Upgrade to enjoy this feature!
Vital MX fantasy is free to play, but paid users have great benefits. Paid member benefits:
- View and download rider stats
- Pick trends
- Create a private league
- And more!
Only $10 for all 2024 SX, MX, and SMX series (regularly $30).
Herlings, Cairoli, Tomac, Musquin and Anderson. Period.
You can argue the GP's are more competitive now. I do believe the GP's has the two best riders in the entire world and I also believe they have much more depth right now. Back when Reed was still riding great, Stewart was still around and the two Ryan's weren't retired? Not a chance in hell the GP's could match up.
I doubt either of them would have been paid more to ride regional SX , than they would have to go 450 on a factory team.
And neither of them would have ridden against those guys on a 250, its a shame that RV & Dungey both gave up their titles instead of making someone win them, but that , coupled with Stewart going AWOL and Canard being , well Canard, by the time they got to 450 , it wasnt the class they came to win.
I could agree with you , but whats the point of us both being wrong?
The Shop
I think there in general there is a ton of over thinking going on in most replies.
We dont need to do this US against them shit, SX VS MX etc. They are different sports. SX is pretty much a US only deal.
SX is a sport for money & casual fans. Casuals fans don't post on vital, they prob don't even know what the GP's are. Most of them prob dont even have a passport.
Look at the SX series from a proper fan point. Within a couple of rounds 90% of the talent is out injured. Now we are treated to Anderson hopping around playing safe, Tomac & MM going for pointless wins. Its crap racing.
Taking 2 elite riders away from SX wont change much, it will still be a shit show after a few rounds as the talent crash out.
The 2 elite riders instead train for outdoors MXGP & arrive at rd 1 ready to campaign for a proper World Title.
I think it's pretty sad the majority of folk don't respect & crave a World Title. Ultimately it's costing your talent progressing in the sport we all love.
It might see more Europeans racing Supercross and more Americans racing GPs
Of course my point my be completely useless, just my 2 cents (or 2 pennies)
https://www.mxlarge.com/news/2018-european-motocross-calendar
Americans care more about attending a USA MXON that any GP.
Pit Row
NO
Why do most US MX fans not give a shit about an MXGP rd ? It's because you dont have any of your elite riders contending for a championship.
If Bagget dug deep over the winter, came out swinging at the start of the MXGP season, was mixing it up with JH & AC it would be huge news. Probably the biggest hype in the industry. With the hype would come the crowds.
The trouble is IMO the USA turn everything into an in house only deal. It's not just a moto thing, it's the US mentality. You believe your the best at everything & prefer to feed the fantasy rather then show up at the world stage & be accountable if you fail.
Not all riders are or fans, but in general it seems the logic.
IMO there is a certain pride that money cant buy to being a guy who conquers on the world stage. I just hope at some stage the US mentality changes as I really do think US participation within MXGP would be a major win for our sport.
You are right about one thing - MXGP will never take off in the US until the top riders from the US participate in it. And that seems unlikely because they get more money in the US racing SX/MX. Also, in the US you grow up watching our SX and MX championships - so just like how you think MXGP is the most prestigious, here we grow up looking at our series as the pinnacle of the sport.
MX fans that post on Vital know about the MXGP series and follow it. But go to a local riding spot in the US and most people won't know thing about it outside of that Dutch guy Herlings being crazy fast and what happened at the last MXDN.
If the ama/is series had a race in Canada,Mexico and South America would that qualify as a world championship or make the series better? No
Racing in Qatar Thailand Mexico where little to no riders come from isn’t adding or should I say drawing talent from those locations.
The Mxgp and ama series are equal to a world championship because anyone from anywhere can compete in either series.
Sx is a stop gap for the outdoors. Herrings proved Gp guys are another level.
I could see SX turning in to a World Championship with half the races here and the others all over the world. No east/west, but a North America/Europe 250 structure. Maybe 125 support classes more regional at each round. I personally could give a shit less if it takes rides away from our 250 class. Maybe it would give a hard slap of reality to Some of these parents and kids who metaphorically sell the farm to make it as an unsuccessful pro for multiple years. Many bubble guys come to mind. Guys who were occasionally making mains a few years ago that get 10th in the LCQ's now. The ship has sailed and they're not on it. They reached their peak and it wasnt enough.
This is the pinnacle of off road motorcycle racing we're talking about here. It's not supposed to be easily accessible for anyone to participate it. It's meant for the world's elite. Use your countries national series, arenacross series, etc. to find talent, not 3 20 minute moto's in August on a glorified pitbike track.
Maybe in the past the AMA had an equal or perhaps faster top 10. Now the AMA nationals looks just like any other national series to me. The guys towards the back of an AMA national don't look like they should be out there. Like Herlings said after Ironman, half the field weren't even jumping the jumps. Lapping occours very early in an AMA nat & its quite frustrating to see the elite guys held up.
It perfectly clear MXGP is on another level in every aspect to outdoor racing. Gone are the slow privateers for the most part. Coming through the pack after a bad start is much harder, you have to ride a lot more over 2 days, you rider a greater variety of terrains.
I think now the difference is clear for most people to see, it's time to for the US elite to have a go. Like I said before it a US world champ might actually help the US industry more then a national champ. The AMA nats would be seen as the feeder series to breed the next world champ.
USA just need to step up & think bigger.
Post a reply to: If the public demand was high enough, could it happen ?