So I just bought a stolen Stark!

RichieW13
Posts
2502
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Thousand Oaks, CA, USA
12/12/2024 12:59pm
groggylbc wrote:
....why would a guy knowingly  with a stolen bike sell it sell it using his real name and at his business? Maybe he bought the bike...

....why would a guy knowingly  with a stolen bike sell it sell it using his real name and at his business? Maybe he bought the bike not knowing it was stolen too.....

 
 


 

Except why would he be ghosting OP's attempts to contact him?

4
soggy
Posts
8979
Joined
12/3/2018
Location
USA
12/12/2024 1:06pm Edited Date/Time 12/12/2024 1:08pm
groggylbc wrote:
....why would a guy knowingly  with a stolen bike sell it sell it using his real name and at his business? Maybe he bought the bike...

....why would a guy knowingly  with a stolen bike sell it sell it using his real name and at his business? Maybe he bought the bike not knowing it was stolen too.....

 
 


 

RichieW13 wrote:

Except why would he be ghosting OP's attempts to contact him?

If the police are involved they’ve probably told all parties to cease communication with each other.  

Im not sure Shawn is the bad actor here, or the only one.

3
avidchimp
Posts
5841
Joined
7/9/2008
Location
EGL, MN, USA
12/12/2024 1:08pm
groggylbc wrote:
....why would a guy knowingly  with a stolen bike sell it sell it using his real name and at his business? Maybe he bought the bike...

....why would a guy knowingly  with a stolen bike sell it sell it using his real name and at his business? Maybe he bought the bike not knowing it was stolen too.....

 
 


 

RichieW13 wrote:

Except why would he be ghosting OP's attempts to contact him?

soggy wrote:
If the police are involved they’ve probably told all parties to cease communication with each other.  Im not sure Shawn is the bad actor here, or...

If the police are involved they’ve probably told all parties to cease communication with each other.  

Im not sure Shawn is the bad actor here, or the only one.

What Soggy said.

MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
USA
12/12/2024 1:12pm
soggy wrote:
If the police are involved they’ve probably told all parties to cease communication with each other.  Im not sure Shawn is the bad actor here, or...

If the police are involved they’ve probably told all parties to cease communication with each other.  

Im not sure Shawn is the bad actor here, or the only one.

Maybe Shawn knew (the back story also but try and prove it in court) he had legal title to the bike but couldn't get it unlocked. Now none of this mess is his problem. 

3

The Shop

GrapeApe
Posts
9021
Joined
6/7/2010
Location
Mc Kinney, TX, USA
12/12/2024 1:12pm
groggylbc wrote:
....why would a guy knowingly  with a stolen bike sell it sell it using his real name and at his business? Maybe he bought the bike...

....why would a guy knowingly  with a stolen bike sell it sell it using his real name and at his business? Maybe he bought the bike not knowing it was stolen too.....

 
 


 

That's kind of the whole idea behind fencing - move stolen property through a legitimate business.

Not saying that's what happened here, I have no idea.

1
3strokemx
Posts
3035
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
12/12/2024 1:13pm
RichieW13 wrote:

Except why would he be ghosting OP's attempts to contact him?

Maybe he thinks the buyer is trying to scam him?

soggy
Posts
8979
Joined
12/3/2018
Location
USA
12/12/2024 1:16pm
soggy wrote:
If the police are involved they’ve probably told all parties to cease communication with each other.  Im not sure Shawn is the bad actor here, or...

If the police are involved they’ve probably told all parties to cease communication with each other.  

Im not sure Shawn is the bad actor here, or the only one.

MxAddic wrote:
Maybe Shawn knew (the back story also but try and prove it in court) he had legal title to the bike but couldn't get it unlocked...

Maybe Shawn knew (the back story also but try and prove it in court) he had legal title to the bike but couldn't get it unlocked. Now none of this mess is his problem. 

The title sounds like it was a fake so it’s possible he didn’t know.  But he could be in on it too. 

I dunno lots of people jumping to conclusions ready to take a baseball bat to Shawn (great way to catch a charge yourself) and we certainly don’t have the full story. 

1
soggy
Posts
8979
Joined
12/3/2018
Location
USA
12/12/2024 1:18pm
RichieW13 wrote:

Except why would he be ghosting OP's attempts to contact him?

3strokemx wrote:

Maybe he thinks the buyer is trying to scam him?

Once police are involved the parties aren’t going to talk to each other.  

