pay your respects - 23' YZ250 engine failure

tek14
Posts
4586
Joined
1/26/2014
Location
Vantaa FI
1/24/2023 12:18am

Cold weather and running lean. 

3
Chatmore
Posts
1581
Joined
11/22/2022
Location
Memphis, TN US
1/24/2023 2:10am
WarrenMX wrote:
4th post in 12 years... this one really got you fired up 

4th post in 12 years... this one really got you fired up Laughing

Mike is a man of few words, but when he does speak it’s usually important. 😉

To his point, you would have thought the OP would have chimed in already but he’s probably trying to find a rebuild kit that is still in the manufacturing stages. lol

2
1
Vet57
Posts
1785
Joined
12/13/2010
Location
White House, DC US
1/24/2023 2:17am

This was not a detonation problem. 

Something got loose/broke and caused that.

Your fuel choice is just fine.

This right here!

1
5

The Shop

CPR
Posts
4373
Joined
10/4/2018
Location
AU
1/24/2023 2:35am

Been detonating for some time by the looks, which always leads to a failure eventually, whether it’s the piston, ring, electrode falling off, or locating pin as in this case.

1
mikenovel
Posts
10
Joined
4/5/2011
Location
Corona, CA US
1/24/2023 3:57am
WarrenMX wrote:
4th post in 12 years... this one really got you fired up 

4th post in 12 years... this one really got you fired up Laughing

I forgot my login in password!
I was cleaning up my home office desk and found the post-it note I wrote it on over the weekend. 

IT’S ON NOW!!! 🤣

10
1
ADynes
Posts
226
Joined
5/26/2011
Location
IN US
1/24/2023 3:58am Edited Date/Time 1/24/2023 4:12am

Got too hot from not being rich enough. Combustion temps are hottest around stoichiometric ratio ~14.7:1. Not technically "lean", just not rich enough to achieve necessary fuel cooling at WOT. Piston failed near the exhaust port (as is typical) due to seizing and high heat. I'm guessing what many are assuming is the ring gap in the wrong spot is actually a broken edge of the ring, which happened due to no longer having top ring land support and catching the bad spot in the cylinder. I assume the majority of the damage is from the debris rather than just detonation pitting.

A bummer for sure, but I bet it's happened to most of us here who have ridden a two stroke aggressively, so don't feel too bad

2
maxer
Posts
191
Joined
12/9/2020
Location
Grapevine, TX US
Fantasy
364th
1/24/2023 4:03am
Yz229 wrote:

Looks like lean detonation. What was your jetting?

maxer wrote:
running lean may of been a contributing factor as well. I didnt change my jetting once it got a little colder due to my ignorance. i...

running lean may of been a contributing factor as well. I didnt change my jetting once it got a little colder due to my ignorance. i havent been on 2 strokes in a while and thought since it was running great i didnt need to mess with it - i was wrong! 

Yz229 wrote:
That's usually what happens. Exhaust side get's very hot when lean, causing detonation. (sometimes not noticed). Finally melts/explodes on exhaust side and piston/ring debris enter the...

That's usually what happens. Exhaust side get's very hot when lean, causing detonation. (sometimes not noticed). Finally melts/explodes on exhaust side and piston/ring debris enter the chamber at wide open causing a lot of the damage you are seeing. 

What was jetting, altitude and temp?

I haven’t touched the jetting since i got it from the dealer in October. I live in dallas tx so under 500 sea level and it was in the 30s the race day it gave out on me. I haven’t rode it often in very cold temps it’s been pretty mild around here

2
maxer
Posts
191
Joined
12/9/2020
Location
Grapevine, TX US
Fantasy
364th
1/24/2023 4:05am
sandman768 wrote:

Need to see piston with cylinder off… to inspect ring locator pin … plug photo wouldn’t hurt either…

maxer wrote:

i'll try to get some more photos, i dropped it off with someone much smarter than me on this stuff

lostboy819 wrote:
Bummer for you no matter what, feel bad because most of us have had something happen at one time or another, sucks thats its a new...

Bummer for you no matter what, feel bad because most of us have had something happen at one time or another, sucks thats its a new bike. Sad

and i switched back to a 2t to save some money 😂 don’t think i have anyone to blame but myself, definitely sucks though. not a cheap fix

1/24/2023 4:27am

Whoever rebuilds that motor have them check the ignition timing with a degree wheel and make sure its on point.  We had a few 23' YZ250's up here in CT that were banging out of the box on straight C12..timing was off on them.  May not be the case here but it would not hurt to do it.

Good luck-J

24
Bulldog
Posts
277
Joined
7/21/2009
Location
Smithfield, VA US
1/24/2023 6:24am

Same thing happened to us on our 2013.  Predetonation using pump gas.  Happened at 18 hours..  After a bucket of money we went 50/50 races gas/93 octan and problem was solved.   Yamaha support stuck to the manual - top end every 10 hours, we're sorry.

kijen
Posts
1031
Joined
10/1/2010
Location
Jacksonville, FL US
1/24/2023 6:32am

While rebuilding recommend you measure your squish and get the head cut to preferred .050 or whatever it is, sure quite a few folks still do this. We're running pump, with no issues with a pretty good rider and some flordia sand.

