Knee braces are cumbersome

PracticeChamp141
10 straight years never once threw a leg over the bike without wearing knee braces. Various companies, sizes, knee socks, strap technology yet yeilding the same result. One day having forgot my knee braces I decided to ride with 25 dollar knee cups. Could not believe the results associated with physically gripping the bike, lifting leg through deep ruts and overall comfort. Night and day difference between the two. I do realize the safty factors associated, but the reduction in arm pump and overall maneuverability when transitioning from sitting to standing are not easyily offset.
|
twotwosix
Profile picture for user twotwosix
Posts
1853
Joined
9/29/2016
Location
TN US
twotwosix 2/9/2018 8:18am
2/9/2018 8:18am
I can't ride a dirt bike properly without wearing knee braces. I have been forced to ride without them before and my inside knees were literally bleeding at the end of the day.
Ramrod
Profile picture for user Ramrod
Posts
4735
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Ontario CA
Fantasy
1692nd
Ramrod 2/9/2018 8:22am
2/9/2018 8:22am
It's a double edged sword. Wear them and have some form of protection but less feel or don't and have more feel and risk.

You for sure get used to wearing them but you lose a lot of feel for the bike.

I won't ride without after learning the hard way but I'm not sure if they do anything but help me mentally.
ktm212
Profile picture for user ktm212
Posts
608
Joined
11/30/2009
Location
Lafayette, NJ US
ktm212 2/9/2018 8:25am
2/9/2018 8:25am
save your knees, a half second a lap doesnt make up for knee surgery for a practice champ.
peelout
Profile picture for user peelout
Posts
17873
Joined
1/6/2011
Location
Ogden, UT US
peelout 2/9/2018 8:28am
2/9/2018 8:28am
for a 20 minute moto, knee brace is where it's at. for everything else, i just wear some nice comfortable knee pads.

The Shop

See All »
walent215
Profile picture for user walent215
Posts
2417
Joined
12/6/2014
Location
Ridgecrest, CA US
walent215 2/9/2018 9:23am
2/9/2018 9:23am
Never wore them. Buddy had his asterisks on and still had his knee blown out. Not saying they cant/ wont prevent injury but ill continue to ride without em. To each their own.
Wandell
Profile picture for user Wandell
Posts
7563
Joined
12/17/2008
Location
Cairo, GA US
Wandell 2/9/2018 9:34am
2/9/2018 9:34am
Neither I nor my son have ever worn knee braces on a dirt bike, just cheap knee guards. But last year my son used Donjoy knee braces playing football. From the first practice he was comfortable with them and says he doesn't even notice them. I would think that knee braces would be more noticeable/cumbursome on a football field than on a mx track. I guess everyone is different.
Ghost of Jabroni 2/9/2018 9:47am
2/9/2018 9:47am Edited Date/Time 2/9/2018 9:49am
Ramrod wrote:
It's a double edged sword. Wear them and have some form of protection but less feel or don't and have more feel and risk. You for...
It's a double edged sword. Wear them and have some form of protection but less feel or don't and have more feel and risk.

You for sure get used to wearing them but you lose a lot of feel for the bike.

I won't ride without after learning the hard way but I'm not sure if they do anything but help me mentally.
Same here. I too forgot my braces once, rode so loose & comfortable. I felt 10x safer.

Ultimately, if I ride better w/o them, it’s safer.

Im about PREVENTING crashes. I dont “plan” on crashing. If I did, I wouldn’t ride at all.
NorCal 50+
Profile picture for user NorCal 50+
Posts
1457
Joined
5/31/2017
Location
Grass Valley, CA US
NorCal 50+ 2/9/2018 9:55am
2/9/2018 9:55am
Basic knee guards are much better these days and offer much better protection. I got some Fox ones that practically feel like knee braces.'
I had the same experience with braces- too restrictive for me.
Gixxxerboy
Profile picture for user Gixxxerboy
Posts
111
Joined
9/5/2017
Location
Metairie, LA US
Gixxxerboy 2/9/2018 10:16am
2/9/2018 10:16am
In 2006, I had a bad crash at 3 palms. I was only wearing knee guards. I completely tore my MCL, ACL, PCL all in one get off. My knee cap rolled off and was almost on the back of my leg. Underwent a total knee reconstruction that took 9 hours. They told me that my leg was basically being held together by only one ligament and that they have never seen anything to that extreme. Of course they advised me to never ride again but as soon as I was able, I was back riding. I have had 2 sets of knee braces since then ( EVS Web and Asterisk Ultra Cells ). I could not imagine riding without them.
Squirrelings 2/9/2018 10:16am
2/9/2018 10:16am
Ghost of Jabroni wrote:
Same here. I too forgot my braces once, rode so loose & comfortable. I felt 10x safer. Ultimately, if I ride better w/o them, it’s safer...
Same here. I too forgot my braces once, rode so loose & comfortable. I felt 10x safer.

