450 fitness vs 250 fitness

MotofactioN
Posts
655
Joined
6/25/2020
Location
Gloucester, VA US
When I ride a 450, I start to struggle from arm pump at around lap 5 at your typical motocross track. On a 250, It's like arm pump doesnt even exist. I can pound laps in until I am out of breath and then pull off and maybe think, hmm I was starting to get a little arm pump.

Is there something I am doing wrong? I'm pretty strong, 200lbs 6"3, it's not like I can't handle the weight of a 450. I rode a friends YZ250F this last weekend and must've went 10+ laps and my arms didn't bother me at all, but riding my RMZ450 and friends FC450, arms start getting bad and I have to slow down around lap 5. Is it the torque, pulling me off the bike? I'm seriously going to get a 250F in a couple months and sell the 450 due to this. Tired of battling it.
3
|
SoCalMX70
Posts
2824
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Thousand Oaks, CA US
4/15/2022 2:01pm
Coming off a 250 2 stroke, a 450 is a handful. I can go more laps on my old 2 stroke when riding full out. The benefit of my CRF is I'm faster just being smooth at 80-90% effort. When I push it, it gets wild and I get tired quick. Part of it is probably me not being in tip top shape, bigger part is my technique is not there yet.

6'1" 195 lbs in OKish shape right now. Aiming for 185 and focusing on better technique.

Only tip I can provide as a slow old guy is to grip with legs more and stay on your toes... I know, world shattering advice! Silly
5
GripNRip617
Posts
199
Joined
3/13/2018
Location
Austin, TX US
4/15/2022 2:03pm
Have you compared lap times? Maybe you're accelerating/braking harder on your 450.
1
Leeham
Posts
1087
Joined
10/29/2018
Location
Rochester, WA US
Fantasy
3084th
4/15/2022 2:19pm
Are you holding your breath because you are coming into corners faster on the 450. Making you hold on trying to get the bike settled?

Suspension setup?

Your RMZ compared to the Yam is going to be a lot more feedback coming into the bars/chassis. I noticed going from my Honda 250 to the Yamaha 250, the suspension and chassis absorbed more of the energy. Which was more comfortable and I could relax more. The Suzuki frame turns so good because of the stiff frame, where the Yamaha frame is softer and doesn't turn as good as the RMZ/CRF.

Also the 450 engine weight and power is harder to "man handle" and force around the track. The YZ250F I have, even revved to the limiter I can still turn well enough and its easier to stop. And im not super strong. Lean 155lbs 5'9 athletic build. Ill probably be a small bore guy forever. The KTM 350 would be as big as I would ever go. Feels like what I imagine a nice race 250 would be like.
3
Brent
Posts
5303
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Party in Temecula, CA US
4/15/2022 2:36pm Edited Date/Time 4/15/2022 2:37pm
run a gear up or use a different less aggressive map.

We all have the same issue on the big bike, the G forces under acceleration on a 450 are hard to deal with, thats why Jett is using Steg Pegz on his 450 practice bike.

The Shop

cwel11
Posts
1614
Joined
12/4/2019
Location
Orangeville, PA US
4/15/2022 3:30pm Edited Date/Time 4/15/2022 3:31pm
This is why the 350 is the perfect bike. Plenty of grunt without the pump
3
4
brimx153
Posts
3338
Joined
5/3/2012
Location
IE
4/15/2022 5:01pm
Ride higher gears . If I ride a 450 like a 250 .I can't even last a lap .
4
TbonesPop
Posts
3464
Joined
1/26/2010
Location
Gilbert, AZ US
Fantasy
405th
4/15/2022 5:41pm
When I ride a 450, I start to struggle from arm pump at around lap 5 at your typical motocross track. On a 250, It's like...
When I ride a 450, I start to struggle from arm pump at around lap 5 at your typical motocross track. On a 250, It's like arm pump doesnt even exist. I can pound laps in until I am out of breath and then pull off and maybe think, hmm I was starting to get a little arm pump.

