House re-plumb, copper vs pex ?

Gworm
Posts
2807
Joined
4/5/2017
Location
Monett, MO, USA
7/1/2022 2:13pm
Gworm wrote:
Another PEX question. Have any of you guys seen this. My daughter bought a nice house after her divorce. It is about 10 years old, and...
Another PEX question.

Have any of you guys seen this. My daughter bought a nice house after her divorce. It is about 10 years old, and not a cheap house. She has been there 2 years and has had 5 leaks in the body of the pex lines. They have all been on the hot water (red) lines. All in hard places to get to. No sign of mouse damage.

In this pic the line looks rough, but in person it didn’t look that bad.






You can see the very fine stream in the highlighted area. This was behind her kitchen cabinet.

I just wonder how well pex ages. For a pinhole to develop after this long, it’s kind of scary thinking that it’s throughout her house.

I come from a construction background. My Dad was a home builder for about 50 years, and I built a few after he retired. We always used copper, and never had any problems.

I’m thinking of building another house or two, and was leaning towards pex until this. Now I don’t think I’d plumb a dog house with it.
Josh422 wrote:
Non expansion pex, I see a crimp ring. In my humble opinion, is inferior to cold expansion type or PEX A. Again, rarely ever see rodents...
Non expansion pex, I see a crimp ring. In my humble opinion, is inferior to cold expansion type or PEX A.

Again, rarely ever see rodents chewing through pex. We have lots of rodents, almost all residential has a crawlspace and lots of pex. I’ll choose expansion pex all day over anything else.
Thanks. I know just slightly more than zero (after yesterday) about pex. I thought it was all supposed to expand. Working with what was there it was hard to believe it would expand like they say.

What are your thoughts on Fostapex? I never knew about it till yesterday. So to answer Chances’ question, I do know there is a Viega Fostapax under the slab.
Chance1216
Posts
8797
Joined
4/1/2018
Location
Carson, CA, USA
7/1/2022 4:19pm
Gworm wrote:
Another PEX question. Have any of you guys seen this. My daughter bought a nice house after her divorce. It is about 10 years old, and...
Another PEX question.

Have any of you guys seen this. My daughter bought a nice house after her divorce. It is about 10 years old, and not a cheap house. She has been there 2 years and has had 5 leaks in the body of the pex lines. They have all been on the hot water (red) lines. All in hard places to get to. No sign of mouse damage.

In this pic the line looks rough, but in person it didn’t look that bad.






You can see the very fine stream in the highlighted area. This was behind her kitchen cabinet.

I just wonder how well pex ages. For a pinhole to develop after this long, it’s kind of scary thinking that it’s throughout her house.

I come from a construction background. My Dad was a home builder for about 50 years, and I built a few after he retired. We always used copper, and never had any problems.

I’m thinking of building another house or two, and was leaning towards pex until this. Now I don’t think I’d plumb a dog house with it.
Josh422 wrote:
Non expansion pex, I see a crimp ring. In my humble opinion, is inferior to cold expansion type or PEX A. Again, rarely ever see rodents...
Non expansion pex, I see a crimp ring. In my humble opinion, is inferior to cold expansion type or PEX A.

Again, rarely ever see rodents chewing through pex. We have lots of rodents, almost all residential has a crawlspace and lots of pex. I’ll choose expansion pex all day over anything else.
Gworm wrote:
Thanks. I know just slightly more than zero (after yesterday) about pex. I thought it was all supposed to expand. Working with what was there it...
Thanks. I know just slightly more than zero (after yesterday) about pex. I thought it was all supposed to expand. Working with what was there it was hard to believe it would expand like they say.

What are your thoughts on Fostapex? I never knew about it till yesterday. So to answer Chances’ question, I do know there is a Viega Fostapax under the slab.
FostaPex was discontinued by the manufacturer.
Mx746
Posts
531
Joined
11/30/2010
Location
Marietta, GA, USA
7/1/2022 4:30pm
sumdood wrote:
On the fence. My old school self says 3/4” type L copper and call it done. Or use the new style Pex ? I know it’s...
On the fence. My old school self says 3/4” type L copper and call it done. Or use the new style Pex ?
I know it’s the latest greatest, but so was particle board and “Trex” decking at one point. And both of those turned out to be complete shit. I had a pinhole show up over the 3 day weekend. Luckily my house is on piers so we heard it, and it was accessible to McGyver it Laughing
Might not be so lucky next time. So if it was your house, what would you do, copper or plastic ?
I love my trex deck, 10 years later the trex is fine and the wood supporting it looks like crap
1
sumdood
Posts
8970
Joined
3/11/2013
Location
San Clemente, CA, USA
Fantasy
7/1/2022 11:14pm
Mx746 wrote:
I love my trex deck, 10 years later the trex is fine and the wood supporting it looks like crap
Really ? Maybe the fake decking I've seen is something different, or early versions before they got it figured out. This stuff I'm talking about is gray and smooth, and the cut ends look like particle board, a few customers have it. Their decks are saggy and all flexy when you walk on them, they have deep gouges from the furniture, where the bbq juice drips the decks are getting eaten away, they have spots that are powdery and you see little sparkly flakes of what looks like fiberglass in the air if you sweep them. There must be different manufacturers that use different material because I can't see anyone liking the stuff I'm talking about. I built our deck out of doug fir and figured it would last about 20 years. That was 22 years ago. Turned out to be a good guess, it's pretty tired. But it's lasted 22 years so there is that

