If it was an open class

just James
Posts
1133
Joined
12/20/2012
Location
Wolf Creek, OR US
Edited Date/Time 5/11/2016 3:12pm
Rather than being limited to 450cc, what size motor do you think most of the teams would run in the nationals? I mean if there was no limit at all.
Also, would any of the factories develop/run a two stroke (for said open class)?

I, personally think that they are getting about all the power that can be used out of the 450's, and I doubt that anyone would go much, if any, bigger.
As far as the two strokes, I think it would depend on the weigh limit, or lack thereof.
Thoughts?
|
gt80rider
Posts
6275
Joined
4/19/2008
Location
Boulder, CO US
5/10/2016 7:52pm
You can get a Lot of reliable power out of a 350 smoker twin, and be light too...
kzizok
Posts
8393
Joined
10/19/2010
Location
AS US
Fantasy
2034th
5/10/2016 8:10pm
gt80rider wrote:
You can get a Lot of reliable power out of a 350 smoker twin, and be light too...
700cc's? Reliable=perhaps, Rideable=probably not, light=twin would be heavier than single.
ando
Posts
3051
Joined
8/20/2009
Location
Perth AU
5/10/2016 8:17pm
I don't believe there is any "goldilocks" displacement that is going to make a two stroke bike faster than current four strokes.
early
Posts
8260
Joined
2/13/2013
Location
University Heights, OH US
Fantasy
2212th
5/10/2016 8:21pm
gt80rider wrote:
You can get a Lot of reliable power out of a 350 smoker twin, and be light too...
kzizok wrote:
700cc's? Reliable=perhaps, Rideable=probably not, light=twin would be heavier than single.
Pretty sure he meant 175cc each. Like a Banshee engine, which came from the RD350LC (RZ350), which came from the RD350, which i have in my garage ('73 model)

I would say 500cc 2 or 4 stroke would be max efficient displacement. I personally dont like the idea of opening the multi-cylinder can of worms.

The Shop

zehn
Posts
7258
Joined
1/15/2013
Location
Anchorage, AK US
5/10/2016 8:33pm
gt80rider wrote:
You can get a Lot of reliable power out of a 350 smoker twin, and be light too...
kzizok wrote:
700cc's? Reliable=perhaps, Rideable=probably not, light=twin would be heavier than single.
early wrote:
Pretty sure he meant 175cc each. Like a Banshee engine, which came from the RD350LC (RZ350), which came from the RD350, which i have in my...
Pretty sure he meant 175cc each. Like a Banshee engine, which came from the RD350LC (RZ350), which came from the RD350, which i have in my garage ('73 model)

I would say 500cc 2 or 4 stroke would be max efficient displacement. I personally dont like the idea of opening the multi-cylinder can of worms.
Got a couple bored RD400s we race in AHRMA... Thinking of that motor in a dirt scooter is a scary thought!
Crush
Posts
20960
Joined
4/26/2009
Location
Sydney AU
5/10/2016 8:35pm
350F with no weight limit. Get it down to 250 2-stroke weight.
Overall weight difference MY16 vs MY15
TC 125: 192.7lbs. without fuel.
TC 250: 211.2lbs. without fuel.
FC 250: 217.8lbs. without fuel.
FC 350: 221.3lbs. without fuel.
FC 450: 223.1lbs. without fuel

Reckon they can find 10 pounds?!
zehn
Posts
7258
Joined
1/15/2013
Location
Anchorage, AK US
5/10/2016 8:37pm
350F with no weight limit. Get it down to 250 2-stroke weight.
Crush wrote:
Overall weight difference MY16 vs MY15 TC 125: 192.7lbs. without fuel. [b]TC 250: 211.2lbs. without fuel. [/b]FC 250: 217.8lbs. without fuel. [b]FC 350: 221.3lbs. without fuel.[/b]...
Overall weight difference MY16 vs MY15
TC 125: 192.7lbs. without fuel.
TC 250: 211.2lbs. without fuel.
FC 250: 217.8lbs. without fuel.
FC 350: 221.3lbs. without fuel.
FC 450: 223.1lbs. without fuel

