Unions are killing Auto industry

RMZ819
Posts
1320
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
11/15/2008 11:24am Edited Date/Time 4/16/2016 9:13pm
Have you ever in your life been in a car plant??? You do not have a clue. Dummies like you think the Unions save lazy people but that can't be farther from the truth. Trust me dummy if Mr line worker is a fuck off he will get fired.

Unions are not even close to being the problem on why the auto makers are going down the tubes. In this case shit does not run down hill. management fucked this up not the plant workers. To think otherwise would make a person border line retarded.
JustMX
Posts
5352
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
11/15/2008 11:33am
um....

It is "retarded".
`ol Ger
Posts
6269
Joined
7/15/2007
Location
Piqua, OH, USA
11/15/2008 12:31pm
Secondly, over the past generations the majority of Americans have become more and more lazy and the union serves as a nice crutch to hold them up (since their work ethic can't).

B I N G O
11/15/2008 12:44pm
Unions sure get a lot of the blame for slow "sales" at the big three. My understanding of the industry is that they are poised to turn considerable profits due to the downsizing of their workforce which is already complete. Here's something about Unions. They fought for the 40 hr. work week because they believed that a man should have time to spend with his family. They fought for health care and retirement benefits so that you don't have to beg your own kids for money in your later years of life. They fought for real wages and wage increases so that a middle class life could be attained and their children could go on to higher education. What about the workers who are not Unionized? Why don't they just give up their minimum wages and 40 hour work week and then explain how bad unions are. I watched a documentary film about the Duke Power Company filmed in the early 1970s. The company would hire men to intimidate the workers who supported unions. The workers were complaining that Duke Power would not supply temporary housing with running water. The workers washed their kids in outdoor plastic tubs. The CEO of Duke stated he was working on this "issue". I'm not sure how Duke treats its workers in 2008 but I'm sure the Unions have raised the lever of the Duke workforce up past the poverty level. Union or not, when you purchased your car or truck you didn't care who made the vehicle or what country it was manufactured in. All GM has to do is build a product the consumer wants to purchase.

The Shop

Tiki
Posts
10677
Joined
8/1/2006
Location
Corona, CA, USA
Fantasy
11/15/2008 1:00pm
mxtweeker
Posts
106
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Barnegat, NJ, USA
11/15/2008 1:38pm
flarider wrote:
Couple problems I have with Unions. The loyalty of the employee is not with the company, but with the union. It's misplaced priorities. "Not my job"...
Couple problems I have with Unions.


The loyalty of the employee is not with the company, but with the union. It's misplaced priorities.



"Not my job" is another issue, where employees tasks are so specified and enforced that an employee will sit and watch work being done without pitching in because it's against union rules to do anything outside of your specified task.

Again, misplaced priorities and evidence of people not working together as a team for a common purpose.

That is a recipe for failure
Not all unions are like that... I am a certified high pressure welder for the boilermakers.. I donr just go to a job to weld, then sit on my ass all day... I turn wrenchs pull chain falls / come a longs, layout, burn, cut, chip, whatever the job is we do..
WhKnuckle
Posts
7327
Joined
7/17/2007
Location
USA
11/15/2008 1:40pm
flarider wrote:
Couple problems I have with Unions. The loyalty of the employee is not with the company, but with the union. It's misplaced priorities. "Not my job"...
Couple problems I have with Unions.


The loyalty of the employee is not with the company, but with the union. It's misplaced priorities.



"Not my job" is another issue, where employees tasks are so specified and enforced that an employee will sit and watch work being done without pitching in because it's against union rules to do anything outside of your specified task.

Again, misplaced priorities and evidence of people not working together as a team for a common purpose.