The Shop

borg
Posts
6879
Joined
12/7/2009
Location
Long Beach, CA, USA
7/2/2022 5:27am
Mx746 wrote:
I love my trex deck, 10 years later the trex is fine and the wood supporting it looks like crap
sumdood wrote:
Really ? Maybe the fake decking I've seen is something different, or early versions before they got it figured out. This stuff I'm talking about is...
Really ? Maybe the fake decking I've seen is something different, or early versions before they got it figured out. This stuff I'm talking about is gray and smooth, and the cut ends look like particle board, a few customers have it. Their decks are saggy and all flexy when you walk on them, they have deep gouges from the furniture, where the bbq juice drips the decks are getting eaten away, they have spots that are powdery and you see little sparkly flakes of what looks like fiberglass in the air if you sweep them. There must be different manufacturers that use different material because I can't see anyone liking the stuff I'm talking about. I built our deck out of doug fir and figured it would last about 20 years. That was 22 years ago. Turned out to be a good guess, it's pretty tired. But it's lasted 22 years so there is that
I did a fairly large Trex installation several years ago. There was 2 colors then brown and grey. They wanted brown. I built the deck and in less than 2 years it had turned grey. As far as I know it has held up ok.
sumdood
Posts
8970
Joined
3/11/2013
Location
San Clemente, CA, USA
Fantasy
7/2/2022 7:04am
Mx746 wrote:
I love my trex deck, 10 years later the trex is fine and the wood supporting it looks like crap
sumdood wrote:
Really ? Maybe the fake decking I've seen is something different, or early versions before they got it figured out. This stuff I'm talking about is...
Really ? Maybe the fake decking I've seen is something different, or early versions before they got it figured out. This stuff I'm talking about is gray and smooth, and the cut ends look like particle board, a few customers have it. Their decks are saggy and all flexy when you walk on them, they have deep gouges from the furniture, where the bbq juice drips the decks are getting eaten away, they have spots that are powdery and you see little sparkly flakes of what looks like fiberglass in the air if you sweep them. There must be different manufacturers that use different material because I can't see anyone liking the stuff I'm talking about. I built our deck out of doug fir and figured it would last about 20 years. That was 22 years ago. Turned out to be a good guess, it's pretty tired. But it's lasted 22 years so there is that
borg wrote:
I did a fairly large Trex installation several years ago. There was 2 colors then brown and grey. They wanted brown. I built the deck and...
I did a fairly large Trex installation several years ago. There was 2 colors then brown and grey. They wanted brown. I built the deck and in less than 2 years it had turned grey. As far as I know it has held up ok.
Might be closer in price to wood now ? I don’t know. When I built my deck it was 3x + more per board. (Than cheap Doug fir anyway). I didn’t price out redwood cause we were on a tight budget. No idea how it compares to wood price ways these days. Redwood would have been cool but way too much $ at the time.
KennyT
Posts
4399
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Vista, CA, USA
Fantasy
7/2/2022 8:02am
This is a great thread. I’m a general contractor that does a lot of my own plumbing on my remodels so I love learning from licensed plumbers. Can I ask you guys what your thoughts are on using the occasional shark bite fitting in a tough time solder area. I get mixed reviews and don’t know what to believe. I’m in a so cal coastal climate zone with no freezing issues. Sometimes if it’s a tight area and I’m hesitant to torch the house I find the shark bite is a great option. I do have a licensed plumber I use once in awhile and he keeps some on his truck. He trust them but of course we all know you can’t believe everything you hear when it comes to plumbing. Any advice from you Pros? Thanks!

Btw I love learning about the Pex. At 62 I’m not sure I want to venture over from copper but if it’s easy to learn how to do I may make the move
2
Chance1216
Posts
8797
Joined
4/1/2018
Location
Carson, CA, USA
7/2/2022 9:02am
KennyT wrote:
This is a great thread. I’m a general contractor that does a lot of my own plumbing on my remodels so I love learning from licensed...
This is a great thread. I’m a general contractor that does a lot of my own plumbing on my remodels so I love learning from licensed plumbers. Can I ask you guys what your thoughts are on using the occasional shark bite fitting in a tough time solder area. I get mixed reviews and don’t know what to believe. I’m in a so cal coastal climate zone with no freezing issues. Sometimes if it’s a tight area and I’m hesitant to torch the house I find the shark bite is a great option. I do have a licensed plumber I use once in awhile and he keeps some on his truck. He trust them but of course we all know you can’t believe everything you hear when it comes to plumbing. Any advice from you Pros? Thanks!

Btw I love learning about the Pex. At 62 I’m not sure I want to venture over from copper but if it’s easy to learn how to do I may make the move
A friend of mine who works at a residential shop uses shark bites to transition from copper to pex on remodels. I do not know of any issues. Personally, I wouldn’t use them myself. I’d use them as a temporary fix for a leak or, capping off a line.
Other then that, I’d sweat the copper.

There’s heat shields you can use in tight quarters while sweating copper to avoid using a shark bite.

Oatey or, Turbo Torch make these. There’s a few different styles.


2
Josh422
Posts
1146
Joined
4/29/2008
Location
Joshougal, WA, USA
7/2/2022 9:09am
KennyT wrote:
This is a great thread. I’m a general contractor that does a lot of my own plumbing on my remodels so I love learning from licensed...
This is a great thread. I’m a general contractor that does a lot of my own plumbing on my remodels so I love learning from licensed plumbers. Can I ask you guys what your thoughts are on using the occasional shark bite fitting in a tough time solder area. I get mixed reviews and don’t know what to believe. I’m in a so cal coastal climate zone with no freezing issues. Sometimes if it’s a tight area and I’m hesitant to torch the house I find the shark bite is a great option. I do have a licensed plumber I use once in awhile and he keeps some on his truck. He trust them but of course we all know you can’t believe everything you hear when it comes to plumbing. Any advice from you Pros? Thanks!

