AMA vs. MXGP

3/6/2015 12:56pm
What they add to racing is what the whole sport is about. If they only took the top guys that could win for each moto, what...
What they add to racing is what the whole sport is about. If they only took the top guys that could win for each moto, what would that bring for the fans and the people whose goal is to line up even if a factory guy calls em a squid? There's people out there that cheer just for those back markers. Yea, they could potentially mess with the leaders but its part of racing. If they want only the top guys in races, stick to the dash for cash's in arena cross. Lappers are more of an issue in SX and with this season, 20 out of the 22 on the gate had winning potential within the last 5 years. American motocross is all about the 40 man gate!
iBobbyb wrote:
still not one example of what they add to the racing..... and as far as Sx goes, id say they all actually belong out there. at...
still not one example of what they add to the racing..... and as far as Sx goes, id say they all actually belong out there. at A1 20 of em finished on the lead lap. and if the % of riders that finish on the lead lap was higher in mx, id be all for it. but seriously, whats the point of having a guy thats 13 seconds slower a lap on the track? because some people cheer for them? they could cheer for them at a local race then... and its only a part of racing because we have 40 man gates, and only roughly 20 guys fast enough to not get lapped every week. and what exactly is the whole sport about? i thought we raced to win, which would mean winning is what the sports about. but i guess im wrong? i guess its about lining up at a pro gate, even if you cant hang with the known pros? im not saying cut it down to 5 guys, since thats really about how many actually have a shot at winning. im just saying we dont need guys on the gate that could rip a holeshot, not have a single crash in the moto, and still end up finishing in a non point paying position. and what exactly makes american motocross all about a 40 man gate? because thats the number they came up with a long time ago? change is the devil huh.

and maybe if the gate was smaller, those riders whose goal is to just line up, would be forced to work harder to accomplish that goal, and then we could potentially have more riders who arent just in the way.

you have yet to really explain any points you have tried to make. your just stating your opinion with nothing to support it...

and the funniest part of this to me, is im actually a fan of the guy that qualified 36th, and im using as an example. and theres also a few local pros who i root for who have no chance at top 20. lol



Those guys are out there trying to make it. It is ALL A PART of racing. Watching a battle of the top guys trying to work their away around lappers is ALL A PART of racing.

Fortunately, I don't need to tell DC to, "Leave it as it is." He already knows that guys trying to make it are a part of racing.
3/6/2015 1:13pm
If you really want to enjoy motocross then TV will never do it justice. I love full gates and privateers mixing it up with factory riders...
If you really want to enjoy motocross then TV will never do it justice. I love full gates and privateers mixing it up with factory riders.





jemcee wrote:
while I agree with the sentiment but also don't care about there only being 20-30 on a GP gate.. but I've only quoted cause your bottom...
while I agree with the sentiment but also don't care about there only being 20-30 on a GP gate.. but I've only quoted cause your bottom pic is JLaw and Ryan Hughes and I'm not sure either have ever been privateers haha unless I'm missing your point
That was in 2005. I'm sure JLaw had sponsorships but this wasn't a factory supported effort. Here's one to play it safe.
If you show up and give it 100% sometimes you even end up with a factory ride




Even this "meaningless" battle in the back of the pack was worth watching.




iBobbyb
Posts
158
Joined
12/18/2014
Location
Mt Morris, MI, USA
3/6/2015 1:28pm
DC wrote:
I get iBobby's points, but I disagree with them. I like the 40-man gates and was lucky enough to be on a couple, at the very...
I get iBobby's points, but I disagree with them. I like the 40-man gates and was lucky enough to be on a couple, at the very far outside. I didn't score any points at the 1985 High Point 125 National, but it was one of my all-time favorite memories, and I got lapped by Ron Lechien, but not until almost the very end. I was in the local newspaper, and I think I had some friends from high school and college there cheering for me. Getting lapped made me reconsider my future and my commitment to college, and I think I chose well. But had I not had the chance to have that experience, maybe I would not have raced mini cycles and amateurs all those years to get there.