That is a recipe for failure
mxtweeker wrote:
Not all unions are like that... I am a certified high pressure welder for the boilermakers.. I donr just go to a job to weld, then...
Not all unions are like that... I am a certified high pressure welder for the boilermakers.. I donr just go to a job to weld, then sit on my ass all day... I turn wrenchs pull chain falls / come a longs, layout, burn, cut, chip, whatever the job is we do..
It's hard to argue against sterotypes and assumed "truth" - and I'm not referring to what Dave wrote, just the notion that union people are completely different kinds of workers than everyone else. When people decide they "know" something, you can't tell them any different.
flarider
Posts
25496
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Daytona Beach, FL, USA
11/15/2008 1:47pm
My direct experience with unions has been trade shows and seeing everything I described.
On many occasions I have seen "I can't do that, that's another union" to "I am not allowed to move anything"
Ask people in the industry (you know this Tweeker) why we don't have SX in the Northeast...Unions
mxtweeker
Posts
106
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Barnegat, NJ, USA
11/15/2008 1:47pm
People see 1 side and assume thats how it all is... Unions are not as strong as they were in the past.. If so people saw what we do in a boiler shutdown repair or in a refinery shutdown they would think twice.. Sure there is some slow time and we fuck off, but when we gotta get the job done we can go 7 days 12 - 16 hr a day till it's done so we all can put gas in our cars and trucks and so the boilers and produce the steam that makes the electricity that we all use to sit here on the computer and talk shit all day...
mxtweeker
Posts
106
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Barnegat, NJ, USA
11/15/2008 1:53pm
Unions protect their own.. As do you dave with your product.. The Northeast is a Union area..
WhKnuckle
Posts
7327
Joined
7/17/2007
Location
USA
11/15/2008 2:10pm
My company has power plants all over the country. Some them have union workers but most don't, and when I go to a union plant I can't tell any difference in how they work. And some of those are in deep union country, like New York, Pennsylvania, and places like that. Unions do things differently but if a person says they can't do business in the Northeast because of unions, then they don't want to do business up there very bad. Again, I'm not a union guy and I'm glad I've never had to be in one, but my dad was in unions off and on for years - and he found ways to do his work the same way in a union shop as he did in a non-union shop. Sure, he had to work within the rules and sure, some of those rules were silly and onerous for workers, but it didn't stop progress. I work within silly and onerous rules in non-union plants all the time.

Unions just do things differently. They provide a lot of work direction that management normally provides, they oversee their own safety issues that management normally does, stuff like that. If a company is set up to work with unions, they eliminate a whole layer of management that they'd normally provide and various HR issues they normally grapple with are out of their hands. Again, I'm not pro-union; I'm just saying that there's no reason to think unions are going to stop progress and make business impossible. On balance, I don't like them but if you follow the process you can do whatever you need to do, and there ARE some benefits.
SteveS
Posts
5598
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
USA
11/15/2008 2:18pm
I guess you've never been to the union power plants around here. The Lake of the Ozarks (where I live) was created by a hydro project of Union Electric (now AmerenUE). The plant at the dam is union. Though the guys there (management and union types) are very friendly and work together well, it's funny how we have to follow the union's rules when we go there. We deliver signs there, and we have to use certain gates at certain times because we're not union. There are gates marked for their workers, for visitors, for others. They have to maintain these so that they can continue to do things in case there's a strike--even if it's not their own guys striking.

We don't have any union construction companies locally. The nearest is over 45 miles away. But if they hire a local company to remodel a room or paint something, they have to be prepared for the construction unions elsewhere to come strike the place because a non-union painter is there. In a strike, the union guys who work at the plant cannot cross the picket line. But they cannot picket the employees only gate 50 feet away, so they guys can still go to work. In a strike, if we had to deliver a sign, we'd have to go through the gate being picketed.

Stupid.
WhKnuckle
Posts
7327
Joined
7/17/2007
Location
USA
11/15/2008 3:14pm
You're anti-union because you don't like the gate you have to go through? I rest my case. That's anti-union thought process at its finest.

You must not go to very many industrial sites. You go through the gate you're told to enter and exity by. You drive on the roads that you're told to use. You go to the bathroom where you're told to. You smoke only in designated areas. You refrain from horseplay. You don't bring weapons or drugs on site - even legal drugs for which you have a perscription. You don't bring in any cameras. Every chemical in your vehicle must have a current MSDS in your posession. You must have a current list of tools and supplies that you bring in. You can be refused access at any time for any reason. You wear hard hats and safety glasses, and you may be required to wear steel toed shoes. You may be required to carry a respirator. You may be required to carry a chemically reactive warning device. You may be orientated and you may be required to pass a test to gain access. If you have any DWIs or felony convictions in your background you may be denied access. AND THAT'S AT A NON-UNION PLANT.
SteveS
Posts
5598
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
USA
11/15/2008 3:54pm
WhKnuckle wrote:
You're anti-union because you don't like the gate you have to go through? I rest my case. That's anti-union thought process at its finest. You must...
You're anti-union because you don't like the gate you have to go through? I rest my case. That's anti-union thought process at its finest.

You must not go to very many industrial sites. You go through the gate you're told to enter and exity by. You drive on the roads that you're told to use. You go to the bathroom where you're told to. You smoke only in designated areas. You refrain from horseplay. You don't bring weapons or drugs on site - even legal drugs for which you have a perscription. You don't bring in any cameras. Every chemical in your vehicle must have a current MSDS in your posession. You must have a current list of tools and supplies that you bring in. You can be refused access at any time for any reason. You wear hard hats and safety glasses, and you may be required to wear steel toed shoes. You may be required to carry a respirator. You may be required to carry a chemically reactive warning device. You may be orientated and you may be required to pass a test to gain access. If you have any DWIs or felony convictions in your background you may be denied access. AND THAT'S AT A NON-UNION PLANT.
The post I made was not an anti-union post. It was directed at your comment about electrical power plants not being any different in how they work.

