Upgrade to enjoy this feature!
Vital MX fantasy is free to play, but Premium users receive great benefits. Premium benefits include:
- View and download rider stats
- Pick trends
- Create a private league
- And more!
Only $10 for all 2026 SX, MX, and SMX series.
With that said, I believe there are other manufacturers that are also trying to provide us with safer products. I currently own 3 helmets and I believe each are dedicated to providing safer helmets for us. I can't speak on any manufacturer's behalf as to how safe their product is, but I'd like to do other comparisons between the 3 I own.
I own a Fly Racing Formula Stryper, Shoei VFX-W and Bell Moto-9 Carbon (pre all carbon version).
Weight (lightest first) - Shoei, Bell, Fly
Comfort - Shoei, Bell, Fly
Ventilation - Bell, Fly, Shoei
Fit (my head is of the oval variety) - Bell, Shoei, Fly
A few things I'd like to point out is my head measures 23 5/8 and I typically wear a 7 1/2 fitted hat. I wear a large in the Shoei and Fly, but I need an extra large in the Bell. Even though the Bell is XL, it still tends to stay more secure on my head, although each helmet stays quite secure. The Fly must be a better fit for a round type head, because I get considerably more force on my forehead than with the other 2 helmets. Other than that fact, all 3 helmets are very plush and comfortable. The Shoei is very marginally more comfortable than the Bell in my opinion and I want to emphasize that.
I agree with many of the posters here that have already stated the importance of trying a helmet before purchase if possible. That wasn't an option for me and that is the reason I currently own 3. The very top of the line helmets are probably very comparable in most respects, but the best fit is different for each individual. The one that fits best for me will not work for everyone obviously.
In my opinion, our protective gear (and probably the helmet) is the most important decision we make. Top quality helmets are not cheap at all, but I like to feel like I am protected as much as possible.
My son has taken a few bad crashes as well, with videos posted elsewhere, and he has never sustained a concussion with a 6D helmet. He had a headache for a few minutes after a really bad crash that destroyed the lid, and I was counting down to concussion time, but it never came. Unreal.
I read everything I can helmet related, and I have learned to differentiate between marketing (which includes helmet standards, by the way) and reality. I read mags like MXA and Dirt Bike cover-to-cover, so I see the ads and the "tests". To MXA's credit, I think there have been 3 helmets they consider "Five Star", and that evaluation was based on "safety" (which is impact protection). One of them was the Shoei you have. Arai was the other, and here is what they said about the ATR-1:
"MXA has only given five stars to two helmets over the last 20 years. The 6D ATR-1 is the third."
I give them credit for that, because they are differentiating, but 20 years? That is a long time for technology. When I first put my son on two wheels, I figured a helmet was a helmet, and if it had a certain certification sticker on it, it was just as good as anything else with the same sticker. I really believed that. I was really wrong.
We can expect "safety" to become more of a core marketing message since 6D came out. It matters. I remember reading that article in MXA and asking my wife "What do you think about buying Liam a $750 helmet?" I was kind of joking, really. She told me to do it if I thought it was right. So, I did some research and decided it was right. Days after that conversation my son was curled up in a ball on a track and that helmet looked like it went through a war. He was completely unhurt. A couple years later, and a few crashes later, I have done a lot more research into helmets.
I can buy any helmet I want for my son, mostly because his safety is more important than my retirement . . . or, really, anything else. I don't care in the least about weight, comfort, or ventilation (though the ATR-1 is a Cadillac lid from those perspectives) I care about what happens in the few milliseconds between helmet hitting ground and brain hitting skull. If you had told me before I experienced it myself that you can feel those milliseconds, I would have said "No way!" but you can. If other helmet manufacturers are focused on the stuff that happens in those milliseconds, good for all of us. I would love to see more websites like 6D's. Only because impact protection matters.
No doubt your head is in the right place about helmets. There is a difference.
I feel very sure that the other top manufacturer's put their helmets through very similar tests and in some (if not all) cases, the exact same. The technology that 6D has developed appears to be very impressive and it seems to be a monumental step in the positive evolution of protective gear. While everything these companies innovate seems to be an improvement, the testing (at least in my mind) is hypothetical. Every crash, imparted force, individual rider is different and while testing has been elevated to the current highest level, these are still lab generated results.
Your experience is very important and well taken. There is no doubt in my mind that 6D helmets are as protective as the other 3 we mention here, but there is no way to prove if any one helmet is truly superior to the rest in my opinion. We can read many posts here describing the virtues of any of these helmets. There are several that will describe similar scenarios you describe while wearing these other brands. They are all superb helmets in my opinion.
The key is for us to purchase what we place the most confidence in, at least until one helmet is undeniably proven to be better than the rest. As you said, our children's safety should require that we do the very best for them. I'm with you on that. My son doesn't race, but I still spent lots of hard earned cash to buy him the best protection I could.
The later of the two means a helmet twice the size of where we are, so it will take more technology to create something compact and light with the highest level of protection.
The ideal helmet is the helmet that becomes a helmet a fraction of a second before we need it. This concept is really what should be on the drawing boards for all types of safety equipment. When that begins to happen, we enter into a world of injury free riding...and gone are the days of rigid-only bracing and suppression.
