Engine Builders or Moto Dads who do the work their own, what bearings do you use?!

8/13/2024 8:32pm

I wonder what kind of bearings they used or all thd little tricks to get them faster. Snowmobiles where raced just after 1926, 2- strokes.  This is a 1966 Panther with a high compression 8 hp Kohler engine 4-st. It was very hard to start. Engine was made in Kohler Wisconsin . I delivered a container from Chicago there, very old building. IMG 0639.png?VersionId=0IMG 7014 2

2
4
8/13/2024 8:32pm
Top End wrote:
fletch
But not all balls are the same!Schaeffler's published data on steel bearing friction loss...3% ball deformation loss of total bearing friction loss is insignificant, compared to...

But not all balls are the same!

Schaeffler's published data on steel bearing friction loss...

powerlossdistributionschaeffler-1024x669

3% ball deformation loss of total bearing friction loss is insignificant, compared to other friction losses between the crank and rear wheel.

Top End wrote:
"But not all balls are the same!"Lets not forget the cages and races tooInteresting graph get rid of the seal and grease and you have a...

"But not all balls are the same!"

Lets not forget the cages and races too

Interesting graph get rid of the seal and grease and you have a 88% gain

Swap out the steel cage for a plastic one and gain a little more 

 

 ...I'm going to need a set of pliers and 30w ball bearings....   Fletch

The improvements are not as much as you expect, blue is steel bearing, red is ceramic bearing...

https://www.hambini.com/ceramic-bearings-vs-steel-bearings-an-engineering-analysis/

greaseandseals-1024x669

Frictional losses from the bearings are insignificant compared to other losses from the crank to the rear wheel.

Spur gears typically lose 1-2% (so total loss of 2-4% from primary drive gear to clutch outer, and mainshaft to countershaft), clutches loses 0-5% depending on load, clamping force and friction area, the chain drive loses 9-10%, depending on type of chain and condition.

If your looking to reduce frictional losses start with a well maintained, well lubricated conventional chain, o-rings in chains increase friction

6
OldPro277
Posts
1875
Joined
11/9/2009
Location
Avonmore, PA, USA
8/14/2024 10:19am
PTshox wrote:
LOL... you guys are clowns. Probably totally broke too. I have to call “bullshit”on some or all , of your story of speaking to your Professor a...

LOL... you guys are clowns. Probably totally broke too. 

I have to call “bullshit”on some or all , of your story of speaking to your Professor a few hours after the incident . If Boeing already had determined that the rivets were the issue less than 24 hours after it happened, it would have been an all-time fastest investigation conclusion in Aviation history. I think you may have embellished either your timeline …or the body of the conversation a bit. 

Professors name was John Majastead (spelling could be off). I stated what he said to me exactly. 

Make sure to make that turn off the cliff when your GPS tell you too. 

 

Soooo....  Since you're an Engineer nonpareil---  explain to me how you were able to determine all of your detractors financial portfolios from just a few posts contained in this thread ??   I rescind all of my earlier statements--- you ARE the smartest man alive !!!!!  Bravo 👏

5
8/14/2024 10:28am
Top End wrote:
fletch
But not all balls are the same!Schaeffler's published data on steel bearing friction loss...3% ball deformation loss of total bearing friction loss is insignificant, compared to...

But not all balls are the same!

Schaeffler's published data on steel bearing friction loss...

powerlossdistributionschaeffler-1024x669

3% ball deformation loss of total bearing friction loss is insignificant, compared to other friction losses between the crank and rear wheel.

chuckie108 wrote:
I spoke to a bearing engineer once about ceramic bearings- his take was the best application for ceramic bearings on an MX bike would be the...

I spoke to a bearing engineer once about ceramic bearings- his take was the best application for ceramic bearings on an MX bike would be the wheel bearings as that is where the most load a bearing sees and therefore the most deformation of the balls. I put my wallet back in my pocket at that point. 

And my bearing guy told me that wheels would be the last place he would put ceramics on a dirt bike, he said ceramics are a lot more susceptible to failure when exposed to dirt, mud, water etc. 

The Shop

LungButter
Posts
8684
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
Yellow Pine, ID, USA
8/14/2024 10:31am

PTShox....when you tested this "polished engine theory" how do you know that all variables were exactly the same?

Was the moisture content in the dirt exactly the same?

Was the track prepped the exact same to ensure the same exact traction?

Outside temperature exactly the same?

Brand new tires on the bike each time?