1
Jrey2
Posts
416
Joined
11/6/2022
Location
Big Pine Key, FL US
1/24/2023 6:34am
Whoever rebuilds that motor have them check the ignition timing with a degree wheel and make sure its on point.  We had a few 23' YZ250's...

Whoever rebuilds that motor have them check the ignition timing with a degree wheel and make sure its on point.  We had a few 23' YZ250's up here in CT that were banging out of the box on straight C12..timing was off on them.  May not be the case here but it would not hurt to do it.

Good luck-J

My 21 has been a little knock prone out of the box. It was angry in FL at high load/temp as well. is there a rule of thumb on jetting for colder weather you'd be willing to share?

Jrey2
Posts
416
Joined
11/6/2022
Location
Big Pine Key, FL US
1/24/2023 6:35am
kijen wrote:
While rebuilding recommend you measure your squish and get the head cut to preferred .050 or whatever it is, sure quite a few folks still do...

While rebuilding recommend you measure your squish and get the head cut to preferred .050 or whatever it is, sure quite a few folks still do this. We're running pump, with no issues with a pretty good rider and some flordia sand.

Who did your head work?

nrosso391
Posts
2427
Joined
2/8/2014
Location
Champlin, MN US
Fantasy
2824th
1/24/2023 7:41am

But here's the thing now one is talking about...this guy can fix this for around $500, based on the parts shown. Try to replace the same components on a Four-stroke and it will cost $2500+.

3
9
dcg141
Posts
2177
Joined
11/30/2009
Location
MS US
1/24/2023 7:45am Edited Date/Time 1/24/2023 7:52am

What does the spark plug look like?  It probably got beat up too but I would like to see it. If it did end up running so lean I would suspect an air leak vs fuel or jetting. You guys are looking at what a shop goes through to determine a failure on a engine. 

wrc777
Posts
2201
Joined
5/21/2020
Location
Greenwood, IN US
Fantasy
783rd
1/24/2023 7:50am
nrosso391 wrote:
But here's the thing now one is talking about...this guy can fix this for around $500, based on the parts shown. Try to replace the same...

But here's the thing now one is talking about...this guy can fix this for around $500, based on the parts shown. Try to replace the same components on a Four-stroke and it will cost $2500+.

Has anyone seen this type of failure on a fuel injected 4t? Yes 2 strokes are generally cheaper to rebuild, but they take a better mechanic/tuner to keep from blowing up too.

2
1
dcg141
Posts
2177
Joined
11/30/2009
Location
MS US
1/24/2023 7:57am Edited Date/Time 1/24/2023 8:00am
brocster wrote:
To me it looks like a head gasket leak is what caused the sequence of events meltdown.   

To me it looks like a head gasket leak is what caused the sequence of events meltdown. 7DAEE63A-8127-40FF-9B94-4338BB5514B5

 

I'm with you on the blown head gasket...that amount of lean is usually an air leak. Did the bike ever have trouble coming back to idle? 

2
seth505
Posts
9369
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
SD, CA US
Fantasy
1092nd
1/24/2023 8:04am
nrosso391 wrote:
But here's the thing now one is talking about...this guy can fix this for around $500, based on the parts shown. Try to replace the same...

But here's the thing now one is talking about...this guy can fix this for around $500, based on the parts shown. Try to replace the same components on a Four-stroke and it will cost $2500+.

wrc777 wrote:
Has anyone seen this type of failure on a fuel injected 4t? Yes 2 strokes are generally cheaper to rebuild, but they take a better mechanic/tuner...

Has anyone seen this type of failure on a fuel injected 4t? Yes 2 strokes are generally cheaper to rebuild, but they take a better mechanic/tuner to keep from blowing up too.

You're correct to a point. The solution is to just put in larger jets that are $5 and take 5-10 minutes to change.  Not bagging on the OP but 30 degrees is very cold to not change the jetting and he knows now.  I used to ride my old yz at an indoor facility in winter (in the north east) and definitely would have blown it up if I didn't richen it up.   Sorry for your loss, OP!

3
YZDAD
Posts
193
Joined
3/16/2009
Location
Tucson, AZ US
Fantasy
1776th
1/24/2023 8:17am
kijen wrote:
While rebuilding recommend you measure your squish and get the head cut to preferred .050 or whatever it is, sure quite a few folks still do...

While rebuilding recommend you measure your squish and get the head cut to preferred .050 or whatever it is, sure quite a few folks still do this. We're running pump, with no issues with a pretty good rider and some flordia sand.

Jrey2 wrote:

Who did your head work?

