ESPN Top 100 athletes of 21 century - no MX rider?

stewie94
Posts
4673
Joined
2/25/2013
Location
La Plata, MD US
7/22/2024 2:48am
stewie94 wrote:
IMG 5826 2

Wilt Chamberlain....

wilt was ahead of his time but I can make a case tht wilt under pure athleticism not even top 5 nba player all time , hell even “accomplishments” rarely anybody got him in the top 5 

wreckitrandy
Posts
4204
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Granite Falls, NC US
7/22/2024 6:00am Edited Date/Time 7/22/2024 6:18am
stewie94 wrote:
IMG 5826 2

Wilt Chamberlain....

stewie94 wrote:
wilt was ahead of his time but I can make a case tht wilt under pure athleticism not even top 5 nba player all time...

wilt was ahead of his time but I can make a case tht wilt under pure athleticism not even top 5 nba player all time , hell even “accomplishments” rarely anybody got him in the top 5 

Everything Sharpe claimed, Wilt was more of it. 

wreckitrandy
Posts
4204
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Granite Falls, NC US
7/22/2024 6:06am
Sandusky26 wrote:

Rugby is a game.

A shitty game.

I don't care for it either but, them's some rough individuals. ARF, to me is a cool game. Same deal, just rough as all get out but, higher scoring. The NFL don't need me for a fan.

1
stewie94
Posts
4673
Joined
2/25/2013
Location
La Plata, MD US
7/22/2024 6:18am

Wilt Chamberlain....

stewie94 wrote:
wilt was ahead of his time but I can make a case tht wilt under pure athleticism not even top 5 nba player all time...

wilt was ahead of his time but I can make a case tht wilt under pure athleticism not even top 5 nba player all time , hell even “accomplishments” rarely anybody got him in the top 5 

Everything Sharpe claimed, Wilt was more of it. 

yal goona have to show me some other film of wilt cause I ain’t see it as far as having more of it 

The Shop

Moto Braap
Posts
1219
Joined
6/28/2019
Location
Honolulu, HI US
7/22/2024 9:19am
moto111 wrote:

American football is not a sport, its a show. 

If football is a show is that why they wear mascara eye makeup and then what are the show commercials called?  

They want you to go out and buy game day snacks and have parties over while watching people get their helmets blown off from tackles that give 10 yard penalties.

1
LoudLove
Posts
2807
Joined
7/16/2010
Location
US
7/22/2024 10:38am Edited Date/Time 7/22/2024 10:44am

Success at MX takes extreme stamina, fantastic coordination, and dogged determination. No one is denying that. 

What MX lacks is “depth at position”. It’s a niche sport with a high cost-of-entry.  The gates are filled with white suburban kids who likely would not excel at stick & ball or track & field.   Being tremendously athletic and being a great athlete are not the same. 

Anyone earning a living at football, basketball, etc. competed against thousands, maybe tens of thousands, of people.  Almost all high schools provide students with the ability to participate in a variety of sports, creating a very deep gene pool.   It’s the exact opposite for MX or any motorized sport. 

Suffice to say that if MX were as accessible as school sponsored sports, no one on the gate today would have a ride. 

1
NateDawg241
Posts
595
Joined
1/19/2024
Location
Duluth, GA US
7/22/2024 11:15am

Anyone can build stamina and endurance. Not everyone can be explosive, fast, strong.  

Lol, ok then I challenge you to qualify for the 2028 Olympic marathon. You said ANYONE can build stamina and endurance so there's no excuses. You got 4 years to get it done, better start training now

And gotta love how you ignored the part I said about having elite reflexes and hand-eye coordination 

1
yzr250r
Posts
41
Joined
8/16/2020
Location
Douglas, WY US
7/22/2024 1:36pm

Here is another way to look at athleticism. Pro motocross/supercross riders crash once in a while and almost every time, get up, get back on the bike like nothing happened. Take that 350lb football player and the first MX/SX obstacle they hit and crash on, they would be lucky to just break bones but most likely would never walk or maybe even breath again. That is just one obstacle and it would be even worse if they somehow managed not to die and made it to the 30 minute mark exhausted and then crashed. 350lbs and gravity do not mix well!

