mx sports fines riders for track cutting

BobbyM
Posts
21435
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
USA
5/28/2013 8:49pm
Crush wrote:
Fuck, not this again... He still lost time, he entered at a safe spot, what's the big deal? Don't wanna argue, but are you guys just...
Fuck, not this again... He still lost time, he entered at a safe spot, what's the big deal?

Don't wanna argue, but are you guys just baggin on RV cause he is winning? Are you Dunge or Stewy fans?

He LOST time... He didn't mean to go off track... penalising someone for "overriding"

Bob Hannah would laugh, as would RJ, RC and a whole bunch of others.

Barcia? did the same thing going off the lead jump on that hill, missed the next one and re-entered
Like an OB in golf...got to pay the piper.
Brent
Posts
5907
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Temecula, CA, USA
5/28/2013 8:55pm
tracks are too gnarly and the bikes are too fast to expect anyone to stay inside the lines every lap
mynewcr250
Posts
681
Joined
10/22/2012
Location
USA
5/28/2013 9:02pm Edited Date/Time 5/28/2013 9:03pm
my opinion, im right in between the 2 side. i dont think you should have to go back to where you went off the track, however i do believe you should have to stop the second (obviously not possible but asap) you realize youre off the track and enter the track safely at that point (where you came to a complete stop), none of this WOT to the next jump and continue racing. JMO.
motoBRD
Posts
408
Joined
6/7/2012
Location
Rochester, NY, USA
5/28/2013 9:05pm
Seems like there's a few thoughts at play here:

1. Going off the track and re-entering safely is enough of a penalty because it causes the rider to lose time anyway

OR

2. Going off the track should be considered a more serious offense to make sure the riders are more in control when on the racing surface; thereby, when they go off they should re-enter where they left to increase the penalty

As stated in previous posts, there are a few other things that come into play if you want to look at these both (i.e. re-entering where you left could be dangerous). I think there should be a mix of both. The time a rider loses going off the track and re-entering a ways down is not a viable penalty IMO. Riders "lose time" just in the course of riding on the track by making mistakes. Going back to the original idea of the thread, if there are fines being assessed upwards of $25,000, riders are getting lax with going off the track and the issue should be addressed in changing the race outcome, not fining after the fact.

I think there should be a more defined rule. Look at other motorsports. Didn't Montoya get DQ'd for speeding on pit road? I don't remember, but I don't think it was a few spots docked. Anyway, I don't think the answer is putting green fencing inches from the track like the GPs and MXDN have had in the past. Some of those rulings in the past seemed really screwy (i.e. Barcia/Sun incident). It should be something like, if you go off you have to make an attempt to re-enter where you left unless it's unsafe and that you can't just cruise down the track to re-enter. To the cutting the track point, it seems like leaving the track and re-entering down the track is cutting whether you made up time or lost it. You're not racing the course. Just my .02 the way I see it.

The Shop

KennyT
Posts
4423
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Vista, CA, USA
5/28/2013 9:55pm Edited Date/Time 5/28/2013 9:56pm
I don't buy the idea that bikes are too fast and tracks too rough. Tracks were rough and bikes were fast 30 years ago. If you can't stay in bounds then slow down or be penalized. This bullshit of riders blasting full throttle off of the track needs to stop before they kill someone. Barcias run through the mechanics area going 40+ at the San Diego SX within inches of mechanics should have resulted in a massive fine or DQ
NV825
Posts
2218
Joined
8/26/2006
Location
Carson City, NV, USA
5/28/2013 10:01pm
I think off the track should no matter what mean slow speeds till you are safely back on the track. Perfect example is Musquin off the track vs. Villopoto. Marvin didn't pin it off the track, but he also wasn't in first gear. He let up off the gas and was looking for a safe place to enter back in. RV on the other hand held the throttle WFO and even though it worked out he is lucky some track worker/photog/medical crew wasn't in the road as he came ripping around the corner.
flapper
Posts
112
Joined
10/28/2008
Location
Land Of Endless Riding!, USA
5/28/2013 10:20pm Edited Date/Time 5/28/2013 10:24pm
Last time I checked this was called RACING,not ride within the lines! Racers in all sports go off course period, and these guys are being fined when they do so.Adding a bunch more rules on how to re-enter is just going to lead to a huge shit storm on how the entry is interpreted. If no gains are made so be it,the money is going to a good cause so how about bitching about something that actually matters? Cutting the track= fine. Bouncing, swapping,flying off track= get back on track safely without gain.
mynewcr250
Posts
681
Joined
10/22/2012
Location
USA
5/28/2013 11:01pm Edited Date/Time 5/28/2013 11:07pm
flapper wrote:
Last time I checked this was called RACING,not ride within the lines! Racers in all sports go off course period, and these guys are being fined...
Last time I checked this was called RACING,not ride within the lines! Racers in all sports go off course period, and these guys are being fined when they do so.Adding a bunch more rules on how to re-enter is just going to lead to a huge shit storm on how the entry is interpreted. If no gains are made so be it,the money is going to a good cause so how about bitching about something that actually matters? Cutting the track= fine. Bouncing, swapping,flying off track= get back on track safely without gain.
LOL, yea its called RACING... on a "RACE TRACK" ie: ride within the lines