Same fuel from the same batch each time?

2
1
OldPro277
Posts
1875
Joined
11/9/2009
Location
Avonmore, PA, USA
8/14/2024 10:54am
LungButter wrote:
PTShox....when you tested this "polished engine theory" how do you know that all variables were exactly the same?Was the moisture content in the dirt exactly the...

PTShox....when you tested this "polished engine theory" how do you know that all variables were exactly the same?

Was the moisture content in the dirt exactly the same?

Was the track prepped the exact same to ensure the same exact traction?

Outside temperature exactly the same?

Brand new tires on the bike each time?

Same fuel from the same batch each time?

LB--  all of what you asked  is inconsequential when you have data like this .  Exhibit A-----"People would come up to him at various races and say "what the heck did you do to those motors? Those things bark".  I rest my case......

6
8/14/2024 12:24pm
1000016342.jpg?VersionId=ue3pr

These (generic picture of the bearing) have gone into lots of very high end motors including factory. Only thing to watch for is OD clearance some of them might be on tight side so its very important to check fit as in rare cases with some top 15 guys have cracked the cases on a SX. I've  never heard of anyone outside of them having an issue.  If need be you can spin the bearing on a buff wheel with some cutting compound a quick spin and I was told that will fix it. But again it a very rare issue.

PTshox
Posts
1590
Joined
10/1/2011
Location
Highland Village, TX, USA
8/14/2024 1:25pm
LungButter wrote:
PTShox....when you tested this "polished engine theory" how do you know that all variables were exactly the same?Was the moisture content in the dirt exactly the...

PTShox....when you tested this "polished engine theory" how do you know that all variables were exactly the same?

Was the moisture content in the dirt exactly the same?

Was the track prepped the exact same to ensure the same exact traction?

Outside temperature exactly the same?

Brand new tires on the bike each time?

Same fuel from the same batch each time?

OldPro277 wrote:
LB--  all of what you asked  is inconsequential when you have data like this .  Exhibit A-----"People would come up to him at various races and...

LB--  all of what you asked  is inconsequential when you have data like this .  Exhibit A-----"People would come up to him at various races and say "what the heck did you do to those motors? Those things bark".  I rest my case......

You guys are so smart! Brillant. Just an amazing amount of talent and foresight. 

Let me ask you... how many computers have you seen riding a dirt bike? How many? What did the computer tell you about how the suspension worked or how the motor performed? 

The guy that taught me this trick... His name is Arnold Plant. He was a MX Pro back in the day from Sacramento. Arnold wrench on the US National Moto/Supercross circuit for several years. He built motors for folks that won National motos and supercross, He also worked for Bob Fox @ Fox shocks. Tell Arnold it can't and doesn't work because of whatever reason you want to come up with. LOL... Armchair quarter backs. 

 

1
11
LungButter
Posts
8684
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
Yellow Pine, ID, USA
8/14/2024 1:33pm
PTshox wrote:
You guys are so smart! Brillant. Just an amazing amount of talent and foresight. Let me ask you... how many computers have you seen riding a dirt...

You guys are so smart! Brillant. Just an amazing amount of talent and foresight. 

Let me ask you... how many computers have you seen riding a dirt bike? How many? What did the computer tell you about how the suspension worked or how the motor performed? 

The guy that taught me this trick... His name is Arnold Plant. He was a MX Pro back in the day from Sacramento. Arnold wrench on the US National Moto/Supercross circuit for several years. He built motors for folks that won National motos and supercross, He also worked for Bob Fox @ Fox shocks. Tell Arnold it can't and doesn't work because of whatever reason you want to come up with. LOL... Armchair quarter backs. 

 

I never said a god damn thing about computers.  

Can you answer the very, very simple questions that I asked or not?

You definitely have the typical arrogant asshole engineer attitude that's for sure.

 

2
3
8/14/2024 1:34pm
LungButter wrote:
PTShox....when you tested this "polished engine theory" how do you know that all variables were exactly the same?Was the moisture content in the dirt exactly the...

PTShox....when you tested this "polished engine theory" how do you know that all variables were exactly the same?

Was the moisture content in the dirt exactly the same?

Was the track prepped the exact same to ensure the same exact traction?

Outside temperature exactly the same?

Brand new tires on the bike each time?

Same fuel from the same batch each time?

OldPro277 wrote:
LB--  all of what you asked  is inconsequential when you have data like this .  Exhibit A-----"People would come up to him at various races and...

