Vital MX forum sponsored by:
Start_new_topic
Forum Main ›› Moto-Related ›› one moto format in 09?

Participating Members

Vital MX member sbarrington314
Vital MX member Cygnus
Vital MX member Crash82
Vital MX member Foster576
Vital MX member BobbyM
Vital MX member David Izer
Vital MX member APLMAN
Vital MX member indy_maico
Vital MX member Highsider
Vital MX member docweedon
Vital MX member flarider
Vital MX member txmxer
Vital MX member race
Vital MX member Trinitite
Vital MX member WORCSRacer
Vital MX member eurohero
Vital MX member zookrider62
Vital MX member G-man
Vital MX member P
Vital MX member Racer92
Vital MX member CR250Rider
Vital MX member twizzler
Vital MX member Shocker
Vital MX member Dean
Vital MX member mxmedic
Vital MX member WSR
Vital MX member mxmiken
Vital MX member WhipMeister
Vital MX member Jabjr222
Vital MX member davis224
Vital MX member Mod Killer
Vital MX member Sondy132001
Vital MX member level
Vital MX member alphado
Vital MX member FLvet
Vital MX member wardy
Vital MX member KAWboy14
Vital MX member Craze
Vital MX member NV825
Vital MX member mx918
Vital MX member Scott Kalisch
Vital MX member JPT
Vital MX member BIGWIG
Vital MX member Tiki
Vital MX member kmx384
Vital MX member harescrambled
Vital MX member WhKnuckle
Vital MX member JustMX
Vital MX member -eagle-
Vital MX member gt80rider
Vital MX member Bret28g
Vital MX member wpcjs
Vital MX member rockcrawlerdude

one moto format in 09?

sbarrington314
Vital MX member sbarrington314

Posts: 387

Joined: 5/07/2008

Location:
MASSILLON, OH

Quote

5/8/2008 8:42 AM

wtf. if they keep cutting back, attendence is gonna blow.
Cygnus
Vital MX member Cygnus

Posts: 2545

Joined: 8/15/2006

Location:
Hanover, CO

Quote

5/8/2008 8:44 AM

NIght races and one moto Hmmm. Sounds like SX.
Crash82
Vital MX member Crash82

Posts: 1411

Joined: 9/16/2006

Location:
Montgomery, AL

Quote

5/8/2008 8:45 AM

?????????????????????wtf????????????????????
Foster576
Vital MX member Foster576

Posts: 634

Joined: 4/01/2008

Location:
EL PASO, TX

Quote

5/8/2008 8:46 AM

This is BULLSHIT!!!!
BobbyM
Vital MX member BobbyM

Posts: 3657

Joined: 8/15/2006

Location:
,

Quote

5/8/2008 8:46 AM

on 350's no less, i bet PC will run 353's.
David Izer
Vital MX member David Izer

Posts: 127

Joined: 8/15/2006

Location:
Atlanta, GA

Quote

5/8/2008 8:46 AM

Bailey mentioned on DMXS last night that the outdoors would be going to a one-moto format in 2009.

Lots of pros and cons.
APLMAN
Vital MX member APLMAN

Posts: 747

Joined: 8/15/2006

Location:
East Wenatchee, WA

Quote

5/8/2008 8:47 AM

Damn, I remember Dave telling me I was reaching too far when I said that the Colorado night dealio was just another step towards making motocross into stuporcross.......

Is this really being proposed?
indy_maico
Vital MX member indy_maico

Posts: 400

Joined: 4/01/2008

Location:
Indianapolis, IN

Quote

5/8/2008 8:50 AM

Didn't they try this with the GP's awhile back and found out it sucked enough to go back to the 2 moto format?

GNCC looks better and better...........!
Highsider
Vital MX member Highsider

Posts: 687

Joined: 8/15/2006

Location:
Lamoni, IA

Quote

5/8/2008 9:02 AM

Who remembers when DeCoster tried it at Glen Helen?

Jimi J
docweedon
Vital MX member docweedon

Posts: 274

Joined: 8/17/2006

Location:
Escondido, CA

Quote

5/8/2008 9:03 AM

Back in 93, they tried this one moto format at Glen Helen for the last race of the season. It was called "Motofest". They basically had heats, semis, LCQ and a main. While it was interesting, it wasn't a National.

The Nationals don't need this one moto format, it needs more promotion and better factory involvement.

flarider
Vital MX member flarider

Posts: 12048

Joined: 4/01/2008

Location:
MERRITT ISLAND, FL

Quote

5/8/2008 9:07 AM

When DORNA was running the GP's (NOT Youthsteam or Luongo), they tried the one moto format and it was a miserable failure.
Their reasoning was for TV.
They could run, in a three hour span, a 125GP, a 250GP and an Open GP, 40 min motos each.

Stefan Everts hated it so much, to prove a point, he ran all three the same day and won all three GP's.
He is, and will always be, the only rider to win three GP's in a day
BobbyM
Vital MX member BobbyM

Posts: 3657

Joined: 8/15/2006

Location:
,

Quote

5/8/2008 9:08 AM

for live tv they need 3 20 min motos which could be covered in 2 hours easy.

speedway is HUGE in europe on tv and they have literally dozens of races a night. somebody sold somebody a bag of horseshit it seems.

and unless you promote the commodity/riders in this sport and make people identify with them and where' they are from and what they look like and what they ride tv will never go anywhere.

this is a nascar idea obviously so maybe they know what they are doing. let's hope so.
txmxer
Vital MX member txmxer

Posts: 2374

Joined: 8/21/2006

Location:
Weatherford, TX

Quote

5/8/2008 9:08 AM

Sad
BobbyM
Vital MX member BobbyM

Posts: 3657

Joined: 8/15/2006

Location:
,

Quote

5/8/2008 9:09 AM

Stefan Everts hated it so much, to prove a point, he ran all three the same day and won all three GP's.
He is, and will always be, the only rider to win three GP's in a day


now THAT is cool!
race
Vital MX member race

Posts: 1025

Joined: 8/26/2006

Location:
, CA

Quote

5/8/2008 9:15 AM

Highsider wrote: Who remembers when DeCoster tried it at Glen Helen?