Btw I love learning about the Pex. At 62 I’m not sure I want to venture over from copper but if it’s easy to learn how to do I may make the move
We treat them as temporary or if the scenario calls for it. Any good plumber isn’t going to pull it out first. I’ll use them as a transition for polybutylene to pex when making a repair (usually mobile homes). If the house is trashed and they are better off tossing a grenade, I’ll use one. If there’s a history of pinholes and a repipe is in their future I’ll use them. I see them way too often for my liking, like a nice tankless install finished off with shark bites. I don’t put them in walls.

You also want to wrap them if you put them in the ground. They make a silicone sealing tape meant for it.
Chance1216
Posts
8797
Joined
4/1/2018
Location
Carson, CA, USA
7/2/2022 9:47am
After thinking about it, I realized I forgot to mention the head has to be rotated. The original tool was pretty crude although, the material changed plumbing forever. The head had to be rotated manually.
I remember using it for the first time. Back then it was copper and, CPVC for water supply. I hated pex. I worked myself into a corner the tool wouldn’t fit in. Like a dumb ass I supported the line going up through wall, through the top plate of the framing and, directly above the wall was the roof line. It was a kitchen sink wall. I couldn’t get the tool in to expand it. Lack of pre planning on my part. I should’ve ran the line from the top, installed the 90 then, pulled it down the wall and cut the excess pipe off down low.

The new tools like a Milwaukee M12 pex tool automatically rotated as its expanding the pipe and, ring. Eliminating one of the biggest causes for leaks on pex.

The other thing was there were no stops on the rings back then. It really sucked using pex in the rain. The ring and pipe would get wet, then when expanding, the ring would slide down the pipe away from the edge. Living in the PNW where it rains all the time, it was a real bitch to deal with. The rings have stops on one side now eliminating that problem.

Pex has come a long way from 98 when I first used it.
Every material has its short comings.

Pex, if not installed properly, like not rotating the head during the install can and, will leak.

Copper, if not sweated properly, will also leak. If there’s water in the line, good luck getting a solid joint. If you overheat and, burn the flux out, the solder won’t draw into the joint as well. Then, you have to pull it apart and, flux and sweat it again. The other issue is working in tight quarters with an open flame. I have several burn scars on my arms, hands and, even my face from over the years. Mostly from dripping flux while soldering or, bumping into a hot line after soldering.
KennyT
Posts
4399
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Vista, CA, USA
Fantasy
7/2/2022 10:21am
Chance1216 wrote:
After thinking about it, I realized I forgot to mention the head has to be rotated. The original tool was pretty crude although, the material changed...
After thinking about it, I realized I forgot to mention the head has to be rotated. The original tool was pretty crude although, the material changed plumbing forever. The head had to be rotated manually.
I remember using it for the first time. Back then it was copper and, CPVC for water supply. I hated pex. I worked myself into a corner the tool wouldn’t fit in. Like a dumb ass I supported the line going up through wall, through the top plate of the framing and, directly above the wall was the roof line. It was a kitchen sink wall. I couldn’t get the tool in to expand it. Lack of pre planning on my part. I should’ve ran the line from the top, installed the 90 then, pulled it down the wall and cut the excess pipe off down low.

The new tools like a Milwaukee M12 pex tool automatically rotated as its expanding the pipe and, ring. Eliminating one of the biggest causes for leaks on pex.

The other thing was there were no stops on the rings back then. It really sucked using pex in the rain. The ring and pipe would get wet, then when expanding, the ring would slide down the pipe away from the edge. Living in the PNW where it rains all the time, it was a real bitch to deal with. The rings have stops on one side now eliminating that problem.

Pex has come a long way from 98 when I first used it.
Every material has its short comings.

Pex, if not installed properly, like not rotating the head during the install can and, will leak.

Copper, if not sweated properly, will also leak. If there’s water in the line, good luck getting a solid joint. If you overheat and, burn the flux out, the solder won’t draw into the joint as well. Then, you have to pull it apart and, flux and sweat it again. The other issue is working in tight quarters with an open flame. I have several burn scars on my arms, hands and, even my face from over the years. Mostly from dripping flux while soldering or, bumping into a hot line after soldering.
Thank you for all the tips.

Over the years I have been called to numerous houses to do drywall repair after leaks and to repair pipes (if I’m able)

Many of those leaks were coming from copper elbows or couplings in pipes that have been in place for 10-20 years. It seems off that a soldered fitting would hold for that long and then develop a pin hole leak. Plumbing is a bitch!
1
Chance1216
Posts
8797
Joined
4/1/2018
Location
Carson, CA, USA
7/2/2022 10:49am
Chance1216 wrote:
After thinking about it, I realized I forgot to mention the head has to be rotated. The original tool was pretty crude although, the material changed...
After thinking about it, I realized I forgot to mention the head has to be rotated. The original tool was pretty crude although, the material changed plumbing forever. The head had to be rotated manually.
I remember using it for the first time. Back then it was copper and, CPVC for water supply. I hated pex. I worked myself into a corner the tool wouldn’t fit in. Like a dumb ass I supported the line going up through wall, through the top plate of the framing and, directly above the wall was the roof line. It was a kitchen sink wall. I couldn’t get the tool in to expand it. Lack of pre planning on my part. I should’ve ran the line from the top, installed the 90 then, pulled it down the wall and cut the excess pipe off down low.

The new tools like a Milwaukee M12 pex tool automatically rotated as its expanding the pipe and, ring. Eliminating one of the biggest causes for leaks on pex.

The other thing was there were no stops on the rings back then. It really sucked using pex in the rain. The ring and pipe would get wet, then when expanding, the ring would slide down the pipe away from the edge. Living in the PNW where it rains all the time, it was a real bitch to deal with. The rings have stops on one side now eliminating that problem.

