Garbage disposers

SteveS
Profile picture for user SteveS
Posts
5598
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
USA
SteveS
Edited Date/Time 1/1/2012 9:37am
Anyone know anything about them?

My house came equipped with an InSinkErator Badger 1 when I bought it some 18 years ago. Yesterday it up and died. Not jammed (checked with the wrench--turns freely), reset button has no effect. Flip switch and it makes a humming noise. No motor noise at all.

So I looked online and I can get another Badger 1 at Lowes for $70 or thereabouts. I was thinking I should be able to just buy a new one, remove the old one and replace it.

But then I saw how many other models there are. I understand that a Badger 5 upgrades the 1/3 HP motor to 1/2 HP. And there's a Badger with a 1 HP motor. That gets you up to $140 or something. But then they have other models that are upwards of $300 and $400. What is in those that makes them cost so much?
|
BUTCH
Profile picture for user BUTCH
Posts
5088
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
USA
BUTCH 5/19/2009 1:27pm
5/19/2009 1:27pm
So the noise is coming from the switch?
jonjon714
Profile picture for user jonjon714
Posts
5916
Joined
4/29/2008
Location
Virginia Beach, VA, USA
jonjon714 5/19/2009 1:33pm
5/19/2009 1:33pm
Bigger motors and quieter equal more loot... $70 over 18 years is 3.88 per year.

I'd replace with the same unit unless you've had problems. Super easy to do.....
txmxer
Profile picture for user txmxer
Posts
9770
Joined
8/21/2006
Location
Weatherford, TX, USA
txmxer 5/19/2009 1:40pm
5/19/2009 1:40pm
I wouldn't go spend crazy. You would be happy if the old was still working. Unless there something you need that it didn't do, just replacement in kind.
Ivan
Profile picture for user Ivan
Posts
792
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Long Beach, CA, USA
Ivan 5/19/2009 2:09pm
5/19/2009 2:09pm Edited Date/Time 5/19/2009 2:17pm
Stay with the 1. Easy to replace. If your dishwasher drains into the GD, make sure you knockout the plug inside the connector on GD. Just in case you didn't already know.

The Shop

See All »
motogeezer
Profile picture for user motogeezer
Posts
5573
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Yorba Linda, CA, USA
motogeezer 5/19/2009 2:43pm
5/19/2009 2:43pm
Ivan wrote:
Stay with the 1. Easy to replace. If your dishwasher drains into the GD, make sure you knockout the plug inside the connector on GD. Just...
Stay with the 1. Easy to replace. If your dishwasher drains into the GD, make sure you knockout the plug inside the connector on GD. Just in case you didn't already know.
I could tell you a story, but it's a little bit embarrassing...
BUTCH
Profile picture for user BUTCH
Posts
5088
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
USA
BUTCH 5/19/2009 2:48pm
5/19/2009 2:48pm
Ivan wrote:
Stay with the 1. Easy to replace. If your dishwasher drains into the GD, make sure you knockout the plug inside the connector on GD. Just...
Stay with the 1. Easy to replace. If your dishwasher drains into the GD, make sure you knockout the plug inside the connector on GD. Just in case you didn't already know.
motogeezer wrote:
I could tell you a story, but it's a little bit embarrassing...
Those stories are not uncommon when it comes to homeowner disposal insalls.Laughing
Cygnus
Profile picture for user Cygnus
Posts
14845
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Hanover, CO, USA
Cygnus 5/19/2009 3:18pm
5/19/2009 3:18pm Edited Date/Time 5/19/2009 3:20pm
I am a cheap fucker I would just replace the motor it is easier than the unit,3 wires and one clamp, and if you have no leaks ?
Cygnus
Profile picture for user Cygnus
Posts
14845
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Hanover, CO, USA
Cygnus 5/19/2009 3:19pm
5/19/2009 3:19pm
oh shit i have no disposer . I have a septic system.
SteveS
Profile picture for user SteveS
Posts
5598
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
USA
SteveS 5/19/2009 3:43pm
5/19/2009 3:43pm
BUTCH wrote:
So the noise is coming from the switch?
No, from the disposer.
SteveS
Profile picture for user SteveS
Posts
5598
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
USA
SteveS 5/19/2009 3:44pm
5/19/2009 3:44pm
Ivan wrote:
Stay with the 1. Easy to replace. If your dishwasher drains into the GD, make sure you knockout the plug inside the connector on GD. Just...
Stay with the 1. Easy to replace. If your dishwasher drains into the GD, make sure you knockout the plug inside the connector on GD. Just in case you didn't already know.
They have the dishwasher going into the other sink's drain. But yes, I knew that was a possibility.
SteveS
Profile picture for user SteveS
Posts
5598
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
USA
SteveS 5/19/2009 3:45pm
5/19/2009 3:45pm
So either everyone here is cheap like me, or basically the $400 disposers are for the same people who buy 24" chrome spinners for their Navigators.
BUTCH
Profile picture for user BUTCH
Posts
5088
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
USA
BUTCH 5/19/2009 3:47pm
5/19/2009 3:47pm
You were unclear. You said" I flip the switch and it makes a humming noise. No motor noise at all."
SEEMEFIRST
Profile picture for user SEEMEFIRST
Posts
14145
Joined
8/21/2006
Location
Arlington, TX, USA
SEEMEFIRST 5/19/2009 4:05pm
5/19/2009 4:05pm
Ivan wrote:
Stay with the 1. Easy to replace. If your dishwasher drains into the GD, make sure you knockout the plug inside the connector on GD. Just...
Stay with the 1. Easy to replace. If your dishwasher drains into the GD, make sure you knockout the plug inside the connector on GD. Just in case you didn't already know.
SteveS wrote:
They have the dishwasher going into the other sink's drain. But yes, I knew that was a possibility.
Remember Ivan's plug advise, every time I've replaced one, I've forgotten that little tid-bit, and my wife gets pissed because the dishwasher didn't drain...DAMMIT!!! If you decide to go with the Badger 5, the head is exactly the same as the 1 so all plumbing will match perfectly. If you switch brands, you might have to adjust the length of the drain pipe. making it longer will require another trip to the hardware store, and if you're anything like me when it comes to plumbing, one trip will not be enough.Wink
SEEMEFIRST
Profile picture for user SEEMEFIRST
Posts
14145
Joined
8/21/2006
Location
Arlington, TX, USA
SEEMEFIRST 5/19/2009 4:08pm
5/19/2009 4:08pm
As for the priceier ones, they're quieter, and chop stuff up finer. If you've got decent drains I'd stick with the Badgers. I got 15 years out of one, and only had to replace it because one of my kids decided to see what a 1" diameter rock would do in it...It blows the side out in case you wondered as well.
Ivan
Profile picture for user Ivan
Posts
792
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Long Beach, CA, USA
Ivan 5/19/2009 5:44pm
5/19/2009 5:44pm
Anyone ever tell you to throw some broken glass in to sharpen it?
Please somebody on here admit that you tried it.

Cygnus
Profile picture for user Cygnus
Posts
14845
Joined
8/15/2006
Location
Hanover, CO, USA
Cygnus 5/19/2009 5:50pm
5/19/2009 5:50pm
Ivan wrote:
Anyone ever tell you to throw some broken glass in to sharpen it?
Please somebody on here admit that you tried it.

Yes I have ran some broken glass down one when I did have one.Huh

Post a reply to: Garbage disposers