1
LoudLove
Posts
2807
Joined
7/16/2010
Location
US
7/22/2024 2:21pm
yzr250r wrote:
Here is another way to look at athleticism. Pro motocross/supercross riders crash once in a while and almost every time, get up, get back on the...

Here is another way to look at athleticism. Pro motocross/supercross riders crash once in a while and almost every time, get up, get back on the bike like nothing happened. Take that 350lb football player and the first MX/SX obstacle they hit and crash on, they would be lucky to just break bones but most likely would never walk or maybe even breath again. That is just one obstacle and it would be even worse if they somehow managed not to die and made it to the 30 minute mark exhausted and then crashed. 350lbs and gravity do not mix well!

Now take Haiden Deegan and put him on the D-line of an NFL team. How would that turn out?  Oh, and Deegs needs to line up for 25-40 plays.  There would be little left of Dangerboy after a single series, much less an entire game. 

 

1
1
MarkyMark
Posts
27
Joined
4/4/2024
Location
Edmonton, AB CA
7/22/2024 2:35pm

My take: 

Baseball players - not athletes, and not required to be athletic but can be. 

Football players - not athletes, and not required to be athletic but can be. Typical actual play time for NFL game is 11-13mins. No endurance required. Just need really big/fat dudes to hold the line and small fast dudes to run and catch a ball, and 1 or 2 guys who can throw a ball. 

Basketball players - very athletic but limited in disciplines due to size.  

MX'rs - top athletes. Can crossover into many other disciplines. Eg. David Bailey after suffering paralysis competed in Ironman Triathlon. Right out the gate finished 3rd. That's how fit they are. 

2
5
NateDawg241
Posts
595
Joined
1/19/2024
Location
Duluth, GA US
7/22/2024 2:42pm
LoudLove wrote:
Now take Haiden Deegan and put him on the D-line of an NFL team. How would that turn out?  Oh, and Deegs needs to line up...

Now take Haiden Deegan and put him on the D-line of an NFL team. How would that turn out?  Oh, and Deegs needs to line up for 25-40 plays.  There would be little left of Dangerboy after a single series, much less an entire game. 

 

It's almost like they compete in different sports that require different athletic attributes and skills...

3
LoudLove
Posts
2807
Joined
7/16/2010
Location
US
7/22/2024 2:56pm
LoudLove wrote:
Now take Haiden Deegan and put him on the D-line of an NFL team. How would that turn out?  Oh, and Deegs needs to line up...

Now take Haiden Deegan and put him on the D-line of an NFL team. How would that turn out?  Oh, and Deegs needs to line up for 25-40 plays.  There would be little left of Dangerboy after a single series, much less an entire game. 

 

It's almost like they compete in different sports that require different athletic attributes and skills...

Exactly. We all know MX is hard. Just like trying to move a 300 lb O-lineman is hard. Or hitting a round ball with a round bat is hard.

wreckitrandy
Posts
4204
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Granite Falls, NC US
7/22/2024 3:15pm
LoudLove wrote:
Now take Haiden Deegan and put him on the D-line of an NFL team. How would that turn out?  Oh, and Deegs needs to line up...

Now take Haiden Deegan and put him on the D-line of an NFL team. How would that turn out?  Oh, and Deegs needs to line up for 25-40 plays.  There would be little left of Dangerboy after a single series, much less an entire game. 

 

It's almost like they compete in different sports that require different athletic attributes and skills...

LoudLove wrote:
Exactly. We all know MX is hard. Just like trying to move a 300 lb O-lineman is hard. Or hitting a round ball with a round...

Exactly. We all know MX is hard. Just like trying to move a 300 lb O-lineman is hard. Or hitting a round ball with a round bat is hard.

Which would you say happens first, Deegs hit's a baseball or, 300 pound NFL lineman hits a double jump?

