Is there a "go fast" gene?

Titan1
Posts
8618
Joined
2/3/2010
Location
Lehi, UT US
Edited Date/Time 3/22/2013 9:39am
Seriously, though, why do some people just seem to go incredibly fast on everything?

For example my brother and I...he's faster than me at everything we do (BMX, mountain biking, go carts, motocross, off road, motorcycles). And I think all it comes down to is that he can turn off the "fear/caution" part of his brain better than me. He'll pin it, when I'll let off because the "fear" side of my brain won't allow me to twist the grip.

We ride off road all the time together and we wear POV cameras...and then we'll watch the videos side by side...and it happens over and over again....there will be a particular obstacle (rock, turn, tree, blind spot, whatever) and I'll let off, and he'll just keep it pinned and make a ton of time on me.

So why are some people able to do that better/more often than others? Is it a gene? A personality trait?

Is that what separates a guy like Andrew Short from Ryan Villopoto? Both are in great shape, both are incredibly talented, both have great equipment...but, RV just keeps it pinned when AS lets off a little bit?
|
FreshTopEnd
Posts
12476
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Sacramento, CA US
Fantasy
4231st
3/20/2013 11:10am
There apparently is a fearlessness/risk taking/forget pain gene. I think National Geo mag had an article about it awhile back.

I also think great riders have exceptional inner ears/vestibular systems. Personally, I think that ultimately is the difference maker.

Put those two together and you have someone who can go for it and stay on the bike.
Mr. G
Posts
4191
Joined
12/23/2009
Location
Riverside, CA US
3/20/2013 11:16am
No. The thing all the great's have in common is a good mental condition that is above the norm.
ocscottie
Posts
69108
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Redding, CA US
3/20/2013 11:22am
There apparently is a fearlessness/risk taking/forget pain gene. I think National Geo mag had an article about it awhile back. I also think great riders have...
There apparently is a fearlessness/risk taking/forget pain gene. I think National Geo mag had an article about it awhile back.

I also think great riders have exceptional inner ears/vestibular systems. Personally, I think that ultimately is the difference maker.

Put those two together and you have someone who can go for it and stay on the bike.
FTE: "I think National Geo mag had an article about it awhile back."

Hey Michael, i would like to read that, do you know if it has an archive online?
cwtoyota
Posts
1930
Joined
3/11/2013
Location
Tacoma, WA US
3/20/2013 11:24am
Titan1 wrote:
Seriously, though, why do some people just seem to go incredibly fast on everything? For example my brother and I...he's faster than me at everything we...
Seriously, though, why do some people just seem to go incredibly fast on everything?

For example my brother and I...he's faster than me at everything we do (BMX, mountain biking, go carts, motocross, off road, motorcycles). And I think all it comes down to is that he can turn off the "fear/caution" part of his brain better than me. He'll pin it, when I'll let off because the "fear" side of my brain won't allow me to twist the grip.

We ride off road all the time together and we wear POV cameras...and then we'll watch the videos side by side...and it happens over and over again....there will be a particular obstacle (rock, turn, tree, blind spot, whatever) and I'll let off, and he'll just keep it pinned and make a ton of time on me.

So why are some people able to do that better/more often than others? Is it a gene? A personality trait?

Is that what separates a guy like Andrew Short from Ryan Villopoto? Both are in great shape, both are incredibly talented, both have great equipment...but, RV just keeps it pinned when AS lets off a little bit?
I've thought about this a lot over the years. and my take is yes, that is what seperates Villopoto, Barcia, Carmichael, Hannah, etc from the guys like Dungey, Windham and Short.

Jeff Stanton said something in an interview with Steve Matthes that I've always believed: "You can't teach aggression".
He was talking about Barcia and taming the aggression a bit vs trying to teach it.

