Business owner question.....

borg
Posts
7078
Joined
12/7/2009
Location
Long Beach, CA, USA
3/25/2013 4:51pm
SlingShot wrote:
If I have to pay an online sales tax, I'll make damn sure I shop online as much as possible then. And for the guy above...
If I have to pay an online sales tax, I'll make damn sure I shop online as much as possible then.

And for the guy above talking about "showcasing" (where a person walks into a store to check prices, then goes home and orders online), what's wrong with that? Hell I do it all the time. And consumers are crazy if they don't.
What the F is wrong with covering your ass before making a purchase? Am I to spend extra and "buy local" out of pity?
Holy shit. You bed wetting punters are out of your minds.
Some of us appreciate that we can walk into a store that has the product on the floor so we can pick it up, touch it, check it out and try it on. It's totally chickenshit to then go home and order it online from somebody else for the difference of sales tax. I'm talking about the local mom and pop stores that actually stock the shit on the shelf and know your name like the guy that started this thread.

You sound like one of those assholes that buys a tool from Home Depot, uses it and then takes back for a refund. Are you such a tight ass that you screw your fucking socks on in the morning?
MR. X
Posts
6913
Joined
6/24/2010
Location
North Tonawanda, NY, USA
3/25/2013 5:29pm
I agree about saving sales tax is not a reason to shop online , the last decent purchase i made was a rifle scope , went local and they wanted 450 , checked optics planet and they wanted 299 , i would have loved to spend locally but they wouldn't budge so i went online.
tunedlength
Posts
2787
Joined
12/9/2006
Location
Ontario, CA, USA
3/25/2013 5:53pm
SlingShot wrote:
If I have to pay an online sales tax, I'll make damn sure I shop online as much as possible then. And for the guy above...
If I have to pay an online sales tax, I'll make damn sure I shop online as much as possible then.

And for the guy above talking about "showcasing" (where a person walks into a store to check prices, then goes home and orders online), what's wrong with that? Hell I do it all the time. And consumers are crazy if they don't.
What the F is wrong with covering your ass before making a purchase? Am I to spend extra and "buy local" out of pity?
Holy shit. You bed wetting punters are out of your minds.
Well there you go.
This is becoming your typical walk in customer. I see it at the bicycle shop I frequent.
"customer" asks the shop keeper about what he would suggest for a suspension upgrade.
Shop keeper spends an hour of his life explaining why this Fork will be better then another fork for the "customer".
All the while they are in a building that costs the shop keeper money. the AC is running for the convenience of the clientele.
He may even have the fork on hand (shop keeper paid for it already) so the customer can hold it, salivate over it etc..
The "customer" leaves with the the information and buys the component online.
The "customer" see's nothing wrong with this.
The same customer will wonder why the dealer went out of business.
Choppy
Posts
1931
Joined
12/16/2012
Location
USA
3/25/2013 6:12pm Edited Date/Time 3/25/2013 6:13pm
SlingShot wrote:
If I have to pay an online sales tax, I'll make damn sure I shop online as much as possible then. And for the guy above...
If I have to pay an online sales tax, I'll make damn sure I shop online as much as possible then.

And for the guy above talking about "showcasing" (where a person walks into a store to check prices, then goes home and orders online), what's wrong with that? Hell I do it all the time. And consumers are crazy if they don't.
What the F is wrong with covering your ass before making a purchase? Am I to spend extra and "buy local" out of pity?
Holy shit. You bed wetting punters are out of your minds.
If people like you continue to do things like that you won't have the option to check things out in person before buying them anymore....

The Shop

SlingShot
Posts
230
Joined
10/20/2012
Location
Tulsa, OK, USA
3/25/2013 6:40pm
I guess capitalism is only mean for companies selling shit?
It works both ways. Consumers save cash and cut corners when they're smart enough.
Some of you crack me up.