Ultimately, if I ride better w/o them, it’s safer.

Im about PREVENTING crashes. I dont “plan” on crashing. If I did, I wouldn’t ride at all.
The dumbest motocrosser is one who never never plans on crashing. No need to make a plan as in set a date and time, but it's best to be prepared. To each their own. I wouldn't ride without them. I wear a chest protector too.
agn5009
Profile picture for user agn5009
Posts
6757
Joined
6/8/2012
Location
State College, PA US
agn5009 2/9/2018 10:24am
2/9/2018 10:24am
Ramrod wrote:
It's a double edged sword. Wear them and have some form of protection but less feel or don't and have more feel and risk. You for...
It's a double edged sword. Wear them and have some form of protection but less feel or don't and have more feel and risk.

You for sure get used to wearing them but you lose a lot of feel for the bike.

I won't ride without after learning the hard way but I'm not sure if they do anything but help me mentally.
I have been wearing knee braces for about 15 years or so. I forgot mine one time when I went to the track. I always kept a pair of knee pads in my bag just in case. This one particular day my foot caught in a rut and I tore my miniscus. I don't know if having my knee pads on would have prevented that or not but in my own head I think it would have.
DTHA70
Profile picture for user DTHA70
Posts
336
Joined
9/25/2008
Location
Surprise, AZ US
DTHA70 2/9/2018 11:05am
2/9/2018 11:05am
you know what else is cumbersome? Crutches and a 6 month recovery. Done 3 ligaments and cartilage in each knee between football, powerlifting and moto, cant ride without them now and unfortunately back then, there wrent really OTC options. Insurance wouldn't cover until AFTER an injury that required surgery. 6 operations later my knees are in fair shape and knee braces keep them that way. Im not trying to spend another year in a wheelchair or immobilizers ever again.
Ghost of Jabroni 2/9/2018 11:11am
2/9/2018 11:11am
Ghost of Jabroni wrote:
Same here. I too forgot my braces once, rode so loose & comfortable. I felt 10x safer. Ultimately, if I ride better w/o them, it’s safer...
Same here. I too forgot my braces once, rode so loose & comfortable. I felt 10x safer.

Ultimately, if I ride better w/o them, it’s safer.

Im about PREVENTING crashes. I dont “plan” on crashing. If I did, I wouldn’t ride at all.
Squirrelings wrote:
The dumbest motocrosser is one who never never plans on crashing. No need to make a plan as in set a date and time, but it's...
The dumbest motocrosser is one who never never plans on crashing. No need to make a plan as in set a date and time, but it's best to be prepared. To each their own. I wouldn't ride without them. I wear a chest protector too.
They say the same about sport bikes. Ive been riding for 10 years. Never had so much as a close call. And that's while mostly riding on the nutso freeways of Southern California. I ride a lot in Arizona, no helmet. I dont care how much that helmet is supposed to protect me, I NEVER want to find out it's limits.

How? I ride within my own limits... I dont trust ANY of the other cars on the roads (not for a single moment)... I certainly aint out there doing stupid shit like wheeling down the freeway or weaving in and out of traffic.

I cant stand people who think that because they're wearing a seatbelt that they're safe. They literally go on autopilot and are more worried about the damage to their automobile or the traffic ticket then their own health. Here's a novel approach, how about do everything in your power to NOT get in a accident so that you never need that seatbelt? The false sense of security is mind blowing because people then use it to justify driving like dumbasses.