I figured this out with my brother as well... Growing up, he always had that talent. He was better at everything than most kids the first time he'd try it. I was the little brother with a talent defficiency. I learned to work hard and most importantly I learned aggression. After a while I would beat my brother at just about anything. My aggression keeps me racing and helps me win. My brother quit riding and doing all that sort of stuff. It was easy for him, so he lost interest.

Sometimes you get a guy who has above average talent and has that aggressive side, the type who never gives in and works hard. That's your Carmichael, Hannah, Villopoto, etc. They don't have the talent of a Windham, Lechein, Bradshaw, etc but they have something more valuable for a racer.

The Shop

peelout
Posts
17870
Joined
1/6/2011
Location
Ogden, UT US
3/20/2013 11:28am
seems like the red-heads can twist it a little further.

no idea why.

had a ginger in my age group BMX racing and we all though he had a motor on his 20" powerlite.

on a serious note, not to gloat, but i have a group of friends that i'm always that little bit better than them at everything. mx, bmx, dirtjumping, mtnbikes, pool, golf, videogames, baggin' fatties, nunchucks, etc. my one friend takes it personal. i think it's a competitive nature of some people are not willing to be beat. not saying i'm unable to be beat, but i am a very very competitive dude.

good topic Titan, bro
Titan1
Posts
8618
Joined
2/3/2010
Location
Lehi, UT US
3/20/2013 11:38am
There apparently is a fearlessness/risk taking/forget pain gene. I think National Geo mag had an article about it awhile back. I also think great riders have...
There apparently is a fearlessness/risk taking/forget pain gene. I think National Geo mag had an article about it awhile back.

I also think great riders have exceptional inner ears/vestibular systems. Personally, I think that ultimately is the difference maker.

Put those two together and you have someone who can go for it and stay on the bike.
That inner ear thing is an interesting point (I THINK it has to do with balance, right?) My brother is just a tick faster than me in most places...but in the slower more technical parts of a trail, he is about 4 or 5 ticks faster than me. I've always said its because he has better balance-which he does.
Shawn142
Posts
2598
Joined
10/27/2008
Location
Burleson, TX US
3/20/2013 11:42am
What makes a kid separate himself from the pack as early as 6 or 7? I grew up in the era of Pastrana, Wey, Marley, Fonesca, etc.. the guys who won championships as amateurs and had at least marginal success as pros were ALWAYS faster, even from the very beginning. I had some good runs with top 10s in some tough classes but at no point was I ever competition for the likes of Pastrana. I doubt he rode more than me, he damn sure was more frail than I was. So what about him made it so that he could ride that stupid Suzuki at least 2 seconds a lap faster than my best pace?

The only exceptions to the rule I've ever seen are Andrew Short and Ivan Tedesco. Both of those guys were roughly my speed as amateurs. When Andrew especially turned pro he did about what I expected. But then somehow he did what most people consider impossible, which is gain significant speed after turning pro.
cwtoyota
Posts
1930
Joined
3/11/2013
Location
Tacoma, WA US
3/20/2013 11:49am
I think the inner ear thing is often associated to "talent"... I group it in there...

It has to be true though. Think about a fighter pilot. They have to have some insanely quick reflexes. Perhaps the rest of us can train our brains to that level, but they already have it naturally.

Tell me that Travis Pastrana isn't just the most fearless, balanced kid with insane-quick reflexes of this modern age. He lacks one thing... The focus to pick one subject and dedicate himself to it.
Hman144
Posts
2101
Joined
12/4/2007
Location
York, PA US
Fantasy
714th
3/20/2013 11:50am
Don't think you can narrow it down to just one factor like superior balance or lack of fear. While each of those things may be a necessary ingredient, I believe it is a combination of a few things that for some, come together in a perfect storm. Any person who rises to the top of their chosen,(some might say destined), field has that beautiful mix.

As case in point, those fine young men riding my cousin's stolen bike on one wheel through the streets of Baltimore display an awesome sense of balance. I'd be willing to bet few of them could ride a track or even a trail as well as your average B class rider, despite being able to out-wheelie most. Pure speculation, but I'd bet.