LB--  all of what you asked  is inconsequential when you have data like this .  Exhibit A-----"People would come up to him at various races and say "what the heck did you do to those motors? Those things bark".  I rest my case......

PTshox wrote:
You guys are so smart! Brillant. Just an amazing amount of talent and foresight. Let me ask you... how many computers have you seen riding a dirt...

You guys are so smart! Brillant. Just an amazing amount of talent and foresight. 

Let me ask you... how many computers have you seen riding a dirt bike? How many? What did the computer tell you about how the suspension worked or how the motor performed? 

The guy that taught me this trick... His name is Arnold Plant. He was a MX Pro back in the day from Sacramento. Arnold wrench on the US National Moto/Supercross circuit for several years. He built motors for folks that won National motos and supercross, He also worked for Bob Fox @ Fox shocks. Tell Arnold it can't and doesn't work because of whatever reason you want to come up with. LOL... Armchair quarter backs. 

 

All this time spent arguing on vital while you could be revalving suspension and making millions with all that knowledge!

6
PTshox
Posts
1590
Joined
10/1/2011
Location
Highland Village, TX, USA
8/14/2024 2:18pm
OldPro277 wrote:
LB--  all of what you asked  is inconsequential when you have data like this .  Exhibit A-----"People would come up to him at various races and...

LB--  all of what you asked  is inconsequential when you have data like this .  Exhibit A-----"People would come up to him at various races and say "what the heck did you do to those motors? Those things bark".  I rest my case......

PTshox wrote:
You guys are so smart! Brillant. Just an amazing amount of talent and foresight. Let me ask you... how many computers have you seen riding a dirt...

You guys are so smart! Brillant. Just an amazing amount of talent and foresight. 

Let me ask you... how many computers have you seen riding a dirt bike? How many? What did the computer tell you about how the suspension worked or how the motor performed? 

The guy that taught me this trick... His name is Arnold Plant. He was a MX Pro back in the day from Sacramento. Arnold wrench on the US National Moto/Supercross circuit for several years. He built motors for folks that won National motos and supercross, He also worked for Bob Fox @ Fox shocks. Tell Arnold it can't and doesn't work because of whatever reason you want to come up with. LOL... Armchair quarter backs. 

 

Rickyisms wrote:

All this time spent arguing on vital while you could be revalving suspension and making millions with all that knowledge!

Isn't that your line of business? 

I wouldn't bother with that as a business personally. But for you... maybe a great fit. 

6
OldTech
Posts
1303
Joined
1/13/2024
Location
Decatur, AL, USA
8/14/2024 6:10pm

You win man, I'm polishing my engine cases right now!

2
8/14/2024 6:26pm
PTshox wrote:
You guys are so smart! Brillant. Just an amazing amount of talent and foresight. Let me ask you... how many computers have you seen riding a dirt...

You guys are so smart! Brillant. Just an amazing amount of talent and foresight. 

Let me ask you... how many computers have you seen riding a dirt bike? How many? What did the computer tell you about how the suspension worked or how the motor performed? 

The guy that taught me this trick... His name is Arnold Plant. He was a MX Pro back in the day from Sacramento. Arnold wrench on the US National Moto/Supercross circuit for several years. He built motors for folks that won National motos and supercross, He also worked for Bob Fox @ Fox shocks. Tell Arnold it can't and doesn't work because of whatever reason you want to come up with. LOL... Armchair quarter backs. 

 

LungButter wrote:
I never said a god damn thing about computers.  Can you answer the very, very simple questions that I asked or not?You definitely have the typical...

I never said a god damn thing about computers.  

Can you answer the very, very simple questions that I asked or not?

You definitely have the typical arrogant asshole engineer attitude that's for sure.

 

Don't judge all engineers by him.

There are arrogant, incompetent people in every profession.

2
PTshox
Posts
1590
Joined
10/1/2011
Location
Highland Village, TX, USA
8/14/2024 9:21pm
PTshox wrote:
You guys are so smart! Brillant. Just an amazing amount of talent and foresight. Let me ask you... how many computers have you seen riding a dirt...

You guys are so smart! Brillant. Just an amazing amount of talent and foresight. 

Let me ask you... how many computers have you seen riding a dirt bike? How many? What did the computer tell you about how the suspension worked or how the motor performed? 

