John Tomac Said...

ILoveMoto
Posts
3618
Joined
3/15/2022
Location
Jacksonville, FL US
2/5/2024 3:39pm
ILoveMoto wrote:

Nope, that was when his shifter was bent. I want to say the shock blew on the start straight in the main.

Here it is Screenshot 20240205-183600 Google 0

2
3
Johnny Ringo
Posts
6673
Joined
1/11/2016
Location
Tombstone, AZ US
2/5/2024 3:40pm
ILoveMoto wrote:

Nope, that was when his shifter was bent. I want to say the shock blew on the start straight in the main.

ILoveMoto wrote:
Here it is 

Here it is Screenshot 20240205-183600 Google 0

I believe that was the heat, Phoenix 2012

3
ILoveMoto
Posts
3618
Joined
3/15/2022
Location
Jacksonville, FL US
2/5/2024 3:43pm Edited Date/Time 2/5/2024 3:46pm

I believe that was the heat, Phoenix 2012

2013 Heat Race

"As the revs came up and the gate got ready to drop, Ryan Dungey sat up, bounced on the seat a couple times, and didn't launch with everyone else. He'd felt his bike's rear air shock lose pressure. That meant he'd have to go through the LCQ"

6
ILoveMoto
Posts
3618
Joined
3/15/2022
Location
Jacksonville, FL US
2/5/2024 3:47pm
ILoveMoto wrote:
2013 Heat Race "As the revs came up and the gate got ready to drop, Ryan Dungey sat up, bounced on the seat a couple times...

2013 Heat Race

"As the revs came up and the gate got ready to drop, Ryan Dungey sat up, bounced on the seat a couple times, and didn't launch with everyone else. He'd felt his bike's rear air shock lose pressure. That meant he'd have to go through the LCQ"

Screenshot 20240205-184539 Chrome

4

The Shop

yak651
Posts
7272
Joined
8/26/2006
Location
Appleton, WI US
Fantasy
418th
2/5/2024 3:50pm
valveless wrote:

Real respectful of Eli (if it truly was a bike issue) to let his fans know. 

I'll say it once more, you're not a fan. Every Saturday in the race thread all you do is trash him. 

Well he said he’s not a Jett fanboy so I guess you just have to think of him as bizarro Jerry…the opposite of everything he says

Village Idiot
Posts
1513
Joined
5/19/2023
Location
MXoN - a term used by newbs, goobs and rubes, PW US
2/5/2024 4:16pm
ILoveMoto wrote:
2013 Heat Race "As the revs came up and the gate got ready to drop, Ryan Dungey sat up, bounced on the seat a couple times...

2013 Heat Race

"As the revs came up and the gate got ready to drop, Ryan Dungey sat up, bounced on the seat a couple times, and didn't launch with everyone else. He'd felt his bike's rear air shock lose pressure. That meant he'd have to go through the LCQ"

ILoveMoto wrote:

Screenshot 20240205-184539 Chrome

Wasn't it Andrew Short who had one of these flatulate itself empty while sitting on the starting line?

1
ILoveMoto
Posts
3618
Joined
3/15/2022
Location
Jacksonville, FL US
2/5/2024 4:39pm

Wasn't it Andrew Short who had one of these flatulate itself empty while sitting on the starting line?

I can't recall that incident, not to say it didn't happen. Tony 222 also tested the airshock Europe

1
6
Village Idiot
Posts
1513
Joined
5/19/2023
Location
MXoN - a term used by newbs, goobs and rubes, PW US
2/5/2024 4:49pm

Wasn't it Andrew Short who had one of these flatulate itself empty while sitting on the starting line?

ILoveMoto wrote:

I can't recall that incident, not to say it didn't happen. Tony 222 also tested the airshock Europe

I can't find anything definitive on it, but it might have been Dungey who had the failure at the gate. This snip from MXA confirms Short had a failure but doesn't give the circumstances.

image-20240205194806-1

2
ILoveMoto
Posts
3618
Joined
3/15/2022
Location
Jacksonville, FL US
2/5/2024 4:58pm
I can't find anything definitive on it, but it might have been Dungey who had the failure at the gate. This snip from MXA confirms Short...