One of the characteristics mentioned in that "old guy" video posted earlier was vision. I've always thought that the really fast guys have the ability to see and process things differently than the average joe. Don't think this has ever been studied, but I'd be interested to see about it.

H
Lone Wolf
Posts
494
Joined
9/25/2012
Location
NZ
3/20/2013 12:04pm Edited Date/Time 3/20/2013 12:15pm
I don't know if it is genetic or what, but I think some people are just destined to be better at motocross. I have heard natural reaction time, co-ordination and balance suggested as factors that determine someone's potential as a rider. I'm sure it is a combination of a lot of things, and fearlessness would probably have a significant bearing, too. I guess all sports have a specific set of traits that will separate peoples ability. I suppose that is what is commonly referred to as "talent."

In reference to what Peelout said, my best friend as a child was one of those guys who was just good at everything - Rugby, Cricket, Athletics, Distance Running, Swimming, Gymnastics, Target Shooting, Golf etc - and he was pretty fast on a dirtbike, too. However,one of the other guys in our crew was just a munter (granted he must've had some talent) - he would just send it and was faster at motocross. My buddy was so used to being the best at everything that this pissed him off no end. He would ride virtually everyday, but could never close the gap. In the end, he got so frustrated that he gave the sport away
mgifracing
Posts
1518
Joined
1/25/2007
Location
Newton, KS US
Fantasy
346th
3/20/2013 12:12pm Edited Date/Time 3/20/2013 12:15pm
Pastrana did pick one thing and stuck to it. MAKING MONEY, He figured out how to do so in whatever he tries, Smartest motorcycle rider ever or just the best publicised.
PFO186
Posts
110
Joined
8/20/2009
Location
Brewerton, NY US
3/20/2013 12:17pm
i remember andrew short mentioning what allows certain people to be fast, and it made sense to me. He said it's the ability for a persons brain to process whats going on better. to be able to take in whats coming at you, adjust and react to it. if we tried to go stew's speed, we'd cartwheel and not even know what happened because our brains can't process what's going on fast enough. i think this is true for any racing, but with moto you obviously have the athletic side of things (balance, strength etc...).
yzvet426
Posts
862
Joined
5/12/2008
Location
Lake Zurich, IL US
3/20/2013 12:18pm
Yes, most definitely.For some the world moves at a different speed. They see things and react in a different way. I believe it's genetic. Heck you can't tel me having 3 Mannings play starting quarterback isn't genetics's
Lone Wolf
Posts
494
Joined
9/25/2012
Location
NZ
3/20/2013 12:22pm
Something that might also be a factor is confidence. Those who do well from the day they start become accustomed to doing well, and expect it every time they race. Those who are just average the day they start (like me) expect to just be average and subconsciously settle for that.
bd
Posts
5976
Joined
4/6/2007
Location
Las Vegas, NV US
3/20/2013 12:23pm
Motocross is like any sport or occupation.

To be the best, you need to have a high IQ, EQ, BQ, and MQ. When RC was a rookie, he had extremely high IQ (moto brilliance), EQ (self knowledge, personal ownership, in moment), BQ (lacked fitness compared to some of the competition), and MQ (raced within the rules and ethics of MX). It wasnt until he increased his BQ that he beat Mcgrath in SX (Aldon Baker as fitness coach). I'll give some examples:

RV: IQ (motocross brilliance off the charts), EQ (emotional intelligence off the charts), BQ (increased significatly with Aldon Baker), MQ

RD5: IQ (motocross brilliance off the charts), EQ (emotional intelligence off the charts), BQ, MQ

KW: IQ (motocross brilliance off the charts), EQ (emotional intelligence not as high as RV2, RC, RD... higher than most), BQ (not as hight as RD and RV), MQ

Lil Hany: IQ (motocross smart), EQ (emotional intelligence low.... implodes often), BQ (not as hight as RD and RV), MQ (suspect)