The guy that taught me this trick... His name is Arnold Plant. He was a MX Pro back in the day from Sacramento. Arnold wrench on the US National Moto/Supercross circuit for several years. He built motors for folks that won National motos and supercross, He also worked for Bob Fox @ Fox shocks. Tell Arnold it can't and doesn't work because of whatever reason you want to come up with. LOL... Armchair quarter backs. 

 

LungButter wrote:
I never said a god damn thing about computers.  Can you answer the very, very simple questions that I asked or not?You definitely have the typical...

I never said a god damn thing about computers.  

Can you answer the very, very simple questions that I asked or not?

You definitely have the typical arrogant asshole engineer attitude that's for sure.

 

Don't judge all engineers by him.

There are arrogant, incompetent people in every profession.

And the porn industry has fluffers. You could be... IMO, a fluffer in the dyno industry.

You ever worked with Bob Wirth? Run stuff on the dyno he built? 

 

I know.. you know all.. you know more than Bob.. But Shell Oil hires Bob to do dyno work for them when they were developing race gas formulas. Also Yamaha Japan hires him. And KHI ( you may struggle with the initials). As do various F1 teams. Star racing Yamaha as well. If you have run race gas in the last 10 years.. very good chance it was developed on Bob’s dyno. That he custom built. 

 

You don’t even know who he is… you fluffer! LMAO. Clown. 

1
10
Sidewinder 1
Posts
116
Joined
7/23/2023
Location
Bossier City, LA, USA
8/14/2024 9:25pm

I bet if you built 2 engines, 1 with ceramic and the other 1 with the standard bearing you wouldn’t be able to tell any difference 

BINGO

2
PTshox
Posts
1590
Joined
10/1/2011
Location
Highland Village, TX, USA
8/14/2024 9:29pm
OldTech wrote:

You win man, I'm polishing my engine cases right now!

No.. you won. You are clearly brilliant! Amazing. Super smart. 200+ IQ. Solving cancer issues in your spare time. Of course.....

 

1
4
PTshox
Posts
1590
Joined
10/1/2011
Location
Highland Village, TX, USA
8/14/2024 9:49pm
PTshox wrote:
LOL... you guys are clowns. Probably totally broke too. I have to call “bullshit”on some or all , of your story of speaking to your Professor a...

LOL... you guys are clowns. Probably totally broke too. 

I have to call “bullshit”on some or all , of your story of speaking to your Professor a few hours after the incident . If Boeing already had determined that the rivets were the issue less than 24 hours after it happened, it would have been an all-time fastest investigation conclusion in Aviation history. I think you may have embellished either your timeline …or the body of the conversation a bit. 

Professors name was John Majastead (spelling could be off). I stated what he said to me exactly. 

Make sure to make that turn off the cliff when your GPS tell you too. 

 

OldPro277 wrote:
Soooo....  Since you're an Engineer nonpareil---  explain to me how you were able to determine all of your detractors financial portfolios from just a few posts...

Soooo....  Since you're an Engineer nonpareil---  explain to me how you were able to determine all of your detractors financial portfolios from just a few posts contained in this thread ??   I rescind all of my earlier statements--- you ARE the smartest man alive !!!!!  Bravo 👏

I bow down to you. Clearly you are a brilliant mind. And from your profile photo... Of course Geoff Fox must have invited you to the 50th anniversary party in Cambell Ca last month? Where were you sitting? 

Did you bring a computer? A dyno? 

1
7
FHKRacingZ
Posts
309
Joined
10/28/2006
Location
Boise, ID, USA
8/14/2024 10:01pm
PTshox wrote:
I come here in peace.  Try it. Or don’t if you have been told and convinced you have to have tumble, ruff intakes and smoother exhaust ports...

I come here in peace. 

 

Try it. Or don’t if you have been told and convinced you have to have tumble, ruff intakes and smoother exhaust ports. If you are a believer of that religion.. don’t do it. It’s wrong as you know. Not for you.  Note: I was told the exact same thing btw. I don’t blame you for one second. Maybe…I’m  just a crazy old man. I m now 60 years old. Which f*C*ED with me a bit btw. 

 

I m not here to waste you young pups time or mine. I m not here to debate. I m come to share…and learn too.  I ask questions. Listen, comment on experiences I can speak to first hand etc. I look to learn from others experiences too (key word – experience. Not theory). Doing a bunch of experiments/ trial and error alone sucks. It takes a lot of time. 

