Way too reasonable. We must come to a disagreement on this.
Well, we'll work on it...
But you are assuming your religious beliefs apply to all, and that's simply not practical. If it's truly a religiously sanctified event, then laws have no place in the picture at all do they? It's between you and your maker, whomever you believe that to be.
I actually kind of like Ron Paul's stance on this and just eliminate the state sanctioning of marriage.
A common argument for homosexual marriage is that it doesn't affect anybody else which in a sense is true but it could force people who are morally opposed to have to be involved in ceremonies such as clergy, churches and businesses who rent their facilities, florists, photographers, caterers, etc.