Engineers and/or metallurgists. Luxon?

motoxfmx27
Posts
91
Joined
7/17/2017
Location
Van Buren, AR, USA

Luxon, if you see this, please reply. I look forward to your input.

I'm in the process of rebuilding my CRF50 I built way back in the mid/late 2000s when pit bike racing was huge. I want to sand and mirror polish the swingarm before I have it anodized. The swingarm has a few light gouges in it. I really want to fill the gouges before I sand the swingarm.

The swingarm was machined out of a huge slab of 6061. There isn't a single weld on it from the manufacturer. The swingarm is very rare and hasn't been made for well over a decade. Needless to say, I can't and don't want to cause any damage or loss of strength to it due to heat if I don't have to.

I can't TIG myself. The aluminum brazing rods I looked at say the base metal needs to be heated to 730 degrees in order to melt the rods. Is that not way too hot for aluminum if strength loss is a concern? I really want to fill the gouges, but I will just sand the high spots if TIGing or the brazing rods can't be an appropriate fix.

Thank you.30351154772055.jpg?VersionId=GGnLTA6Tv.J7.9Occk.aunWcyZV

 30351155030311

 30351155042362.jpg?VersionId=0u31CPA1V1vKfQs9j2jH5

 

|
Luxon MX
Posts
1402
Joined
11/6/2017
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
4/3/2023 7:25pm

You can weld 6061-T6 and it will age to the T4 condition over time (a few weeks), which is fairly strong. If it's not in a critical spot, then I wouldn't worry about it.

But if you're anodizing it, you need to be careful. Brazing rod wouldn't work as it won't take the anodize (I think it's zinc). You'd have to weld it. And if you weld it, the weld will anodize a different color  (or just darker/lighter) than the base material. Using 5356 filler rod instead of 4043 is supposed to minimize the difference, but you're still going to notice it. 6061 filler isn't an option as it will just crack at the weld. Black anodize will be less noticeable, but you'll probably still see it. 

If you can blend out the gouges and not weld anything, that's the way to go. A bead blasted texture will make the blends less noticeable. Polishing will make every imperfection show clearly. Hope this helps, good luck!

3
96motorhead
Posts
78
Joined
6/17/2021
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
4/4/2023 6:49pm

Have a competent TIG welder fill the gouges with 5356. I built some aluminum brackets from scratch a few years ago which required two 2" long welds each. I used the 5356 filler and had them black anodized, there was no difference between the filler and parent material color, it was a perfect match.

1
Luxon MX
Posts
1402
Joined
11/6/2017
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
4/4/2023 7:03pm
Have a competent TIG welder fill the gouges with 5356. I built some aluminum brackets from scratch a few years ago which required two 2" long...

Have a competent TIG welder fill the gouges with 5356. I built some aluminum brackets from scratch a few years ago which required two 2" long welds each. I used the 5356 filler and had them black anodized, there was no difference between the filler and parent material color, it was a perfect match.

What were the brackets made from? If they were sheet metal, odds are they were 5052, so 5356 would be a good match.

But if the brackets were 6061 and the anodized still matched with the 5356 filler, then that may be a good option. 

96motorhead
Posts
78
Joined
6/17/2021
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
4/4/2023 7:39pm
Have a competent TIG welder fill the gouges with 5356. I built some aluminum brackets from scratch a few years ago which required two 2" long...

Have a competent TIG welder fill the gouges with 5356. I built some aluminum brackets from scratch a few years ago which required two 2" long welds each. I used the 5356 filler and had them black anodized, there was no difference between the filler and parent material color, it was a perfect match.

Luxon MX wrote:
What were the brackets made from? If they were sheet metal, odds are they were 5052, so 5356 would be a good match. But if the...

What were the brackets made from? If they were sheet metal, odds are they were 5052, so 5356 would be a good match.

But if the brackets were 6061 and the anodized still matched with the 5356 filler, then that may be a good option. 

The brackets I made used 6061. I'm looking back at a picture I took right before I sent the brackets off to anodize and I can tell a slight variation in color between the raw aluminum and the 5356 filler. I don't have a picture of the anodized welds but I remember thinking they came out way better than I expected after anodize. If the weld was a slightly different color then I can't see how the anodize would match. I have another set of 2 piece anodized black brackets that were welded together in storage. I can try to dig them out and check those.

1

The Shop

TK40_FC
Posts
682
Joined
5/17/2021
Location
Canton, OH, USA
4/5/2023 9:17am

Since you're mainly concerned with blending out cosmetic blemishes, I recommend trying to mechanically polish them out using red 3M scotchbrite pads on an angle grinder and/or die grinder. These are not aggressive enough to remove material like a sanding disc might, but are abrasive enough to blend out blemishes with adjustments in pressure. I've never used them on aluminum, so start with less pressure and slowly apply more once you get a feel for how its manipulating the piece, but I've had alot of great results when using them on car restorations and sheetmetal fab. At a minimum, it'd be worth trying before you resort to welding. 

1
motoxfmx27
Posts
91
Joined
7/17/2017
Location
Van Buren, AR, USA
4/6/2023 11:12pm Edited Date/Time 4/6/2023 11:13pm
Luxon MX wrote:
You can weld 6061-T6 and it will age to the T4 condition over time (a few weeks), which is fairly strong. If it's not in a...