 

I’ve been riding since I was 8 years old. I ve been in the technical field in Silicon Valley since I was 24 years old. I have one of those engine-amagoerring degrees from San Jose State in the middle of Silicon Valley (not to mention working on an MBA – I pulled the plug on that after a few semesters because it was useless for me). I have worked in some serious tech companies.  This thread started talking about bearings.. I worked for the company that supplied NSK bearing (Honda’s bearing supplier) the equipment to test their products for flaws as they came off the production line. Timpken bearings used the same products too. I have no need or interest in "convincing" you or anyone else of anything. I could care less what the design software you use says (however I may know folks on the team that wrote that software- and are selling it to you). I come here for fun. I seek no money… I seek no arguments. I do however want to add to the mosaic of information. I do seek to dispel theory’s and ideologies that from experience I have found to be false. There is a lot of misinformation in the world. What matters to me is practical experience. Fuck the degree and what the software models say. Does it work in the real world? That’s the test. Build prototypes. Try it. See if it works. Rince and repeat. No software program will replace real world prototypes. Heck  - why do you thing mfg’er have racing programs? 

 

I will tell you this. If you try it...you will learn something. You will find theory and the real world... are not the same thing. I too heard all the stuff you have written above about ruff surfaces, boundary layers, dimples etc. All that stuff about tumble in the intake track…. Ruff surface finishes on intake to atomize fuel…etc. Ok to smooth out the exhaust but not the intake. That would be very bad. Various models show xyz etc. Wonderful theory. Makes a lazy guy at the computer’s tummy nice and warm. And if you find something that goes counter to theory… do you share it … or keep it to yourself? Procircuit has made some positive 250 CC engine strides as of late (more holeshots). Has Mitch come out and told you what that is? Ask him… see what he has to say. Fact is if you find something  that works - especially if it goes against current theory  - you don't talk about it. 

 

I did what I shared with you. The difference was … noticeable in a very good way. Power came on sooner, smoother, pulled harder. and farther. Easier to ride. Theory is.. just that. Theory. It doesn’t mean shit. 

Mitch hired Ryan Cox, that’s what he did. Ryan is a genius when it comes to building usable power.

SEEMEFIRST
Posts
13974
Joined
8/21/2006
Location
Arlington, TX, USA
8/15/2024 6:12am
PTshox wrote:
And the porn industry has fluffers. You could be... IMO, a fluffer in the dyno industry.You ever worked with Bob Wirth? Run stuff on the dyno...

And the porn industry has fluffers. You could be... IMO, a fluffer in the dyno industry.

You ever worked with Bob Wirth? Run stuff on the dyno he built? 

 

I know.. you know all.. you know more than Bob.. But Shell Oil hires Bob to do dyno work for them when they were developing race gas formulas. Also Yamaha Japan hires him. And KHI ( you may struggle with the initials). As do various F1 teams. Star racing Yamaha as well. If you have run race gas in the last 10 years.. very good chance it was developed on Bob’s dyno. That he custom built. 

 

You don’t even know who he is… you fluffer! LMAO. Clown. 

Is Bob's dyno a "Butt dyno"?

Asking for a friend.

3
1
soggy
Posts
8826
Joined
12/3/2018
Location
USA
8/15/2024 6:57am
FYI, Pivot Works (under the All Balls Group) has become the "Premium" brand of bearings, utilizing 3 different Japanese brands. They're very high quality these days...

FYI, Pivot Works (under the All Balls Group) has become the "Premium" brand of bearings, utilizing 3 different Japanese brands. They're very high quality these days, for those looking for an aftermarket price with OEM quality.

Really?? My past experience they were junk. This was 5 or so years ago. 

3
LungButter
Posts
8684
Joined
1/9/2016
Location
Yellow Pine, ID, USA
8/15/2024 7:48am
LungButter wrote:
PTShox....when you tested this "polished engine theory" how do you know that all variables were exactly the same?Was the moisture content in the dirt exactly the...

PTShox....when you tested this "polished engine theory" how do you know that all variables were exactly the same?

Was the moisture content in the dirt exactly the same?

Was the track prepped the exact same to ensure the same exact traction?

Outside temperature exactly the same?

Brand new tires on the bike each time?

Same fuel from the same batch each time?

Bump.

1
8/15/2024 7:52am
PTshox wrote:
And the porn industry has fluffers. You could be... IMO, a fluffer in the dyno industry.You ever worked with Bob Wirth? Run stuff on the dyno...

And the porn industry has fluffers. You could be... IMO, a fluffer in the dyno industry.