Reckon they can find 10 pounds?!
With the right rules I bet they could. It would take Mag/Ti out the ass but I bet it could be done.
kiwifan
Posts
9485
Joined
10/31/2009
Location
CA US
5/10/2016 8:43pm
If i remember some of the last works Honda two strokes were only 400cc Leisk 1989?
No the last works open class Hondas were 500's, the 400 was a experimental low emission 2 stroke raced in Rally's
5/10/2016 8:46pm
gt80rider wrote:
You can get a Lot of reliable power out of a 350 smoker twin, and be light too...
kzizok wrote:
700cc's? Reliable=perhaps, Rideable=probably not, light=twin would be heavier than single.
early wrote:
Pretty sure he meant 175cc each. Like a Banshee engine, which came from the RD350LC (RZ350), which came from the RD350, which i have in my...
Pretty sure he meant 175cc each. Like a Banshee engine, which came from the RD350LC (RZ350), which came from the RD350, which i have in my garage ('73 model)

I would say 500cc 2 or 4 stroke would be max efficient displacement. I personally dont like the idea of opening the multi-cylinder can of worms.
A v-twin 250 smoker could make an awesome dirt scooter motor. Keeping the exhaust in the frame would be tricky.
kzizok
Posts
8393
Joined
10/19/2010
Location
AS US
Fantasy
2034th
5/10/2016 8:49pm Edited Date/Time 5/10/2016 8:52pm
gt80rider wrote:
You can get a Lot of reliable power out of a 350 smoker twin, and be light too...
kzizok wrote:
700cc's? Reliable=perhaps, Rideable=probably not, light=twin would be heavier than single.
early wrote:
Pretty sure he meant 175cc each. Like a Banshee engine, which came from the RD350LC (RZ350), which came from the RD350, which i have in my...
Pretty sure he meant 175cc each. Like a Banshee engine, which came from the RD350LC (RZ350), which came from the RD350, which i have in my garage ('73 model)

I would say 500cc 2 or 4 stroke would be max efficient displacement. I personally dont like the idea of opening the multi-cylinder can of worms.
Yeah you are probably right. My common sense meter must be broken today.

Still, a twin? It would never happen.
Crush
Posts
20960
Joined
4/26/2009
Location
Sydney AU
5/10/2016 9:19pm
zehn wrote:
With the right rules I bet they could. It would take Mag/Ti out the ass but I bet it could be done.
Well sure, I love factory bikes too, but my bank account isn't that fond of them!
shanes
Posts
578
Joined
3/4/2014
Location
AD
5/10/2016 9:21pm
the factory yamaha's in MXGP are 400cc , that came from a guy in Yamaha
Bearuno
Posts
4141
Joined
6/28/2014
Location
AU
5/10/2016 10:41pm
If i remember some of the last works Honda two strokes were only 400cc Leisk 1989?
kiwifan wrote:
No the last works open class Hondas were 500's, the 400 was a experimental low emission 2 stroke raced in Rally's
A few privaters ran near 400cc CR500s in the last few years of the 500 series. Being a short stroke engine, they worked very well with a de-bore.

I'm a bit tongue tied with the blokes name right now - a Surname starting with B, and quite a Pommie one ( and that, he is), who ran various Belgian MX series , and may still do so, for some time after retiring. I remember reading an interview with him and him saying it was the best engine he ever ran.

One of our Brit contributors here should have a better memory of his name. Was he Chris Burnham?

I'd love to see an Open Class. Just naturally aspirated engines as a limit. I think around the 400cc size for 2ts could be the sweet spot for them, and, I'd welcome a return of genuine grunt, with big capacity 4ts, made 'minimally'. A smaller version of the JBS Racing M1, is what I'm thinking of. Modern weight saving techniques could bring 600+CC 4ts back with a few small manufacturers, and perhaps a big manufacturer. I've read / heard several times from riders of the 600/ 650cc 4ts that the engines would be more than competitive with modern bikes, it's their weight, old geometry and suspension that would just need to be sorted. I'd love to hear and see a variety of engines out there, instead of just the cookie cutter, blarping scream of high revving 450 4ts.

