Family car + mx transport: Impossible mission?

huck
Posts
17024
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Mountain Home, AR, USA
1/13/2010 8:01am
DrSweden wrote:
I'm buying a car this spring in US that should be able to fill these demands. Possible? Suggestions? 1. Transport at least 4 persons and luggage...
I'm buying a car this spring in US that should be able to fill these demands. Possible? Suggestions?


1. Transport at least 4 persons and luggage. Often I will go with my wife, kid and the pram/stroller.


2. Economical (low) on petrol, the hope is to find something that take less than a liter every 10 km, which equals at least 23 miles per gallon I think.


3. High quality and therefore good reputation. I'm not interested in gadgets and hi-tech. AC, ABS and leather seats are my only interest.


4. Should be able to transport a bike and gear.


In Sweden we often put a towing hook on our cars for trailers and stuff. We can buy these hooks around the corner for most brands of cars. Afterwards we put this metal construction similar to the beneth illustration.


http://www.sporthoj.com/forum/attachment.php?attachmentid=135315&d=1142…
If he did...I'd call him sir!
holeshot100
Posts
1176
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Billings, MO, USA
1/13/2010 10:40am
Mini van and a little utility or 3 rail trailer-$2000-2200 for the van and $300-500 for the trailer. $2500 all done. High mile{well kept} Ford Windstar or something similar about 6-8 years old. Make sure it has a good tranny. Imports mini vans seem to not go through the tranny's and have less problems, but they bring more money.

The Shop

Roscoe33
Posts
942
Joined
12/10/2009
Location
London, CA
1/14/2010 3:41pm Edited Date/Time 1/14/2010 3:42pm
Subaru Outback built in the USA, reliable , cheap to fix, fold down seats, recommended by consumer reports.Put on your hitch and Bob's your uncle.
DrSweden
Posts
6761
Joined
8/30/2008
Location
Stockholm, SE
1/15/2010 3:15pm
Sorry for harassing you guys with further questions. I was pretty satisfied with the info, gave it some thought and decided for the minivan thing because of the possibility to hide the bike, less fuel consumption and often we will be more than 4 people. Anyway this started something new since I then discovered the Chevy Astro/GMC Safari (same car I assume) are often low ranked in every aspect as minivans but the interior height is superior? Is that correct? If you ditch the rear seats in a minivan like Dodge Caravan, Honda Odyssey, Plymouth Caravan etc the interior hight are not enough for a dirt bike?

Have you seen or experienced people using these kind of wheels for dirt bike transports?
CamP
Posts
6826
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Colleyville, TX, USA
1/15/2010 5:12pm Edited Date/Time 1/15/2010 5:14pm
Nobody uses minivans to carry their bikes to the track here. Besides the guys with transporters and trailers, it's 90% trucks and 10% full size vans.
Audie
Posts
56
Joined
11/14/2009
Location
Canton, OH, USA
1/15/2010 5:28pm
Simple man. Go Jeep. I use a Jeep Wrangler (4 Door) with a hitch and a special bike hauler that hauls two dirt bikes on the trailer hitch without the need for a trailer. It gets great gas mileage (in terms of a truck), 4 x 4, and you can take the top off. And for the most part it wont break your bank account - Brand New can be had in top of the line Rubicon Form for 27-28K US. Used, even better.

You can also go with the Subaru Forester which can, and does haul a trailer, and has very good gas mileage. You will lose major cool points with this one. But it is an option none the less.
drz117
Posts
40
Joined
1/28/2008
Location
Knoxville, TN, USA
1/15/2010 6:35pm Edited Date/Time 4/17/2016 8:03pm
What about this thing? 19 City 24 hwy

berno929
Posts
878
Joined
9/29/2009
Location
CA
1/15/2010 6:41pm
I have a Plymouth Grand Voyager! Sucks ass to transport a dirtbike... it will fit in if you take you front wheel off, but then that makes it really hard to actually get the bike in the van as it doesn't fit laying down either.. gotta keep it straight up without the front wheel...
SteveS
Posts
5598
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
USA
1/15/2010 6:59pm
drz117 wrote:
What about this thing? 19 City 24 hwy
What about this thing? 19 City 24 hwy

Good little delivery van, but he'll never find a used one. They just came out.
SteveS
Posts
5598
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
USA
1/15/2010 7:01pm
berno929 wrote:
I have a Plymouth Grand Voyager! Sucks ass to transport a dirtbike... it will fit in if you take you front wheel off, but then that...
I have a Plymouth Grand Voyager! Sucks ass to transport a dirtbike... it will fit in if you take you front wheel off, but then that makes it really hard to actually get the bike in the van as it doesn't fit laying down either.. gotta keep it straight up without the front wheel...
Other problem with a minivan is there would be no room for the family with bikes in there.