maybe we should just get rid of the track entirely and have everyone willy nilly cruise around where they please and have judges pick a winner?

isnt getting back on the track after going WFO and not loosing any real ground technically a "gain" considering the whole thing was initiated by a mistake/miscalculation which by its very definition is a word that describes something that will have an undesired outcome? we do know what the prefix "mis" means dont we?
PressPassP
Posts
3329
Joined
3/3/2010
Location
Ipswich, GB
5/29/2013 1:07am
If a rider makes a mistake and goes off the track he's virtually always going to lose time (unless its a blatant shorcut) but 2 seconds in a 2.10 second lap is way different to 2 sec in a 50 sec indoor laptime

IMO the rider should re-enter where he went off

If its a dangerous place like the face/middle of a jump then the yellow flags should come out,if they aren't already and other riders ride under caution and don't double or roll in SX and so on

In the event of the rider actually crashing,he can re-enter at the next safest place

Marshalls at any particularly dangerous spots can always be breifed beforehand on the above,but its mostly common sense as above

For example as in Chad Reed's big crash,he could re-enter further up as its a hazzard to go back up and enter up in the middle of the ,jump butif it was a flat part of trackI think he could to as his time penalty was plenty and he obviously didn't gain anything

Marvin  or RV on the other hand served virtually no penalties(,in Road Racing they have to give something up etc)
5/29/2013 1:10am Edited Date/Time 5/29/2013 1:13am
smeg wrote:
Sorry but IMO that is one rule that should never have been changed in regards to MX............. In SX I can agree with not re-entering at...
Sorry but IMO that is one rule that should never have been changed in regards to MX............. In SX I can agree with not re-entering at the same spot due to the nature of SX tracks. As far as MX, you go off the track you should be required to re-enter at the same spot you left the track.

Just one mans opinion.
I agree! This one hits close to the heart. 1982, KX80, my first race ever. In the first moto, I got a bad start and went for it down a steep hill to pass some dudes. It was slick and I blew through the corner at the bottom. I lost a few spots and jumped back on the track about two pegs after my exit spot (remember the wood posts and banner tape?).

It was a safe entry, no harm no foul, and I lost a few spots. Anyway, made my way up to 4th at the end and then managed a 3rd in the second moto for 3rd overall. My first race! I was licking my chops for that plastic trophy. Then, some mini mom protested me at the end of the day! The ref came up to me and asked if I exited the track and didn't return in the same spot. He even said that he didn't see it so if I say I didn't do it, he would let it go. Nice guy! I didn't have my parents there for advice, I hitched a ride with a friend. Anyway, I couldn't lie so I said I did it, lost 5 spots or something, and missed out on my first trophy.