If I were an O'Mara Hughes Baker, I would work on increasing IQ, EQ, BQ, and MQ. I believe you'll see Hughes in the future take EQ to new heights. I am very excited about his program
Lone Wolf
Posts
494
Joined
9/25/2012
Location
NZ
3/20/2013 12:24pm Edited Date/Time 3/20/2013 12:29pm
PFO186 wrote:
i remember andrew short mentioning what allows certain people to be fast, and it made sense to me. He said it's the ability for a persons...
i remember andrew short mentioning what allows certain people to be fast, and it made sense to me. He said it's the ability for a persons brain to process whats going on better. to be able to take in whats coming at you, adjust and react to it. if we tried to go stew's speed, we'd cartwheel and not even know what happened because our brains can't process what's going on fast enough. i think this is true for any racing, but with moto you obviously have the athletic side of things (balance, strength etc...).
That sounds about right. I am pretty sure I have heard something similar applied to Formula 1 drivers before.

This is a good thread - why some people are inherently faster is something that has always intrigued (and frustrated) me.
cwtoyota
Posts
1930
Joined
3/11/2013
Location
Tacoma, WA US
3/20/2013 1:18pm
mgifracing wrote:
Pastrana did pick one thing and stuck to it. MAKING MONEY, He figured out how to do so in whatever he tries, Smartest motorcycle rider ever...
Pastrana did pick one thing and stuck to it. MAKING MONEY, He figured out how to do so in whatever he tries, Smartest motorcycle rider ever or just the best publicised.
That's a fair point... I didn't think of it quite that way. One aspect is that he has the right people around him to help him out with the making money part. Perhaps he learned that as a result of his pro-motocross career.
TomZ
Posts
707
Joined
7/24/2008
Location
West Bloomfield, MI US
Fantasy
4402nd
3/20/2013 1:22pm
There is at least one industry insider (non-racer) who swears there is a wheelie gene..........

Seriously after talking with many of the top pros it seems one common trait is the ability to process information at a different speed than is considered normal. Combine that with unusual inner ear balance and you have the needed combo. Add in an aggressive attitude and you have champ potential.
BDOG
Posts
1328
Joined
1/10/2008
Location
Danville, VA US
3/20/2013 2:07pm
Heart, desire, athletic ability, thousands of hours of practice and in today's racing climate- lot's of money. (and some luck too)
WeiserGuy
Posts
717
Joined
3/5/2012
Location
Over the hills & far away, OH US
3/20/2013 2:33pm Edited Date/Time 3/20/2013 2:35pm
No go fast gene.. The difference is all mental make up, period.

At young ages the greats get locked in the zone at some point. Your on top of the world and can't do a damn thing wrong while locked in this unbreakable mental state.. These few continue to get "locked in" and are capable of shutting off everything to remain there. This includes such things as pressure, phyisical pain, problems outside the job and yes you guessed it FEAR..

All pros have been there, but the greats continue to find this special place.
jeffro503
Posts
27442
Joined
7/22/2007
Location
St Helens, OR US
3/20/2013 3:05pm
God I love actually being able to cruise through a "great thread" on here!