If I see a TV I like at best buy, am I supposed to buy it there on the spot, or do my research and order the thing online and save myself 50-60 bucks?
Choppy
Posts
1931
Joined
12/16/2012
Location
USA
3/25/2013 7:02pm Edited Date/Time 3/25/2013 7:03pm
SlingShot wrote:
I guess capitalism is only mean for companies selling shit? It works both ways. Consumers save cash and cut corners when they're smart enough. Some of...
I guess capitalism is only mean for companies selling shit?
It works both ways. Consumers save cash and cut corners when they're smart enough.
Some of you crack me up.

If I see a TV I like at best buy, am I supposed to buy it there on the spot, or do my research and order the thing online and save myself 50-60 bucks?
What will you do when you can't do that anymore because Best Buy goes out of business because of people like you?
SlingShot
Posts
230
Joined
10/20/2012
Location
Tulsa, OK, USA
3/25/2013 7:05pm
SlingShot wrote:
I guess capitalism is only mean for companies selling shit? It works both ways. Consumers save cash and cut corners when they're smart enough. Some of...
I guess capitalism is only mean for companies selling shit?
It works both ways. Consumers save cash and cut corners when they're smart enough.
Some of you crack me up.

If I see a TV I like at best buy, am I supposed to buy it there on the spot, or do my research and order the thing online and save myself 50-60 bucks?
Choppy wrote:
What will you do when you can't do that anymore because Best Buy goes out of business because of people like you?
Order from Walmart.com. Duh.
tunedlength
Posts
2787
Joined
12/9/2006
Location
Ontario, CA, USA
3/25/2013 7:52pm
SlingShot wrote:
I guess capitalism is only mean for companies selling shit? It works both ways. Consumers save cash and cut corners when they're smart enough. Some of...
I guess capitalism is only mean for companies selling shit?
It works both ways. Consumers save cash and cut corners when they're smart enough.
Some of you crack me up.

If I see a TV I like at best buy, am I supposed to buy it there on the spot, or do my research and order the thing online and save myself 50-60 bucks?
If you are OK with the new commerce model (online only, no brick and mortar) then everything is cool.
racin mason
Posts
893
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Long Beach, WA, USA
3/25/2013 7:54pm
SlingShot wrote:
I guess capitalism is only mean for companies selling shit? It works both ways. Consumers save cash and cut corners when they're smart enough. Some of...
I guess capitalism is only mean for companies selling shit?
It works both ways. Consumers save cash and cut corners when they're smart enough.
Some of you crack me up.

If I see a TV I like at best buy, am I supposed to buy it there on the spot, or do my research and order the thing online and save myself 50-60 bucks?
Best Buys footin the bill for the show room where you are checkin out some tv's, sales man answering your questions,it IS costing them money to talk to you.You go buy your tv from some one else,you sir are a douche,not one of the good kinds , just plain old vinegar and water..
SlingShot
Posts
230
Joined
10/20/2012
Location
Tulsa, OK, USA
3/25/2013 8:04pm
SlingShot wrote:
I guess capitalism is only mean for companies selling shit? It works both ways. Consumers save cash and cut corners when they're smart enough. Some of...
I guess capitalism is only mean for companies selling shit?
It works both ways. Consumers save cash and cut corners when they're smart enough.
Some of you crack me up.

If I see a TV I like at best buy, am I supposed to buy it there on the spot, or do my research and order the thing online and save myself 50-60 bucks?
Best Buys footin the bill for the show room where you are checkin out some tv's, sales man answering your questions,it IS costing them money to...
Best Buys footin the bill for the show room where you are checkin out some tv's, sales man answering your questions,it IS costing them money to talk to you.You go buy your tv from some one else,you sir are a douche,not one of the good kinds , just plain old vinegar and water..
You're wrong. I don't talk to anyone at Best Buy.
silver753
Posts
145
Joined
5/18/2010
Location
Brick, NJ, USA
3/25/2013 9:30pm
Just a quick thought to this comment....

Sometimes I feel like I'm not paying my guys enough, but realistically there's only room for myself and my right hand guy to make a good living (in my opinion), at least at my current financial situation. As a current retail/service shop, I can only imagine what costs are on a warehouse operation, but I'm pretty sure I could hire quite a few employees to close to minimum wage. Not that I would want to, but I could. I can't hire an up front counter person and a good mechanic for a cheap wage. NEVER.
silver753
Posts
145
Joined
5/18/2010
Location
Brick, NJ, USA
3/25/2013 10:06pm
Bueller here...