You ever worked with Bob Wirth? Run stuff on the dyno he built? 

 

I know.. you know all.. you know more than Bob.. But Shell Oil hires Bob to do dyno work for them when they were developing race gas formulas. Also Yamaha Japan hires him. And KHI ( you may struggle with the initials). As do various F1 teams. Star racing Yamaha as well. If you have run race gas in the last 10 years.. very good chance it was developed on Bob’s dyno. That he custom built. 

 

You don’t even know who he is… you fluffer! LMAO. Clown. 

SEEMEFIRST wrote:

Is Bob's dyno a "Butt dyno"?

Asking for a friend.

PT, Yeah not alot of people know that. It was a pretty well kept secret. I know ive talked about him in the past. His work is kind of like ron hamp. Not many people know hamps head, pistons and cams were in tomacs mx title bikes over khi, pc and in house. He started working with Star around 07-08 if i remeber ccorrectly which was around the same time they started workin with Dasa. He was heavily iinvolved in the newer generation motor (14+) develpoment as well. Didnt he work with VP when they were updating their motorcycle race fuels and new ones. 

 

See me first: He's a Motor building engineering genuis who had his hands on multiple championship or factory bikes for fun. Nothing pt said is an exaggeration about the guy. Hes done testing for more then just shell oil, othere big corps and many oems in cars, truck and motorcycles. If you know him or are able to get him to help you with anything count yourself lucky. 

Pt is also a lot more knowledgeable then hes getting credit for. I wouldnt doubt to much of what he says when it comes to shit like this. 

Just some observations from a guy whos seen some shit. 

1
3
SEEMEFIRST
Posts
13974
Joined
8/21/2006
Location
Arlington, TX, USA
8/15/2024 8:08am
PT, Yeah not alot of people know that. It was a pretty well kept secret. I know ive talked about him in the past. His work...

PT, Yeah not alot of people know that. It was a pretty well kept secret. I know ive talked about him in the past. His work is kind of like ron hamp. Not many people know hamps head, pistons and cams were in tomacs mx title bikes over khi, pc and in house. He started working with Star around 07-08 if i remeber ccorrectly which was around the same time they started workin with Dasa. He was heavily iinvolved in the newer generation motor (14+) develpoment as well. Didnt he work with VP when they were updating their motorcycle race fuels and new ones. 

 

See me first: He's a Motor building engineering genuis who had his hands on multiple championship or factory bikes for fun. Nothing pt said is an exaggeration about the guy. Hes done testing for more then just shell oil, othere big corps and many oems in cars, truck and motorcycles. If you know him or are able to get him to help you with anything count yourself lucky. 

Pt is also a lot more knowledgeable then hes getting credit for. I wouldnt doubt to much of what he says when it comes to shit like this. 

Just some observations from a guy whos seen some shit. 

Yeah, I wasn't trying to dispairage Bob's accomplishments.

It was just funny to me how PT went from discounting computers to praising them.

A little confused is all 

2
8/15/2024 8:13am
PTshox wrote:
You guys are so smart! Brillant. Just an amazing amount of talent and foresight. Let me ask you... how many computers have you seen riding a dirt...

You guys are so smart! Brillant. Just an amazing amount of talent and foresight. 

Let me ask you... how many computers have you seen riding a dirt bike? How many? What did the computer tell you about how the suspension worked or how the motor performed? 

The guy that taught me this trick... His name is Arnold Plant. He was a MX Pro back in the day from Sacramento. Arnold wrench on the US National Moto/Supercross circuit for several years. He built motors for folks that won National motos and supercross, He also worked for Bob Fox @ Fox shocks. Tell Arnold it can't and doesn't work because of whatever reason you want to come up with. LOL... Armchair quarter backs. 

 

Rickyisms wrote:

All this time spent arguing on vital while you could be revalving suspension and making millions with all that knowledge!

PTshox wrote:

Isn't that your line of business? 

I wouldn't bother with that as a business personally. But for you... maybe a great fit. 

Idk man. You’re the one that told me to build a KYB A-Kit shock for my KTM when all I had asked about was a $120 bladder kit. You seem to know more than all of us combined. Let me know what address to ship my stuff to so you can back up your claims. 

seth505
Posts
10210
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
SD, CA, USA
8/15/2024 11:56am
PTshox wrote:
LOL... you guys are clowns. Probably totally broke too. I have to call “bullshit”on some or all , of your story of speaking to your Professor a...