I can't find anything definitive on it, but it might have been Dungey who had the failure at the gate. This snip from MXA confirms Short had a failure but doesn't give the circumstances.

image-20240205194806-1

Good stuff thanks for sharing!

3
APLMAN99
Posts
10773
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Dallas, TX US
2/5/2024 6:08pm

I don’t think I’d find myself questioning John Tomac’s honesty, so I’d take him at his word. But it really seems odd that with all the hours of testing and practicing that this would be happening during the races this far into the season. Star seems like a very smart team and they seem to bring in top talent to get the equipment right, so it’s bizarre to think that they have just been struggling with this for a while and haven’t went back to some more proven methods for races until they figure out what is causing whatever failure they are experiencing. 

1
2
Last2Stroke
Posts
3645
Joined
3/17/2022
Location
AU
Fantasy
1525th
2/5/2024 6:18pm
APLMAN99 wrote:
I don’t think I’d find myself questioning John Tomac’s honesty, so I’d take him at his word. But it really seems odd that with all the...

I don’t think I’d find myself questioning John Tomac’s honesty, so I’d take him at his word. But it really seems odd that with all the hours of testing and practicing that this would be happening during the races this far into the season. Star seems like a very smart team and they seem to bring in top talent to get the equipment right, so it’s bizarre to think that they have just been struggling with this for a while and haven’t went back to some more proven methods for races until they figure out what is causing whatever failure they are experiencing. 

Star is like all organizations, sometimes they can't identify an issue, then they solve it and think, that was obvious, why didn't we solve it earlier.

2
1
APLMAN99
Posts
10773
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Dallas, TX US
2/5/2024 6:24pm
APLMAN99 wrote:
I don’t think I’d find myself questioning John Tomac’s honesty, so I’d take him at his word. But it really seems odd that with all the...

I don’t think I’d find myself questioning John Tomac’s honesty, so I’d take him at his word. But it really seems odd that with all the hours of testing and practicing that this would be happening during the races this far into the season. Star seems like a very smart team and they seem to bring in top talent to get the equipment right, so it’s bizarre to think that they have just been struggling with this for a while and haven’t went back to some more proven methods for races until they figure out what is causing whatever failure they are experiencing. 

Star is like all organizations, sometimes they can't identify an issue, then they solve it and think, that was obvious, why didn't we solve it earlier.

Yeah, but it sounds like it’s only happening to Tomac’s bike, right?  Not Webb or Cooper?  And is the ‘24 so different that they couldn’t use the ‘23 shock?  Maybe it is different enough, but if it fits it was the shock that was leading the ‘23 title deep into the season before his injury. It just amazes me that this is something that would be going on this late in the season, and it sounds like it has been occurring for a while when you read the opening post. 

1
3
brocster
Posts
3936
Joined
6/9/2009
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA US
2/5/2024 6:43pm

Know someone that was close to the Windham camp BITD and I learned that they ran such tight clearances in the suspension to get “the feel right/comfort” that it’s basically out of tolerance/worn out after one night of racing. I am guessing the Star is pushing those limits as well. 

2
Last2Stroke
Posts
3645
Joined
3/17/2022
Location
AU
Fantasy
1525th
2/5/2024 6:45pm
APLMAN99 wrote:
I don’t think I’d find myself questioning John Tomac’s honesty, so I’d take him at his word. But it really seems odd that with all the...

I don’t think I’d find myself questioning John Tomac’s honesty, so I’d take him at his word. But it really seems odd that with all the hours of testing and practicing that this would be happening during the races this far into the season. Star seems like a very smart team and they seem to bring in top talent to get the equipment right, so it’s bizarre to think that they have just been struggling with this for a while and haven’t went back to some more proven methods for races until they figure out what is causing whatever failure they are experiencing. 

Star is like all organizations, sometimes they can't identify an issue, then they solve it and think, that was obvious, why didn't we solve it earlier.

APLMAN99 wrote:
Yeah, but it sounds like it’s only happening to Tomac’s bike, right?  Not Webb or Cooper?  And is the ‘24 so different that they couldn’t use...