I know what you're saying about being competitive, as a shop we are, that's why we are here and will be in the future. I think you might have read my post out of context, or maybe I wrote it wrong. Either way, I'm just saying it's like 2 kids opening up a lemonade stand down the street from each other. My shop would be one, "online" would be the other. We both sell to an actual person, they both live on the same street, and they both use or consume the product. But one lemonade stand has to charge tax, the other doesn't.

I'm not arguing about margins, a buck here, a buck there, I know how to be competitive. I'm just asking my state to level the "TAX" field for my business and customers. Like my second example on the wheels stated, we made $25.00 profit on an $800 set of wheels. It could have been triple that if my state/federal gov would close the gap. Some states already do, mine doesn't. I'm not petitioning, I'm not picketing, I'm not writing a letter, but the bill is probably gonna be on the ballot so that's what I'm leaning towards.

You are correct about the costs of goods. Like I stated, we have been buying for close to ten years and I get some of the biggest discounts available in my state, I know for a fact it's the same as or more than pretty much all the OEM dealers in my area. The places where shops like myself and the dealer suffer is the HUUUUUGE purchases the HUUUUUUGE online retailers make. Why? Because they buy more in one month than I would in 20 years. I know, you tell me to suck it up and become a multi-million dollar shop. That's what I'm trying to do.......it's just hard to get there when they automatically get a 6% to 10% advantage on barganing price (depending on what state you live in). If I made an extra 10% for the last 9 years in business maybe I would be a big success story like you tell me to be.

And just so you know, I get killer rates on plastic. I've been dealing with those companies for cloes to 15 years, I know what really goes on in that industry. And when did you last buy a tire for $50?! I'm sure it wasn't a Dunlop, Bridgestone, Pirelli, Michelin, Maxxis, IRC, or Kenda.
silver753
Posts
145
Joined
5/18/2010
Location
Brick, NJ, USA
3/25/2013 10:09pm
SlingShot wrote:
If I have to pay an online sales tax, I'll make damn sure I shop online as much as possible then. And for the guy above...
If I have to pay an online sales tax, I'll make damn sure I shop online as much as possible then.

And for the guy above talking about "showcasing" (where a person walks into a store to check prices, then goes home and orders online), what's wrong with that? Hell I do it all the time. And consumers are crazy if they don't.
What the F is wrong with covering your ass before making a purchase? Am I to spend extra and "buy local" out of pity?
Holy shit. You bed wetting punters are out of your minds.
Well there you go. This is becoming your typical walk in customer. I see it at the bicycle shop I frequent. "customer" asks the shop keeper...
Well there you go.
This is becoming your typical walk in customer. I see it at the bicycle shop I frequent.
"customer" asks the shop keeper about what he would suggest for a suspension upgrade.
Shop keeper spends an hour of his life explaining why this Fork will be better then another fork for the "customer".
All the while they are in a building that costs the shop keeper money. the AC is running for the convenience of the clientele.
He may even have the fork on hand (shop keeper paid for it already) so the customer can hold it, salivate over it etc..
The "customer" leaves with the the information and buys the component online.
The "customer" see's nothing wrong with this.
The same customer will wonder why the dealer went out of business.
Tunedlength understands this. Especially the last 2 lines.
tunedlength
Posts
2787
Joined
12/9/2006
Location
Ontario, CA, USA
3/25/2013 10:46pm
The tax increases his bottom line price to the customer.
The dealer will usually have to pay shipping to get the product to his shop, So leave shipping out of the equation.
Why cant you see this?
jtomasik
Posts
12895
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Golden, CO, USA
3/26/2013 8:55am Edited Date/Time 3/26/2013 8:55am
Um, I often have had to pay for shipping in addition to the advertised price for products I buy online. Not all is free. So, are you saying for those guys, we should then charge a sales tax, because the shipping is paid for by the customer?
ken754
Posts
87
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
USA
3/26/2013 9:00am
I rarely pay shipping cost when ordering online, mostly from Amazon. For me, paying tax for online purchases would not change my buying habits. I purchase local when the price is comparable or I need the product now. Most all of my online buying is for my own convenience or local price was much higher.
jtomasik
Posts
12895
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Golden, CO, USA
3/26/2013 9:05am
And, again, very often I have to pay for shipping in addition to the price that's advertised. So, for those guys, they don't incur the cost you're saying is part of every online retailer's business. Your blanket statement is inaccurate. It only works for SOME online retailers, but definitely not all.