If you choose a minivan, you're pretty much stuck with getting a three rail trailer if you have to have 4 passengers in the car.
lwsmithjr
Posts
2
Joined
1/15/2010
Location
Trussville, AL, USA
1/15/2010 7:03pm Edited Date/Time 4/17/2016 8:03pm
Some of you guys missed the part about $5K !!

You can do a lot with a minivan. We raced for almost two years with one of these...

mpv" class="img-fluid" />

pulling this.....

Photobucket
It was a 4x8 trailer and the Mazda had a Class III receiver type hitch.

We moved from this through the ranks to a truck with a 7x16 enclosed to a current setup of a 3/4 ton diesel with a 32 f. 5th wheel toyhauler. I would have been better off staying with our first setup!

My family (father, father-in-law, brother and myself) have owned a total of 8 Astro/Safaris. Gas Mileage isn't great (16 - 18MPG) but they do last. All went 180K + miles before motor / transmission issues.

I currently own a Pontiac Montana bought new in 2000 with a receiver hitch that will tow 2500 - 3000 lbs. easily. It gets 23 MPG city and 28MPG highway -- without towing obviously. But a bike will NOT fit inside. Pretty nice amenities though. Mine has 143K miles right now and never any issues. With the self leveling rear suspension on the van, a bike hauler would work great.

You could do a lot with $5000.00

7I3N
Posts
1746
Joined
10/22/2009
Location
Moto Paradise, UT, USA
1/15/2010 7:17pm Edited Date/Time 4/17/2016 8:03pm
Family car + MX transport FAIL




Void Main
Posts
17013
Joined
3/19/2008
Location
USA
1/15/2010 7:32pm
7I3N wrote:
Family car + MX transport FAIL




Man I searched for everything I could think of trying to find that video but never hit the right combination. What did you use for search terms???
Dirty Knob
Posts
89
Joined
12/12/2009
Location
Beverly Hills, CA, USA
1/15/2010 8:18pm Edited Date/Time 4/17/2016 8:03pm


I stand my my original "goofy attitude" answer (which was supercross party fueled.) Even though, I probably did deserve the smackdown.


For $5000 in America your two best options are...


A Chevy Astro or GMC Safari (same model). You will have to use a tie down strap to compress the forks to get full-sized dirt bikes in the back.


Any full-sized van made by Chevy, Ford, Dodge. These are NOT minivans.


While it is possible to get bikes into minivans, believe me you will not like it. The openings in the back and side door are too small, and the overall cargo area is much less heightwise than full-sized vans. Many models of minivan will not allow you to get a bike in there at all, without taking off the rear wheel and letting the front wheel stick out the back. (Minivan rear windows cost $1000's and break easier than you can imagine when stuffing bikes in the back.)


A pickup (truck) would work great too, if you don't mind leaving your stuff in the cargo bed and eventually getting ripped off... But for $5000 you will only be able to find a completely beat to crap pickup that will likely cost you extra and leave you stranded, unless you are a top notch judge of used crappy vehicles. Pickups hold their value better than nearly any other vehicles in America, mainly because even a beat to hell pickup still is very useful to a lot of people.


As for the vans, I would definitely go for the larger full-sized vans, because the smaller Astro/Safari only save you a couple miles per gallon, at the cost of a lot of space. The trade off is not worth it. As well as there is a huge difference between a vehicle intended for mere consumers, like the Asstro/Safari versus a Chevy/Ford/Dodge 3/4ton or 1ton van. The full-sized cargo vans are built for commercial use, and with proper care can get 200,000 to 300,000 miles out of them. Astros will be dead and gone long before that many miles.


Now until April is a good time to look for cargo vans. Many small companies are broke, the winter has stopped business, and tax time is coming.


Good luck!

7I3N
Posts
1746
Joined
10/22/2009
Location
Moto Paradise, UT, USA
1/15/2010 8:35pm
Void Main wrote:
Man I searched for everything I could think of trying to find that video but never hit the right combination. What did you use for search...
Man I searched for everything I could think of trying to find that video but never hit the right combination. What did you use for search terms???
CRF450 highway. A friend emailed that to me a few weeks ago so it was still fresh in my mind.
CamP
Posts
6826
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Colleyville, TX, USA
1/15/2010 8:38pm
Vans suck, regular or mini.