Pex has come a long way from 98 when I first used it.
Every material has its short comings.

Pex, if not installed properly, like not rotating the head during the install can and, will leak.

Copper, if not sweated properly, will also leak. If there’s water in the line, good luck getting a solid joint. If you overheat and, burn the flux out, the solder won’t draw into the joint as well. Then, you have to pull it apart and, flux and sweat it again. The other issue is working in tight quarters with an open flame. I have several burn scars on my arms, hands and, even my face from over the years. Mostly from dripping flux while soldering or, bumping into a hot line after soldering.
KennyT wrote:
Thank you for all the tips. Over the years I have been called to numerous houses to do drywall repair after leaks and to repair pipes...
Thank you for all the tips.

Over the years I have been called to numerous houses to do drywall repair after leaks and to repair pipes (if I’m able)

Many of those leaks were coming from copper elbows or couplings in pipes that have been in place for 10-20 years. It seems off that a soldered fitting would hold for that long and then develop a pin hole leak. Plumbing is a bitch!
I sent you an email Kenny. Hopefully, you got it.
1
7/2/2022 10:55am
I hate plumbing!
3
borg
Posts
6879
Joined
12/7/2009
Location
Long Beach, CA, USA
7/2/2022 4:10pm
KennyT wrote:
This is a great thread. I’m a general contractor that does a lot of my own plumbing on my remodels so I love learning from licensed...
This is a great thread. I’m a general contractor that does a lot of my own plumbing on my remodels so I love learning from licensed plumbers. Can I ask you guys what your thoughts are on using the occasional shark bite fitting in a tough time solder area. I get mixed reviews and don’t know what to believe. I’m in a so cal coastal climate zone with no freezing issues. Sometimes if it’s a tight area and I’m hesitant to torch the house I find the shark bite is a great option. I do have a licensed plumber I use once in awhile and he keeps some on his truck. He trust them but of course we all know you can’t believe everything you hear when it comes to plumbing. Any advice from you Pros? Thanks!

Btw I love learning about the Pex. At 62 I’m not sure I want to venture over from copper but if it’s easy to learn how to do I may make the move
Have never used a Sharkbite. Too $$$$$
Not sure that I would trust them in a concealed location either.
They are probably fine for a quick fix for somebody that doesn't have a sweat kit or doesn't know how.
1
7/7/2022 3:41pm
sumdood wrote:
On the fence. My old school self says 3/4” type L copper and call it done. Or use the new style Pex ? I know it’s...
On the fence. My old school self says 3/4” type L copper and call it done. Or use the new style Pex ?
I know it’s the latest greatest, but so was particle board and “Trex” decking at one point. And both of those turned out to be complete shit. I had a pinhole show up over the 3 day weekend. Luckily my house is on piers so we heard it, and it was accessible to McGyver it Laughing
Might not be so lucky next time. So if it was your house, what would you do, copper or plastic ?
Mx746 wrote:
I love my trex deck, 10 years later the trex is fine and the wood supporting it looks like crap
Trex looks nice when it looks nice. We had a Trex deck installed maybe 12 years back. It went bad about 5 years in, and Trex paid to have it replaced the first time. Note they refused to replace the railings and railing posts. Said they weren't bad enough. The crew they sent to replace wasn't smart enough to match the pattern, You know the corners meet corners. So I complained. They said that's the best they got. I asked if they wanted to hire my first contractor, they said OK. All new material again, now deck was built with the right pattern. Recently, the "real wood" under the deck went bad.
New contractor, was supposed to take off old looking trex, rebuild structure, reinstall trex. Unfortunately, the day they did it was rather cold. The front of the deck is arced and they broke one of the pieces. Now had had to buy all new perimeter Trex so it would match. The new Trex has PVC sleeve on top because the old Trex kept going bad. Now, when you try and heat the boards to make the bend the PVC blisters. We still don't have the front perimeter of the deck installed.
TM

sumdood
Posts
8970
Joined
3/11/2013
Location
San Clemente, CA, USA
Fantasy
10/6/2023 11:04pm

Finally got it done. Was kind of an ordeal. I called one plumber who came out, checked out the job then went Mia for weeks, I called him back, crickets, texted a few times and got e reply that he needs to come out next week and look at again, next week comes and goes and nada, so over that guy.  Call another plumber right down the street from me, comes out, checks it out, says repipe 1 might be cheaper than us but I’ll get you a bid. Over 2 weeks go by with no call back. Over that guy. Call repipe 1, a slick as snot salesman comes out with no less than 10 full color brochures telling me how great they are and pictures of the process etc.  They seemed super professional, their bid was over 11 grand (2 bath 1200 sq. ft. House with a crawlspace and no drywall repairs. I told him as nicely as I could to gtfo of here. Called my old otmx nemesis plumber buddy who moved to Iowa to retire to see if he knew anyone that wanted to work and wasn’t on crack. Luckily he’s still winding down and had his crew finishing up some projects. Have a new 1” main from the meter and replumbed the house in PEX.  My old shower valve had 2 handles which I learned is a no no now. No biggie except the escutcheon didn’t cover the 2 holes from the old valves. I had a couple sea themed tiles in my garage so I covered them with those. Kind of hokey but it’s an old beach house so.... good enough 😂.  Outdoor shower next, then driveway and ADU rental in the back. AC863893-83E8-46DD-AC8D-FDF0640EDD79.jpeg?VersionId=zK7CrSslsbHVyLnGPlfhUnfc2y8I0C9C22C18-AD57-4110-BE58-11BCA3C6343B 3BABD2E8-E073-44C8-BA3D-5DF34AC45BAE.png?VersionId=JlDKPD4eKkN

1
Chance1216
Posts
8797
Joined
4/1/2018
Location
Carson, CA, USA
10/7/2023 8:52am

Your tile looks way cooler anyways. 
Just for future reference, there are remodel cover plates available that are large enough to cover two holes. Home Depot carries then as well as, plumbing supply houses. I think Depot  would most likely have them on hand though. 
 