Yeah, but it sounds like it’s only happening to Tomac’s bike, right?  Not Webb or Cooper?  And is the ‘24 so different that they couldn’t use the ‘23 shock?  Maybe it is different enough, but if it fits it was the shock that was leading the ‘23 title deep into the season before his injury. It just amazes me that this is something that would be going on this late in the season, and it sounds like it has been occurring for a while when you read the opening post. 

Webb uses a KYB shock, Tomac uses a solid bar, no dampening, and no damping!

image-20240206134458-1

6
2
APLMAN99
Posts
10773
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Dallas, TX US
2/5/2024 6:53pm

Star is like all organizations, sometimes they can't identify an issue, then they solve it and think, that was obvious, why didn't we solve it earlier.

APLMAN99 wrote:
Yeah, but it sounds like it’s only happening to Tomac’s bike, right?  Not Webb or Cooper?  And is the ‘24 so different that they couldn’t use...

Yeah, but it sounds like it’s only happening to Tomac’s bike, right?  Not Webb or Cooper?  And is the ‘24 so different that they couldn’t use the ‘23 shock?  Maybe it is different enough, but if it fits it was the shock that was leading the ‘23 title deep into the season before his injury. It just amazes me that this is something that would be going on this late in the season, and it sounds like it has been occurring for a while when you read the opening post. 

Webb uses a KYB shock, Tomac uses a solid bar, no dampening, and no damping!

Webb uses a KYB shock, Tomac uses a solid bar, no dampening, and no damping!

image-20240206134458-1

Damn, now I’m not sure what to think about Papa Tomac’s story about the shims….!  😎

2
1
Village Idiot
Posts
1513
Joined
5/19/2023
Location
MXoN - a term used by newbs, goobs and rubes, PW US
2/5/2024 6:58pm

Star is like all organizations, sometimes they can't identify an issue, then they solve it and think, that was obvious, why didn't we solve it earlier.

APLMAN99 wrote:
Yeah, but it sounds like it’s only happening to Tomac’s bike, right?  Not Webb or Cooper?  And is the ‘24 so different that they couldn’t use...

Yeah, but it sounds like it’s only happening to Tomac’s bike, right?  Not Webb or Cooper?  And is the ‘24 so different that they couldn’t use the ‘23 shock?  Maybe it is different enough, but if it fits it was the shock that was leading the ‘23 title deep into the season before his injury. It just amazes me that this is something that would be going on this late in the season, and it sounds like it has been occurring for a while when you read the opening post. 

Webb uses a KYB shock, Tomac uses a solid bar, no dampening, and no damping!

Webb uses a KYB shock, Tomac uses a solid bar, no dampening, and no damping!

image-20240206134458-1

But does that bar use clamping or clampening?

7
Last2Stroke
Posts
3645
Joined
3/17/2022
Location
AU
Fantasy
1525th
2/5/2024 7:03pm
APLMAN99 wrote:
Yeah, but it sounds like it’s only happening to Tomac’s bike, right?  Not Webb or Cooper?  And is the ‘24 so different that they couldn’t use...

Yeah, but it sounds like it’s only happening to Tomac’s bike, right?  Not Webb or Cooper?  And is the ‘24 so different that they couldn’t use the ‘23 shock?  Maybe it is different enough, but if it fits it was the shock that was leading the ‘23 title deep into the season before his injury. It just amazes me that this is something that would be going on this late in the season, and it sounds like it has been occurring for a while when you read the opening post. 

Webb uses a KYB shock, Tomac uses a solid bar, no dampening, and no damping!

Webb uses a KYB shock, Tomac uses a solid bar, no dampening, and no damping!

image-20240206134458-1

But does that bar use clamping or clampening?

Clamped!

1
TAUTOG
Posts
850
Joined
1/27/2023
Location
Mohrsville, PA US
2/5/2024 7:25pm
ILoveMoto wrote:
Tweaked knee?

Tweaked knee?

Screenshot 20240205-212746 YouTube

Dude stfu

What is the online equivalent for you just like the sound of your own voice?

5
ILoveMoto
Posts
3618
Joined
3/15/2022
Location
Jacksonville, FL US
2/5/2024 7:32pm Edited Date/Time 2/5/2024 11:21pm
TAUTOG wrote:

Dude stfu

What is the online equivalent for you just like the sound of your own voice?