So, when I see guys not turn around and go back, it brings back these haunting memories. Like I was robbed by a rule that wouldn't stand the test of time anyway. If I had to pay, they should all pay. More importantly, I hope the mini mom got some karma. Hey, maybe her kids are the ones fined by mxsports (grand kids actually). There's hope. Justice. Peace at last.
Tbteam
Posts
2872
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Ormond Beach, FL, USA
5/29/2013 3:19am
Maybe the title of this thread should have been "Tons of riders have been caught cutting the track so far this season and now they have to pay for it".
DC
Posts
3889
Joined
5/1/2009
Location
Morgantown, WV, USA
5/29/2013 3:31am Edited Date/Time 5/29/2013 3:34am
Sorry, but that is ridiculous. I think you have added an extra "0" to your number.

But you are right about one thing: all fine money goes to support the Asterisk Mobile Medical Unit, and it's been that way for years in both Supercross and motocross

Riders are being penalized for going outside the course markers, just as they are in every other form of racing I know of. And there is no better place for that money to go than to Asterisk, not to pay any bills we owe, but to help them fund their ability to give riders better care.

As for RV, had he turned around and gone back it might have caused worse problems -- uphill step-up jumps are not a good place to turn around. But I do think we need to slow down guys somehow as they try to get back on the track.

DC
MX Sports
Shawn142
Posts
2602
Joined
10/27/2008
Location
Burleson, TX, USA
5/29/2013 4:15am
The AMA has been warning these guys for a couple years now that those yellow stakes are not a kind suggestion, they are the race track and forming lines outside of those barriers will get you penalized. So to complain about breaking a rule you clearly know and have known about is stupid on your part, end of story. The riders being fined knew they were lifting money out of their own pockets to begin with. If you wanna complain about that then you should make another thread bitching about taxes.
reagan
Posts
165
Joined
3/27/2012
Location
Saint Petersburg, FL, USA
5/29/2013 4:21am
Maybe a list should be posted every week of the riders who are fined and what the fine cost? Its possible those riders that can afford the fines will find it worth it to cut the track in order to make time OR not lose time to the other riders that can afford the fines?
DC
Posts
3889
Joined
5/1/2009
Location
Morgantown, WV, USA
5/29/2013 4:32am Edited Date/Time 5/29/2013 4:33am
Reagan, thanks for the suggestion, and maybe you could change the title of your original post since it's a bogus statement?

DC
MX Sports
reagan
Posts
165
Joined
3/27/2012
Location
Saint Petersburg, FL, USA
5/29/2013 4:45am
How much were the riders fined in past two races? i will be happy to post that amount and the riders who were fined and the fines for each.

it will be good bench racing also,since everyone has seen how many top riders have gone off track this might make for good notes comparing.
ga_pike
Posts
2650
Joined
7/14/2011
Location
Valdosta, GA, USA
5/29/2013 5:47am
As far as RV going off the track, he re-entered "safely" and didn't gain an advantage. However, running WFO around the outside of the track, that close to spectators and the flagger (who got roosted something serious) is uncalled for and is the only thing I take issue with. Personally, when you are not on the racing surface, these guys should be forced to slow down to a "safe" speed. Safe meaning not WFO. What if there had been a rock or bump that wasn't expected? What if the flagger had been 1 foot closer to the track? Too many things could go wrong in that situation to warrant a need for RV to have slowed down and proceeded with caution. Had he done so,m he also may have been able to enter the track at an earlier position instead of where he did. Would it have limited the penalty as much? Nope. But it would have been safer for all in the area. Truth be told, RV still would have most likely won the moto. However, running over a flagger or tossing a bike into the spectators would have been disastrous.
Neil_Romero
Posts
170
Joined
9/18/2011
Location
Sacramento, CA, USA
5/29/2013 5:56am
dantheman wrote:
Why doesn't everyone discuss the TOPIC, you know... the $25,000 in FINES! One can only guess that @ 250.00 per infraction that'd be 100 fines handed...
Why doesn't everyone discuss the TOPIC, you know... the $25,000 in FINES!