E1317C8E-3754-4213-9B4C-45BC12F18898.png?VersionId=1.0Yf9gNVtZPByMNDa

1
sumdood
Posts
8970
Joined
3/11/2013
Location
San Clemente, CA, USA
Fantasy
10/7/2023 5:29pm

Thanks Chance, yeah the guys said they make remodel escutcheons but I liked the tile idea, plus I already had them and the grout. It seemed cheesy putting the new tiles on top of the other tile but the height was the same as the escutcheon so it almost looks planned lol 

1
228YZ
Posts
206
Joined
9/3/2008
Location
Destin, FL, USA
10/8/2023 3:52pm
Gworm wrote:
Another PEX question. Have any of you guys seen this. My daughter bought a nice house after her divorce. It is about 10 years old, and...
Another PEX question.

Have any of you guys seen this. My daughter bought a nice house after her divorce. It is about 10 years old, and not a cheap house. She has been there 2 years and has had 5 leaks in the body of the pex lines. They have all been on the hot water (red) lines. All in hard places to get to. No sign of mouse damage.

In this pic the line looks rough, but in person it didn’t look that bad.






You can see the very fine stream in the highlighted area. This was behind her kitchen cabinet.

I just wonder how well pex ages. For a pinhole to develop after this long, it’s kind of scary thinking that it’s throughout her house.

I come from a construction background. My Dad was a home builder for about 50 years, and I built a few after he retired. We always used copper, and never had any problems.

I’m thinking of building another house or two, and was leaning towards pex until this. Now I don’t think I’d plumb a dog house with it.

Had the same issues on my house and had the manufacturer rep out. By any chance does you daughter have a tanked hot water heater with a recirculating pump? My leaks were only in the hot water side and I had the set up I just mentioned. The rep said my leaks came because the plumber hooked up my recirculating pump up on the bottom of my water heater and the sediment was being pumped with it and it acted like sandpaper and caused my leaks. My hot side did have a whitish color on the inside. I personally find that explanation hard to believe since my leaks looked like you daughters each hole was about the diameter of a hair. He also recommended an expansion tank  (was not code when I built) as they placed a pressure gauge on a hose bib for a week and found out my water pressure spiked to around 130 PSI at night.

BMR179
Posts
510
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
East Texas, TX, USA
Fantasy
10/9/2023 8:35am
Gworm wrote:
Another PEX question. Have any of you guys seen this. My daughter bought a nice house after her divorce. It is about 10 years old, and...
Another PEX question.

Have any of you guys seen this. My daughter bought a nice house after her divorce. It is about 10 years old, and not a cheap house. She has been there 2 years and has had 5 leaks in the body of the pex lines. They have all been on the hot water (red) lines. All in hard places to get to. No sign of mouse damage.

In this pic the line looks rough, but in person it didn’t look that bad.






You can see the very fine stream in the highlighted area. This was behind her kitchen cabinet.

I just wonder how well pex ages. For a pinhole to develop after this long, it’s kind of scary thinking that it’s throughout her house.

I come from a construction background. My Dad was a home builder for about 50 years, and I built a few after he retired. We always used copper, and never had any problems.

I’m thinking of building another house or two, and was leaning towards pex until this. Now I don’t think I’d plumb a dog house with it.
228YZ wrote:
Had the same issues on my house and had the manufacturer rep out. By any chance does you daughter have a tanked hot water heater with...

Had the same issues on my house and had the manufacturer rep out. By any chance does you daughter have a tanked hot water heater with a recirculating pump? My leaks were only in the hot water side and I had the set up I just mentioned. The rep said my leaks came because the plumber hooked up my recirculating pump up on the bottom of my water heater and the sediment was being pumped with it and it acted like sandpaper and caused my leaks. My hot side did have a whitish color on the inside. I personally find that explanation hard to believe since my leaks looked like you daughters each hole was about the diameter of a hair. He also recommended an expansion tank  (was not code when I built) as they placed a pressure gauge on a hose bib for a week and found out my water pressure spiked to around 130 PSI at night.

Not an expert on pex, but what the rep said sounds "somewhat" feasible.  

If your water pressure is above 80psi, you should have a pressure reducing valve and an expansion tank.  An expansion tank should be installed at the water heater in any closed system (psi reducing valve, back flow prevention, etc.).  

Best of luck with the leaking problems...so much damage can be caused.  

 

1
motomind132
Posts
281
Joined
5/12/2023
Location
Chicago, IL, USA
10/9/2023 10:45am Edited Date/Time 10/9/2023 10:47am

I will say this pex to me is only a option ins small amounts. As someone who owns a Restoration company I see more water damages from pex then copper and galvanized. Most common cause of loss I see is mouse, rat ect eating the line and flooding the house. That's why I only allow copper on my jobs. It's takes longer, costs more but I don't see the issues I do with pex.

 

As far as shark bites. I know someone who's a plumber who back in 2010 or 11 that built his entire vacation house out in the wood with them on a bet with a supply house manager. Any connections that absolutely didn't need to be solder in his opinion got a bite on it. So far still no leaks from a single fitting and he paid the 500.00 bet a few years back.

I've done plenty of late night repairs with them cause I didn't want to be torching in the middle of the night and not one call back yet.