Here's who did mine.  He does great work!  I don't know about the newer YZ250 but I know the older ones had too much clearance in the squish area. Mine had .085" with all OEM parts used.

yz-head (rb-designs.com)

1
RussB
Posts
851
Joined
7/12/2014
Location
GB
Fantasy
986th
1/24/2023 8:28am

+1 on the ignition.

May not have been the cause but still 100% worth getting it properly set. A friend of mine got a YZ250 brand new in 2017, the stator came completely loose within a few hours. Seems to be a common issue with YZ's from new

Chatmore
Posts
1581
Joined
11/22/2022
Location
Memphis, TN US
1/24/2023 9:29am
mikenovel wrote:
I forgot my login in password! I was cleaning up my home office desk and found the post-it note I wrote it on over the weekend. ...

I forgot my login in password!
I was cleaning up my home office desk and found the post-it note I wrote it on over the weekend. 

IT’S ON NOW!!! 🤣

Get ‘em Mike! Show them that now they have awakened the beast!!😂

1
Moto520
Posts
3387
Joined
2/4/2013
Location
Schaumburg, IL US
1/24/2023 9:36am Edited Date/Time 1/24/2023 9:37am

sorry to hear about this....i know how much this sucks for you as and as a fellow rider i feel you pain.  I have a YZ250 as well and the local motor guy around here (TZR Motorsports) tells me to run 50/50 pump/ race gas so you're good there.  I go up on the main jet one size as well.  These motors are not as bulletproof as you would think.  The transmission indent thing happens around 60 hours from my experience.

RCMXracing
Posts
848
Joined
8/10/2011
Location
N., TX US
1/24/2023 9:56am

Don’t believe stock jetting will cause that level of a lean condition…

I had this happen and it turned out there was a small gap (defect) in sealing the cases causing it to suck in air making it lean

Somewhere/somehow the engine is getting excess air… crank seal another possible culprit

2
brocster
Posts
3608
Joined
6/9/2009
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA US
1/24/2023 10:04am
brocster wrote:
To me it looks like a head gasket leak is what caused the sequence of events meltdown.   

To me it looks like a head gasket leak is what caused the sequence of events meltdown. 7DAEE63A-8127-40FF-9B94-4338BB5514B5

 

dcg141 wrote:

I'm with you on the blown head gasket...that amount of lean is usually an air leak. Did the bike ever have trouble coming back to idle? 

I wasn’t thinking lean but more so sucking a little coolant, creating steam/heat, that ended up causing the breaking down/melting of the piston lleading to ring failure. 2 stokes often detonate with no harm to the piston. Something caused the dimples or wash away of certain spots on top of the piston. The eventual loose debris is what caused all the ping marks. Had a CR do this about a year and looked identical. Albeit a consistent Southern Cal weather day where the bike had been running fine, running lean was not a factor. My 2 cents of course. Anyway, sucks for the OP and his new bike. Hope it goes back together well and can get back on it soon. 

2
Jrey2
Posts
416
Joined
11/6/2022
Location
Big Pine Key, FL US
1/24/2023 10:53am
kijen wrote:
While rebuilding recommend you measure your squish and get the head cut to preferred .050 or whatever it is, sure quite a few folks still do...

While rebuilding recommend you measure your squish and get the head cut to preferred .050 or whatever it is, sure quite a few folks still do this. We're running pump, with no issues with a pretty good rider and some flordia sand.

Jrey2 wrote:

Who did your head work?

YZDAD wrote:
Here's who did mine.  He does great work!  I don't know about the newer YZ250 but I know the older ones had too much clearance in...

Here's who did mine.  He does great work!  I don't know about the newer YZ250 but I know the older ones had too much clearance in the squish area. Mine had .085" with all OEM parts used.

yz-head (rb-designs.com)

Awesome, heard good things about him but the site stated he was done doing it when i was interested last. Glad to know it's on again!

1
Gary Duck
Posts
540
Joined
4/16/2019
Location
CA US
1/24/2023 11:11am
nrosso391 wrote:
But here's the thing now one is talking about...this guy can fix this for around $500, based on the parts shown. Try to replace the same...

But here's the thing now one is talking about...this guy can fix this for around $500, based on the parts shown. Try to replace the same components on a Four-stroke and it will cost $2500+.

Your numbers are quite a bit off. Just sayin'

Screenshot 2023-01-24 10.52.18 AM

 

 Screenshot 2023-01-24 11.07.37 AM

 Screenshot 2023-01-24 11.08.23 AM.png?VersionId=hBzlgD.xQMs4tNGxqz o

 

7
2
philG
Posts
9706
Joined
5/12/2012
Location
GB
1/24/2023 11:20am
JK BRO wrote:

The engine didn't fail. C12/Pump w/stock compression, running lean ruined that engine.

No way that motor wasn't knocking like a solar salesman.

I'd like this twice if i could. 

3
1

Post a reply to: pay your respects - 23' YZ250 engine failure

The Latest