Won't happen though, we can't even get 300 2ts in the 4 stroke handicapping class. It's just a piss poor situation.
5/10/2016 11:52pm
If i remember some of the last works Honda two strokes were only 400cc Leisk 1989?
kiwifan wrote:
No the last works open class Hondas were 500's, the 400 was a experimental low emission 2 stroke raced in Rally's
Sorry, i beg to differ, those info actually came from the mouth of Leisks aussie mechanic, Budda.
His name eludes me for now
scott_nz
Posts
5320
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
NZ
Fantasy
655th
5/11/2016 2:40am
If i remember some of the last works Honda two strokes were only 400cc Leisk 1989?
kiwifan wrote:
No the last works open class Hondas were 500's, the 400 was a experimental low emission 2 stroke raced in Rally's
Bearuno wrote:
A few privaters ran near 400cc CR500s in the last few years of the 500 series. Being a short stroke engine, they worked very well with...
A few privaters ran near 400cc CR500s in the last few years of the 500 series. Being a short stroke engine, they worked very well with a de-bore.

I'm a bit tongue tied with the blokes name right now - a Surname starting with B, and quite a Pommie one ( and that, he is), who ran various Belgian MX series , and may still do so, for some time after retiring. I remember reading an interview with him and him saying it was the best engine he ever ran.

One of our Brit contributors here should have a better memory of his name. Was he Chris Burnham?

I'd love to see an Open Class. Just naturally aspirated engines as a limit. I think around the 400cc size for 2ts could be the sweet spot for them, and, I'd welcome a return of genuine grunt, with big capacity 4ts, made 'minimally'. A smaller version of the JBS Racing M1, is what I'm thinking of. Modern weight saving techniques could bring 600+CC 4ts back with a few small manufacturers, and perhaps a big manufacturer. I've read / heard several times from riders of the 600/ 650cc 4ts that the engines would be more than competitive with modern bikes, it's their weight, old geometry and suspension that would just need to be sorted. I'd love to hear and see a variety of engines out there, instead of just the cookie cutter, blarping scream of high revving 450 4ts.

Won't happen though, we can't even get 300 2ts in the 4 stroke handicapping class. It's just a piss poor situation.
Shayne King was the last rider to win the series on a 2 stroke, and it was a 360, right on the lower limit,

jock
Posts
1588
Joined
9/25/2006
Location
Postmans Ridge, QLD AU
Fantasy
1st
5/11/2016 3:54am Edited Date/Time 5/11/2016 3:56am
If i remember some of the last works Honda two strokes were only 400cc Leisk 1989?
kiwifan wrote:
No the last works open class Hondas were 500's, the 400 was a experimental low emission 2 stroke raced in Rally's
Sorry, i beg to differ, those info actually came from the mouth of Leisks aussie mechanic, Budda.
His name eludes me for now
Gary Benn?
UpTiTe
Posts
7758
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
CA US
Fantasy
4091st
5/11/2016 4:52am
I think people pining over 500 2 strokes have either never rode one, or forgot how crappy they were to ride.
mattmatt300
Posts
1448
Joined
3/30/2009
Location
Rockmart, GA US
5/11/2016 6:07am
450's would still rule. I believe they have reached the limit of useable power on an MX or SX track.
ga_pike
Posts
2607
Joined
7/14/2011
Location
Valdosta, GA US
5/11/2016 6:42am


700cc 2 stroke. You know someone would do it.

Bearuno
Posts
4141
Joined
6/28/2014
Location
AU
5/11/2016 7:08am Edited Date/Time 5/11/2016 7:17am
scott_nz wrote:
Shayne King was the last rider to win the series on a 2 stroke, and it was a 360, right on the lower limit,

That, I know. 1996 for King. The last Championship won on an old Dang Danger (hell, I ride one still , so can call them whatever I want to), was Marcus Hansson in 1994. Both, a loooooooong time ago

It was about the use of downsized CR500s, by a few privateers.

