Hydraulic Clutch on Honda

KimJongUn
Posts
24
Joined
5/25/2017
Location
Florissant, MO US
10/29/2017 6:45pm Edited Date/Time 10/30/2017 8:26pm
Has anybody ever put a KTM hydraulic clutch on a Honda? What all would be involved? Machine the case to fit and the slave cylinder would work?

I've seen the Magura but I'm not big on the lever and master cylinder.. looks cheap. Could I use just the Magura slave cylinder and KTM lever/line/master cylinder?

Maybe the 2019 Honda's will have hydraulic clutch from the factory...

|
kiwifan
Posts
9487
Joined
10/31/2009
Location
CA US
10/29/2017 6:52pm
I actually prefer the feel of a cable clutch, call me crazy...
Mike_Lawlor
Posts
106
Joined
8/8/2017
Location
Berlin, NY US
10/29/2017 7:00pm
The cases have the set up for a ktm style slave cylinder. You just need to machine out the cases and drill and tap the holes. And make a block off plate for the cable actuator arm. Google factory Honda and you will see Cole Sealys bike with one. The cases have to be the same as a production bike so the base for what you need is there it's just not machined out yet.
colintrax
Posts
4704
Joined
8/25/2015
Location
Taylorsville, GA US
Fantasy
2250th
10/29/2017 7:01pm
With so much slave labor at your disposal why not make your own cases that are machined for a ktm hydro clutch? I don't think you'll like the bill it'd cost to machine stock cases for that. Be cheaper to stuff a ktm engine into a Honda frame.

BTW what do you not like about the magura levers? Magura has come stock on some ktms and huskies, I think they feel better than the brembos. The biggest problem in feel between ktm hydros and the Japanese is that the Magura system for turning cable into hydro clutches still uses the rotating arm, where as ktm has the slave mounted on the case pushing straight into the pin. Makes for a more direct feeling clutch (because it is)

I'm not sure if you could use the brembo master cylinder with a Magura slave as I believe they use different oils. And even if they use the same oil, you might have problems with the throw.

The Shop

EZZA 95B
Posts
9081
Joined
11/3/2010
Location
AU
Fantasy
1185th
10/29/2017 7:02pm
kiwifan wrote:
I actually prefer the feel of a cable clutch, call me crazy...
You're crazy.Silly

I loved them on my Gas Gasesses.
kiwifan
Posts
9487
Joined
10/31/2009
Location
CA US
10/29/2017 7:10pm
kiwifan wrote:
I actually prefer the feel of a cable clutch, call me crazy...
EZZA 95B wrote:
You're crazy.Silly

I loved them on my Gas Gasesses.
lol each to their own Smile
EZZA 95B
Posts
9081
Joined
11/3/2010
Location
AU
Fantasy
1185th
10/29/2017 7:16pm
kiwifan wrote:
lol each to their own Smile
I wish I would have added "Shirley you can't be serious"Laughing
10/29/2017 7:51pm
kiwifan wrote:
I actually prefer the feel of a cable clutch, call me crazy...
You’re not alone...
MX558
Posts
1744
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
US
10/29/2017 7:55pm
I also prefer the feel of a cable over hydrolic, much better feel imho
kiwifan
Posts
9487
Joined
10/31/2009
Location
CA US
10/29/2017 8:35pm
kiwifan wrote:
lol each to their own Smile
EZZA 95B wrote:
I wish I would have added "Shirley you can't be serious"Laughing
it seems I am not the only Shirley here Smile
EZZA 95B
Posts
9081
Joined
11/3/2010
Location
AU
Fantasy
1185th
10/29/2017 8:37pm
kiwifan wrote:
it seems I am not the only Shirley here Smile
LaughingWink
BobPA
Posts
8022
Joined
10/31/2013
Location
PA US
10/29/2017 8:42pm Edited Date/Time 10/29/2017 8:42pm
450's and 250 two strokes I prefer a hydro

125's I prefer a cable
VRR7
Posts
793
Joined
6/1/2011
Location
ZA
10/30/2017 12:17am
Honda tried the Hydro clutch in AMA MX - The riders sudden got better results when they went back to cable ! Keep it simple stupid -



I also prefer cable over hydro and cannot understand all the hype about hydro clutches. Reliability and maintenance of cable is much more sane. A properly setup cable has much better feel than a hydraulic clutch. A badly setup and or maintained cable is off course terrible as would a failing hydo be ... Cost to repair refurbish same parts .... ! Just because it costs more does not make it better.
EZZA 95B
Posts
9081
Joined
11/3/2010
Location
AU
Fantasy
1185th
10/30/2017 12:28am
Look It's because I was a weak-girlie-man with a puny index finger muscles ok!

Isn't this where I say "if anyone wants to say something about me using a hydraulic clutch in 2003 to my face, come and see me at the track"?Silly
Myrz
Posts
71
Joined
6/18/2017
Location
IL US
10/30/2017 2:54am
kiwifan wrote:
lol each to their own Smile
EZZA 95B wrote:
I wish I would have added "Shirley you can't be serious"Laughing
I'm dead serious! ...and don't call me Shirley! Laughing
ob
Posts
1624
Joined
3/14/2010
Location
Carlsbad, CA US
10/30/2017 6:38am
If you have ridden a new Honda you know why he is asking. Worst clutch feel ever. Great bike but terrible clutch.
1
JWACK
Posts
2479
Joined
8/7/2009
Location
NM US
10/30/2017 7:15am
ob wrote:
If you have ridden a new Honda you know why he is asking. Worst clutch feel ever. Great bike but terrible clutch.
Then you never owned an rm250!!! Super jumpy at the friction point. My 18 Honda is much better. But I do agree. Not the best ever.
Mr. Info
Posts
1672
Joined
5/3/2010
Location
Perris, CA US
10/30/2017 8:16am
Had a Magura system on my 2008 Honda 450 but it seem to thru plates quicker because of a slight drag. But when plates were new it as better than stock.
ML512
Posts
15379
Joined
12/28/2008
Location
Wildomar, CA US
Fantasy
32nd
10/30/2017 8:20am
I didn't know Rocketman was a member of our forum...Woohoo
mattyhamz2
Posts
10847
Joined
7/6/2015
Location
So Cal, CA US
Fantasy
769th
10/30/2017 8:25am
ob wrote:
If you have ridden a new Honda you know why he is asking. Worst clutch feel ever. Great bike but terrible clutch.
Hasn't that been a normal Honda issue since like 2009?
Xeno
Posts
3628
Joined
12/30/2010
Location
San Clemente, CA US
10/30/2017 8:30am
Note the upside-down brake lever boot:



