This should be some good bench racing...

RCB33
Profile picture for user RCB33
Posts
838
Joined
6/22/2015
Location
Drexel, MO US
Fantasy
170th
RCB33
Edited Date/Time 10/25/2015 1:59pm
Ok,so if you had to pick who would be in a 20 lap supercross race with a 22 rider gate who would be there.they can be on any bike(cr 500 if that is what you want them on).

In no specific order

McGrath
Carmichael
Villopoto
Hannah
Stewart
Emig
Johnson
Bailey
Decoster
Pastrana
Dungey
Windham
Loracco(sp)
Reed
Bradshaw
Ward
Stanton
cooper
O'mara
Pichon
Huffman
Kiedrowski I know I probably forgot some good ones,who would be on your lists?
|
kzizok
Profile picture for user kzizok
Posts
8405
Joined
10/19/2010
Location
AS US
Fantasy
1439th
kzizok 10/24/2015 2:17pm
10/24/2015 2:17pm
Add Potsie and Fred Flintstone to my list.

The Shop

See All »
bents
Profile picture for user bents
Posts
3292
Joined
12/31/2009
Location
CA
Fantasy
1059th
bents 10/24/2015 6:20pm
10/24/2015 6:20pm
Put them all on 250 2 strokes and I still take McGrath for the win, assuming all are in their prime.
TDeath21
Profile picture for user TDeath21
Posts
6522
Joined
2/22/2011
Location
Somewhere, MO US
TDeath21 10/24/2015 8:47pm
10/24/2015 8:47pm
McGrath
Carmichael
Villopoto
Stewart
Hannah
Johnson
Bailey
JMB
Reed
Dungey
O'show
Stanton
Bradshaw
Windham
Vuillemin
Emig
Larocco
Lechein
Hansen
Lusk
Huffman
Pichon
RCB33
Profile picture for user RCB33
Posts
838
Joined
6/22/2015
Location
Drexel, MO US
Fantasy
170th
RCB33 10/24/2015 9:04pm
10/24/2015 9:04pm
TDeath21 wrote:
McGrath
Carmichael
Villopoto
Stewart
Hannah
Johnson
Bailey
JMB
Reed
Dungey
O'show
Stanton
Bradshaw
Windham
Vuillemin
Emig
Larocco
Lechein
Hansen
Lusk
Huffman
Pichon
Assuming Donnie Hanson?
TDeath21
Profile picture for user TDeath21
Posts
6522
Joined
2/22/2011
Location
Somewhere, MO US
TDeath21 10/24/2015 9:13pm
10/24/2015 9:13pm
TDeath21 wrote:
McGrath
Carmichael
Villopoto
Stewart
Hannah
Johnson
Bailey
JMB
Reed
Dungey
O'show
Stanton
Bradshaw
Windham
Vuillemin
Emig
Larocco
Lechein
Hansen
Lusk
Huffman
Pichon
RCB33 wrote:
Assuming Donnie Hanson?
You assume correct.

Pit Row

See All »
RCB33
Profile picture for user RCB33
Posts
838
Joined
6/22/2015
Location
Drexel, MO US
Fantasy
170th
RCB33 10/25/2015 5:51am
10/25/2015 5:51am Edited Date/Time 10/25/2015 5:51am
Why is it that everyone(including me) so far besides one guy has forgot Magoo... Add him to my list.
Motocross83 10/25/2015 6:11am
10/25/2015 6:11am Edited Date/Time 10/25/2015 6:13am
In regards to results; the most recent, or there about, top riders should imo be considered the favourites. In other words even if all were in their prime and on equal machinery, there'd generally be (though some overlap may occur) a noticeable split in riders from the 00's, 90s, and 80s eras.

My top 5....

1. Stewart
2. Villopoto
3. Reed
4. Carmichael
5. Dungey
6. McGrath (Edit).

As for who I would choose to be in it, I think the OP covered it pretty well. However it would awesome to also see a fully healthy and fully fit Travis Pastrana in the mix.
RCB33
Profile picture for user RCB33
Posts
838
Joined
6/22/2015
Location
Drexel, MO US
Fantasy
170th
RCB33 10/25/2015 6:17am
10/25/2015 6:17am
Motocross83 wrote:
In regards to results; the most recent, or there about, top riders should imo be considered the favourites. In other words even if all were in...
In regards to results; the most recent, or there about, top riders should imo be considered the favourites. In other words even if all were in their prime and on equal machinery, there'd generally be (though some overlap may occur) a noticeable split in riders from the 00's, 90s, and 80s eras.

My top 5....