2
-MAVERICK-
Posts
65852
Joined
3/26/2015
Location
Ontario CA
7/22/2024 3:46pm

Which would you say happens first, Deegs hit's a baseball or, 300 pound NFL lineman hits a double jump?

Hitting a baseball from a MLB pitcher is not as easy as you think. This guy has a baseball background. 

1
wreckitrandy
Posts
4204
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Granite Falls, NC US
7/22/2024 3:46pm
stewie94 wrote:
wilt was ahead of his time but I can make a case tht wilt under pure athleticism not even top 5 nba player all time...

wilt was ahead of his time but I can make a case tht wilt under pure athleticism not even top 5 nba player all time , hell even “accomplishments” rarely anybody got him in the top 5 

Everything Sharpe claimed, Wilt was more of it. 

stewie94 wrote:

yal goona have to show me some other film of wilt cause I ain’t see it as far as having more of it 

There's all sorts of video on youtube about Wilt. As far as the 'numbers' go, you do realize that if you take Jordan's, Kobe's, LeBron's and probably several more high profile player's statistical league records and put them together, Wilt still has twice as many? 

Wilt could, touch the top of the backboard. Bench press over 500 pounds. Outrun Jim Brown in the 40. Played every minute of every game except one, for a whole season. HOF in two professional sports. And did it all without oxygen or steroids.

2
wreckitrandy
Posts
4204
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Granite Falls, NC US
7/22/2024 4:02pm

Which would you say happens first, Deegs hit's a baseball or, 300 pound NFL lineman hits a double jump?

-MAVERICK- wrote:

Hitting a baseball from a MLB pitcher is not as easy as you think. This guy has a baseball background. 

Never said it was easy. Just asked a question. I'll ask it again. Which happens first, Deegs hits a baseball or, 300 pound lineman hits a double? AND, if Deegs has to hit a MLB pitcher, said lineman has to hit the finish line double at a SX. You and I both know the answer. 

1
stewie94
Posts
4673
Joined
2/25/2013
Location
La Plata, MD US
7/22/2024 4:09pm
MarkyMark wrote:
My take: Baseball players - not athletes, and not required to be athletic but can be. Football players - not athletes, and not required to be athletic but...

My take: 

Baseball players - not athletes, and not required to be athletic but can be. 

Football players - not athletes, and not required to be athletic but can be. Typical actual play time for NFL game is 11-13mins. No endurance required. Just need really big/fat dudes to hold the line and small fast dudes to run and catch a ball, and 1 or 2 guys who can throw a ball. 

Basketball players - very athletic but limited in disciplines due to size.  

MX'rs - top athletes. Can crossover into many other disciplines. Eg. David Bailey after suffering paralysis competed in Ironman Triathlon. Right out the gate finished 3rd. That's how fit they are. 

bruh…. thts all I got to say 

1
stewie94
Posts
4673
Joined
2/25/2013
Location
La Plata, MD US
7/22/2024 4:12pm

Everything Sharpe claimed, Wilt was more of it. 

stewie94 wrote:

yal goona have to show me some other film of wilt cause I ain’t see it as far as having more of it 

There's all sorts of video on youtube about Wilt. As far as the 'numbers' go, you do realize that if you take Jordan's, Kobe's, LeBron's and...

There's all sorts of video on youtube about Wilt. As far as the 'numbers' go, you do realize that if you take Jordan's, Kobe's, LeBron's and probably several more high profile player's statistical league records and put them together, Wilt still has twice as many? 

Wilt could, touch the top of the backboard. Bench press over 500 pounds. Outrun Jim Brown in the 40. Played every minute of every game except one, for a whole season. HOF in two professional sports. And did it all without oxygen or steroids.

ima get back to the film room & really pay attention to see wht I missed out on 👍🏾 

2
h20
Posts
532
Joined
6/24/2023
Location
San Diego , CA US
7/22/2024 4:16pm
Mavetism wrote:
ESPN just released their Top 100 athletes of 21 century list. We all know our sport is small and niche, so it's probably not a surprise...