You can weld 6061-T6 and it will age to the T4 condition over time (a few weeks), which is fairly strong. If it's not in a critical spot, then I wouldn't worry about it.

But if you're anodizing it, you need to be careful. Brazing rod wouldn't work as it won't take the anodize (I think it's zinc). You'd have to weld it. And if you weld it, the weld will anodize a different color  (or just darker/lighter) than the base material. Using 5356 filler rod instead of 4043 is supposed to minimize the difference, but you're still going to notice it. 6061 filler isn't an option as it will just crack at the weld. Black anodize will be less noticeable, but you'll probably still see it. 

If you can blend out the gouges and not weld anything, that's the way to go. A bead blasted texture will make the blends less noticeable. Polishing will make every imperfection show clearly. Hope this helps, good luck!

Billy, thank you for responding and the information you bring to the forum. I'll try to make this short.

Of the 3 options I have of blending, welding, or sanding the high spots, I most want to fill the gouges with weld. However, I don't want to lose any hardness/strength due to welding. The underside of the swingarm (pictured below) is machined out. The outside walls and all the walls of the machined pockets are 3.3mm thick. The gouges aren't super deep, but they are easily caught with my fingernails. If I were to blend the gouges out, considering the depth of the gouges, I feel like I would be removing a bit too much from already thin material.

To my next point...welding and heat treating back to T6. I've found a local fabricator that will fill the gouges. I called a few local-ish (closest is 1.5 hours away) heat treating companies Thursday. Two of the three told me they can do it, but I was told distortion/warpage could occur. I'm not going to have any welding done on the swingarm until I take it to the closest treatment company and find out what they think after seeing it in person. I'll ask the treatment company when I go, but what are my options for keeping the swingarm straight if I can get it heat treated? If it's even an option, all I can think of is to figure out a way to have the pivot and axle bolts in place at the time of heat treating.

I'm bad about overthinking and making something simple difficult. I should probably just get some scotchbrite wheels like mentioned, smooth the high spots, and call it good enough.

​​​Thank you.

IMG 1777

 

Luxon MX
Posts
1402
Joined
11/6/2017
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
4/7/2023 7:29am
motoxfmx27 wrote:
Billy, thank you for responding and the information you bring to the forum. I'll try to make this short. Of the 3 options I have of blending...

Billy, thank you for responding and the information you bring to the forum. I'll try to make this short.

Of the 3 options I have of blending, welding, or sanding the high spots, I most want to fill the gouges with weld. However, I don't want to lose any hardness/strength due to welding. The underside of the swingarm (pictured below) is machined out. The outside walls and all the walls of the machined pockets are 3.3mm thick. The gouges aren't super deep, but they are easily caught with my fingernails. If I were to blend the gouges out, considering the depth of the gouges, I feel like I would be removing a bit too much from already thin material.

To my next point...welding and heat treating back to T6. I've found a local fabricator that will fill the gouges. I called a few local-ish (closest is 1.5 hours away) heat treating companies Thursday. Two of the three told me they can do it, but I was told distortion/warpage could occur. I'm not going to have any welding done on the swingarm until I take it to the closest treatment company and find out what they think after seeing it in person. I'll ask the treatment company when I go, but what are my options for keeping the swingarm straight if I can get it heat treated? If it's even an option, all I can think of is to figure out a way to have the pivot and axle bolts in place at the time of heat treating.

I'm bad about overthinking and making something simple difficult. I should probably just get some scotchbrite wheels like mentioned, smooth the high spots, and call it good enough.

​​​Thank you.

IMG 1777

 

The right move really depends on a few factors:

Where are the gouges? If they're in low stress locations, then it doesn't matter how they're fixed so much as if they are in high-stress locations. 

What's the strength of the initial design? Is the swingarm so well designed/optimized that it's on the verge of breaking everywhere save for some margin of safety? I can tell by looking at it that it's most definitely not. They just machined to the outer perimeter and hollowed out the bottom with big rectangular pockets. It's actually a rather poor design from a structural standpoint! But if it's held up, then we know it's "good enough" from a strength perspective. So there are definitely spots that are over designed and have a lot of margin. So reducing strength in those areas isn't a big deal. 

6061-T6 has a yield strength of 276 MPa and T4 has a yield of 145 MPa. So it's nearly half the strength without heat treatment to T6. But that 145 may be strong enough in the welded areas. A good welder will pre-heat the whole thing, then minimize time in the weld to minimize the heat input so the low strength areas are minimized. 

Heat treatment will likely warp things to some extent. You might be able to design a jig to help hold things in position during heat treatment, but the typical method is to heat treat without and re-align things after to a jig. This is A LOT of work for a one-off piece.

What's your overall budget for doing this? If you were to clean this up, fill all the gouges with proper welding, smooth them back to nominal, heat treat the whole thing, re-align it using some sort of jig, then anodize it, that gets pretty expensive and a lot of work. You might consider having it re-made by a machine shop. That's also expensive, but you'll have no strength or alignment issues and the anodize will come out great.

If it were me, I'd take one of two options:

1) Blend the gouges, clean it up really well, anodize it, and be done with it

2) Same as #1, but weld the deep gouges with the 5356 filler first (with minimal heat input)

I wouldn't bother with heat treatment at all and just risk the strength issues.

Post a reply to: Engineers and/or metallurgists. Luxon?

The Latest