Is there something I am doing wrong? I'm pretty strong, 200lbs 6"3, it's not like I can't handle the weight of a 450. I rode a friends YZ250F this last weekend and must've went 10+ laps and my arms didn't bother me at all, but riding my RMZ450 and friends FC450, arms start getting bad and I have to slow down around lap 5. Is it the torque, pulling me off the bike? I'm seriously going to get a 250F in a couple months and sell the 450 due to this. Tired of battling it.
I would buy a '18 or newer YZ450F and really mellow out the mapping for MX tracks, or just got get a 350F.

Are you only getting tired and getting arm pump when riding MX or do you get it from single track too? My guess is, its only MX. If that's the case, I would just mellow out a bigger bore engine bike as opposed to going down to the 250F and wringing the piss out of it Bam Bam style. Just my $0.02.
1
chasetwo79
Posts
1030
Joined
12/1/2019
Location
Truckee, CA, CA US
4/15/2022 9:49pm
To be in shape enough to really ride a 450 takes weeks on weeks of consistent riding like 2-3 times a week.

Only freaks of nature can show up as a once a week rider and pound extensive laps on a 450 at pace.

The only way out is through with a 450. Either ride it as much as you can or sell it because being an in betweener is going to piss you off as it already is.
3
Richy
Posts
2901
Joined
7/18/2020
Location
UK GB
4/15/2022 11:23pm
I don't know what it's like in the US with bigger tracks / wide open space being wayyy more common, but in the UK it only really seems to be commited racers or people dealing with the same frustration seen above who ride 450s.

Often at practice tracks or even local am races, even the guys who are really moving are still on 250s / 350s.
dancolvin633
Posts
639
Joined
6/28/2016
Location
Plumas Lake, CA US
Fantasy
2236th
4/16/2022 12:17am
I have ridden 450s for about 10 years. Decided a year ago to try a 250 to just work on my technique and ride longer without arm pump. I am 6ft 195 and it was the best decision I have made riding. It’s more enjoyable, my technique got better since I wasn’t holding on for dear life and just a blast to ride. I would try it, I don’t think you will regret it one bit.
3
vet40
Posts
95
Joined
11/22/2021
Location
GB
4/16/2022 3:31am
chasetwo79 wrote:
To be in shape enough to really ride a 450 takes weeks on weeks of consistent riding like 2-3 times a week. Only freaks of nature...
To be in shape enough to really ride a 450 takes weeks on weeks of consistent riding like 2-3 times a week.

Only freaks of nature can show up as a once a week rider and pound extensive laps on a 450 at pace.

The only way out is through with a 450. Either ride it as much as you can or sell it because being an in betweener is going to piss you off as it already is.
That’s definitely not true.

The problem here is the OP’s technique is okay for a 250 but not good enough a 450.

For most amateur racing it’s not a fitness things, it’s just the riders haven’t developed the throttle control.

450’s need to be ridden a certain way, short shift, smoother riding in general.
3
Andy7
Posts
312
Joined
2/24/2017
Location
Venado Tuerto AR
Fantasy
1191st
4/16/2022 5:15am
I went from a 450 to a 250 2 stroke, and I can do a whole lot more laps on my YZ than I could on my old 2012 KX450F. Only when I got to ride every weekend I was close to enjoying the 450. No matter how much you train off the bike, the only way to truly enjoy a 450 is to ride often, otherwise it is pretty much a handfull.
1
JJO741
Posts
2917
Joined
10/7/2010
Location
Orange, CA US
Fantasy
3035th
4/16/2022 9:04am
I’m happy to see some guys around my height and weight (6’ 200lbs.) are stating the 250 seems to have enough power to get around a track just fine. Within next year I am going to get back into riding and this will be the first time I’ll ever be buying a new bike and I’ve been torn between 450 and 250. Good info in here.
Leeham
Posts
1087
Joined
10/29/2018
Location
Rochester, WA US
Fantasy
3084th
4/16/2022 9:21am
JJO741 wrote:
I’m happy to see some guys around my height and weight (6’ 200lbs.) are stating the 250 seems to have enough power to get around a...
I’m happy to see some guys around my height and weight (6’ 200lbs.) are stating the 250 seems to have enough power to get around a track just fine. Within next year I am going to get back into riding and this will be the first time I’ll ever be buying a new bike and I’ve been torn between 450 and 250. Good info in here.
My brother is 6'1 260lbs. His 19 YZ250F gets him around no problem. That bike is excellent for a 250. His 19 is the whole reason I have my 21. Made my 19 Honda 250 feel like a dog.