LOL... you guys are clowns. Probably totally broke too. 

I have to call “bullshit”on some or all , of your story of speaking to your Professor a few hours after the incident . If Boeing already had determined that the rivets were the issue less than 24 hours after it happened, it would have been an all-time fastest investigation conclusion in Aviation history. I think you may have embellished either your timeline …or the body of the conversation a bit. 

Professors name was John Majastead (spelling could be off). I stated what he said to me exactly. 

Make sure to make that turn off the cliff when your GPS tell you too. 

 

OldPro277 wrote:
Soooo....  Since you're an Engineer nonpareil---  explain to me how you were able to determine all of your detractors financial portfolios from just a few posts...

Soooo....  Since you're an Engineer nonpareil---  explain to me how you were able to determine all of your detractors financial portfolios from just a few posts contained in this thread ??   I rescind all of my earlier statements--- you ARE the smartest man alive !!!!!  Bravo 👏

PTshox wrote:
I bow down to you. Clearly you are a brilliant mind. And from your profile photo... Of course Geoff Fox must have invited you to the...

I bow down to you. Clearly you are a brilliant mind. And from your profile photo... Of course Geoff Fox must have invited you to the 50th anniversary party in Cambell Ca last month? Where were you sitting? 

Did you bring a computer? A dyno? 

1) What are you drinking? Is it even sold over the counter in stores?

2) Which Fox family member are you dating?

1
MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
USA
8/16/2024 3:17am
OldTech wrote:

You win man, I'm polishing my engine cases right now!

If they spent more time polishing their cases and less time polishing their shaft they would know if it worked…l

PTshox
Posts
1590
Joined
10/1/2011
Location
Highland Village, TX, USA
8/16/2024 10:49am
Rickyisms wrote:

All this time spent arguing on vital while you could be revalving suspension and making millions with all that knowledge!

PTshox wrote:

Isn't that your line of business? 

I wouldn't bother with that as a business personally. But for you... maybe a great fit. 

Rickyisms wrote:
Idk man. You’re the one that told me to build a KYB A-Kit shock for my KTM when all I had asked about was a $120...

Idk man. You’re the one that told me to build a KYB A-Kit shock for my KTM when all I had asked about was a $120 bladder kit. You seem to know more than all of us combined. Let me know what address to ship my stuff to so you can back up your claims. 

Don't do it... Don't do any of it. It's too hard. Won't work for you. 

 

4
PTshox
Posts
1590
Joined
10/1/2011
Location
Highland Village, TX, USA
8/16/2024 11:16am
PTshox wrote:
And the porn industry has fluffers. You could be... IMO, a fluffer in the dyno industry.You ever worked with Bob Wirth? Run stuff on the dyno...

And the porn industry has fluffers. You could be... IMO, a fluffer in the dyno industry.

You ever worked with Bob Wirth? Run stuff on the dyno he built? 

 

I know.. you know all.. you know more than Bob.. But Shell Oil hires Bob to do dyno work for them when they were developing race gas formulas. Also Yamaha Japan hires him. And KHI ( you may struggle with the initials). As do various F1 teams. Star racing Yamaha as well. If you have run race gas in the last 10 years.. very good chance it was developed on Bob’s dyno. That he custom built. 

 

You don’t even know who he is… you fluffer! LMAO. Clown. 

SEEMEFIRST wrote:

Is Bob's dyno a "Butt dyno"?

Asking for a friend.

PT, Yeah not alot of people know that. It was a pretty well kept secret. I know ive talked about him in the past. His work...

PT, Yeah not alot of people know that. It was a pretty well kept secret. I know ive talked about him in the past. His work is kind of like ron hamp. Not many people know hamps head, pistons and cams were in tomacs mx title bikes over khi, pc and in house. He started working with Star around 07-08 if i remeber ccorrectly which was around the same time they started workin with Dasa. He was heavily iinvolved in the newer generation motor (14+) develpoment as well. Didnt he work with VP when they were updating their motorcycle race fuels and new ones. 

 

See me first: He's a Motor building engineering genuis who had his hands on multiple championship or factory bikes for fun. Nothing pt said is an exaggeration about the guy. Hes done testing for more then just shell oil, othere big corps and many oems in cars, truck and motorcycles. If you know him or are able to get him to help you with anything count yourself lucky. 

Pt is also a lot more knowledgeable then hes getting credit for. I wouldnt doubt to much of what he says when it comes to shit like this. 