You can buy a nice fully loaded low mileage, extended cab 2000 Chevy truck in Texas for $5k. I don't know what they cost in Beverly Hills. Security isn't an issue unless you don't have a place to keep your bike and want to store them in your vehicle. I know plenty of people that have had their bikes stolen out of their vans and trailers so you can't rely on a van to be secure for overnight storage. I like to hang onto my bikes so they stay in my garage when I'm not riding.
DrSweden
Posts
6761
Joined
8/30/2008
Location
Stockholm, SE
1/16/2010 4:09am
Dirty Knob wrote:
I stand my my original "goofy attitude" answer (which was supercross party fueled.) Even though, I probably did deserve the smackdown. For $5000 in America your...


I stand my my original "goofy attitude" answer (which was supercross party fueled.) Even though, I probably did deserve the smackdown.


For $5000 in America your two best options are...


A Chevy Astro or GMC Safari (same model). You will have to use a tie down strap to compress the forks to get full-sized dirt bikes in the back.


Any full-sized van made by Chevy, Ford, Dodge. These are NOT minivans.


While it is possible to get bikes into minivans, believe me you will not like it. The openings in the back and side door are too small, and the overall cargo area is much less heightwise than full-sized vans. Many models of minivan will not allow you to get a bike in there at all, without taking off the rear wheel and letting the front wheel stick out the back. (Minivan rear windows cost $1000's and break easier than you can imagine when stuffing bikes in the back.)


A pickup (truck) would work great too, if you don't mind leaving your stuff in the cargo bed and eventually getting ripped off... But for $5000 you will only be able to find a completely beat to crap pickup that will likely cost you extra and leave you stranded, unless you are a top notch judge of used crappy vehicles. Pickups hold their value better than nearly any other vehicles in America, mainly because even a beat to hell pickup still is very useful to a lot of people.


As for the vans, I would definitely go for the larger full-sized vans, because the smaller Astro/Safari only save you a couple miles per gallon, at the cost of a lot of space. The trade off is not worth it. As well as there is a huge difference between a vehicle intended for mere consumers, like the Asstro/Safari versus a Chevy/Ford/Dodge 3/4ton or 1ton van. The full-sized cargo vans are built for commercial use, and with proper care can get 200,000 to 300,000 miles out of them. Astros will be dead and gone long before that many miles.


Now until April is a good time to look for cargo vans. Many small companies are broke, the winter has stopped business, and tax time is coming.


Good luck!

Good answer, and you totally compensate the previous "goofy attitude"! Smile

1. Astro/Safari
- Have to compress the fork every time you load the bike, a bit fragile in construction, dirt and petrol exposure for driver.
+ When friends visit (which will happen every second month or so) we will all fit, ok fuel consumption.

2. Classic van
- A bit more fuel consumption, a bit more bulky to use as a standard car, dirt and petrol exposure for driver.
+ space is good for bike and people even in combo.

3. Pick-upp, ex Chevrolet Silverado extended cab.
- Fuel consumption high, only four seats, risk of getting a melon, more stuff gets exposed for theft like bike, luggage. Wife will probably don't agree to the deal because looks, image and fuel.
+ Very easy to load bike/bikes, don't have to bother about dirt, petrol etc.

4. Standard car, or SUV, or minivan and a hitch with Bike Rack or a trailer
- Bike exposure, if trailer extra cost, and storage, if rack, only one bike.
+ Very low mpg, I can choose the best car for daily travel, which will be the major purpose, wife digs this option.

I went from 3 to 1 and now I'm leaning towards no 4 (like what lwsmithjr did)...

CamP, Dirty? No 4 stupid?
motogrady
Posts
3931
Joined
1/27/2008
Location
USA
1/16/2010 4:47am

Doc, after watching a parade of ideas, most legit, get yourself a Ford, Chevy
or Dodge full size van with a 6 cylinder motor. A Ford E100 is the ticket, imho.
R-acer
Posts
4047
Joined
3/20/2008
Location
Toronto, CA
1/16/2010 4:56am
huck wrote:
I like using this little setup... [IMG]http://i115.photobucket.com/albums/n282/huck218/Cooperland/DSC_0081.jpg[/IMG]
I like using this little setup...

Is this legal?
motogrady
Posts
3931
Joined
1/27/2008
Location
USA
1/16/2010 5:01am
R-acer wrote:
Is this legal?


UPS, FedX do it all day and night long.