228YZ
Posts
206
Joined
9/3/2008
Location
Destin, FL, USA
10/9/2023 3:18pm Edited Date/Time 10/9/2023 3:19pm
Gworm wrote:
Another PEX question. Have any of you guys seen this. My daughter bought a nice house after her divorce. It is about 10 years old, and...
Another PEX question.

Have any of you guys seen this. My daughter bought a nice house after her divorce. It is about 10 years old, and not a cheap house. She has been there 2 years and has had 5 leaks in the body of the pex lines. They have all been on the hot water (red) lines. All in hard places to get to. No sign of mouse damage.

In this pic the line looks rough, but in person it didn’t look that bad.






You can see the very fine stream in the highlighted area. This was behind her kitchen cabinet.

I just wonder how well pex ages. For a pinhole to develop after this long, it’s kind of scary thinking that it’s throughout her house.

I come from a construction background. My Dad was a home builder for about 50 years, and I built a few after he retired. We always used copper, and never had any problems.

I’m thinking of building another house or two, and was leaning towards pex until this. Now I don’t think I’d plumb a dog house with it.
228YZ wrote:
Had the same issues on my house and had the manufacturer rep out. By any chance does you daughter have a tanked hot water heater with...

Had the same issues on my house and had the manufacturer rep out. By any chance does you daughter have a tanked hot water heater with a recirculating pump? My leaks were only in the hot water side and I had the set up I just mentioned. The rep said my leaks came because the plumber hooked up my recirculating pump up on the bottom of my water heater and the sediment was being pumped with it and it acted like sandpaper and caused my leaks. My hot side did have a whitish color on the inside. I personally find that explanation hard to believe since my leaks looked like you daughters each hole was about the diameter of a hair. He also recommended an expansion tank  (was not code when I built) as they placed a pressure gauge on a hose bib for a week and found out my water pressure spiked to around 130 PSI at night.

BMR179 wrote:
Not an expert on pex, but what the rep said sounds "somewhat" feasible.   If your water pressure is above 80psi, you should have a pressure reducing...

Not an expert on pex, but what the rep said sounds "somewhat" feasible.  

If your water pressure is above 80psi, you should have a pressure reducing valve and an expansion tank.  An expansion tank should be installed at the water heater in any closed system (psi reducing valve, back flow prevention, etc.).  

Best of luck with the leaking problems...so much damage can be caused.  

 

I would think too much pressure the Lexi would burst not have a very small pin hole. I put in an expansion tank and still have had several leaks.

I did hear there was a class action lawsuit against NIBCO the manufacturer of pex.

sumdood
Posts
8970
Joined
3/11/2013
Location
San Clemente, CA, USA
Fantasy
10/9/2023 11:51pm

Well I don’t have a rat or mice problem, I don’t have a pressure regulator or an expansion tank on my water heater but my pressure has never gone above 50 in this old neighborhood in the 23 years we’ve been here, I don’t have a recirc pump, 90% of the pex is accessible from the crawl space so......on paper I’m looking good. They say pex lasts for “150 years” Pretty bold claim for a product that’s only been around what ? 20 years ? Lasts 150 years eh ?  Might as well make it 500 I mean why the fuck not, 150 years, 500 years, what’s the difference ?  Laughing 

3
lumpy790
Posts
11618
Joined
9/18/2007
Location
York, SC, USA
10/10/2023 9:53pm

Our entire neighborhood has been PEX leaking. One neighbor a few houses down had 4 leaks in 1 year. Did you know insurance companies will not pay 4 times in a year for leaks? Neighbors on both sides have had many bandaid repaired leaks through 4 different home owners. Our 1st time we caught bit fairly early and repiped the whole house hot water side … or at least we thought. About 6 weeks ago the small part that we thought they didn't replace leaked. From a certain angle in the bathroom my wife saw a slight reflection of light from about 1/16 of water below the wall board. She thought maybe I had splashed water while washing my hands. The carpet on the other side of the wall had been sucking up the water for a while. After Sheetrock replaced and all walls connected with the same color on 2 floors gets repainted then the Whole carpet and linoleum get replaced. PVC hard wood is stupid expensive to have installed.  

Contractor explained the why they fail part that makes sense. He said the shift in temperatures from hot cold and cold hot causes expansion and contraction flex in the pipe. 

8327CF3B-8A1C-4C9F-A584-ACA2679908D5.jpeg?VersionId=ZeG3dTXZG9H1OnzOW.RJhQmnX

1
Gworm
Posts
2807
Joined
4/5/2017
Location
Monett, MO, USA
10/11/2023 9:25am
Gworm wrote:
Another PEX question. Have any of you guys seen this. My daughter bought a nice house after her divorce. It is about 10 years old, and...
Another PEX question.

Have any of you guys seen this. My daughter bought a nice house after her divorce. It is about 10 years old, and not a cheap house. She has been there 2 years and has had 5 leaks in the body of the pex lines. They have all been on the hot water (red) lines. All in hard places to get to. No sign of mouse damage.

In this pic the line looks rough, but in person it didn’t look that bad.






You can see the very fine stream in the highlighted area. This was behind her kitchen cabinet.

I just wonder how well pex ages. For a pinhole to develop after this long, it’s kind of scary thinking that it’s throughout her house.

I come from a construction background. My Dad was a home builder for about 50 years, and I built a few after he retired. We always used copper, and never had any problems.

I’m thinking of building another house or two, and was leaning towards pex until this. Now I don’t think I’d plumb a dog house with it.
228YZ wrote:
Had the same issues on my house and had the manufacturer rep out. By any chance does you daughter have a tanked hot water heater with...