Oh, and I remember both Shae Bentley and Nathan Ramsey winning the Las Vegas SX after qualifying with the very last LCQ spot, which equates to qualifying 44th. And didn't Jeremy McGrath qualify last at Pontiac in 1994 and then win the main?

DC
MX Sports
i get why you disagree with them, because you have personal feeling about this situation, since you would have been one of the guys to not make it, if it was the way i suggested.. but i have personal feelings about it as well, after being lapped when i was younger, and getting in the way of a battle for the lead, costing the kid a shot at a win. it was only a local, little kid race. but i felt terrible about it, and it gave me a personal vendetta against lappers. lol... i didnt belong on the track with those kids, and it cost him. and i dont think my fun, and experiences that i had are worth taking away from someone elses fun and experience. he worked harder, put more time in, or something to be faster than me. so why should he be the one that gets punished. its kinda like giving everyone a participation trophy.

and im not saying i think everyone on the gate has to be fast enough to win, or finish top 20. just being a guy as fast as you, and making it close to the end before getting lapped would be fine. but like i said before. should we make the gate even bigger? so more guys can have those experiences? theres room on the track for it. the leaders arent in lappers the whole race currently, and getting around lappers seems to be what racing is all about, so lets add more to it. it would also guarantee theres always something to watch at a track like redbud. because i know when i was there, there was still some gaps where there wasnt nothing to watch, especially on the first few laps.


you said getting lapped made you reconsider your future. so having a 40 man gate crushed your dreams. you say if you wouldnt have had that chance, you might not have raced to get there... but what if it just made you push harder to be fast enough to make a smaller sized gate, and then you didnt get lapped, and you kept following your dream. basically what im saying here is, if your goal is to just make the motos, then that as hard as your gonna work. so if you set the bar higher, theyll reach higher.

@wired
sure that battle at the back of the pack was probably exciting. but if the leaders caught them and had to deal with there "meaningless" battle, it could very quickly becoming "meaningful" if it hampers with the leaders and the outcome of the race and possible championship. so personally, id rather see those extremely fast guys go to a AM national and battle it out closer to the front of the pack.


in a perfect world, id say combine both series. have ONE major series that all the fast guys from all over the world race in. then we would have a 40 man gate of people close to the top guys speed.

and just to make sure everyone still knows, this isnt personal to me. im bored, at home, alone, passing time till i go to my buddies. so id literally argue anything at the moment, even if i was arguing against my beliefs. i have a problem, i know. should have been a lawyer i guess. lol. and i also apologize if some of my paragraphs dont make sense, or jump around. i go back and add and remove and change things while im working on the other paragraphs. haha. and also, i dont recommend doing dabs, and debating. ahaha
3/6/2015 2:01pm Edited Date/Time 3/6/2015 3:02pm
iBobbyb wrote:
i get why you disagree with them, because you have personal feeling about this situation, since you would have been one of the guys to not...
i get why you disagree with them, because you have personal feeling about this situation, since you would have been one of the guys to not make it, if it was the way i suggested.. but i have personal feelings about it as well, after being lapped when i was younger, and getting in the way of a battle for the lead, costing the kid a shot at a win. it was only a local, little kid race. but i felt terrible about it, and it gave me a personal vendetta against lappers. lol... i didnt belong on the track with those kids, and it cost him. and i dont think my fun, and experiences that i had are worth taking away from someone elses fun and experience. he worked harder, put more time in, or something to be faster than me. so why should he be the one that gets punished. its kinda like giving everyone a participation trophy.

and im not saying i think everyone on the gate has to be fast enough to win, or finish top 20. just being a guy as fast as you, and making it close to the end before getting lapped would be fine. but like i said before. should we make the gate even bigger? so more guys can have those experiences? theres room on the track for it. the leaders arent in lappers the whole race currently, and getting around lappers seems to be what racing is all about, so lets add more to it. it would also guarantee theres always something to watch at a track like redbud. because i know when i was there, there was still some gaps where there wasnt nothing to watch, especially on the first few laps.


you said getting lapped made you reconsider your future. so having a 40 man gate crushed your dreams. you say if you wouldnt have had that chance, you might not have raced to get there... but what if it just made you push harder to be fast enough to make a smaller sized gate, and then you didnt get lapped, and you kept following your dream. basically what im saying here is, if your goal is to just make the motos, then that as hard as your gonna work. so if you set the bar higher, theyll reach higher.