One can only guess that @ 250.00 per infraction that'd be 100 fines handed out! It would be nice to hear some official explanation, as that does seems a bit much.
It's too bad that everywhere you turn, the riders are getting charged for something else, while the promoters are selling 20,000 tickets and stacking it higher every weekend.
holeshot100
Posts
1176
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Billings, MO, USA
5/29/2013 5:59am
reagan wrote:
i am hearing mx sports has taken aprox 25k from mx riders during the last two races for cutting the track. mx sports calls it a...
i am hearing mx sports has taken aprox 25k from mx riders during the last two races for cutting the track. mx sports calls it a fine but the riders are calling it extortion.

the fines are given to asterisk to help pay for expenses.

riders need to force the track crew to make the tracks wider ,and fix the low lines that run off the track other wise before we know it mx sports will be giving the entire purse and then some to asterisk every weekend.
Just curious to why you would make a post like that without knowing the facts?
How would you feel if someone did the same to you or your business?
DrSweden
Posts
6761
Joined
8/30/2008
Location
Stockholm, SE
5/29/2013 6:15am
Brent wrote:
until there are details and specifics i don't believe it Who what where when why If the Sanctioning body is handing out fines, is there a...
until there are details and specifics i don't believe it

Who what where when why

If the Sanctioning body is handing out fines, is there a press release? if not why not?
Totally. People have opinions about something that might not be an issue? No proof of this being RD. I know shit, but I would feel a fine would be fine after seeing JS using a smooth line outside the markers to avoid braking bumps for about 100 ft.
DC
Posts
3889
Joined
5/1/2009
Location
Morgantown, WV, USA
5/29/2013 6:28am Edited Date/Time 5/29/2013 6:28am
Reagan, that's not the way it usually works -- you make a bogus, uninformed statement to make a company look bad and then say would be glad to post the proper amount when they tell you what it really is...

But I will take you up on your offer: there has been about $500 in fines so far -- so you were actually two decimal places and five dollars off in your original post of $25,000. And all of the money will go to the Asterisk Mobile Medical Unit.

I am sure Jeff Canfield and Roy Janson will be discussing the issue of guys going outside the markers in riders meeting this weekend.

DC
MX Sports
Mr. Ted
Posts
1686
Joined
5/7/2010
Location
Atoka, TN, USA
5/29/2013 6:42am
So as the rule stands now, it doesn't matter if it is a cutting of the track for gain or a mistake and going off of the track with no intended gains? The penalty is the same? If that is the case the only dis-incentive to cutting the track is monetary (not a worry for some guys) or a rider's ethics (probably not a worry for some guys also)? How many will take the fine just to gain a spot or time?
DC
Posts
3889
Joined
5/1/2009
Location
Morgantown, WV, USA
5/29/2013 6:46am
First comes a warning. Then comes a fine and/or positions.

But if it's a totally blatant cut, intentional and meant to advance your position, then that's a different matter all together.

DC
MX Sports
reagan
Posts
165
Joined
3/27/2012
Location
Saint Petersburg, FL, USA
5/29/2013 6:50am
DC wrote:
Reagan, that's not the way it usually works -- you make a bogus, uninformed statement to make a company look bad and then say would be...
Reagan, that's not the way it usually works -- you make a bogus, uninformed statement to make a company look bad and then say would be glad to post the proper amount when they tell you what it really is...

But I will take you up on your offer: there has been about $500 in fines so far -- so you were actually two decimal places and five dollars off in your original post of $25,000. And all of the money will go to the Asterisk Mobile Medical Unit.

I am sure Jeff Canfield and Roy Janson will be discussing the issue of guys going outside the markers in riders meeting this weekend.

DC
MX Sports
well i would say your the master of the first statement so its sure a case of takes one to know one .

in terms of only $500 in fines,i call BS on that one.

show us who and how much you fined the riders. Unless of course you have something to hide .
Bry745
Posts
166
Joined
7/14/2010
Location
Greenville, WI, USA
5/29/2013 7:05am
DC wrote:
Reagan, that's not the way it usually works -- you make a bogus, uninformed statement to make a company look bad and then say would be...
Reagan, that's not the way it usually works -- you make a bogus, uninformed statement to make a company look bad and then say would be glad to post the proper amount when they tell you what it really is...