Had the same issues on my house and had the manufacturer rep out. By any chance does you daughter have a tanked hot water heater with a recirculating pump? My leaks were only in the hot water side and I had the set up I just mentioned. The rep said my leaks came because the plumber hooked up my recirculating pump up on the bottom of my water heater and the sediment was being pumped with it and it acted like sandpaper and caused my leaks. My hot side did have a whitish color on the inside. I personally find that explanation hard to believe since my leaks looked like you daughters each hole was about the diameter of a hair. He also recommended an expansion tank  (was not code when I built) as they placed a pressure gauge on a hose bib for a week and found out my water pressure spiked to around 130 PSI at night.

My daughter does not have a recirculating pump. 
 

Someone, I think Chance  said if the temp was too high even for a while it could cause this problem. 

Chance1216
Posts
8797
Joined
4/1/2018
Location
Carson, CA, USA
10/11/2023 12:17pm Edited Date/Time 10/11/2023 12:21pm
lumpy790 wrote:
Our entire neighborhood has been PEX leaking. One neighbor a few houses down had 4 leaks in 1 year. Did you know insurance companies will not...

Our entire neighborhood has been PEX leaking. One neighbor a few houses down had 4 leaks in 1 year. Did you know insurance companies will not pay 4 times in a year for leaks? Neighbors on both sides have had many bandaid repaired leaks through 4 different home owners. Our 1st time we caught bit fairly early and repiped the whole house hot water side … or at least we thought. About 6 weeks ago the small part that we thought they didn't replace leaked. From a certain angle in the bathroom my wife saw a slight reflection of light from about 1/16 of water below the wall board. She thought maybe I had splashed water while washing my hands. The carpet on the other side of the wall had been sucking up the water for a while. After Sheetrock replaced and all walls connected with the same color on 2 floors gets repainted then the Whole carpet and linoleum get replaced. PVC hard wood is stupid expensive to have installed.  

Contractor explained the why they fail part that makes sense. He said the shift in temperatures from hot cold and cold hot causes expansion and contraction flex in the pipe. 

8327CF3B-8A1C-4C9F-A584-ACA2679908D5.jpeg?VersionId=ZeG3dTXZG9H1OnzOW.RJhQmnX

That’s that Home Depot bullshit. 
that’s brittle to begin  with and those crimp rings are garbage. Not all pex is the same. I’d blame the installer for using that nonsense. 
 

Uponor is the only pex to use. The fittings require the pipe and, it’s rings to be expanded before being installed. 
 

The contractor is full of shit. I’ve tossed pex (Uponor brand) in the freezer with both ends capped off and, full of water to test it. The fittings go before the pipe. Brass fittings. 

Tell that contractor quit buying garbage to save a buck. Coming from a licensed plumber. 
And, that fucking pipe isn’t even supported correctly. That install pisses me off. 
If the contractor “THINKS” it’s because of expanding and, contracting, why fucking install that instead of copper. Because he’s full of shit. 
 

Rant over. 

1
1
Chance1216
Posts
8797
Joined
4/1/2018
Location
Carson, CA, USA
10/11/2023 1:14pm Edited Date/Time 10/11/2023 1:17pm
Gworm wrote:
Another PEX question. Have any of you guys seen this. My daughter bought a nice house after her divorce. It is about 10 years old, and...
Another PEX question.

Have any of you guys seen this. My daughter bought a nice house after her divorce. It is about 10 years old, and not a cheap house. She has been there 2 years and has had 5 leaks in the body of the pex lines. They have all been on the hot water (red) lines. All in hard places to get to. No sign of mouse damage.

In this pic the line looks rough, but in person it didn’t look that bad.






You can see the very fine stream in the highlighted area. This was behind her kitchen cabinet.

I just wonder how well pex ages. For a pinhole to develop after this long, it’s kind of scary thinking that it’s throughout her house.

I come from a construction background. My Dad was a home builder for about 50 years, and I built a few after he retired. We always used copper, and never had any problems.

I’m thinking of building another house or two, and was leaning towards pex until this. Now I don’t think I’d plumb a dog house with it.
228YZ wrote:
Had the same issues on my house and had the manufacturer rep out. By any chance does you daughter have a tanked hot water heater with...

Had the same issues on my house and had the manufacturer rep out. By any chance does you daughter have a tanked hot water heater with a recirculating pump? My leaks were only in the hot water side and I had the set up I just mentioned. The rep said my leaks came because the plumber hooked up my recirculating pump up on the bottom of my water heater and the sediment was being pumped with it and it acted like sandpaper and caused my leaks. My hot side did have a whitish color on the inside. I personally find that explanation hard to believe since my leaks looked like you daughters each hole was about the diameter of a hair. He also recommended an expansion tank  (was not code when I built) as they placed a pressure gauge on a hose bib for a week and found out my water pressure spiked to around 130 PSI at night.

Gworm wrote:
My daughter does not have a recirculating pump.    Someone, I think Chance  said if the temp was too high even for a while it could...

My daughter does not have a recirculating pump. 
 

Someone, I think Chance  said if the temp was too high even for a while it could cause this problem. 

Pex is rated 100 psi at 180*. 

HePex is rated higher. It’s sometimes used in commercial kitchen settings which require higher temps. 

lumpy790
Posts
11618
Joined
9/18/2007
Location
York, SC, USA
10/11/2023 4:06pm
lumpy790 wrote:
Our entire neighborhood has been PEX leaking. One neighbor a few houses down had 4 leaks in 1 year. Did you know insurance companies will not...

