Chase Format for SX

SPYGUY
Posts
2201
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
USA
8/13/2015 3:34pm
1st. In 2006 RC reed and kdub all showed up at the SX xgames race. rc won 2nd no it would be like any other saturday...
1st. In 2006 RC reed and kdub all showed up at the SX xgames race. rc won

2nd no it would be like any other saturday. just because there are less riders does not mean better racing. everyone will still settle into their respective positions.

how do i know? ive raced in a class with 40 guys at once. the fastest guy was out front and i was in the top ten

then same year i was in the same class but with half the guys. Shocker, the fast guy was still out front and i was still top ten


THE ONLY DIFFERENCE is if someone crashes he doesnt finish last in 20th. he finishes LAST in 10th.
You're honestly saying that the racing wouldn't be better week in and week out if all of the top guys started near each other instead of spread out among the rest of the field?

If Eli Tomac gets a bad start now, he will never see the leaders because he has to spend a few laps getting through guys like Kyle Chisholm, Jimmy Albertson and Nick Schmidt.

If the main events were only had, say, 12 riders, Tomac's "bad start" wouldn't be quite so bad and there's a better chance he'd be up front with the rest of the race win contenders.

Obviously there are going to be years when a McGrath or a Carmichael dominate the rest of the field which will lead to better racing but in the other years where the competition is closer (like it is presently), it would increase the chances of the racing being better each week.

You can use your own personal results at Chicken Licks Raceway as evidence if you'd like, but it has no relevance here. The talent spread at any local race is going to vary much more than at the elite level of SX competition.

And that X-Games race you're referencing wasn't in 2006, it was 2007.
Alex814
Posts
1313
Joined
12/18/2014
Location
USA
8/13/2015 3:59pm
steveada wrote:
I think the solution is simple, without inverting gate picks or giving points for qualifiers and points for holeshots and points for best whip or any...
I think the solution is simple, without inverting gate picks or giving points for qualifiers and points for holeshots and points for best whip or any other gimmick. To me 90% or more of the time the finish order is pretty much set by half way through a 20 lap main, and the rest of the time is filled by announcers trying to find something to talk about and the cameramen trying to find some battle somewhere in the pack to show. Get rid of the single 20 lap main and have more of a motocross format with two 10 or 12 lap mains, both paying points. You can make it interesting by giving a couple of extra points for the overall. I think that would make it more exciting to watch. I understand some people think longer motos would be more challenging fitness wise, but I really think that wouldn't change the results and as a spectator it would just make it more like Nascar, having to watch them going around and around longer without anything happening.
2 mains in the 450 class would be more interesting to watch I think. Would take more TV time. I'm not sure if I'd like seeing this at every round. I think they should take a few rounds and make them pay more points then the others. Whether it's by doing this and making a "triple crown" of 2-main events in the middle of the season, or increasing points payouts in the last few races, something that can help offer an opportunity for points to be made up. Offering more points for a race would not handicap riders that are not the fastest/winning. It would simply give them another chance to make up points.
BAMX
Posts
2906
Joined
1/22/2012
Location
Fallbrook, CA, USA
8/13/2015 4:25pm
...and why did they implement the chase system? Because the ratings and attendance were dropping. That's also why it went from 10-12 after three years. Then...
...and why did they implement the chase system? Because the ratings and attendance were dropping. That's also why it went from 10-12 after three years. Then back to 10 with 2 wild card drivers (2 with the most wins) for four years. Now it's a "playoff" format with 16 cars dropping drivers after every couple of races.

If "your" driver doesn't make the chase or gets knocked out after week 3 how interested are you? If they missed it by one spot how stupid do you think it is?

It's just a giant gimmick and they realize it. That's why they change the rules every 3-4 years, to keep interest in what is obviously a flawed system. If attendance and viewership was up they wouldn't be changing every 3-4 years like clockwork, there would be no reason to.
I guess it is a bit of a chicken or the egg argument. Attendance and viewership aren't going to go up. They dumped all of the good that they had and tossed it in search of new fans that only an insane person would have though would ever be long term fans.