Unless you are racing against 450s in an open class or vet class. A 250 is plenty. If you want more, get the 350.
2
1
kb228
Posts
6161
Joined
1/31/2018
Location
Mansfield, OH US
4/16/2022 9:57am
450s are all about smooth riding. Its its own animal and romping it like a 250f or a 2 stroke is the wrong thing to do. Slow is smooth and smooth is fast. I bet if you compare lap times while riding at 70% theyd be pretty close.
3
Rider 5280
Posts
2010
Joined
11/9/2011
Location
Denver Metro, CO US
4/16/2022 10:23am Edited Date/Time 4/16/2022 11:34am
I've had great luck taming 450Fs with a Rekluse autoclutch and 1 tooth larger counter sprocket. Both take the edge off of the initial hit "just enough" that the 450 becomes quite manageable and fun IMO.

But, as @dancolvin633 said, a 250F is one of the best decisions I ever made in terms of riding, too. In tight stuff, nothing beats it. The flickability is awesome and the power is quite good. I am looking for a bit more grunt currently, so I am converting my 2016 YZ250F to a big bore (270cc Cylinder Works paired with GYTR head, Hot Cams cams, Vortex ignition, large volume GYTR airbox, Twin Air Powerflow intake, Lightspeed carbon fiber velocity stack). If you are curious about this big-bore setup, look me up later this summer.

Summary:
Modern 250Fs are impressive. You won't be disappointed ... but the 350 really seems to be the ideal solution, IMO.


Sandusky26
Posts
2672
Joined
7/28/2021
Location
Eastern, NC US
4/16/2022 10:40am
Rider 5280 wrote:
I've had great luck taming 450Fs with a Rekluse autoclutch and 1 tooth larger counter sprocket. Both take the edge off of the initial hit "just...
I've had great luck taming 450Fs with a Rekluse autoclutch and 1 tooth larger counter sprocket. Both take the edge off of the initial hit "just enough" that the 450 becomes quite manageable and fun IMO.

But, as @dancolvin633 said, a 250F is one of the best decisions I ever made in terms of riding, too. In tight stuff, nothing beats it. The flickability is awesome and the power is quite good. I am looking for a bit more grunt currently, so I am converting my 2016 YZ250F to a big bore (270cc Cylinder Works paired with GYTR head, Hot Cams cams, Vortex ignition, large volume GYTR airbox, Twin Air Powerflow intake, Lightspeed carbon fiber velocity stack). If you are curious about this big-bore setup, look me up later this summer.

Summary:
Modern 250Fs are impressive. You won't be disappointed ... but the 350 really seems to be the ideal solution, IMO.


Switching to 14/52 on my Suzuki really helped calm it down when the revs are up.
1
JBecker 72
Posts
1738
Joined
3/25/2014
Location
VA US
4/16/2022 1:19pm
I sold my 450 last year and went back to a 250F because of how tired it was making me. No regrets whatsoever about that decision. I’m just a casual rider who only gets out a few times a month if I’m lucky.
1
Titan1
Posts
8619
Joined
2/3/2010
Location
Lehi, UT US
4/16/2022 9:20pm
To the guys who have gone from 450 to 250f with no regrets…are you faster on the 250?

I’ve been a 450 guy for a decade and a half…and I’ve pretty talked myself into getting a 250f for my next bike…but I worry I’ll miss the power.

I’m 6’, 185 lbs…vet A rider (mid pack locally). Actually, I’m technically a “Senior A” rider now…since I’m over 40…but I’ll usually be 1st or 2nd in that class…mid pack with the over 30 guys…but saying “senior” while talking about myself doesn’t sit right with me. Lol
3
JBecker 72
Posts
1738
Joined
3/25/2014
Location
VA US
4/17/2022 6:11am
Titan1 wrote:
To the guys who have gone from 450 to 250f with no regrets…are you faster on the 250? I’ve been a 450 guy for a decade...
To the guys who have gone from 450 to 250f with no regrets…are you faster on the 250?