Maybe if you don't read my posts your panties won't get in a wad and your vagina won't hurt anymore. Hope this helps sweetie 

3
24
2/6/2024 6:52am

Star is like all organizations, sometimes they can't identify an issue, then they solve it and think, that was obvious, why didn't we solve it earlier.

APLMAN99 wrote:
Yeah, but it sounds like it’s only happening to Tomac’s bike, right?  Not Webb or Cooper?  And is the ‘24 so different that they couldn’t use...

Yeah, but it sounds like it’s only happening to Tomac’s bike, right?  Not Webb or Cooper?  And is the ‘24 so different that they couldn’t use the ‘23 shock?  Maybe it is different enough, but if it fits it was the shock that was leading the ‘23 title deep into the season before his injury. It just amazes me that this is something that would be going on this late in the season, and it sounds like it has been occurring for a while when you read the opening post. 

Webb uses a KYB shock, Tomac uses a solid bar, no dampening, and no damping!

Webb uses a KYB shock, Tomac uses a solid bar, no dampening, and no damping!

image-20240206134458-1

He'd still bend that sum'bitch too Cool

1
2/6/2024 7:11am

I heard from the same story from a buddy who’s at the races every week. It would explain the random drop off. Crazy.

1
MB19
Posts
83
Joined
1/20/2014
Location
Leverett, MA US
Fantasy
1017th
2/6/2024 10:20am

One thing that bothers me about what John Tomac allegedly said was that the rear shock shims have been failing on the stickier type tracks. If they HAVE BEEN failing, that means they had a problem they knew about but still used that setup anyways?? It doesn’t seem like something Yamaha would do but what do I know 

5
dog_lover_136
Posts
1618
Joined
1/30/2023
Location
Riverside, CA US
Fantasy
1932nd
2/6/2024 10:54am

What I don't understand is how and why he couldn't use his setup from last year that was so good. 

3
2/6/2024 11:34am

SInce the info is 3rd hand at this point. It could have been changed slightly. And maybe it was the second time they failed? Frustration can lead to using words that may not describe something super accurately. Time is relative. And 2 times would be a lot for a part to fail for a factory team.  Perhaps they did not know what it was earlier on. Then thought it could have been a bad part and they went to a fresh supply. And it still failed. 2 or 3 times would be a longtime and a lot of failures for a team of that level. I would take the info for what it is. And not get too into the exact wording since it was repeated in a casual conversation.

Eli might like it enough that he thought the risk was worth it? It is odd that the lap  times do not drop more consistently . But that could be many things. Lappers , better lines one lap than the other, the shock being inconsistent causing it to work well one lap and not the next.

 

Maybe he was thinking about Mcadoo ?  

1
1
mooch
Posts
1486
Joined
2/16/2008
Location
OH US
Fantasy
423rd
2/6/2024 11:51am
ILoveMoto wrote:
Tweaked knee?

Tweaked knee?

Screenshot 20240205-212746 YouTube

TAUTOG wrote:

Dude stfu

What is the online equivalent for you just like the sound of your own voice?

Thanks for the reality check!  Thought maybe I was the only one getting tired of his high volume of nonsense posts. 

3
1
ILoveMoto
Posts
3618
Joined
3/15/2022
Location
Jacksonville, FL US
2/6/2024 12:32pm Edited Date/Time 2/6/2024 12:47pm
mooch wrote:

Thanks for the reality check!  Thought maybe I was the only one getting tired of his high volume of nonsense posts. 

Marsha! Marsha! Marsha! 😅

9
nrosso391
Posts
3064
Joined
2/8/2014
Location
Millville, MN US
2/6/2024 12:39pm

If he had a hard enough case, like someone mentioned earlier, that could've been all that was needed to bend those shims permanently open and cause the shock valving to fail.

4
2
kpiper
Posts
2278
Joined
3/20/2019
Location
AZ US
2/6/2024 5:26pm

Does anyone have a screenshot of this claimed FB post saying they talked to JT? Just wondering. I still suggest that if it were a bike issue someone official would have said something along those lines. Have not seen that.

Post a reply to: John Tomac Said...

The Latest