Just some observations from a guy whos seen some shit. 

Thanks. I have talked to Bob W. He's from the same town I am from. I know a few of his very good friends. Bob told me some of this information I shared directly.  There is some I didn't share..And I talked to Bob about polishing cases in the intake track . I asked him what he thought was going on.... Because it goes against conventional wisdom. He told me his take on what he thinks is happing -  which I'll keep to myself. I don't want to burst the dyno guys and the theory's guys all knowing  knowledge (LOL) )   And I used to talk talk to Ron Hamp all the time. I ran his heads and coated valves on a CRF250 bigbore in 2005-2008. He was just awesome to work with and talk to. Hands on guy that was real.. and used real world data. It's a real shame he never got the attention he deserved. I miss that guy a lot! Very few realize how much knowledge he had (although some industry folks did). He used to have a guy Rouch racing used weld up intake port floors so he could reshape them and get the angle of the air flow down onto the valve at the angle he wanted.  I have a Yamaha 250F I m about to do some work to and if Ron was around it would be headed to him. 

One guy has a clue here.. those are not good numbers....

 

9
8/16/2024 12:03pm
PTshox wrote:
Thanks. I have talked to Bob W. He's from the same town I am from. I know a few of his very good friends. Bob told...

Thanks. I have talked to Bob W. He's from the same town I am from. I know a few of his very good friends. Bob told me some of this information I shared directly.  There is some I didn't share..And I talked to Bob about polishing cases in the intake track . I asked him what he thought was going on.... Because it goes against conventional wisdom. He told me his take on what he thinks is happing -  which I'll keep to myself. I don't want to burst the dyno guys and the theory's guys all knowing  knowledge (LOL) )   And I used to talk talk to Ron Hamp all the time. I ran his heads and coated valves on a CRF250 bigbore in 2005-2008. He was just awesome to work with and talk to. Hands on guy that was real.. and used real world data. It's a real shame he never got the attention he deserved. I miss that guy a lot! Very few realize how much knowledge he had (although some industry folks did). He used to have a guy Rouch racing used weld up intake port floors so he could reshape them and get the angle of the air flow down onto the valve at the angle he wanted.  I have a Yamaha 250F I m about to do some work to and if Ron was around it would be headed to him. 

One guy has a clue here.. those are not good numbers....

 

Thats the thing some things work but don't make perfect sense. Ive seen things that are identical perform ccompletely different from each other and both different one better, one worse then the data model predicted. Nothing on specs or in the data measured different. Same same but not the same. Kinda like dimples you always hear they dont work but i know a few motors that had them in there. No they don't work for every aapplication but I'v seen them work when they said they shouldn't.  

 

Man I miss Santa Claus. The best thing about him is if you were genuinely intreste in learning he was happy to show you and explain the whys and hows as he understood them.

Brian Truesdale is another guy whos really and under the radar guy who does amazing work. He was gonna teach me the ins and outs but at that time i had to double down on my business. Might have to see if i can revistit that with him one day.

 

Theres alot of guys that have a clue they just dont post as much as they use to to avoide some of vitals bs. Look at williams, and harris they use to post all the time and barley do now. Im waiting for the day billy at luxon gives up to lol.

 

2
PTshox
Posts
1590
Joined
10/1/2011
Location
Highland Village, TX, USA
8/16/2024 12:58pm

 

"Thats the thing some things work but don't make perfect sense. Ive seen things that are identical perform ccompletely different from each other and both different one better, one worse then the data model predicted. Nothing on specs or in the data measured different. Same same but not the same. Kinda like dimples you always hear they dont work but i know a few motors that had them in there. No they don't work for every aapplication but I'v seen them work when they said they shouldn't."

 

Totally 100% agree. That's why when I see/hear someone say "the computer model says xyz"... or the data says,, bgf... or the theory says wxf...

Does it work? That's what matters. Does it work? From there you can reverse engineer it and try to figure out the why. You won't always get there. There are still lots of  unknowns as to the "why" stuff works. 

How do you know about Bob? Not a lot know just how good he is and what he does. Certainly not the general public. I talked to guys that went to grade school with him and he was doing wild stuff to mini bikes as a very young kid. Jim Regar was the same. 

Shell spent a LOT of $ to build a sister to Bob's self built dyno though. 

6

Post a reply to: Engine Builders or Moto Dads who do the work their own, what bearings do you use?!

The Latest