The Shop
Luxon 4-Post Bar Mounts
$189.95 - $239.95
DeCal Works Huge Plastic Inventory of UFO and Polisport kits.
I have seen data about the Moto 9 offered by others who sell Bell products, but I have been frustrated trying to find data on my own. Google "Bell Moto 9 Data" and you get . . . marketing. Then Google "6D Data". That leads you to a website rich with data; not just 6D data, but comparative data.
I am sure Bell tests their helmets thoroughly. I am familiar with the Dome from the videos, but testing does nothing for us without data. Put it this way, Bell has the Dome they are very proud of, right? How many 6Ds have been destroyed in testing in that Dome? Probably about as many as I have purchased, which is saying something. My point is, if they had a product even equal to the 6D from a data perspective, we would see that data. 6D is aware that data is data, so putting it right out there for all to see and say "Go ahead, beat it!" takes courage and confidence. I think it was brilliant.
Your argument about anecdotal evidence would be appropriate, except my anecdotal experience, and my son's, and Zach Bell's, and many, many others in real life crash events are consistent. Obviously, the database continues to grow. Crashes happen. Crashing with a 6D is unlike crashing with any other helmet. It is far softer and you can feel it slowing your head down. It is a miracle of technology that I have read about, witnessed, videotaped and personally experienced.
Of course, you can wear whatever you want, and buy your son whatever you think is best. Doesn't matter that your son doesn't race, a crash is a crash, and a concussion is a concussion. You don't want him to have any of those, much less a few of them. Google Dragon67 Helmet. That's where my interest in the subject started in earnest. Thanks for the discussion.
And if you have a lot of light hits to the head, over and over again, it will cause serious damage to the brain. Most of which you will not see or have to deal with until you are older.
Everyone in any sport that involves an impact to the head should watch the following.
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/league-of-denial/
And EVERYONE, parents including, should rent/watch the following documentary.
http://dvd.netflix.com/Movie/The-Crash-Reel/70267552
We still have a ways to go in protecting our brains.
Now, if the 6D crew could make a football helmet that didn't feel like a brick (and they do) that would be something!
Ride safe.
DR484
Congrats on the new 6D. Is this your first one? What did you have before? Curious to your ride report.
DR484
DR484
And you're right... The two Ladies in the background are more important to me than anything, so thought if I'm gonna continue to ride i'd like to know I've got the best bucket around the noggin.
May or may not have gotten some matching TLD gear. BTO has me in a vortex haha
I've seen your bike (it's perfect) and now with the new lid, you might be too busy signing autographs to ride! Ps., i bought mine for the exact same reason. There's 3 way more important people than me that I come home to everyday, hoping this helps me keep coming home.
Doug
He is perhaps most uniquely qualified to appreciate helmet safety. The fact that he chose 6D speaks volumes.
TP has a lot to protect these days and is very conscious of brain safety.....please save the funnies about his activities and safety being used in one sentence......
Give us a call for all your 6D helmet needs we stock the new youth model, the adult models and we ship UPS daily. 803-980-7200
Pit Row
It would be understandable that a previously concussed kid would be more susceptible to a concussion after a crash like that. But, not a single hint of any brain injury.
His mother went out and bought him another 6D. The things prove themselves in the real world, as well as looking good on paper. We run nothing but. In other good news, they are working on a process of QCing the shell of the helmet to make sure it is intact, then rebuilding the interior. Sounds promising.
About the rebuild program, yes, it's official now. I outline my experience with it here, fyi:
6D Rebuild Details
Doug
Anyone else find the 6d has more open vision? Im wearing 100% goggles and they just don't seem to fit well together, i may try a different brand goggle.
Overall I'm really impressed and glad i spent the extra money on the 6D. Also here in Australia 99% of the time, I'm the only person at the track wearing one, everyone wears bells,shoei etc. So its cool to be a bit different…
How good do the new helmets look! Wouldn't mind picking up another one in the next couple of months, they look unreal!
I've been riding with a 6D since I got a concussion one year ago this month. He is not going to ride again until he gets a 6D. He had some cheap helmet from Cycle Gear because he didn't want to spend the money. How much is your head worth? I think he knows now, but that is a hard lesson to learn.
Yeah JB the goggle port is huge compared to some other helmets... even my Airbrakes kinda float a little... The dragon googles look like they'd be a good fit.
Tim gets back to the truck and doesn't remember where he crashed, what happened, starts asking me if he was in the Army and thinking he's back in Afghanistan. Then he wanted to know where his weapon was. Then he kept asking me over and over if we found him wandering on the track. It was all kind of surreal, and I'm even further convinced that concussions are not something to fool around with.
I would also like to thank everyone who has purchased a 6D helmet from us. With your help we actually won a giveaway that 6D was offering to their FLIGHT CREW dealers. We won Eli Tomac's MXoN custom 6D helmet as well as his Astar gear. We are very excited to receive these items and get them ready to put on display for all of our customers to see. THANKS AGAIN EVERYONE.
If it's on our site, it's in stock. MOTOSTUFF.COM / 503-830-6433
Post a reply to: 6D helmet users