So, should we make those guys pay sales tax, because in their case, they don't have the issue you're trying to apply to all online retailers?


A yes or no reply is all that's necessary.
jtomasik
Posts
12895
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Golden, CO, USA
3/26/2013 9:13am
Nope. Never said that. That'd be your attempt at a strawman argument so you don't have to answer the question. Final try: for the sales where the buyer pays shipping, should we make the online retailer pay sales tax?


Yes or no.
whyZ
Posts
1173
Joined
4/15/2009
Location
Phoenix, AZ, USA
3/26/2013 9:19am
I understands oldfarts position on freight cost. Shipping cost in my industry will truly make the difference on making a profit or not. I think where oldfart is point is flawed, is the mom & pop's B&M store, and the online store are not on the same level of discounts offered by carriers.

I have LTL carriers coming in and out of facility everyday, as well as UPS & FedEx daily pick ups. My LTL carriers discount me starting at 65% and usually top out at 80%. I know that I do not pay the same rate as someone with who has a truck pulling in once a month, or even twice, same goes for daily pick up. I have no idea how anyone is supposed to improvise that.
jtomasik
Posts
12895
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Golden, CO, USA
3/26/2013 9:33am
This isn't changing the subject. It's completely relevant. Your argument is that online retailers have an inherent cost of doing business that regular retailers don't. And, it's that which creates a 'level playing field', so online retailers shouldn't have to pay sales tax. I'm saying that isn't true in all cases. There are online retailers who make their customers pay shipping fees. In fact, it's very common. I know I had to pay shipping when ordering from Kohl's. I had to pay shipping when ordering from Sears. It's quite possible that even the majority of online retailers make their customers pay for shipping. So, the 'level playing field' you suggest doesn't apply to them.

Should we make them pay sales tax?
jtomasik
Posts
12895
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Golden, CO, USA
3/26/2013 9:44am
The subject of this thread is whether online retailers should have to pay a sales tax. I'm addressing that directly, based on your ''argument'.

So, you're saying online retailers, even the ones who make their clients pay shipping, shouldn't pay sales tax. In that case, then it's arguable that those online retailers have an advantage over the guy who runs a retail business that is point-of-sale.
jtomasik
Posts
12895
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Golden, CO, USA
3/26/2013 9:52am
Because he doesn't have to pay sales tax.
jtomasik
Posts
12895
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Golden, CO, USA
3/26/2013 10:11am
Then charge freight to your customer like many online retailers do. Duh.
jtomasik
Posts
12895
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Golden, CO, USA
3/26/2013 10:23am
I told you, in the case where the online retailers charge their customers the freight fee, they have the advantage of not having to pay sales tax. In the case where the online retailer incurs the cost of shipping, then that advantage might not exist, depending on the actual sale and numbers. So, your contention that there is no advantage only holds true in selected cases. In others, you're wrong.
4stroke4DWIN
Posts
2765
Joined
1/15/2012
Location
texas city, TX, USA
3/26/2013 10:36am
silver753 wrote:
Are you for or against online sales tax? I've owned my own retail business for almost ten years and I for one, support it. I admit...
Are you for or against online sales tax?

I've owned my own retail business for almost ten years and I for one, support it. I admit, I haven't really done any in depth research on the matter, but from my side, I'm 100% for it. I'm sure some of the respones here will shed some light my way on the other side of it.