People do the same with knee braces and chest protectors in MX. All of a sudden they are not as worried about crashing because they think they're safe. Why not prevent the crash in the first place?

Preventing crashing in activities otherwise known for "guaranteed crashes/injuries" is much easier than people think. Simply dont be a dumbass. Know your limits and respect them.
1
ML512
Profile picture for user ML512
Posts
15463
Joined
12/28/2008
Location
Wildomar, CA US
Fantasy
54th
ML512 2/9/2018 11:15am
2/9/2018 11:15am
I'm on the opposite side-of-the-fence for comfort. I've toyed around with going back to knee guards from braces and I feel quite uncomfortable without my braces. Both in feel for the bike and how tired/sore my legs felt after motos. For me, braces offer more support, control, and an extra layer of safety...I don't have a reason to go back after comparing.
ML512
Profile picture for user ML512
Posts
15463
Joined
12/28/2008
Location
Wildomar, CA US
Fantasy
54th
ML512 2/9/2018 11:17am
2/9/2018 11:17am
Ghost of Jabroni wrote:
Same here. I too forgot my braces once, rode so loose & comfortable. I felt 10x safer. Ultimately, if I ride better w/o them, it’s safer...
Same here. I too forgot my braces once, rode so loose & comfortable. I felt 10x safer.

Ultimately, if I ride better w/o them, it’s safer.

Im about PREVENTING crashes. I dont “plan” on crashing. If I did, I wouldn’t ride at all.
Squirrelings wrote:
The dumbest motocrosser is one who never never plans on crashing. No need to make a plan as in set a date and time, but it's...
The dumbest motocrosser is one who never never plans on crashing. No need to make a plan as in set a date and time, but it's best to be prepared. To each their own. I wouldn't ride without them. I wear a chest protector too.
Ghost of Jabroni wrote:
They say the same about sport bikes. Ive been riding for 10 years. Never had so much as a close call. And that's while mostly riding...
They say the same about sport bikes. Ive been riding for 10 years. Never had so much as a close call. And that's while mostly riding on the nutso freeways of Southern California. I ride a lot in Arizona, no helmet. I dont care how much that helmet is supposed to protect me, I NEVER want to find out it's limits.

How? I ride within my own limits... I dont trust ANY of the other cars on the roads (not for a single moment)... I certainly aint out there doing stupid shit like wheeling down the freeway or weaving in and out of traffic.

I cant stand people who think that because they're wearing a seatbelt that they're safe. They literally go on autopilot and are more worried about the damage to their automobile or the traffic ticket then their own health. Here's a novel approach, how about do everything in your power to NOT get in a accident so that you never need that seatbelt? The false sense of security is mind blowing because people then use it to justify driving like dumbasses.

People do the same with knee braces and chest protectors in MX. All of a sudden they are not as worried about crashing because they think they're safe. Why not prevent the crash in the first place?

Preventing crashing in activities otherwise known for "guaranteed crashes/injuries" is much easier than people think. Simply dont be a dumbass. Know your limits and respect them.
I can't take anyone who rides a streetbike or cruiser without a helmet seriously...SPLAT...
3
pdub187
Profile picture for user pdub187
Posts
742
Joined
1/28/2013
Location
AU
Fantasy
2544th
pdub187 2/9/2018 12:14pm
2/9/2018 12:14pm
Ghost of Jabroni wrote:
They say the same about sport bikes. Ive been riding for 10 years. Never had so much as a close call. And that's while mostly riding...
They say the same about sport bikes. Ive been riding for 10 years. Never had so much as a close call. And that's while mostly riding on the nutso freeways of Southern California. I ride a lot in Arizona, no helmet. I dont care how much that helmet is supposed to protect me, I NEVER want to find out it's limits.

How? I ride within my own limits... I dont trust ANY of the other cars on the roads (not for a single moment)... I certainly aint out there doing stupid shit like wheeling down the freeway or weaving in and out of traffic.

I cant stand people who think that because they're wearing a seatbelt that they're safe. They literally go on autopilot and are more worried about the damage to their automobile or the traffic ticket then their own health. Here's a novel approach, how about do everything in your power to NOT get in a accident so that you never need that seatbelt? The false sense of security is mind blowing because people then use it to justify driving like dumbasses.