It was just pointing out some of the dumb, petty things you have to go through because of the fact that they are a union shop.

And if you think about it, having a separate gate for union employees to enter through because they will not cross a picket line is a bit specious on the part of the workers at that plant.

If you really claim to have solidarity with other unions because of this not crossing picket lines thing, how does going through another gate to avoid the "technical" crossing of a picket line demonstrate such solidarity?
11/15/2008 4:30pm
Walmart will take care of her. She doesn't need two jobs.
Tiki
Posts
10677
Joined
8/1/2006
Location
Corona, CA, USA
Fantasy
11/15/2008 5:13pm
My experience with Unions - Printing Industry, Trade Shows and Hospitals all about the same. Lazy SOB's I mean go out of their way to be lazy. Can't do that now... Im on break in five minutes. Dont move that, you will be fined. Union guy HAS to do it. That floor will be cleaned, we just have to get the team there to do it, so you will have to wait. So my job has to be scheduled around their job.

So in short. If in all those instances when I ask for assistance or need something it would have been done now. Not later. Not after a 15 minuet break that I had to wait five minutes for but now. I have had some dealing with the Union in Hollywood, I have to say that was a different experience, a good one. But on low level menial tasks the union has been more of a hindrance then help. And when all is said and done, two people have been paid for the one persons job. I agree. UAW has been more of hurt to the auto industry then help. I feel if you need someone to stand up for you to do your job, then both sides of that job need to be evaluated. The shitty management, the lazy worker.
`ol Ger
Posts
6269
Joined
7/15/2007
Location
Piqua, OH, USA
11/15/2008 6:10pm Edited Date/Time 4/16/2016 9:13pm
flarider wrote:
My direct experience with unions has been trade shows and seeing everything I described. On many occasions I have seen "I can't do that, that's another...
My direct experience with unions has been trade shows and seeing everything I described.
On many occasions I have seen "I can't do that, that's another union" to "I am not allowed to move anything"
Ask people in the industry (you know this Tweeker) why we don't have SX in the Northeast...Unions
I have worked for GM Allison (as s subcontractor) and personally witnessed the things that Dave described, along with a few others. Laziness, and "I am owed something" abounds in the people I encountered.

Example. Our materials were shipped to the plant in Indianapolis. The drums were stored outside in dry storage. When we needed some of our materials brought over to the work site, I went to find a forklift operator. I found one - a black fellow sitting on a chair out in the sun (doing nothing I might add). I asked him to bring a couple of drums over to the job site (we were ready for them, and needed them). He launched into a meaningless whine about how he wasn't paid enough money at his "job" and wasn't interested in moving the drums. I stood there for a while and listened, not real sure what to do. One thing I know, I was getting angry, real angry (not the funny kind, but the deep down serious no-nonsense kind). Funny thing about olger, his voice gets quieter when he reaches that point (seldom reach it). I said softly "Suit yourself pardner, I don't have time for lazy people" and turned on my heel and headed over to my truck. Really irritated...

Before I reached the truck, He hollered over to me "alright, I'll move the ^%$# drums."

Fine. I told him where to put them. And he did.


oG




`ol Ger
Posts
6269
Joined
7/15/2007
Location
Piqua, OH, USA
11/15/2008 6:11pm
WhKnuckle
Posts
7327
Joined
7/17/2007
Location
USA
11/15/2008 6:43pm
`ol Ger wrote:
I have worked for GM Allison (as s subcontractor) and personally witnessed the things that Dave described, along with a few others. Laziness, and "I am...
I have worked for GM Allison (as s subcontractor) and personally witnessed the things that Dave described, along with a few others. Laziness, and "I am owed something" abounds in the people I encountered.

Example. Our materials were shipped to the plant in Indianapolis. The drums were stored outside in dry storage. When we needed some of our materials brought over to the work site, I went to find a forklift operator. I found one - a black fellow sitting on a chair out in the sun (doing nothing I might add). I asked him to bring a couple of drums over to the job site (we were ready for them, and needed them). He launched into a meaningless whine about how he wasn't paid enough money at his "job" and wasn't interested in moving the drums. I stood there for a while and listened, not real sure what to do. One thing I know, I was getting angry, real angry (not the funny kind, but the deep down serious no-nonsense kind). Funny thing about olger, his voice gets quieter when he reaches that point (seldom reach it). I said softly "Suit yourself pardner, I don't have time for lazy people" and turned on my heel and headed over to my truck. Really irritated...

Before I reached the truck, He hollered over to me "alright, I'll move the ^%$# drums."

Fine. I told him where to put them. And he did.


oG




Yeah, union people are the only Americans who whine about their jobs. Funny, because we did a construction project at our house here a few years ago, and the only crew that whined and then did a crappy job were the roofers.
jonjon714
Posts
5916
Joined
4/29/2008
Location
Virginia Beach, VA, USA
11/15/2008 7:12pm
I'm not bashing unions...just a story about being a non-union contractor in union environments a few years back...