1. Stewart
2. Villopoto
3. Reed
4. Carmichael
5. Dungey
6. McGrath (Edit).

As for who I would choose to be in it, I think the OP covered it pretty well. However it would awesome to also see a fully healthy and fully fit Travis Pastrana in the mix.
That just got me thinking, even with them all in their prime there is next to no chance of the 70's,80's,and 90's guys scrubbing and that would give the likes of Stewart,villopoto, etc a great advantage...
cwtoyota
Profile picture for user cwtoyota
Posts
2117
Joined
3/11/2013
Location
Tacoma, WA US
cwtoyota 10/25/2015 9:19am
10/25/2015 9:19am
Motocross83 wrote:
In regards to results; the most recent, or there about, top riders should imo be considered the favourites. In other words even if all were in...
In regards to results; the most recent, or there about, top riders should imo be considered the favourites. In other words even if all were in their prime and on equal machinery, there'd generally be (though some overlap may occur) a noticeable split in riders from the 00's, 90s, and 80s eras.

My top 5....

1. Stewart
2. Villopoto
3. Reed
4. Carmichael
5. Dungey
6. McGrath (Edit).

As for who I would choose to be in it, I think the OP covered it pretty well. However it would awesome to also see a fully healthy and fully fit Travis Pastrana in the mix.
RCB33 wrote:
That just got me thinking, even with them all in their prime there is next to no chance of the 70's,80's,and 90's guys scrubbing and that...
That just got me thinking, even with them all in their prime there is next to no chance of the 70's,80's,and 90's guys scrubbing and that would give the likes of Stewart,villopoto, etc a great advantage...
I saw somewhere that yesterday was the day Marty McFly showed up in the future... So I guess we're invoking time travel in this hypothetical race? I think while you're making up a starting lineup, you have to pretend that all the guys were brought "back to the future" from the time they were in their prime.


RCB33, I think Jerry Robin was proof of your statement about scrubbing. In my opinion, he looked faster on that old CR250R than any of the guys on their factory bikes did back in 1986. Following that logic, it would be hard to bet against Villopoto if you're going a full 17 rounds. For a one race deal, Dunge, Roczen, Stew, etc. all have to be at the top of the list with RV.

... Unless you're riding a 1990's track with old two strokes. Then my money is on MC for sure!
The tracks in the 90's were so much more challenging to the bikes of the 90's than current tracks/bikes.

RCB33
Profile picture for user RCB33
Posts
838
Joined
6/22/2015
Location
Drexel, MO US
Fantasy
170th
RCB33 10/25/2015 1:59pm
10/25/2015 1:59pm
Motocross83 wrote:
In regards to results; the most recent, or there about, top riders should imo be considered the favourites. In other words even if all were in...
In regards to results; the most recent, or there about, top riders should imo be considered the favourites. In other words even if all were in their prime and on equal machinery, there'd generally be (though some overlap may occur) a noticeable split in riders from the 00's, 90s, and 80s eras.

My top 5....

1. Stewart
2. Villopoto
3. Reed
4. Carmichael
5. Dungey
6. McGrath (Edit).

As for who I would choose to be in it, I think the OP covered it pretty well. However it would awesome to also see a fully healthy and fully fit Travis Pastrana in the mix.
RCB33 wrote:
That just got me thinking, even with them all in their prime there is next to no chance of the 70's,80's,and 90's guys scrubbing and that...
That just got me thinking, even with them all in their prime there is next to no chance of the 70's,80's,and 90's guys scrubbing and that would give the likes of Stewart,villopoto, etc a great advantage...
cwtoyota wrote:
I saw somewhere that yesterday was the day Marty McFly showed up in the future... So I guess we're invoking time travel in this hypothetical race...
I saw somewhere that yesterday was the day Marty McFly showed up in the future... So I guess we're invoking time travel in this hypothetical race? I think while you're making up a starting lineup, you have to pretend that all the guys were brought "back to the future" from the time they were in their prime.


RCB33, I think Jerry Robin was proof of your statement about scrubbing. In my opinion, he looked faster on that old CR250R than any of the guys on their factory bikes did back in 1986. Following that logic, it would be hard to bet against Villopoto if you're going a full 17 rounds. For a one race deal, Dunge, Roczen, Stew, etc. all have to be at the top of the list with RV.

... Unless you're riding a 1990's track with old two strokes. Then my money is on MC for sure!
The tracks in the 90's were so much more challenging to the bikes of the 90's than current tracks/bikes.

How is jerry robin doing by the way, I haven't heard from him since he rode that bike a few years ago at LL's...

Post a reply to: This should be some good bench racing...