People do the same with knee braces and chest protectors in MX. All of a sudden they are not as worried about crashing because they think they're safe. Why not prevent the crash in the first place?

Preventing crashing in activities otherwise known for "guaranteed crashes/injuries" is much easier than people think. Simply dont be a dumbass. Know your limits and respect them.
You're on the freeway bro. It's pretty damn hard to crash going in a straight line unless you're horrendously bad at riding. Find a road with a couple of corners.
ktm212
Profile picture for user ktm212
Posts
608
Joined
11/30/2009
Location
Lafayette, NJ US
ktm212 2/9/2018 12:56pm
2/9/2018 12:56pm
Squirrelings wrote:
The dumbest motocrosser is one who never never plans on crashing. No need to make a plan as in set a date and time, but it's...
The dumbest motocrosser is one who never never plans on crashing. No need to make a plan as in set a date and time, but it's best to be prepared. To each their own. I wouldn't ride without them. I wear a chest protector too.
Ghost of Jabroni wrote:
They say the same about sport bikes. Ive been riding for 10 years. Never had so much as a close call. And that's while mostly riding...
They say the same about sport bikes. Ive been riding for 10 years. Never had so much as a close call. And that's while mostly riding on the nutso freeways of Southern California. I ride a lot in Arizona, no helmet. I dont care how much that helmet is supposed to protect me, I NEVER want to find out it's limits.

How? I ride within my own limits... I dont trust ANY of the other cars on the roads (not for a single moment)... I certainly aint out there doing stupid shit like wheeling down the freeway or weaving in and out of traffic.

I cant stand people who think that because they're wearing a seatbelt that they're safe. They literally go on autopilot and are more worried about the damage to their automobile or the traffic ticket then their own health. Here's a novel approach, how about do everything in your power to NOT get in a accident so that you never need that seatbelt? The false sense of security is mind blowing because people then use it to justify driving like dumbasses.

People do the same with knee braces and chest protectors in MX. All of a sudden they are not as worried about crashing because they think they're safe. Why not prevent the crash in the first place?

Preventing crashing in activities otherwise known for "guaranteed crashes/injuries" is much easier than people think. Simply dont be a dumbass. Know your limits and respect them.
ML512 wrote:
I can't take anyone who rides a streetbike or cruiser without a helmet seriously...SPLAT...
Dry THIS fucking guy, wow.
Naanak
Profile picture for user Naanak
Posts
625
Joined
9/9/2014
Location
NJ US
Naanak 2/9/2018 1:03pm
2/9/2018 1:03pm
Ghost of Jabroni wrote:
Same here. I too forgot my braces once, rode so loose & comfortable. I felt 10x safer. Ultimately, if I ride better w/o them, it’s safer...
Same here. I too forgot my braces once, rode so loose & comfortable. I felt 10x safer.

Ultimately, if I ride better w/o them, it’s safer.

Im about PREVENTING crashes. I dont “plan” on crashing. If I did, I wouldn’t ride at all.
Squirrelings wrote:
The dumbest motocrosser is one who never never plans on crashing. No need to make a plan as in set a date and time, but it's...
The dumbest motocrosser is one who never never plans on crashing. No need to make a plan as in set a date and time, but it's best to be prepared. To each their own. I wouldn't ride without them. I wear a chest protector too.
Ghost of Jabroni wrote:
They say the same about sport bikes. Ive been riding for 10 years. Never had so much as a close call. And that's while mostly riding...
They say the same about sport bikes. Ive been riding for 10 years. Never had so much as a close call. And that's while mostly riding on the nutso freeways of Southern California. I ride a lot in Arizona, no helmet. I dont care how much that helmet is supposed to protect me, I NEVER want to find out it's limits.

How? I ride within my own limits... I dont trust ANY of the other cars on the roads (not for a single moment)... I certainly aint out there doing stupid shit like wheeling down the freeway or weaving in and out of traffic.