@wired
sure that battle at the back of the pack was probably exciting. but if the leaders caught them and had to deal with there "meaningless" battle, it could very quickly becoming "meaningful" if it hampers with the leaders and the outcome of the race and possible championship. so personally, id rather see those extremely fast guys go to a AM national and battle it out closer to the front of the pack.


in a perfect world, id say combine both series. have ONE major series that all the fast guys from all over the world race in. then we would have a 40 man gate of people close to the top guys speed.

and just to make sure everyone still knows, this isnt personal to me. im bored, at home, alone, passing time till i go to my buddies. so id literally argue anything at the moment, even if i was arguing against my beliefs. i have a problem, i know. should have been a lawyer i guess. lol. and i also apologize if some of my paragraphs dont make sense, or jump around. i go back and add and remove and change things while im working on the other paragraphs. haha. and also, i dont recommend doing dabs, and debating. ahaha
Damn....didn't know or understand the pain of getting lapped

The Shop

jemcee
Posts
12903
Joined
8/11/2008
Location
AU
3/6/2015 3:20pm
It's making me laugh a little that a thread titled AMA vs GP features quite a civil discussion about field sizes

yet one that could be called Thailand Track turns into a venomous name calling, contradicting, shit talking, pissing match haha
DC
Posts
3889
Joined
5/1/2009
Location
Morgantown, WV, USA
3/6/2015 8:28pm Edited Date/Time 3/6/2015 8:29pm
iBobbyb, I didn't say "so having a 40 man gate crushed your dreams," I said it made me reconsider my future. So did racing in three SX main events. I was lucky enough to read the writing on the wall early on, and then I realized my other (and better) dream of starting a magazine. But without the passion and love of motocross, I would never be here now, either as a promoter nor publisher, nor even a fan and Vital poster.

Don't be so quick to provide closure to someone else's dream. We all deserve a reasonable, adequate chance at being whoever the hell we want to try to be.... In America, anyway. And certainly on Vital!

Carry on, and good bench-racing this weekend to all.

DC
MX Sports
The Rock
Posts
8758
Joined
3/21/2007
Location
HAIKU, HI, USA
3/6/2015 10:30pm
In a perfect world the USGP at GH would be both the last GP and the last National. Sure there would be beaucoup sticking points but think how cool it would be.

If there is a will there is a way. Maybe run their last motos combined with the top 20 from each series?
Aaryn234
Posts
3328
Joined
8/19/2007
Location
South Australia, SA, AU
3/6/2015 10:36pm
71Fish wrote:
Who is better/faster, AMA MX or MXGP? Some deeper analysis than I did this morning in about 3 minutes would be interesting. I compared the most...
Who is better/faster, AMA MX or MXGP? Some deeper analysis than I did this morning in about 3 minutes would be interesting.

I compared the most recent MXGP race in Qatar to the AMA's last race of the 2014 in Utah. Obviously different tracks, different conditions etc., plus it's only one race. So take it for what it's worth, I have time to kill this morning.

Comparing the top 10, in Qatar 10 place finished an average of 1:05 behind the winner.
In Utah last year, 10 place finished one lap down, or looking at lap times, probably about 2:00 minutes behind. In Qatar you have to go all the way to 18th to find your first lapped rider.

This year Glen Helen will provide a much better comparison. According to the MXGP web site, the last time GP raced there was 2011. Looking at AMA lap times, it seems the track has changed from 2014 to the last time AMA raced there.

Don't know who is better or faster just from looking at one race, but MXGP seems to have closer competition. Glen Helen will be fun.

You could have compared a couple of other things, like how many laps did the guy in 40th place in the American MX race compared to the guy in 40th place in the GP class.

Also how many seconds slower did the 40th guy in the U.S at the final round qualify behind the fastest rider compared to the 40th rider in the first round of the GP.

They are the stats I want to see.

Also how many riders at the first round of the World Championship missed out racing due to not qualifying Smile

Post a reply to: AMA vs. MXGP

The Latest