IMO....SX is fine the way that it is. The reality is that the best way to get more viewers in the future is to put more people on bikes now.
aFACEdismembered
Posts
2848
Joined
8/17/2009
Location
Oak Point, TX, USA
8/13/2015 6:14pm Edited Date/Time 8/13/2015 6:16pm
2 main events could be done. TV time would not be an issue if they ran the 450 qualifying before the night show. It would also get people there sooner. If they can run an entire race during the day in New Jersey they can find time for heats and semis.

Run the 450 LCQ to start the night. Keep 250 heats the same. Replace 20+ laps of 450 heats and semis with 450 main 1. 250 lcq. Track maintenance. 250 main. 450 main 2.

Or keep it the same. I have no problem with it the way it is.

The Shop

Tarz483
Posts
6344
Joined
2/25/2009
Location
Mankato, MN, USA
8/13/2015 6:24pm
h&m_cycle wrote:
Anybody ever win the supercross or outdoor title without winning a main or overall?
I think Tim Ferry Did
125 Sx
Mit12
Posts
2240
Joined
6/23/2014
Location
Lake Havasu City, AZ, USA
8/13/2015 7:57pm
motoxxx599 wrote:
Tim Ferry
Not in the 450/250 SX history.

A chase format is needed for boring racing like NASCAR, They have races that last for 3 hours of going in circles. Or drag racings 3.8 second races in a straight line.
8/13/2015 9:55pm
I'll just say there was a reason I brought this up a couple months ago.
8/14/2015 1:53am
steveada wrote:
I think the solution is simple, without inverting gate picks or giving points for qualifiers and points for holeshots and points for best whip or any...
I think the solution is simple, without inverting gate picks or giving points for qualifiers and points for holeshots and points for best whip or any other gimmick. To me 90% or more of the time the finish order is pretty much set by half way through a 20 lap main, and the rest of the time is filled by announcers trying to find something to talk about and the cameramen trying to find some battle somewhere in the pack to show. Get rid of the single 20 lap main and have more of a motocross format with two 10 or 12 lap mains, both paying points. You can make it interesting by giving a couple of extra points for the overall. I think that would make it more exciting to watch. I understand some people think longer motos would be more challenging fitness wise, but I really think that wouldn't change the results and as a spectator it would just make it more like Nascar, having to watch them going around and around longer without anything happening.
h&m_cycle wrote:
I don't see that changing anything, some of those supercross starting gates have about 5 good picks, the same guys will be out front in the...
I don't see that changing anything, some of those supercross starting gates have about 5 good picks, the same guys
will be out front in the second main too... Then the only excitement is if one of the top guys crashes and changes
things up... just the same old song and dance...
Yeah maybe same guys will be on top 5, but the intensity would be amazing, as it is in MEC. But those shorter races just makes start more and more important.
Tarz483
Posts
6344
Joined
2/25/2009
Location
Mankato, MN, USA
8/14/2015 8:50am
I cant say i have the answers
but i think it is time for some changes
i hope it is being dicussed by higher up
people as well

To me it seems like
points for laps lead , points for heat races perhaps
or ???

Also id like to see them let any one run lites class
if they prefer , no pointing out , some guys have been not ready move up , or just ride the smaller bike better , just my opinion
also perhapse a B main for the guys that dont qualify , with a nice purse , kinda sucks right now that there night is over after 1 heat
a lot goes into being there , plus entey fee's etc
Zracer
Posts
1479
Joined
2/17/2013
Location
Saint Clair, MI, USA
8/14/2015 10:09am
Tarz483 wrote:
I cant say i have the answers but i think it is time for some changes i hope it is being dicussed by higher up people...
I cant say i have the answers
but i think it is time for some changes
i hope it is being dicussed by higher up
people as well

To me it seems like
points for laps lead , points for heat races perhaps
or ???

Also id like to see them let any one run lites class
if they prefer , no pointing out , some guys have been not ready move up , or just ride the smaller bike better , just my opinion
also perhapse a B main for the guys that dont qualify , with a nice purse , kinda sucks right now that there night is over after 1 heat
a lot goes into being there , plus entey fee's etc
They already have a B main. Its called the LCQ.

Post a reply to: Chase Format for SX

The Latest