But I just don't see the powers that be lettin the little guy get away with it...........
grover738
Posts
516
Joined
8/18/2008
Location
Spring Grove, MN, USA
1/16/2010 7:50am Edited Date/Time 4/17/2016 8:03pm
Not legal up here, first hitch has to be a 5th wheel to pull two trailers.

As for the poster, I'd look for an extended cab pickup. For the limited amount of miles you're going, no need to worry about the difference between 18 and 22. Plus with a truck, there is much less chance of blowing a tranny pulling a trailer, you'll have a much better chance of selling it for 90% of what you paid for it. I know I wouldn't buy a mini-van from someone who just pulled a trailer all over with it.
lwsmithjr
Posts
2
Joined
1/15/2010
Location
Trussville, AL, USA
1/16/2010 8:30am Edited Date/Time 4/17/2016 8:03pm
My last $.02........

For $5K the pickup will be the most "used" for the money. Expect close to 200K miles.

The full size van will have most likely been driven by someone who didn't own it (most are company owned), so you would need to be picky. Still not a bad idea.

Conventional mini van, like grover748 pointed out, could develop transmission issues, primarily because they are all FWD. We did it with no problem, and I would pull a trailer with mine and it's 143K miles with no hesitation. Obviously this is what I would do because I've done it and know it works. So to address the minivan issues......

The Astro/Safari is built on a truck chassis instead of a car chassis like other mini vans. The transmission is the same as used on all of General Motors V-8s and the 4.3 liter V-6 is a Chevy small block chevy with 2 cylinders cut off. They are rated to pull 5000 lbs. You can find them in the 100K mileage range for $4 - $5000 pretty easily. The Astro with a small enclosed trailer would allow you to leave all the bike stuff separate. If it started raining at the track, just stick it all in the trailer and be on your way. You don't even have to be in a rush to unload when you get home. Around here, a used 4x8 enclosed will run $800 - $1000. Here is an Astro as an example...
http://www.autotrader.com/fyc/vdp.jsp?ct=u&car_id=271335273&dealer_id=6…

Good Luck!!
CamP
Posts
6826
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Colleyville, TX, USA
1/16/2010 9:14am Edited Date/Time 1/16/2010 9:22am
A custom van with a trailer would be good if you don't mind traveling heavy and dealing with a trailer. Expect about 12mpg with that setup so a van will get worse gas mileage than than a 5.3L Chevy truck which gets 20mpg. Nice trucks are going for under $5k all day long here in Texas. I recently sold a '99 Dodge Ram extended cab Sport truck with every option, including leather, for $3,800, and it only had 125k miles. Dodge trucks suck fuel but that illustrates that good trucks are cheap right now. Also, gas is cheap here compared to Sweden, so you really aren't going to spend a lot of money on gas with a vehicle that gets 20mpg like the 5.3L Chevy truck. If you drove 20k miles in a 1.5 years, your total gas bill will be about $3,000.
1/16/2010 9:33am
Your wife won't like the looks or image of a truck? In the US, the truck is king. Short of a sports car or luxury car, you won't find a better/more desireable image- and there are many folks that would rate a nice truck at the very top of that list.

However, I'd lean toward the full-sized van. It'll do everything you're asking for except fuel economy (as Cam mentioned, the Dodges are extra thirsty). Because van's aren't "cool" in the US, you'll get more vehicle for your dollar. I actually think the biggest struggle with a van will be unloading it when it's time to go home. The very reason you can get a great deal on one is the same reason they're a bit harder to sell- low demand.
KAWboy14
Posts
6502
Joined
12/31/2007
Location
Austin, TX, USA
1/16/2010 10:43am
midpack
Posts
151
Joined
12/2/2006
Location
Tuttle, OK, USA
1/16/2010 11:10am Edited Date/Time 4/17/2016 8:03pm
huck wrote:
I like using this little setup... [IMG]http://i115.photobucket.com/albums/n282/huck218/Cooperland/DSC_0081.jpg[/IMG]
I like using this little setup...

R-acer wrote:
Is this legal?
Photobucket

yes it is. he he
midpack
Posts
151
Joined
12/2/2006
Location
Tuttle, OK, USA
1/16/2010 11:11am
63 ft. long
RACEGUY
Posts
1893
Joined
8/25/2009
Location
Moncton, CA
1/16/2010 1:05pm
No matter what you're driving, doc, you'll be just a bit south of me. C'mon up and take in a Canadian National round the first weekend in August. Saturday is amateur day and I'm sure we have a class just for guys from Sweden.

Post a reply to: Family car + mx transport: Impossible mission?

The Latest