ESPN just released their Top 100 athletes of 21 century list. We all know our sport is small and niche, so it's probably not a surprise to see no MX/SX rider on that list. I think the only ESPN article about MX/SX I've seen so far was about Jett Lawrence..

The List: https://www.espn.com/espn/story/_/id/40446224/top-100-athletes-21st-century

 

Apart from the fact that this list is questionable, where would YOU personally rank in riders like RC/Cairoli/JS7/RV etc on that list against the other top athletes?

I hate polls, so maybe write about what riders do you think deserve to be on that list and where you'd rank them eventually?

It’s MX Sports own fault motocross isn’t more popular. Look how much goes into promoting the UFC.  And that company / sport/ Sports league was created in 1993.  Motocross and Supercross have a 20 year head start on MMA.  I think there needs to be a Netflix documentary or something to introduce fans to the sport.  I personally don’t know anyone that follows Motocross than never rode a dirt bike.  MX needs exposure to the casual fanbase.  That what made MMA/UFC popular, the reality show literally took UFC out of a 40 million dollar debt to a money printing MACHINE.  Supercross can do the same. 

Moto Braap
Posts
1219
Joined
6/28/2019
Location
Honolulu, HI US
7/22/2024 10:39pm Edited Date/Time 7/22/2024 10:56pm

Which would you say happens first, Deegs hit's a baseball or, 300 pound NFL lineman hits a double jump?

-MAVERICK- wrote:

Hitting a baseball from a MLB pitcher is not as easy as you think. This guy has a baseball background. 

I wasn’t a big fan of Brady seeing a lot of screen passes but he had some big plays and he almost went for pro baseball career instead of football when he was down in the draft.  He wore the eye makeup for baseball too:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom_Brady

https://610kona.com/tom-brady-was-almost-a-major-league-baseball-star/
 

Moto Braap
Posts
1219
Joined
6/28/2019
Location
Honolulu, HI US
7/22/2024 10:52pm
stewie94 wrote:

yal goona have to show me some other film of wilt cause I ain’t see it as far as having more of it 

There's all sorts of video on youtube about Wilt. As far as the 'numbers' go, you do realize that if you take Jordan's, Kobe's, LeBron's and...

There's all sorts of video on youtube about Wilt. As far as the 'numbers' go, you do realize that if you take Jordan's, Kobe's, LeBron's and probably several more high profile player's statistical league records and put them together, Wilt still has twice as many? 

Wilt could, touch the top of the backboard. Bench press over 500 pounds. Outrun Jim Brown in the 40. Played every minute of every game except one, for a whole season. HOF in two professional sports. And did it all without oxygen or steroids.

stewie94 wrote:

ima get back to the film room & really pay attention to see wht I missed out on 👍🏾 

Moto Braap
Posts
1219
Joined
6/28/2019
Location
Honolulu, HI US
7/22/2024 11:15pm Edited Date/Time 7/22/2024 11:19pm

If we are talking terminology to compare:

Stewart was the “Tiger Woods of Motocross”.

If Brady is the “GOAT” of football they should include the “GOAT” of MX Carmichael.

If Mike Trout was a “Generational” player we could include ours like Jett or our newest forum friend Deegan.

Phelps is an Olympics hero, who led us to the most medals?

Herr Lich
Posts
2568
Joined
7/11/2023
Location
Sydney, NSW AU
7/23/2024 2:10am
Mavetism wrote:
ESPN just released their Top 100 athletes of 21 century list. We all know our sport is small and niche, so it's probably not a surprise...

ESPN just released their Top 100 athletes of 21 century list. We all know our sport is small and niche, so it's probably not a surprise to see no MX/SX rider on that list. I think the only ESPN article about MX/SX I've seen so far was about Jett Lawrence..

The List: https://www.espn.com/espn/story/_/id/40446224/top-100-athletes-21st-century

 

Apart from the fact that this list is questionable, where would YOU personally rank in riders like RC/Cairoli/JS7/RV etc on that list against the other top athletes?