1
3strokemx
Posts
3035
Joined
9/2/2010
Location
USA
12/12/2024 1:18pm

@mrpip were you able to test ride the bike? What does not fully activated mean?

MOTO13
Posts
626
Joined
12/22/2017
Location
Elkhorn, WI, USA
12/12/2024 1:22pm

There is no way a reputable dealer would only except cash on a MC transaction. Either he's trying to avoid remitting the sales tax, avoiding the transaction as income or he knew about the bike's past. Either way, he sounds like a scammer. 

2
GrapeApe
Posts
9021
Joined
6/7/2010
Location
Mc Kinney, TX, USA
12/12/2024 1:23pm Edited Date/Time 12/12/2024 1:28pm
RichieW13 wrote:

Except why would he be ghosting OP's attempts to contact him?

3strokemx wrote:

Maybe he thinks the buyer is trying to scam him?

soggy wrote:

Once police are involved the parties aren’t going to talk to each other.  

If I were in Shawn's position and innocent I would be talking to everybody and doing everything I can to focus everyone's efforts on finding the guy that sold it to me. 

 

3
12/12/2024 1:23pm
Kindasmoky wrote:

That sucks man, I'm sorry to hear that. Sold your bike to buy it so you're bikeless right now? That's brutal!

mrpip wrote:

Yep, now bike-less and I just bought all new gear to celebrate the new arrival! 🤬

Son of a bitch. I have a spare 125 if you get desperate and need to moto! Hope it all gets figured out man. 

18
1
soggy
Posts
8979
Joined
12/3/2018
Location
USA
12/12/2024 1:27pm
3strokemx wrote:

Maybe he thinks the buyer is trying to scam him?

soggy wrote:

Once police are involved the parties aren’t going to talk to each other.  

GrapeApe wrote:
If I were in Shawn's position and innocent I would be talking to everybody and doing everything I can to focus everyone's efforts on finding the...

If I were in Shawn's position and innocent I would be talking to everybody and doing everything I can to focus everyone's efforts on finding the guy that sold it to me. 

 

If he has a believeable story that he also got duped and the investigators are following up on it. Shouting from the rooftops he’s innocent isn’t going to help much I don’t think. It could also get in the way of the investigation. Best bet is to let it play out and once the dust is settled you can tell your story. 

Or he’s guilty of selling merchandise he knew was stolen. Either way I don’t think making public statements is a good idea. 

1
MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
USA
12/12/2024 1:28pm
soggy wrote:
The title sounds like it was a fake so it’s possible he didn’t know.  But he could be in on it too. I dunno lots of people...

The title sounds like it was a fake so it’s possible he didn’t know.  But he could be in on it too. 

I dunno lots of people jumping to conclusions ready to take a baseball bat to Shawn (great way to catch a charge yourself) and we certainly don’t have the full story. 

"in possession of a California title for the bike"

I took that to mean the title is legit but the means by it was acquired was brought into question by the Stark dealer and never verified with the DMV by the victim.

1
GrapeApe
Posts
9021
Joined
6/7/2010
Location
Mc Kinney, TX, USA
12/12/2024 1:30pm
soggy wrote:

Once police are involved the parties aren’t going to talk to each other.  

GrapeApe wrote:
If I were in Shawn's position and innocent I would be talking to everybody and doing everything I can to focus everyone's efforts on finding the...

If I were in Shawn's position and innocent I would be talking to everybody and doing everything I can to focus everyone's efforts on finding the guy that sold it to me. 

 

soggy wrote:
If he has a believeable story that he also got duped and the investigators are following up on it. Shouting from the rooftops he’s innocent isn’t...

If he has a believeable story that he also got duped and the investigators are following up on it. Shouting from the rooftops he’s innocent isn’t going to help much I don’t think. It could also get in the way of the investigation. Best bet is to let it play out and once the dust is settled you can tell your story. 

Or he’s guilty of selling merchandise he knew was stolen. Either way I don’t think making public statements is a good idea. 

Ultimately, legally, he's on the hook for the $9500 regardless. I would have a hard time sitting on my hands in that situation . . . if I were innocent.

1
MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
USA
12/12/2024 1:36pm
GrapeApe wrote:
Ultimately, legally, he's on the hook for the $9500 regardless. I would have a hard time sitting on my hands in that situation . ....

Ultimately, legally, he's on the hook for the $9500 regardless. I would have a hard time sitting on my hands in that situation . . . if I were innocent.