Good Job Titan! Some very interesting opinions on this.
WeiserGuy
Posts
717
Joined
3/5/2012
Location
Over the hills & far away, OH US
3/20/2013 5:51pm
Something repeated by the greats I always found interesting is the fact they were driven by their fear of failure.
brocster
Posts
3608
Joined
6/9/2009
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA US
3/20/2013 6:34pm
i have always said that those guys brains click to a different tune....we can rail a turn as fast as you think possible and it's equal to their speed, first turn, straight out the pits on a warm up lap. our rough their smooth, our late braking point they're still wfo....definately processor speed and some other things.
Roscoe33
Posts
942
Joined
12/10/2009
Location
London CA
3/20/2013 7:19pm
Old souls who in past lives have had experience with sword fighting seem to have the same traits.
gfmoto
Posts
59
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
US
3/20/2013 8:27pm
"Talent" is a hard thing to define...I've come across a few "talented" riders who don't have to put in the amount of time everyone else does to get fast. it just comes natural to them. I've seen it in school/ college where some people just "get it" right away with difficult subjects. It always drove me a little crazy to be around those people!
I was a pretty good baseball player growing up starting to play at 5. when I was in High school I was MVP my senior year and played above my age bracket all through little league as an All-star. I have a black belt in Tae Kwon Do and I was quite competitive in tournament fighting, which gave me good balance and quick reactions. I'm a very aggressive competitor by nature, so despite not racing until I was 21 I have been a competitive 30+ expert. I know my aggression serves me well in racing, but having crashed hard a few times I know that has slowed me down/ calmed me down quite a bit over the last few years. I know if I would have started earlier I would have turned Pro, but a top flight factory pro.....I never had the "talent" to reach that level. The guys at the top of this sport are the perfect storm of aggression, quick reflexes, dedication, balance, opportunity and luck.
braaap
Posts
473
Joined
1/5/2007
Location
TX US
Fantasy
2172nd
3/20/2013 8:56pm
PFO186 wrote:
i remember andrew short mentioning what allows certain people to be fast, and it made sense to me. He said it's the ability for a persons...
i remember andrew short mentioning what allows certain people to be fast, and it made sense to me. He said it's the ability for a persons brain to process whats going on better. to be able to take in whats coming at you, adjust and react to it. if we tried to go stew's speed, we'd cartwheel and not even know what happened because our brains can't process what's going on fast enough. i think this is true for any racing, but with moto you obviously have the athletic side of things (balance, strength etc...).
This has always been in line with my theory. I believe some people see things in "slow motion" so to speak. What seems fast to some is not to others. This goes hand in hand with the ability to focus better.

Used to ride with a guy that spoke about like Mountain Man from Duck Dynasty....very sloooooow. As a matter of fact he did everything slow until you put him in or on something with an engine. Then it was on. The dude could haul ass in MX, enduro, road racing, speedway bikes, dirt track cars, drag cars... You name it, he could do it fast but you'd never know it by his mannerisms.
3/21/2013 12:35am
peelout wrote:
seems like the red-heads can twist it a little further. no idea why. had a ginger in my age group BMX racing and we all though...
seems like the red-heads can twist it a little further.

no idea why.

had a ginger in my age group BMX racing and we all though he had a motor on his 20" powerlite.

on a serious note, not to gloat, but i have a group of friends that i'm always that little bit better than them at everything. mx, bmx, dirtjumping, mtnbikes, pool, golf, videogames, baggin' fatties, nunchucks, etc. my one friend takes it personal. i think it's a competitive nature of some people are not willing to be beat. not saying i'm unable to be beat, but i am a very very competitive dude.

good topic Titan, bro
I guess you were joking about the ginger stuff, but I've actually heard that redheads were sought in Roman times to make into warriors because they were just more badass. I'm not sure if there are studies, but it sounds like there really could be a genetic advantage to being a ginger.
3/21/2013 1:45am
I wonder if a lack of 3D perception could have something to do with it. Apparently a surprising last percentage of the population can't detect 3D and thus their depth perception is different. My mum is one of these people and she seems to have a hard job gauging speed.
3/21/2013 2:59am
WeiserGuy wrote:
No go fast gene.. The difference is all mental make up, period. At young ages the greats get locked in the zone at some point. Your...
No go fast gene.. The difference is all mental make up, period.

At young ages the greats get locked in the zone at some point. Your on top of the world and can't do a damn thing wrong while locked in this unbreakable mental state.. These few continue to get "locked in" and are capable of shutting off everything to remain there. This includes such things as pressure, phyisical pain, problems outside the job and yes you guessed it FEAR..

All pros have been there, but the greats continue to find this special place.
Winner winner chicken dinner.

Post a reply to: Is there a "go fast" gene?

The Latest