I hate polls, so maybe write about what riders do you think deserve to be on that list and where you'd rank them eventually?

h20 wrote:
It’s MX Sports own fault motocross isn’t more popular. Look how much goes into promoting the UFC.  And that company / sport/ Sports league was created...

It’s MX Sports own fault motocross isn’t more popular. Look how much goes into promoting the UFC.  And that company / sport/ Sports league was created in 1993.  Motocross and Supercross have a 20 year head start on MMA.  I think there needs to be a Netflix documentary or something to introduce fans to the sport.  I personally don’t know anyone that follows Motocross than never rode a dirt bike.  MX needs exposure to the casual fanbase.  That what made MMA/UFC popular, the reality show literally took UFC out of a 40 million dollar debt to a money printing MACHINE.  Supercross can do the same. 

Hey Gypsy Bro, I didn't know this was your account. Welcome to Vital. 

2
7/23/2024 2:22am

This is what i think of when you say American Football ......

 

image 235
LoudLove
Posts
2807
Joined
7/16/2010
Location
US
7/23/2024 4:23am

Which would you say happens first, Deegs hit's a baseball or, 300 pound NFL lineman hits a double jump?

-MAVERICK- wrote:

Hitting a baseball from a MLB pitcher is not as easy as you think. This guy has a baseball background. 

Never said it was easy. Just asked a question. I'll ask it again. Which happens first, Deegs hits a baseball or, 300 pound lineman hits a...

Never said it was easy. Just asked a question. I'll ask it again. Which happens first, Deegs hits a baseball or, 300 pound lineman hits a double? AND, if Deegs has to hit a MLB pitcher, said lineman has to hit the finish line double at a SX. You and I both know the answer. 

Easy.  Clearing the double. Of course a 300 lb lineman would require a highly customized bike, but once he had practiced the basics, clearing a jump is mainly a timing issue. Change it to Larocco’s Leap and there’s a different answer. 

The best pros in the MLB struggle to hit .300. Nearly all can make contact at will, but successfully reaching base is the objective, just as clearing the jump is the objective.  Underrating professional baseball players’ athleticism fails to take into account the tremendously competitive world in which these guys exist. 

Let’s extrapolate the scenario and assume today’s MX pros were fielding pro baseball or basketball teams. Without other competitors we would consider these guys the best in the world.  Expand the gene pool to who actually competes and we soon realize our MX heroes lack certain  genetic gifts.  And when you consider that thousands of pro stick & ball athletes fall just outside the top tier, it’s not a reach to think those same athletes could transcend motocross if given the opportunity.  It’s simple statistics. 

1
AMetts
Posts
1165
Joined
6/15/2022
Location
Lincolnton, NC US
7/23/2024 5:54am
LoudLove wrote:
Success at MX takes extreme stamina, fantastic coordination, and dogged determination. No one is denying that. What MX lacks is “depth at position”. It’s a niche sport...

Success at MX takes extreme stamina, fantastic coordination, and dogged determination. No one is denying that. 

What MX lacks is “depth at position”. It’s a niche sport with a high cost-of-entry.  The gates are filled with white suburban kids who likely would not excel at stick & ball or track & field.   Being tremendously athletic and being a great athlete are not the same. 

Anyone earning a living at football, basketball, etc. competed against thousands, maybe tens of thousands, of people.  Almost all high schools provide students with the ability to participate in a variety of sports, creating a very deep gene pool.   It’s the exact opposite for MX or any motorized sport. 

Suffice to say that if MX were as accessible as school sponsored sports, no one on the gate today would have a ride. 

This is always the argument I try to make when people compare MX to mainstream sports. There is literally at least a million kids playing high school football, most suck but the very best get picked every year and if they make it on a team they will get replaced at the first sign of struggle.The genetic freaks and only the most talented guys will rise to the top. 