I’ve been a 450 guy for a decade and a half…and I’ve pretty talked myself into getting a 250f for my next bike…but I worry I’ll miss the power.

I’m 6’, 185 lbs…vet A rider (mid pack locally). Actually, I’m technically a “Senior A” rider now…since I’m over 40…but I’ll usually be 1st or 2nd in that class…mid pack with the over 30 guys…but saying “senior” while talking about myself doesn’t sit right with me. Lol
I don’t know if I am actually faster. I feel faster, and I definitely think my cornering has improved because I can’t be as lazy on the 250F. Lap times really had nothing to do with why I switched. It was mostly about my endurance and comfort level on the bike.

I’m 37 years old 6’1” 180 pounds and would consider myself a Vet B rider (who doesn’t race anymore.)
RaceFace58
Posts
832
Joined
2/6/2022
Location
Meriden, CT US
4/17/2022 6:13am
When I ride a 450, I start to struggle from arm pump at around lap 5 at your typical motocross track. On a 250, It's like...
When I ride a 450, I start to struggle from arm pump at around lap 5 at your typical motocross track. On a 250, It's like arm pump doesnt even exist. I can pound laps in until I am out of breath and then pull off and maybe think, hmm I was starting to get a little arm pump.

Is there something I am doing wrong? I'm pretty strong, 200lbs 6"3, it's not like I can't handle the weight of a 450. I rode a friends YZ250F this last weekend and must've went 10+ laps and my arms didn't bother me at all, but riding my RMZ450 and friends FC450, arms start getting bad and I have to slow down around lap 5. Is it the torque, pulling me off the bike? I'm seriously going to get a 250F in a couple months and sell the 450 due to this. Tired of battling it.
Have you put a stopwatch to your laptimes on each? It would be interesting to see what the laptimes are. I get arm pump no matter what doesn’t matter motor size.
RaceFace58
Posts
832
Joined
2/6/2022
Location
Meriden, CT US
4/17/2022 6:20am
SoCalMX70 wrote:
Coming off a 250 2 stroke, a 450 is a handful. I can go more laps on my old 2 stroke when riding full out. The...
Coming off a 250 2 stroke, a 450 is a handful. I can go more laps on my old 2 stroke when riding full out. The benefit of my CRF is I'm faster just being smooth at 80-90% effort. When I push it, it gets wild and I get tired quick. Part of it is probably me not being in tip top shape, bigger part is my technique is not there yet.

6'1" 195 lbs in OKish shape right now. Aiming for 185 and focusing on better technique.

Only tip I can provide as a slow old guy is to grip with legs more and stay on your toes... I know, world shattering advice! Silly
What’s funny is I remember James Stewart riding the YZ250t and coming off the track and saying how worn out he was in just a few laps because he had to push it so hard to go fast. Arm pump etc he was saying. I think the bottom line is each their own. There is so much technique involved which is why most Pro Mx guys aren’t big guys throwing 450’s around.
MX558
Posts
1772
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
US
4/17/2022 6:38am
I did a 4 lap test at a rough sand track last fall and was 20 seconds faster on my kids 21 kx 250 than my 19 kx 450 over the 4 lap total. I probably could have closed down the time a little on my 450 but would have been spent lol I still love my 450 and now have 22 ktm 350 also.
In the sand or a rough MX track I'll take the small bore bike .
Titan1
Posts
8619
Joined
2/3/2010
Location
Lehi, UT US
4/17/2022 4:02pm
It seems half the people say 450’s are easy to ride, and can be lugged around, let the bike do all the work…then other half say they are hard to ride and tire them out because they are so much bike.

When I look at going to a 250, one of my worries is I’ll have to ride it harder to go the same speed as I go on my 450 that I’ll tire myself out quickly.
JBecker 72
Posts
1738
Joined
3/25/2014
Location
VA US
4/17/2022 4:25pm
Titan1 wrote:
It seems half the people say 450’s are easy to ride, and can be lugged around, let the bike do all the work…then other half say...
It seems half the people say 450’s are easy to ride, and can be lugged around, let the bike do all the work…then other half say they are hard to ride and tire them out because they are so much bike.