If he had legal title to the bike he is not.

2
soggy
Posts
8979
Joined
12/3/2018
Location
USA
12/12/2024 1:38pm
soggy wrote:
The title sounds like it was a fake so it’s possible he didn’t know.  But he could be in on it too. I dunno lots of people...

The title sounds like it was a fake so it’s possible he didn’t know.  But he could be in on it too. 

I dunno lots of people jumping to conclusions ready to take a baseball bat to Shawn (great way to catch a charge yourself) and we certainly don’t have the full story. 

MxAddic wrote:
"in possession of a California title for the bike"I took that to mean the title is legit but the means by it was acquired was brought...

"in possession of a California title for the bike"

I took that to mean the title is legit but the means by it was acquired was brought into question by the Stark dealer and never verified with the DMV by the victim.

Op said the pink slip was fake somewhere in here. 

MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
USA
12/12/2024 1:42pm
soggy wrote:

Op said the pink slip was fake somewhere in here. 

At this stage of the game I am going with that is a line of BS the dealer gave him to get their bike back. Way to much fuckery going on here.

1
1
12/12/2024 1:50pm Edited Date/Time 12/12/2024 1:52pm
groggylbc wrote:
....why would a guy knowingly  with a stolen bike sell it sell it using his real name and at his business? Maybe he bought the bike...

....why would a guy knowingly  with a stolen bike sell it sell it using his real name and at his business? Maybe he bought the bike not knowing it was stolen too.....

 
 


 

soggy wrote:

Is it possible he didn’t know it was stolen and coyne had a disgruntled employee that ‘sold’ it and pocketed the cash?  

Shawn Guerette is in on this whole deal, otherwise why would he have not activated the computer and at least ride it? I can tell you why because he knew it was stolen to start with. 

5
GrapeApe
Posts
9021
Joined
6/7/2010
Location
Mc Kinney, TX, USA
12/12/2024 1:53pm
GrapeApe wrote:
Ultimately, legally, he's on the hook for the $9500 regardless. I would have a hard time sitting on my hands in that situation . ....

Ultimately, legally, he's on the hook for the $9500 regardless. I would have a hard time sitting on my hands in that situation . . . if I were innocent.

MxAddic wrote:

If he had legal title to the bike he is not.

Ok thanks I'll defer to you on the legal stuff

6
MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
USA
12/12/2024 1:57pm

Maybe the Detective can squeeze Shawn for the money.

Maybe his best hope.

2
Gary Duck
Posts
787
Joined
4/16/2019
Location
USA
12/12/2024 2:03pm

There's some super-smart Columbo MF'r in here, I'm still perplexed that we haven't found the 22 tablecloths yet... 

13
1
12/12/2024 2:06pm
AMetts wrote:
Did the dealer have any proof that the bike was actually stolen? Seems like the guy you bought it from has more proof he owned the...

Did the dealer have any proof that the bike was actually stolen? Seems like the guy you bought it from has more proof he owned the bike than the dealership has that it was stolen from them. 

Did someone break in and steal just the one bike? Did he write a fake check that the dealer somehow didnt find out before giving him a title and the bike? Maybe this was some sort of demo unit they gave to the guy to help get more eyes on it and the relationship soured and he sold the bike instead of giving it back?

At least we can feel abundantly confident that now that the matter is in police hands, they will quickly and accurately discover any crimes committed, and facilitate justice and restitution to any aggrieved parties.

1
2
MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
USA
12/12/2024 2:10pm Edited Date/Time 12/12/2024 2:30pm
At least we can feel abundantly confident that now that the matter is in police hands, they will quickly and accurately discover any crimes committed, and...

At least we can feel abundantly confident that now that the matter is in police hands, they will quickly and accurately discover any crimes committed, and facilitate justice and restitution to any aggrieved parties.

It a civil matter If the guy skipped on the dealer. Nothing they can do.

 

4
12/12/2024 2:12pm Edited Date/Time 12/12/2024 2:16pm
At least we can feel abundantly confident that now that the matter is in police hands, they will quickly and accurately discover any crimes committed, and...

At least we can feel abundantly confident that now that the matter is in police hands, they will quickly and accurately discover any crimes committed, and facilitate justice and restitution to any aggrieved parties.

MxAddic wrote:

It a civil matter If the guy skipped on the dealer. Nothing they can do.

 

Well, it's already been stated by O.P. that there's both a fake identity and fake documentation involved in the case. At least that's the criminal claim of the complaint, and we all can rest assured that they'll be investigating that at great depth.

MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
USA
12/12/2024 2:25pm Edited Date/Time 12/12/2024 2:32pm
Well, it's already been stated by O.P. that there's both a fake identity and fake documentation involved in the case. At least that's the criminal claim...

Well, it's already been stated by O.P. that there's both a fake identity and fake documentation involved in the case. At least that's the criminal claim of the complaint, and we all can rest assured that they'll be investigating that at great depth.

Alleged by the dealer...

They got there bike back. I doubt they will be filing a criminal complaint.

 

1
3
12/12/2024 2:29pm Edited Date/Time 12/12/2024 2:30pm
Well, it's already been stated by O.P. that there's both a fake identity and fake documentation involved in the case. At least that's the criminal claim...

Well, it's already been stated by O.P. that there's both a fake identity and fake documentation involved in the case. At least that's the criminal claim of the complaint, and we all can rest assured that they'll be investigating that at great depth.

MxAddic wrote:

Alleged by the dealer...

They got there bike back. I doubt they will be filing a criminal complaint.

 

Correct. There's allegations by a dealer that I'm sure will be closely looked into, and O.P. will get no runaround or responce of, "Nothing we can do about that."

mrpip
Posts
97
Joined
9/15/2009
Location
Murrieta, CA, USA
12/12/2024 2:39pm

So a quick update for you all and a thanks to everyone who hoped the best for me in this situation. 👍

Shawn finally responded claiming to not know it was stolen. I’ll take that for what it’s worth knowing how many lies have already been spun so far by that guy. Apparently the money has already been spent. Go figure!

The bike was definitely reported stolen by Coyne motorsports back when the fraudulent activity occurred back in August. They are not the bad guys in any of this.

I got a call from the detective leading the case who was very helpful and also thankful to finally have some resolution to this at least for the dealership. Apparently he’s been working on this case for months and is now heading in Shawn’s direction. 
 
And finally a bit of potentially positive news, I’ve heard from Stark, which I believe this thread maybe had something to do with. 😊 All I’ll say so far is that they really do seem to be an unbelievably cool company. I shall keep you all updated as this rollercoaster unravels. 

42
12/12/2024 2:41pm
mrpip wrote:
So a quick update for you all and a thanks to everyone who hoped the best for me in this situation. 👍Shawn finally responded claiming to...

So a quick update for you all and a thanks to everyone who hoped the best for me in this situation. 👍

Shawn finally responded claiming to not know it was stolen. I’ll take that for what it’s worth knowing how many lies have already been spun so far by that guy. Apparently the money has already been spent. Go figure!

The bike was definitely reported stolen by Coyne motorsports back when the fraudulent activity occurred back in August. They are not the bad guys in any of this.

I got a call from the detective leading the case who was very helpful and also thankful to finally have some resolution to this at least for the dealership. Apparently he’s been working on this case for months and is now heading in Shawn’s direction. 
 
And finally a bit of potentially positive news, I’ve heard from Stark, which I believe this thread maybe had something to do with. 😊 All I’ll say so far is that they really do seem to be an unbelievably cool company. I shall keep you all updated as this rollercoaster unravels. 

Fingers crossed on a not-too-negative outcome for you!

13
MxAddic
Posts
5308
Joined
11/24/2022
Location
USA
12/12/2024 2:47pm
mrpip wrote:
So a quick update for you all and a thanks to everyone who hoped the best for me in this situation. 👍Shawn finally responded claiming to...

So a quick update for you all and a thanks to everyone who hoped the best for me in this situation. 👍

Shawn finally responded claiming to not know it was stolen. I’ll take that for what it’s worth knowing how many lies have already been spun so far by that guy. Apparently the money has already been spent. Go figure!

The bike was definitely reported stolen by Coyne motorsports back when the fraudulent activity occurred back in August. They are not the bad guys in any of this.

I got a call from the detective leading the case who was very helpful and also thankful to finally have some resolution to this at least for the dealership. Apparently he’s been working on this case for months and is now heading in Shawn’s direction. 
 
And finally a bit of potentially positive news, I’ve heard from Stark, which I believe this thread maybe had something to do with. 😊 All I’ll say so far is that they really do seem to be an unbelievably cool company. I shall keep you all updated as this rollercoaster unravels. 

I guess the good part is he has a shop. Or maybe you do now.

GL!

2

Post a reply to: So I just bought a stolen Stark!

The Latest