hows the seat and everything else holding up? The cummins will last forever but what about the rest of the truck?

I had another guy recently tell me the same thing you did, that you cant go wrong with a cummins diesel.
motoracer633
Posts
427
Joined
11/14/2011
Location
North Charleston, SC, USA
11/1/2013 5:49am
99 E150 with 185k, 4.6 and it gets 18 mpg avg and runs like a champ!
11/1/2013 11:50am
My wifes 08 Camry is a piece of shit I know several other folks with 08 and 09s with various issues from the suspension to the engine burning oil
Brad460
Posts
4623
Joined
5/15/2012
Location
Richfield, WI, USA
11/1/2013 6:37pm
My commuter car is a 01 Saab 9-5, it is a complicated over-designed mess with just over 227,000 miles on it but the piece of crap just keeps running and running. Nice thing is my '10 Tundra only has 25,000 miles on it!

Biggest piece of shit car we ever had was an 04 Mercedes, looked nice but damn it had all kinds of odds things fail on it.

Hands down best car we have ever owned is my wife's current car, a '12 Acura TL- everything about that car is perfect.
lostboy819
Posts
12809
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Blk Forest, CO, USA
11/1/2013 8:32pm
I was looking at the F150 with the Ecoboost engine but I have seen some problems with them losing power when you step on the gas,don't think its a recall size problem. I am happy with my new Tacoma and will give it to my son when he turns 16 and then may get the new style F150 Ford. I have three years to make up my mind.

Post a reply to: US cars junk?

The Latest