I've seen people lay creedence to Budda - that's not Gary Benn by the way , Jock - saying Leisk was on a 400. I truly don't believe it. Mind you, the difference in revs he used in his first European Moto at Valkenswaard, in '89, when he ran out of petrol whilst leading, was like listening to a 400, as against the far lower revs he used in the second moto Woohoo Throwing the bike at Budda / Buddha, showed a fair bit of emotion, that's for sure. Leisk was on 491cc 500s, complete with the factory decomp cylinder, for his 2 years in the GPs, from everything I ever saw. Also, from the horses mouth : Leisk - I asked him about it, the 400 claim, at a KTM dealership I worked at, and he laughed at the suggestion.

The very first EXP 400 'experiment' was based very closely on the ancient old 500 - just downsized and still with a carb. Rapidly, it became a very, Very exotic thing, with no relationship what so ever to the CR500 :

This patent drawing is, I think, the basic reflection of the above pictured engine :


But, I have this patent drawing stored, labelled as an EXP2 engine as well:


Honda, have / had so much 2t technology they just left behind. At least a bit of the more basic EXP / AR (Active Radical) tech was used on the production CRM250ARs, for a few years. Here's a CRM250AR / AF project:
Bearuno
Posts
4141
Joined
6/28/2014
Location
AU
5/11/2016 7:32am Edited Date/Time 5/11/2016 7:34am
Something to reflect on :

It's funny how easily rules can be / well, were changed, when the main players see something as no real threat to championships they cared about..

Case in point : the rapid allowance of the Aprilia V Twin in GPs (and SM and World Enduros) a few years ago. Many, many years after they were banned from MX after the appearance of Honda, Yamaha and Aprilia Twin Cylinder 2t prototypes, on the grounds of cost and complexity. Pity they didn't think about that with the 4t Handicap classes. . The Aprilia's were neat to see, and hear, and, I'm pretty sure it made for quite wonderful pay days / retirement funds for Josh Coppins in the GPs, and Stefan Merriman in EWC / WEC. Not sure if Alfie Snow(?), a young Brit, ever got much of a wage from it - he's the last one I noticed using the V Twin Aprilia. I think I've seen his name in the MX2 or EMX2 entries. recently.
Johnny Depp
Posts
6438
Joined
10/16/2014
Location
Buda, TX US
5/11/2016 8:49am
A couple of photos of the RXV Aprilia with Josh Coppins whipping it!





That bike dominated Supermoto for quite a while.
gt80rider
Posts
6275
Joined
4/19/2008
Location
Boulder, CO US
5/11/2016 9:30am Edited Date/Time 5/11/2016 9:37am
kzizok wrote:
700cc's? Reliable=perhaps, Rideable=probably not, light=twin would be heavier than single.
I intended 175 x 2... not 350 x 2...

but like another poster mentioned above... heck, even a 125 x 2 smoker would probably be too much... an easy 80 hp.. and while I wouldn't want to work on a twin, if money was no object and you are looking for max power, they would be the way to go...
Stuntman949
Posts
2849
Joined
11/10/2015
Location
San Clemente, CA US
5/11/2016 9:31am
Now that they are to the point of purposely de-tuning the bigger four strokes on occasion, I think you guys are on to something with the weight regulation of an open class. Would be cool to see what some engineering and a squillion dollars could come up with
Andrew337
Posts
128
Joined
6/24/2015
Location
Grand Prairie, TX US
5/11/2016 9:52am
Now that they are to the point of purposely de-tuning the bigger four strokes on occasion, I think you guys are on to something with the...
Now that they are to the point of purposely de-tuning the bigger four strokes on occasion, I think you guys are on to something with the weight regulation of an open class. Would be cool to see what some engineering and a squillion dollars could come up with
Definitely. I think we would see way more innovation on the factory bikes by removing the minimum weight rule than by removing the maximum displacement rule.
5/11/2016 11:49am
aprilla made a v twin dirtbike/supermoto and it sucked.

The only problems we ran into was crank bearings. Didn't last long. If you treated them like the race bike they were and changed them frequently, they were fine. Those motors pulled hard!

Post a reply to: If it was an open class

The Latest