Our entire neighborhood has been PEX leaking. One neighbor a few houses down had 4 leaks in 1 year. Did you know insurance companies will not pay 4 times in a year for leaks? Neighbors on both sides have had many bandaid repaired leaks through 4 different home owners. Our 1st time we caught bit fairly early and repiped the whole house hot water side … or at least we thought. About 6 weeks ago the small part that we thought they didn't replace leaked. From a certain angle in the bathroom my wife saw a slight reflection of light from about 1/16 of water below the wall board. She thought maybe I had splashed water while washing my hands. The carpet on the other side of the wall had been sucking up the water for a while. After Sheetrock replaced and all walls connected with the same color on 2 floors gets repainted then the Whole carpet and linoleum get replaced. PVC hard wood is stupid expensive to have installed.  

Contractor explained the why they fail part that makes sense. He said the shift in temperatures from hot cold and cold hot causes expansion and contraction flex in the pipe. 

8327CF3B-8A1C-4C9F-A584-ACA2679908D5.jpeg?VersionId=ZeG3dTXZG9H1OnzOW.RJhQmnX

Chance1216 wrote:
That’s that Home Depot bullshit.  that’s brittle to begin  with and those crimp rings are garbage. Not all pex is the same. I’d blame the installer...

That’s that Home Depot bullshit. 
that’s brittle to begin  with and those crimp rings are garbage. Not all pex is the same. I’d blame the installer for using that nonsense. 
 

Uponor is the only pex to use. The fittings require the pipe and, it’s rings to be expanded before being installed. 
 

The contractor is full of shit. I’ve tossed pex (Uponor brand) in the freezer with both ends capped off and, full of water to test it. The fittings go before the pipe. Brass fittings. 

Tell that contractor quit buying garbage to save a buck. Coming from a licensed plumber. 
And, that fucking pipe isn’t even supported correctly. That install pisses me off. 
If the contractor “THINKS” it’s because of expanding and, contracting, why fucking install that instead of copper. Because he’s full of shit. 
 

Rant over. 

The old original PEX company went bankrupt it was cheap shit that failed constantly enough there were massive lawsuits.

We also had one fail between the meter in the yard and the house where they had it going under the sewer pipe.

 

1
Chance1216
Posts
8797
Joined
4/1/2018
Location
Carson, CA, USA
10/12/2023 6:46am
lumpy790 wrote:
Our entire neighborhood has been PEX leaking. One neighbor a few houses down had 4 leaks in 1 year. Did you know insurance companies will not...

Our entire neighborhood has been PEX leaking. One neighbor a few houses down had 4 leaks in 1 year. Did you know insurance companies will not pay 4 times in a year for leaks? Neighbors on both sides have had many bandaid repaired leaks through 4 different home owners. Our 1st time we caught bit fairly early and repiped the whole house hot water side … or at least we thought. About 6 weeks ago the small part that we thought they didn't replace leaked. From a certain angle in the bathroom my wife saw a slight reflection of light from about 1/16 of water below the wall board. She thought maybe I had splashed water while washing my hands. The carpet on the other side of the wall had been sucking up the water for a while. After Sheetrock replaced and all walls connected with the same color on 2 floors gets repainted then the Whole carpet and linoleum get replaced. PVC hard wood is stupid expensive to have installed.  

Contractor explained the why they fail part that makes sense. He said the shift in temperatures from hot cold and cold hot causes expansion and contraction flex in the pipe. 

8327CF3B-8A1C-4C9F-A584-ACA2679908D5.jpeg?VersionId=ZeG3dTXZG9H1OnzOW.RJhQmnX

Chance1216 wrote:
That’s that Home Depot bullshit.  that’s brittle to begin  with and those crimp rings are garbage. Not all pex is the same. I’d blame the installer...

That’s that Home Depot bullshit. 
that’s brittle to begin  with and those crimp rings are garbage. Not all pex is the same. I’d blame the installer for using that nonsense. 
 

Uponor is the only pex to use. The fittings require the pipe and, it’s rings to be expanded before being installed. 
 

The contractor is full of shit. I’ve tossed pex (Uponor brand) in the freezer with both ends capped off and, full of water to test it. The fittings go before the pipe. Brass fittings. 

Tell that contractor quit buying garbage to save a buck. Coming from a licensed plumber. 
And, that fucking pipe isn’t even supported correctly. That install pisses me off. 
If the contractor “THINKS” it’s because of expanding and, contracting, why fucking install that instead of copper. Because he’s full of shit. 
 

Rant over. 

lumpy790 wrote:
The old original PEX company went bankrupt it was cheap shit that failed constantly enough there were massive lawsuits. We also had one fail between the...

The old original PEX company went bankrupt it was cheap shit that failed constantly enough there were massive lawsuits.

We also had one fail between the meter in the yard and the house where they had it going under the sewer pipe.

 

That sucks man. We’ve been seeing issues here in Washington and, Oregon with CPVC lately. It gets brittle over time due to chlorine in the water supply. Most of these installs were from the mid to late 90’s. 
 

If you need a re-pipe, I know a guy 😉

1
Jeremy A.K.
Posts
1449
Joined
1/5/2022
Location
North Tonawanda, NY, USA
10/12/2023 9:51am
Chance1216 wrote:
That sucks man. We’ve been seeing issues here in Washington and, Oregon with CPVC lately. It gets brittle over time due to chlorine in the water...

That sucks man. We’ve been seeing issues here in Washington and, Oregon with CPVC lately. It gets brittle over time due to chlorine in the water supply. Most of these installs were from the mid to late 90’s. 
 

If you need a re-pipe, I know a guy 😉

I'm surprised to hear the chlorine in the water was the cause . We built some molds a few years back for chlorinated polyvinyl chloride CPVC. The stuff is incredibly damaging to the molds and cnc equipment used to perform second operation work after molding . Just the degassing from machining it will surface rust a lathe chuck over night . Just from that alone I jumped to the conclusion that nothing would ever break that shit down. 

1

Post a reply to: House re-plumb, copper vs pex ?

The Latest