Ti Front Axle Performance

red_leader
Posts
246
Joined
3/6/2018
Location
Redondo Beach, CA, USA
Hey Gang.

I'm a huge weight weenie, but I've shied away from a titanium front axle due to the additional flex.
(KTM 350SXF)

The front ends of the KTM's in particular need extra rigidity due to the fact one fork does the spring and the other does the damping. It puts an uneven load in the front suspension, so it is more prone to slight binding. The force difference is quite evident, as my spring side will slide up through the triple clamps after a hard ride. (the damping ride stays put). This is even after I put on the ROCs triples for more clamping force!

I'm thinking of trying the MX-tech spring cartridges, which will really even out the fork loads.
This will put less stress on the front end, maybe I could get away with a Ti front axle.

Less weight improves suspension action, but less stiffness can make fork action worse.

Wondering if anyone has any experience good or bad with a Ti axle.

Cheers!




|
Luxon MX
Posts
1402
Joined
11/6/2017
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
6/11/2020 9:13am
I doubt there's any appreciable difference to be felt. But I'm sure many will say they can feel a difference...

The stiffness is actually coming from the fork lug - hub spacer - bearing - bearing spacer - bearing - hub spacer - fork lug path more so than the axle. The axle plays a part, but it's fairly minor in comparison.
red_leader
Posts
246
Joined
3/6/2018
Location
Redondo Beach, CA, USA
6/11/2020 12:58pm
Interesting.
I feel like that's true when talking about wheel flex.
If you're talking about front suspension, I would think rigidity is dominated by the forks (including lugs) triple clamps, and the axle.
The axle being especially important when only one fork leg has a spring in it.
Luxon MX
Posts
1402
Joined
11/6/2017
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
6/11/2020 2:12pm
red_leader wrote:
Interesting. I feel like that's true when talking about wheel flex. If you're talking about front suspension, I would think rigidity is dominated by the forks...
Interesting.
I feel like that's true when talking about wheel flex.
If you're talking about front suspension, I would think rigidity is dominated by the forks (including lugs) triple clamps, and the axle.
The axle being especially important when only one fork leg has a spring in it.
It depends on what direction/form of flex you're worried about. Are you worried about fork/wheel misalignment due to the flex of the axle? Or are you talking about the added flex of a titanium axle changing the feel to the rider at the bars? Or some combination of that?

Regardless, you can look at how much flex might be possible, regardless of material, to get an understanding of what might happen. In the case of an axle, you have shear flex, bending flex, and torsional flex.

Shear is easy to dismiss as any shear displacement in excess of a few hundredths of a millimeter will result in component failure. Since the axle's not failing, it isn't flexing anywhere near a noticeable amount in shear. Your tire is deflecting thousands of times more than any shear deflection of the axle. This is one of the primary modes of deflection that you might worry about with the fork spring/damper force imbalance you mention.

The other mode of deflection you might worry about with the fork force imbalance is in bending. But this is covered by my last post. The bending moment is primarily reacted by the lugs/spacers/bearings, etc., so the axle doesn't have much of an effect. There is a tiny amount of axle that is fully in bending with no help from the lugs/spacers, on the rider's right side. But this length of axle is only a few mm and it's also the largest diameter of the axle. Any flex there will be very minimal.

And finally, the torsional mode of flex is last. It's not really a mode of concern for your force imbalance in the forks as that won't cause any torsional load. But it could be a concern in feel in reacting torsional loads of the front end (like cornering). The axle is the only structural element at the wheel end reacting that torsional load. That said, the torsional load on the axle should be rather low considering the fork legs are connected to one another at the triple clamps. The only force it has to react is the torsional load from the tire. Most of the time this force is pretty low, but it can be somewhat large depending on the situation.

So in summary, the axle won't have much of any effect on flex due to a force imbalance between the left and right fork legs. There's simply no appreciable amount of flex that can occur for someone to be able to feel. But you might (emphasis on might) feel it in cornering due to torsional stiffness differences.
1
red_leader
Posts
246
Joined
3/6/2018
Location
Redondo Beach, CA, USA
6/11/2020 3:11pm
Awesome, thanks!
Im probably too slow to notice subtle bike changes anyway.
Although once and a while I surprise myself and can actually feel certain changes.
2

The Shop

Momus
Posts
441
Joined
12/9/2019
Location
CD
6/12/2020 10:19am Edited Date/Time 6/12/2020 10:23am
red_leader wrote:
Hey Gang. I'm a huge weight weenie, but I've shied away from a titanium front axle due to the additional flex. (KTM 350SXF) The front ends...
Hey Gang.