But I will take you up on your offer: there has been about $500 in fines so far -- so you were actually two decimal places and five dollars off in your original post of $25,000. And all of the money will go to the Asterisk Mobile Medical Unit.

I am sure Jeff Canfield and Roy Janson will be discussing the issue of guys going outside the markers in riders meeting this weekend.

DC
MX Sports
reagan wrote:
well i would say your the master of the first statement so its sure a case of takes one to know one . in terms of...
well i would say your the master of the first statement so its sure a case of takes one to know one .

in terms of only $500 in fines,i call BS on that one.

show us who and how much you fined the riders. Unless of course you have something to hide .
Not that he needs me or anybody else sticking up for him, but Davey doesn't have to show you shit, or prove anything to you.

Who do you think you are?
disbanded
Posts
7017
Joined
8/26/2007
Location
Evergreen, CO, USA
5/29/2013 7:06am
reagan wrote:
well i would say your the master of the first statement so its sure a case of takes one to know one . in terms of...
well i would say your the master of the first statement so its sure a case of takes one to know one .

in terms of only $500 in fines,i call BS on that one.

show us who and how much you fined the riders. Unless of course you have something to hide .
Why don't you tell us where you got your information?
ML512
Posts
17133
Joined
12/28/2008
Location
Wildomar, CA, USA
5/29/2013 7:25am
DC wrote:
Reagan, that's not the way it usually works -- you make a bogus, uninformed statement to make a company look bad and then say would be...
Reagan, that's not the way it usually works -- you make a bogus, uninformed statement to make a company look bad and then say would be glad to post the proper amount when they tell you what it really is...

But I will take you up on your offer: there has been about $500 in fines so far -- so you were actually two decimal places and five dollars off in your original post of $25,000. And all of the money will go to the Asterisk Mobile Medical Unit.

I am sure Jeff Canfield and Roy Janson will be discussing the issue of guys going outside the markers in riders meeting this weekend.

DC
MX Sports
reagan wrote:
well i would say your the master of the first statement so its sure a case of takes one to know one . in terms of...
well i would say your the master of the first statement so its sure a case of takes one to know one .

in terms of only $500 in fines,i call BS on that one.

show us who and how much you fined the riders. Unless of course you have something to hide .
Mr. Info much? Well I haven't heard anyone make any comments about getting fined at either of the first two rounds. What riders are you talking about in the first place and how much they were fined? Unless you have something to hide...
DC
Posts
3889
Joined
5/1/2009
Location
Morgantown, WV, USA
5/29/2013 7:32am
Sure, shoot me an email, Reagan, and I will get it all itemized for you as soon as I finish with this race in Tennessee.

DC@mxsports.com

DC
MX Sports
newmann
Posts
24437
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
5/29/2013 7:37am
Reagan, cough up your list and sources before everyone here thinks you are a flake. Oh, too late!Laughing
GuyB
Posts
35722
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA, USA
5/29/2013 7:41am
I did hear a mention of this during the rider's meeting last week. (I was passing by on my way to shoot some Pit Bits stuff).

They've been trying to enforce the edge of the track limit for a while now. I remember watching an MX sports official (pad in hand, in a very obvious spot) standing in a section where riders were running inside the stakes at Unadilla last year.

I don't think anyone is saying riders can't run off the track (like RV did last week), they're just trying to cut down the willful track cutting. Apparently there was rather large section in Hangtown where some riders were making cuts.

After Thursday's press day in Thunder Valley, officials were asking Eli Tomac if there were sections that needed to be wider. They do listen.

On the other hand, I did have a rider laugh and tell me that he skidded across a section of the yellow stakes on a parade lap one time in an effort to widen a line before the start of a moto.

The whole re-enter the track at the place where you went off thing? Maybe that was cool when bikes were air-cooled, had one inch wide pegs, and had six inches of travel, but I'm not sure it makes sense now. (And yeah, I'm one of the guys that they blast past on their way to getting back on the track.)

I'm just glad Monster doesn't sponsor the outdoor season, too, so people can't lose their minds saying that the officials are biased toward RV because of the series sponsor. Wink

Post a reply to: mx sports fines riders for track cutting

The Latest