I cant stand people who think that because they're wearing a seatbelt that they're safe. They literally go on autopilot and are more worried about the damage to their automobile or the traffic ticket then their own health. Here's a novel approach, how about do everything in your power to NOT get in a accident so that you never need that seatbelt? The false sense of security is mind blowing because people then use it to justify driving like dumbasses.

People do the same with knee braces and chest protectors in MX. All of a sudden they are not as worried about crashing because they think they're safe. Why not prevent the crash in the first place?

Preventing crashing in activities otherwise known for "guaranteed crashes/injuries" is much easier than people think. Simply dont be a dumbass. Know your limits and respect them.
No matter how good you are or how much you do to prevent it crashes can be 100% out of your control. So wear the stuff that will keep you safe and don’t ride dumb and you’ll be as safe as possible. Although not commen unexpected and uncontrollable things can occur and once your heads sliding down the concrete it doesn’t take much to cause some serious damage.

Pit Row

See All »
Flip109
Profile picture for user Flip109
Posts
3460
Joined
6/15/2007
Location
TX US
Flip109 2/9/2018 1:10pm
2/9/2018 1:10pm
I used to wear asterisk. Got in a pretty good crash one time and one of the top members snapped. It was VERY sharp. All I could think about was if that had gouged my main artery and blead me out. Screw that. Never replaced them. Also have a good buddy. Tore both his knees to shreds plenty of times. Both with and without knee braces. He quit wearing them after the second time he tore his knee with a brace on. He had custom fit ctis or whatever they were back in the day. Anyway both those instances made me stray away from them. Plus like the OP said. I like the feel of the bike with just pads instead of all the heavy bracing. To each their own, I can see why someone would or wouldn’t feel safe with them on or off. Kinda like a neck brace. I will say the asterisk braces were very very comfortable for knee braces, and until they broke on me that time I loved them.
BobPA
Profile picture for user BobPA
Posts
8028
Joined
10/31/2013
Location
PA US
BobPA 2/9/2018 1:18pm
2/9/2018 1:18pm
Ramrod wrote:
It's a double edged sword. Wear them and have some form of protection but less feel or don't and have more feel and risk. You for...
It's a double edged sword. Wear them and have some form of protection but less feel or don't and have more feel and risk.

You for sure get used to wearing them but you lose a lot of feel for the bike.

I won't ride without after learning the hard way but I'm not sure if they do anything but help me mentally.
Ghost of Jabroni wrote:
Same here. I too forgot my braces once, rode so loose & comfortable. I felt 10x safer. Ultimately, if I ride better w/o them, it’s safer...
Same here. I too forgot my braces once, rode so loose & comfortable. I felt 10x safer.

Ultimately, if I ride better w/o them, it’s safer.

Im about PREVENTING crashes. I dont “plan” on crashing. If I did, I wouldn’t ride at all.
More than one of my friends have blown out a knee without crashing.

For claiming to be so smart, that is a very very dumb way to think.
BobPA
Profile picture for user BobPA
Posts
8028
Joined
10/31/2013
Location
PA US
BobPA 2/9/2018 1:20pm
2/9/2018 1:20pm
ML512 wrote:
I'm on the opposite side-of-the-fence for comfort. I've toyed around with going back to knee guards from braces and I feel quite uncomfortable without my braces...
I'm on the opposite side-of-the-fence for comfort. I've toyed around with going back to knee guards from braces and I feel quite uncomfortable without my braces. Both in feel for the bike and how tired/sore my legs felt after motos. For me, braces offer more support, control, and an extra layer of safety...I don't have a reason to go back after comparing.
Agreed
Tuna
Profile picture for user Tuna
Posts
1582
Joined
4/3/2017
Location
CA
Tuna 2/9/2018 1:28pm
2/9/2018 1:28pm
Jabroni is gonna learn the hard way someday. If only it was that easy to think other factors could not line up and maim or kill you. You sound a little like the poster boy for stupid. Best of luck bro, hope you stay safe. Sure would be nice if you could prevent factors out of your control.
Tuna
Profile picture for user Tuna
Posts
1582
Joined
4/3/2017
Location
CA
Tuna 2/9/2018 1:29pm
2/9/2018 1:29pm
Love my braces, feel naked without them. Wouldn’t ride without them.
SK523
Profile picture for user SK523
Posts
34
Joined
10/26/2017
Location
Germantown, WI US
SK523 2/9/2018 3:34pm
2/9/2018 3:34pm
I blew out my acl while riding when I was younger. The surgery and recovery was bad and I was 17 at the time. Please guys reconsider not wearing your knee braces. Even if they give you a small bit of protection they are worth it. Try a newer high end pair if you are not happy with your current ones.
Brent
Profile picture for user Brent
Posts
5305
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Party in Temecula, CA US
Brent 2/9/2018 3:42pm
2/9/2018 3:42pm Edited Date/Time 2/9/2018 3:42pm
Asterisks saved my lower leg from amputation after I spun my foot around 180 degrees after a crash.