I'm a huge weight weenie, but I've shied away from a titanium front axle due to the additional flex.
(KTM 350SXF)

The front ends of the KTM's in particular need extra rigidity due to the fact one fork does the spring and the other does the damping. It puts an uneven load in the front suspension, so it is more prone to slight binding. The force difference is quite evident, as my spring side will slide up through the triple clamps after a hard ride. (the damping ride stays put). This is even after I put on the ROCs triples for more clamping force!

I'm thinking of trying the MX-tech spring cartridges, which will really even out the fork loads.
This will put less stress on the front end, maybe I could get away with a Ti front axle.

Less weight improves suspension action, but less stiffness can make fork action worse.

Wondering if anyone has any experience good or bad with a Ti axle.

Cheers!




I agree with that assessment of the fork lozenging for want of a better term and binding.

The trend has been towards larger diameter front spindles but until someone comes out with something 1.5" or 40 mm or so in diameter, hollow titanium and thin wall, with appropriately rigid clamps it wont be sorted. At that diameter the bearings would probably need to be needle rollers sandwiched with Torrington style thrusts to keep the weight down.

As far as the titanium goes, you will save weight but at the same diameter lose considerable rigidity with a Ti axle even using the high modulus stuff the air craft designers can spec. Need to go up in diameter and down in wt.

I've made a few Ti axles from 6-4 for vintage bikes- 12 and 15 mm diameter but am a bit leery with the fronts getting worked hard and on some designs a sharp change in diameter concentrating stress. Governing body here in Australia outlawed Ti spindles, frames and other parts presumably because of the fear of failure.
Momus
Posts
441
Joined
12/9/2019
Location
CD
6/12/2020 10:25am Edited Date/Time 6/12/2020 10:29am
red_leader wrote:
Interesting. I feel like that's true when talking about wheel flex. If you're talking about front suspension, I would think rigidity is dominated by the forks...
Interesting.
I feel like that's true when talking about wheel flex.
If you're talking about front suspension, I would think rigidity is dominated by the forks (including lugs) triple clamps, and the axle.
The axle being especially important when only one fork leg has a spring in it.
Luxon MX wrote:
It depends on what direction/form of flex you're worried about. Are you worried about fork/wheel misalignment due to the flex of the axle? Or are you...
It depends on what direction/form of flex you're worried about. Are you worried about fork/wheel misalignment due to the flex of the axle? Or are you talking about the added flex of a titanium axle changing the feel to the rider at the bars? Or some combination of that?

Regardless, you can look at how much flex might be possible, regardless of material, to get an understanding of what might happen. In the case of an axle, you have shear flex, bending flex, and torsional flex.

Shear is easy to dismiss as any shear displacement in excess of a few hundredths of a millimeter will result in component failure. Since the axle's not failing, it isn't flexing anywhere near a noticeable amount in shear. Your tire is deflecting thousands of times more than any shear deflection of the axle. This is one of the primary modes of deflection that you might worry about with the fork spring/damper force imbalance you mention.

The other mode of deflection you might worry about with the fork force imbalance is in bending. But this is covered by my last post. The bending moment is primarily reacted by the lugs/spacers/bearings, etc., so the axle doesn't have much of an effect. There is a tiny amount of axle that is fully in bending with no help from the lugs/spacers, on the rider's right side. But this length of axle is only a few mm and it's also the largest diameter of the axle. Any flex there will be very minimal.

And finally, the torsional mode of flex is last. It's not really a mode of concern for your force imbalance in the forks as that won't cause any torsional load. But it could be a concern in feel in reacting torsional loads of the front end (like cornering). The axle is the only structural element at the wheel end reacting that torsional load. That said, the torsional load on the axle should be rather low considering the fork legs are connected to one another at the triple clamps. The only force it has to react is the torsional load from the tire. Most of the time this force is pretty low, but it can be somewhat large depending on the situation.