I know this an MX forum but some guys in here act like the NFL is not athletic are out of their mind. 

wreckitrandy
Posts
4204
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Granite Falls, NC US
7/23/2024 7:28am
-MAVERICK- wrote:

Hitting a baseball from a MLB pitcher is not as easy as you think. This guy has a baseball background. 

Never said it was easy. Just asked a question. I'll ask it again. Which happens first, Deegs hits a baseball or, 300 pound lineman hits a...

Never said it was easy. Just asked a question. I'll ask it again. Which happens first, Deegs hits a baseball or, 300 pound lineman hits a double? AND, if Deegs has to hit a MLB pitcher, said lineman has to hit the finish line double at a SX. You and I both know the answer. 

LoudLove wrote:
Easy.  Clearing the double. Of course a 300 lb lineman would require a highly customized bike, but once he had practiced the basics, clearing a jump...

Easy.  Clearing the double. Of course a 300 lb lineman would require a highly customized bike, but once he had practiced the basics, clearing a jump is mainly a timing issue. Change it to Larocco’s Leap and there’s a different answer. 

The best pros in the MLB struggle to hit .300. Nearly all can make contact at will, but successfully reaching base is the objective, just as clearing the jump is the objective.  Underrating professional baseball players’ athleticism fails to take into account the tremendously competitive world in which these guys exist. 

Let’s extrapolate the scenario and assume today’s MX pros were fielding pro baseball or basketball teams. Without other competitors we would consider these guys the best in the world.  Expand the gene pool to who actually competes and we soon realize our MX heroes lack certain  genetic gifts.  And when you consider that thousands of pro stick & ball athletes fall just outside the top tier, it’s not a reach to think those same athletes could transcend motocross if given the opportunity.  It’s simple statistics. 

Easy peasy.... Yeah, it's all about timing. Hand eye coordination. Same as hitting a baseball. Except if you miss... Strike one or,,,, bamalance ride. 

1
SEEMEFIRST
Posts
13665
Joined
8/21/2006
Location
Arlington, TX US
7/23/2024 8:00am

"Football players - not athletes, and not required to be athletic but can be. Typical actual play time for NFL game is 11-13mins. No endurance required. Just need really big/fat dudes to hold the line and small fast dudes to run and catch a ball, and 1 or 2 guys who can throw a ball."

Go take this guy on for 10 minutes and get back to us. He's quick, fast, strong, and smart.

https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_image/image/72965621/usa_today_21976111.0.jpg 

MarkyMark
Posts
27
Joined
4/4/2024
Location
Edmonton, AB CA
7/23/2024 8:46am
SEEMEFIRST wrote:
"Football players - not athletes, and not required to be athletic but can be. Typical actual play time for NFL game is 11-13mins. No endurance required...

"Football players - not athletes, and not required to be athletic but can be. Typical actual play time for NFL game is 11-13mins. No endurance required. Just need really big/fat dudes to hold the line and small fast dudes to run and catch a ball, and 1 or 2 guys who can throw a ball."

Go take this guy on for 10 minutes and get back to us. He's quick, fast, strong, and smart.

https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_image/image/72965621/usa_today_21976111.0.jpg 

Didn't say they couldn't be...........did I?

SEEMEFIRST
Posts
13665
Joined
8/21/2006
Location
Arlington, TX US
7/23/2024 9:56am
SEEMEFIRST wrote:
"Football players - not athletes, and not required to be athletic but can be. Typical actual play time for NFL game is 11-13mins. No endurance required...

"Football players - not athletes, and not required to be athletic but can be. Typical actual play time for NFL game is 11-13mins. No endurance required. Just need really big/fat dudes to hold the line and small fast dudes to run and catch a ball, and 1 or 2 guys who can throw a ball."

Go take this guy on for 10 minutes and get back to us. He's quick, fast, strong, and smart.

https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_image/image/72965621/usa_today_21976111.0.jpg 

MarkyMark wrote:

Didn't say they couldn't be...........did I?

First 2 words?

Post a reply to: ESPN Top 100 athletes of 21 century - no MX rider?

The Latest