When I look at going to a 250, one of my worries is I’ll have to ride it harder to go the same speed as I go on my 450 that I’ll tire myself out quickly.
Definitely see if you can ride one before buying. But every time I traded bikes with someone who wanted to ride my KX450, I always thought the 250Fs were just overall easier to ride and weren’t holding me back from clearing whatever obstacles there were on the track. I just needed to get the corners clean in order to carry enough speed for the bigger jumps. Even riding deep tracks with hills like Budds Creek and Tomahawk, I don’t see a disadvantage on one at my skill level. But they definitely ride different.

If you’re used to lugging the bike and only riding a track in 3rd gear, you’ll have to adjust your riding style for sure. Which I don’t see as a bad thing. But others may feel differently.
MotofactioN
Posts
655
Joined
6/25/2020
Location
Gloucester, VA US
4/17/2022 7:03pm
When I ride a 450, I start to struggle from arm pump at around lap 5 at your typical motocross track. On a 250, It's like...
When I ride a 450, I start to struggle from arm pump at around lap 5 at your typical motocross track. On a 250, It's like arm pump doesnt even exist. I can pound laps in until I am out of breath and then pull off and maybe think, hmm I was starting to get a little arm pump.

Is there something I am doing wrong? I'm pretty strong, 200lbs 6"3, it's not like I can't handle the weight of a 450. I rode a friends YZ250F this last weekend and must've went 10+ laps and my arms didn't bother me at all, but riding my RMZ450 and friends FC450, arms start getting bad and I have to slow down around lap 5. Is it the torque, pulling me off the bike? I'm seriously going to get a 250F in a couple months and sell the 450 due to this. Tired of battling it.
RaceFace58 wrote:
Have you put a stopwatch to your laptimes on each? It would be interesting to see what the laptimes are. I get arm pump no matter...
Have you put a stopwatch to your laptimes on each? It would be interesting to see what the laptimes are. I get arm pump no matter what doesn’t matter motor size.
I haven't but I need to. I will say I definitely feel faster on the 250F. Could it be me just revving the bike out and feeling "lighter?" I suppose I won't know until I bring out the stop watch. Lots of good info in here. I just want a bike I can throw around and ride more laps on at 100%. I mean I like my 450 and all, but maybe I'm just not ready for it yet.
MotofactioN
Posts
655
Joined
6/25/2020
Location
Gloucester, VA US
4/17/2022 7:04pm
Have you compared lap times? Maybe you're accelerating/braking harder on your 450.
Possible. Especially the accelerating part. May not be gripping as tight with my legs coming out of corners as I should be and that could be giving me the arm pump early on that I don't get on a 250F due to less torque.
MotofactioN
Posts
655
Joined
6/25/2020
Location
Gloucester, VA US
4/17/2022 7:06pm
I have ridden 450s for about 10 years. Decided a year ago to try a 250 to just work on my technique and ride longer without...
I have ridden 450s for about 10 years. Decided a year ago to try a 250 to just work on my technique and ride longer without arm pump. I am 6ft 195 and it was the best decision I have made riding. It’s more enjoyable, my technique got better since I wasn’t holding on for dear life and just a blast to ride. I would try it, I don’t think you will regret it one bit.
That's what I am thinking man. I always kind of thought at 6' 3" 200lbs a 250F would feel lackluster. I'm 25, body feels 20, I wanna ride the shit out of a bike, not lug it around lol. I bet when I get this 250F I will get much faster.
yz133rider
Posts
4467
Joined
8/1/2013
Location
Avondale, PA US
4/17/2022 7:07pm
Have you compared lap times? Maybe you're accelerating/braking harder on your 450.
Possible. Especially the accelerating part. May not be gripping as tight with my legs coming out of corners as I should be and that could be...
Possible. Especially the accelerating part. May not be gripping as tight with my legs coming out of corners as I should be and that could be giving me the arm pump early on that I don't get on a 250F due to less torque.
The 250s are just less barky. Every tiny input on a 450 equals larger reactions.

Tiny inputs on 250s are less feedback. It adds up.

Let alone the large inputs.
1

Post a reply to: 450 fitness vs 250 fitness

The Latest