So in summary, the axle won't have much of any effect on flex due to a force imbalance between the left and right fork legs. There's simply no appreciable amount of flex that can occur for someone to be able to feel. But you might (emphasis on might) feel it in cornering due to torsional stiffness differences.
He did make it fairly clear: he is talking about the forks lozenging and putting the axle toward a Z bend as one slider telescopes further- not really bending.
Luxon MX
Posts
1402
Joined
11/6/2017
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
6/12/2020 10:39am
Momus wrote:
He did make it fairly clear: he is talking about the forks lozenging and putting the axle toward a Z bend as one slider telescopes further-...
He did make it fairly clear: he is talking about the forks lozenging and putting the axle toward a Z bend as one slider telescopes further- not really bending.
If one fork leg is moving further into the stroke than the other, what is it doing to the axle? It puts it in bending and shear. How much is it bending or deforming in shear to the relatively minor force differential (which is speed dependent too)? Not much!

Yes, titanium has about half the modulus of steel, and to compensate you could make the diameter bigger, but that's not really an option. The real question, is whether the reduction in material stiffness and therefore increase in compliance makes a noticeable difference to the rider. I suggest that it does not based on the reasoning in my previous posts.

There's a lot of bullshit marketing in motocross not backed up by any real engineering. Axles and engine mounts seem to be plagued by it lately...
2
Motofinne
Posts
11657
Joined
1/4/2014
Location
FI
6/12/2020 12:44pm
Luxon MX wrote:
I doubt there's any appreciable difference to be felt. But I'm sure many will say they can feel a difference... The stiffness is actually coming from...
I doubt there's any appreciable difference to be felt. But I'm sure many will say they can feel a difference...

The stiffness is actually coming from the fork lug - hub spacer - bearing - bearing spacer - bearing - hub spacer - fork lug path more so than the axle. The axle plays a part, but it's fairly minor in comparison.
I bought a set of the "cheap" Talon Evo wheels for my Yamaha 450 in 2018. I still have those wheels and i can't ride with the front wheel on my current 250 2020. It's absolutely crazy but the bike wants to "climb up" in turns like crazy with it compared to the stock hub and spacers.

The difference is massive. We're talking probably 1 second a lap, i'm so much less comfortable on the Talon Evo hub. Something to keep in mind when buying wheels, it was an eye-opener for sure.
Luxon MX
Posts
1402
Joined
11/6/2017
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
6/12/2020 12:51pm
Motofinne wrote:
I bought a set of the "cheap" Talon Evo wheels for my Yamaha 450 in 2018. I still have those wheels and i can't ride with...
I bought a set of the "cheap" Talon Evo wheels for my Yamaha 450 in 2018. I still have those wheels and i can't ride with the front wheel on my current 250 2020. It's absolutely crazy but the bike wants to "climb up" in turns like crazy with it compared to the stock hub and spacers.

The difference is massive. We're talking probably 1 second a lap, i'm so much less comfortable on the Talon Evo hub. Something to keep in mind when buying wheels, it was an eye-opener for sure.
Yamaha increased the contact area (diameter) of the wheel spacers to lug interface significantly in 2020 (maybe 2019, I forget), so that has a big effect on stiffness as it better reacts the bending moment. That might have something to do with it, but you also have a bunch of other variables - the rim, spokes, bearings, etc. all play a part in stiffness of the front end. Basically everything between (and including) the tire and the chassis and bars plays a part in that.
1
Motofinne
Posts
11657
Joined
1/4/2014
Location
FI
6/12/2020 12:55pm
Motofinne wrote:
I bought a set of the "cheap" Talon Evo wheels for my Yamaha 450 in 2018. I still have those wheels and i can't ride with...
I bought a set of the "cheap" Talon Evo wheels for my Yamaha 450 in 2018. I still have those wheels and i can't ride with the front wheel on my current 250 2020. It's absolutely crazy but the bike wants to "climb up" in turns like crazy with it compared to the stock hub and spacers.

