Posts
5063
Joined
7/19/2016
Location
Sac, CA
US
Edited Date/Time
8/26/2020 3:12pm
This excellent skill thread just made me recall how much of McGrath's unique skills were things he innately did for maintaining momentum through complicated sections.
Wondering... Would that skill even be a significant factor any more with so much traction and power on every bike?
Wondering... Would that skill even be a significant factor any more with so much traction and power on every bike?
So in a way, I feel like that applies to MC. The guy is just so skilled and if he were coming up now, he would've been mastering all of the current techniques that have evolved since his day. So I think that still keeps him ahead of most of the guys now. He is a generational talent, much like RC, RV and Eli today. I believe the great ones would excel in any era. Just my opinion.
Lemieux and Gretzky were still using the same basic equipment as a modern player. Yes, I know there have been advances, but they are still used in the exact way as their priors. So what if the equipment in soccer changed so fundamentally that Pele had to use his hands to play? Is he still a generational talent?
The Shop
So for MC, I think had he come up in the scrub era, the 4stroke era etc, he's just a freak talent. So his level of progression still would've out-paced most of the pros, in my opinion. No way to know, of course, but I truly believe he would still be as great or close to it.
/thread
Soccer takes basically a lifetime to learn, and some people make hundreds of millions for how skilled they are.. But I have never heard of even "transcendent" talents to switch to even one other limb regardless of how talented they are.
I think it took more skill to ride the 250 2 stroke than the modern era bikes. Also there is more parity now because of the bikes.
That said in MC's partime year back on a Honda he finished top 5 on a two stroke and four, he is just the King!
Pit Row
The speculation is left to us fans, and it's fun to speculate. My view is that these champions are champions no matter the era. Racers like MC, RC, RV, Dungey, and others have something extra that makes them champions that others lack.
I believe his skills and style meshed well with the evolution of motocross chassis' in the late 80's, whereas today I can't imagine someone having the same technical advantage.
Maybe a bad example but RC became even more dominant once 4 strokes came into the picture. These guys' insane level of talent really shines when they have to adapt to something new.
Just though it was funny as it’s blasphemous to insinuate something such as this about MC!
I see a lot of instances now where a rider doesn't hit a preferred rhythm/line, but still powers through a section or hits the next jump just fine.
But that precision that may no longer be fundamental really separated MC from the pack
Post a reply to: Would MC still be King in 4 stroke era?