Dcope17
Posts
71
Joined
12/20/2016
Location
Troy, IL US
10/30/2017 8:36am
I rode a friend's Husky and liked the hydro clutch feel over my '16 Honda 450.
I was thinking about mounting a hydro setup on mine but since the cable is pull and the hydro is push, I was just going to make a piece to bolt/weld to the arm where the cable hooks to and make it extend off the other side where it can be pushed. Then make some sort of bracket to mount the slave. All external so no need for machining the cover or anything.
Zycki11
Posts
5758
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Ankeny, IA US
10/30/2017 9:23am
kiwifan wrote:
I actually prefer the feel of a cable clutch, call me crazy...
Sheriff245 wrote:
You’re not alone...
I do as well, when i had my 12 crf450 i put a magura hydraulic clutch on it because the pull and feel of the honda clutch is horrible. With that said, Every other bike I have owned that has a normal pull and feel I would prefer the standard cable
The Oracle
Posts
230
Joined
7/30/2012
Location
NO
Fantasy
4134th
10/30/2017 11:02am




Installed a Magura kit on my 18 CRF450. Works perfectly. As expected, feel is nicer with a cable, but I don't really drag the clutch a lot on the 450 so the shorter span and more "on/off feeling" suits me very well. Had two rides on it so far, no problems, took 10 minutes to install and came ready to mount.

I've put in 5 hours on a demo CRF450 as well with the OEM clutch, and did not like that.
dcg141
Posts
2175
Joined
11/30/2009
Location
MS US
10/30/2017 12:00pm
kiwifan wrote:
I actually prefer the feel of a cable clutch, call me crazy...
EZZA 95B wrote:
You're crazy.Silly

I loved them on my Gas Gasesses.
Honda does not have one stock yet so its not any good. Of course when Honda has one stock it will the greatest thing ever. BTW Honda just invented DOHC engines and finger follower valve trains.
ando
Posts
3029
Joined
8/20/2009
Location
Perth AU
10/30/2017 12:42pm
VRR7 wrote:
Honda tried the Hydro clutch in AMA MX - The riders sudden got better results when they went back to cable ! Keep it simple stupid...
Honda tried the Hydro clutch in AMA MX - The riders sudden got better results when they went back to cable ! Keep it simple stupid -



I also prefer cable over hydro and cannot understand all the hype about hydro clutches. Reliability and maintenance of cable is much more sane. A properly setup cable has much better feel than a hydraulic clutch. A badly setup and or maintained cable is off course terrible as would a failing hydo be ... Cost to repair refurbish same parts .... ! Just because it costs more does not make it better.
KTM ditched cable clutches on their MX and enduro bikes nearly twenty years ago. Multiple MXGP, AMA MX and SX, and WEC title suggests there isn’t really a reliability issue.

Do you think hydraulic brakes are unreliable as well?
BobPA
Posts
8022
Joined
10/31/2013
Location
PA US
10/30/2017 12:46pm
VRR7 wrote:
Honda tried the Hydro clutch in AMA MX - The riders sudden got better results when they went back to cable ! Keep it simple stupid...
Honda tried the Hydro clutch in AMA MX - The riders sudden got better results when they went back to cable ! Keep it simple stupid -



I also prefer cable over hydro and cannot understand all the hype about hydro clutches. Reliability and maintenance of cable is much more sane. A properly setup cable has much better feel than a hydraulic clutch. A badly setup and or maintained cable is off course terrible as would a failing hydo be ... Cost to repair refurbish same parts .... ! Just because it costs more does not make it better.
ando wrote:
KTM ditched cable clutches on their MX and enduro bikes nearly twenty years ago. Multiple MXGP, AMA MX and SX, and WEC title suggests there isn’t...
KTM ditched cable clutches on their MX and enduro bikes nearly twenty years ago. Multiple MXGP, AMA MX and SX, and WEC title suggests there isn’t really a reliability issue.

Do you think hydraulic brakes are unreliable as well?
Easy with the facts bro.

I wonder if his mind would be blown to know that brakes are hydraulic too...I heard they have nearly a 75% failure rate, better go back to cable Whistling
Fraser
Posts
781
Joined
9/12/2008
Location
Leics GB
10/30/2017 12:50pm Edited Date/Time 10/30/2017 12:51pm
I had a Magura unit on my 13 crf450, worked really well apart from the time the hydralic pipe moved and burnt through on the back of the exhaust on the start line.... Was going to fit it to the '17 but the size of the cable end is different so I sold it. 17 clutch feels way better than the 13 so I've not done it again. Renthal make an Intelliever2 unbreakable shorty lever for a KTM that fits the Magura clutch so you don't have to run the original Magura lever.
Myke
Posts
2457
Joined
9/28/2009
Location
San Diego, CA US
Fantasy
2849th
10/30/2017 1:45pm
Ken is running one now.



Post a reply to: Hydraulic Clutch on Honda

The Latest