The difference is massive. We're talking probably 1 second a lap, i'm so much less comfortable on the Talon Evo hub. Something to keep in mind when buying wheels, it was an eye-opener for sure.
Luxon MX wrote:
Yamaha increased the contact area (diameter) of the wheel spacers to lug interface significantly in 2020 (maybe 2019, I forget), so that has a big effect...
Yamaha increased the contact area (diameter) of the wheel spacers to lug interface significantly in 2020 (maybe 2019, I forget), so that has a big effect on stiffness as it better reacts the bending moment. That might have something to do with it, but you also have a bunch of other variables - the rim, spokes, bearings, etc. all play a part in stiffness of the front end. Basically everything between (and including) the tire and the chassis and bars plays a part in that.
It might have been in 2019, because i felt the same thing on my 2019 450 but it's even worse on my 2020 250! Just a great example of a part that "fits" the bike but works absolutely horrible.
Momus
Posts
441
Joined
12/9/2019
Location
CD
6/12/2020 1:13pm Edited Date/Time 6/12/2020 1:14pm
Momus wrote:
He did make it fairly clear: he is talking about the forks lozenging and putting the axle toward a Z bend as one slider telescopes further-...
He did make it fairly clear: he is talking about the forks lozenging and putting the axle toward a Z bend as one slider telescopes further- not really bending.
Luxon MX wrote:
If one fork leg is moving further into the stroke than the other, what is it doing to the axle? It puts it in bending and...
If one fork leg is moving further into the stroke than the other, what is it doing to the axle? It puts it in bending and shear. How much is it bending or deforming in shear to the relatively minor force differential (which is speed dependent too)? Not much!

Yes, titanium has about half the modulus of steel, and to compensate you could make the diameter bigger, but that's not really an option. The real question, is whether the reduction in material stiffness and therefore increase in compliance makes a noticeable difference to the rider. I suggest that it does not based on the reasoning in my previous posts.

There's a lot of bullshit marketing in motocross not backed up by any real engineering. Axles and engine mounts seem to be plagued by it lately...
If axle stiffness and fork assembly integrity in general was not noticeable to riders then we would still be using 12 mm and 15 mm front axles. We aren't; diameters have increased incrementally to around 25 mm front.- double the diameter equals plus 16 x the bending stiffness is how it goes. So with a 25 mm axle- pretty sure my YZ450F has them- the front axle is many times stiffer than the 15 mm axle in my old SC500 or the 12 mm unit in my Elsinore

It would be a very worth while experiment to machine up some fork lowers for 40 mm diameter thin wall tubular Ti axles, make hubs to suit, with needle roller bearings and back to back with a good tester.

I agree wholeheartedly about the bullshit marketing. I wonder about some of the triple clamps too.
Luxon MX
Posts
1402
Joined
11/6/2017
Location
San Diego, CA, USA
6/12/2020 1:34pm
Momus wrote:
If axle stiffness and fork assembly integrity in general was not noticeable to riders then we would still be using 12 mm and 15 mm front...
If axle stiffness and fork assembly integrity in general was not noticeable to riders then we would still be using 12 mm and 15 mm front axles. We aren't; diameters have increased incrementally to around 25 mm front.- double the diameter equals plus 16 x the bending stiffness is how it goes. So with a 25 mm axle- pretty sure my YZ450F has them- the front axle is many times stiffer than the 15 mm axle in my old SC500 or the 12 mm unit in my Elsinore

It would be a very worth while experiment to machine up some fork lowers for 40 mm diameter thin wall tubular Ti axles, make hubs to suit, with needle roller bearings and back to back with a good tester.

I agree wholeheartedly about the bullshit marketing. I wonder about some of the triple clamps too.
I didn't at all mean to imply that the stiffness of the front end isn't noticeable to riders, it absolutely is! My point was simply that the difference in stiffness of swapping a modern (e.g. large diameter) stock steel axle for a titanium axle of identical geometry is likely not noticable.

The ti axle has reduced stiffness relative to the steel axle from modulus change alone. But the geometric stiffness is identical as it's the same geometry (e.g. identical moment of inertia). Of course if you throw in other variables such as diameter changes, then this becomes a different conversation completely.

But back to the apples to apples comparison, does the decrease in axle stiffness make a difference? The titanium axle absolutely will deform more than the steel axle. But what is the actual magnitude of that deformation? And what percentage of the total compliance of the front end is the axle compliance? It's not much!

And yes, triple clamp marketing is definitely subject to the same issue. I see a lot of claims that are either suspect or just irrelevant. But with axles and engine mounts there are some flat out lies being told lately in order to sell product. I just can't get behind that!
martin12
Posts
23
Joined
6/18/2020
Location
Atlanta, GA, USA
6/18/2020 6:38pm
Talkin nerdy Luxon, good to hear from engineers that are educated in the matter.
1

Post a reply to: Ti Front Axle Performance

The Latest