As the owner of a small brick and motar motorcycle shop that does roughly 1,000,000 per year, margins are TIGHT. A million sounds like a lot, but once you factor in payroll (2 to 6 employees, depending on the season) taxes, insurance, inventory, rent, utilities, ect, there's not a lot left. As a nameless poster, I will say I make more doing this than I ever did doing concrete or working as an employee at a shop. I don't see myself making over 70,000 per year anytime soon, but I do pretty good considering I work 50 to 60 hours per week for about 9 months out of the year. I sometimes wish for a regular 40 hour per week schedule and a set salary.

Back to the subject, I find it VERY difficult to compete with online stores sometimes. I like to think we make it by on customer service. But it would be nice if the big online guys had to add an extra 5% to 8% sales tax into thier price, like we do. Here's an example. If you buy a Dunlop MX51 110/90-19" or 110/80-19" from us, we pay, as a dealer with a pretty good discount, $80.00. That's our cost (rounded up to the nearest dollar). If I price it at $10.00 over cost, which is what we do, and add sales tax, we are MORE than what you can buy from Rocky Mtn or another online store. So that would be cost+$10.00 plus tax equals close to $96.00. If you pay with a credit card (or debit ran as a credit) it takes 2% to 4% off of that, so we make roughly $7.00 or so. This is what I sell them for and I still hear the occasional "You're too expensive", or "You're raping me on the tires BRO!".

If you put the exra tax on online, it would at least level the field somewhat, almost double my already weak margins. Another example is a set of wheels. Some of you won't believe it, but an extra 5% to 8% would help us out a ton. On a recent set of wheels I sold that matched the online price out the door, it was roughly $800 to the customer. After cost of product, shipping, and then lowering the price an extra $180 to match the already rediculous online price, I took off an extra $50 because I had to charge tax, but now I can offer it to the customer at the same as online price. The customer paid with a credit card (an additional 3%) I ended up with roughly $25 in profit on an $800 ticket. Lame. It could have been $75 if the online guys had to add tax.

Sorry if I sounded like a whiner, I have no reason to cry too loudly from my soap box. I've been doing it for close to 10 years, and I know that's the way the business world works sometimes. We've made it every year and will continue to do so in the future. Sometimes we do good, sometimes we dont'. And some of you against the tax might say I only want it because I'm a greedy business owner and I would use the money to go buy a new pair of Gaerne SG-10's and maybe a down payment on a new 450. Well, you are correct. hahaha
I own a Mom and Pop MC shop also. Not much help on the tax deal buuuuut, The MX51 110/90/19 I pay 66.00 dollars for them. Might want to find a new distibutor. I don't know if it's because I'm in AZ and your in NJ? Just a heads up for you, maybe talk to your reps about the price?
Choppy
Posts
1931
Joined
12/16/2012
Location
USA
3/26/2013 11:00am
If you have to pay a sales tax if you own a shop, but don't have to pay a sales tax selling online then the government is giving an unfair advantage to the online seller/business model.

For the government to make things fair and equal one of two things need to occur.

1. Eliminate sales tax for the shopkeeper.
2. Tax Online retailers the same.
Choppy
Posts
1931
Joined
12/16/2012
Location
USA
3/26/2013 11:15am Edited Date/Time 3/26/2013 11:16am
They're giving a break to online retailers by not charging them a sales tax while they make shopkeepers pay a sales tax.

How's that not an advantage?
jtomasik
Posts
12895
Joined
8/17/2006
Location
Golden, CO, USA
3/26/2013 11:24am
What about a local appliance dealer? Some of them have to ship to the customer location. They charge their customer. They also have to pay sales tax. There are a lot of businesses that have to ship their products to the customer's location, yet they still have to pay sales tax.
Choppy
Posts
1931
Joined
12/16/2012
Location
USA
3/26/2013 11:27am
When you buy online, if it's under 100 dollars, most online retailers give you a choice to pay for ground, air, or next day air thus putting that on the buyer. In almost every store that price must be included in the pricing of the product sold.

"They're giving a break to online retailers by not charging them a sales tax while they make shopkeepers pay a sales tax."

Post a reply to: Business owner question.....

The Latest