I hate wearing knee braces, but I really like having all my body parts.
TbonesPop
Profile picture for user TbonesPop
Posts
3467
Joined
1/26/2010
Location
Gilbert, AZ US
Fantasy
321st
TbonesPop 2/9/2018 4:10pm
2/9/2018 4:10pm
PracticeChamp141 wrote:
10 straight years never once threw a leg over the bike without wearing knee braces. Various companies, sizes, knee socks, strap technology yet yeilding the same...
10 straight years never once threw a leg over the bike without wearing knee braces. Various companies, sizes, knee socks, strap technology yet yeilding the same result. One day having forgot my knee braces I decided to ride with 25 dollar knee cups. Could not believe the results associated with physically gripping the bike, lifting leg through deep ruts and overall comfort. Night and day difference between the two. I do realize the safty factors associated, but the reduction in arm pump and overall maneuverability when transitioning from sitting to standing are not easyily offset.
Try some Leatt C Frames. I tried a bout 4 different brands of knee braces and couldn't deal with my legs sliding around when trying to grip the bike. Then I got some C frames. I grip the bike so good now, I'm keep wearing out my shroud graphics (twice). I can't tell how any knee brace is any better than another during a crash - don't know how anyone could legitimately test that. But as far as high end knee braces go, these were by far the most comfortable for me to get used to. I feel naked without them now and I grip the bike as well or even better now with them on.
tylermx967
Profile picture for user tylermx967
Posts
506
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Athens, TX US
tylermx967 2/9/2018 4:34pm
2/9/2018 4:34pm
I RITED IN THE OTHER THRED THAT I DIND HAVE KNEE BRACES BUT GETED THE BIG GUY ELBOW PADS FOR VOLLEYBALL AND PUT ON THE KNEES YOU CAN DROP DOWN ON THE GRAGE FLOOR AND IT DOSENT EVEN HURT AND THEY LOOK LIKE WRESSELER PADS OF THE WWE SUPERSTARS
zac_k3
Profile picture for user zac_k3
Posts
578
Joined
3/5/2017
Location
TN US
zac_k3 2/9/2018 4:39pm
2/9/2018 4:39pm
I’ve never wore any type of knee protection, I once bought a pair of Thor knee braces but just walking around the house I could tell I would hate them so I never even tried them at the track. I think it’s very funny how some people wouldn’t dare ride without knee protection but have no problem not wearing any sort of neck protectionWhistling
GoggleFiend904 2/9/2018 6:00pm
2/9/2018 6:00pm Edited Date/Time 2/9/2018 6:01pm
Mine work great, I've only shattered my kneecap once..







On a serious note, I feel they are worth wearing. I once dabbed my leg so hard that two toe nails came off. The damn things were purple by the time I got back to the truck and got my boot off. My knee swelled up pretty bad and I was on crutches for a week, but all was good after some time and PT. I think I would have completely blown out my knee without them.

My uncle did the same thing as me in the early 90s. He said his foot hit him in the face while both hands were still on the bars. Lol
captmoto
Profile picture for user captmoto
Posts
5153
Joined
4/22/2009
Location
Rancho Cucamonga, CA US
captmoto 2/9/2018 6:38pm
2/9/2018 6:38pm
60 years old, rode shitty bikes in the late 70's and 80's. Never had a knee injury. I've eaten some major shit over the years, broke a foot real bad, knees are shot from working. Maybe I'll try them after my knee replacement.

Post a reply to: Knee braces are cumbersome