First, the fella's I dealt with at the Ford plant in Norfolk totally understood why my company wasn't a union company in Virginia. During a pre construction meeting the first question they asked me was, "What do you drive?" I told them we had Dodge trucks and they were o.k. with that. A guy told me as long as it's American made you can drive into the plant. I totally respected that. Had no problems and we were there about 6 months.

However, we did a job at Beth Steel's shipyard in Baltimore and it was different story. They sabotaged all sorts of shit...cut every air line I had and threw them off the dry dock and into the water. Never, ever could get promised crane service and had to rent a crane to stage and de-stage our materials and equipment. Caught guys dicking with our welding equipment and compressors to the point I had to assign tenders to monitor them constantly. It was an amazing experience to say the least. And I would have to say the guys at that yard were some of the laziest pieces of shit I've ever been around. Just about got in a fight or had to break guys up everyday for the 2 months we were there...

Every union is different I suppose.
RMZ819
Posts
1320
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
11/16/2008 4:04am Edited Date/Time 11/16/2008 4:12am
Your socialist President just gave away 700 billion of your tax $ to save the rich. But that's OK??? You Republicans are a mess. No wonder you guys are falling apart. You are to dumb to look outside the Republican box and see whats going on in the real world. Hey fucker, Did you cash your stimulus/assistance check that you received over the summer??? As soon as you did you gave up your right to bitch about government help.
11/16/2008 12:56pm
RMZ819 wrote:
Your socialist President just gave away 700 billion of your tax $ to save the rich. But that's OK??? You Republicans are a mess. No wonder...
Your socialist President just gave away 700 billion of your tax $ to save the rich. But that's OK??? You Republicans are a mess. No wonder you guys are falling apart. You are to dumb to look outside the Republican box and see whats going on in the real world. Hey fucker, Did you cash your stimulus/assistance check that you received over the summer??? As soon as you did you gave up your right to bitch about government help.
Don't worry, Obama will make it all go away. The people will be put above our wealthy Business leaders!!! As Obama says, it's time for a CHANGE. Just look at poor Bill Clinton running around the World and you can tell the Democratic Party is about CHANGE.
flarider
Posts
25496
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Daytona Beach, FL, USA
11/16/2008 12:59pm
Don't worry, Obama will make it all go away. The people will be put above our wealthy Business leaders!!! As Obama says, it's time for a...
Don't worry, Obama will make it all go away. The people will be put above our wealthy Business leaders!!! As Obama says, it's time for a CHANGE. Just look at poor Bill Clinton running around the World and you can tell the Democratic Party is about CHANGE.
Another sore loser
flarider
Posts
25496
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Daytona Beach, FL, USA
11/16/2008 1:38pm
You hit your head?
11/16/2008 2:06pm
flarider wrote:
You hit your head?
No, I'm fine. It's just that it's a lot easier to promise than deliver and that's a bipartisan statement. There's a lot that can be done to help both the middle class and lower class. I'm still not a believer in raising taxes to generate business but we'll see if I'm wrong.
flarider
Posts
25496
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Daytona Beach, FL, USA
11/16/2008 2:13pm
But stuff you just mentioned was never promised by anyone.
So if you didn't hit your head, you just must be delusional
11/16/2008 3:14pm
I must be delusional. If I take the man for his word then I'm about to find out when the deadline is. There's a promise in this statement.


Obama, who had resisted measures to tie money for the war to a deadline for withdrawal, said Sunday he would no longer support funding measures in the Senate that do not include deadlines.

"We are going to bring an end to this war and I will fight hard in the United States Senate to make sure we don't pass any funding bill that does not have a deadline," Obama told the crowd.

Oldmotoguy
Posts
1772
Joined
8/29/2008
Location
Oceanside, CA, USA
11/16/2008 3:19pm
I must be delusional. If I take the man for his word then I'm about to find out when the deadline is. There's a promise in...
I must be delusional. If I take the man for his word then I'm about to find out when the deadline is. There's a promise in this statement.


Obama, who had resisted measures to tie money for the war to a deadline for withdrawal, said Sunday he would no longer support funding measures in the Senate that do not include deadlines.

"We are going to bring an end to this war and I will fight hard in the United States Senate to make sure we don't pass any funding bill that does not have a deadline," Obama told the crowd.

BO is almost like slick willy ..he say anything and make big promises,but in the end its just another bullshit polititian..the whole system needs re-building
flarider
Posts
25496
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Daytona Beach, FL, USA
11/16/2008 4:00pm
Yeah, vote for Pat Paulsen who'll be completely alienated by the entire Congress and not be able to accomplish anything!

Hooray!

Post a reply to: Unions are killing Auto industry

The Latest