Jimi J

Kiedrowski remembers it.

Trinitite
Vital MX member Trinitite

Posts: 1280

Joined: 12/31/2007

Location:
Pittsburgh, PA

Quote

5/8/2008 9:16 AM

I think having a one moto format will drive down attendance.
WORCSRacer
Vital MX member WORCSRacer

Posts: 1085

Joined: 4/01/2008

Location:
CLOVIS, CA

Quote

5/8/2008 9:19 AM

Edited Date/Time:

5/8/2008 9:20 AM

Maybe they'll have pitstops and tire changes during the race though. How about adding full course yellows?
race
Vital MX member race

Posts: 1025

Joined: 8/26/2006

Location:
, CA

Quote

5/8/2008 9:26 AM

BobbyM wrote: for live tv they need 3 20 min motos which could be covered in 2 hours easy.

speedway is HUGE in europe on tv and they have literally dozens of races a night. somebody sold somebody a bag of horseshit it seems.

and unless you promote the commodity/riders in this sport and make people identify with them and where' they are from and what they look like and what they ride tv will never go anywhere.

this is a nascar idea obviously so maybe they know what they are doing. let's hope so.

They tried that ( three 20 min motos ) in the Euro GPs as well. And dumped it.

The riders all complained that it turned a tough moto into just a short sprint and put too much emphasis on the start, as you didn't have time to make up for a bad start.

I am so freaking sick of hearing about NASCAR. Apples and oranges. Two completely different and totally unrelated sports. Fock NASCAR.

The SX format used in 1993 at GH was interesting but they found that the riders were able to manipulate it. No great incentive to push in the Heats as gate pick was far less important outdoors.


eurohero
Vital MX member eurohero

Posts: 434

Joined: 5/07/2007

Location:
Berlin, DEU

Quote

5/8/2008 9:28 AM

Running them on Saturdays would be a better change than one moto format. This has been a complaint for some time.
zookrider62
Vital MX member zookrider62

Posts: 556

Joined: 4/01/2008

Location:
,

Quote

5/8/2008 9:31 AM

BobbyM wrote: for live tv they need 3 20 min motos which could be covered in 2 hours easy.

speedway is HUGE in europe on tv and they have literally dozens of races a night. somebody sold somebody a bag of horseshit it seems.

and unless you promote the commodity/riders in this sport and make people identify with them and where' they are from and what they look like and what they ride tv will never go anywhere.

this is a nascar idea obviously so maybe they know what they are doing. let's hope so.

If they had 2 hours to show it, they wouldnt need to change it to 1 moto.
flarider
Vital MX member flarider

Posts: 12048

Joined: 4/01/2008

Location:
MERRITT ISLAND, FL

Quote

5/8/2008 9:31 AM

WORCSRacer wrote: Maybe they'll have pitstops and tire changes during the race though. How about adding full course yellows?

I actually think a better idea than going to one moto is go to two longer motos that would require a pit stop and bring endurance back into the game.

Stock tank won't make an hour, so make the race an hour which would necessitate a fuel stop.
As crazy as this sounds, it does a few things, it adds a new element requiring a rider to shut off the engine, dismount, refuel and re-start. It adds some strategy (when to stop) some concern (will it re-start?) and it allows TV an opportunity to get not only some team element into the race but also team sponsor logo/publicity on camera while the bike is being refueled.

I'd rather two one hour motos requiring endurance and a fuel stop than one moto
G-man
Vital MX member G-man

Posts: 888

Joined: 4/01/2008

Location:
,

Quote

5/8/2008 9:34 AM

Sheesh I thought the new guys in charge were suppose to make things better, not worse! And yea I remember when the FIM tried it and Everts kicked everyone's ass! W00t

But the thing about the FIM is when they know they screwed up they are not afraid to change it right away. Unlike the AMA who continues to make one bad decision after another & stick with it. The "LITES" name and hackjob of the SX format are prime examples, and now this BS!

I know one thing it will just save me time & money from SPECTATING if they continue down this spiral path of stupidity. I'll just go riding--what a concept!
APLMAN
Vital MX member APLMAN

Posts: 747

Joined: 8/15/2006

Location:
East Wenatchee, WA

Quote

5/8/2008 9:38 AM

WORCSRacer wrote: Maybe they'll have pitstops and tire changes during the race though. How about adding full course yellows?

flarider wrote: I actually think a better idea than going to one moto is go to two longer motos that would require a pit stop and bring endurance back into the game.

Stock tank won't make an hour, so make the race an hour which would necessitate a fuel stop.
As crazy as this sounds, it does a few things, it adds a new element requiring a rider to shut off the engine, dismount, refuel and re-start. It adds some strategy (when to stop) some concern (will it re-start?) and it allows TV an opportunity to get not only some team element into the race but also team sponsor logo/publicity on camera while the bike is being refueled.

I'd rather two one hour motos requiring endurance and a fuel stop than one moto

I'd agree with the two longer motos, but I'd rather see them be able to use larger tanks.

Hate to see how the injury toll would climb with all those 4 strokes running out of fuel on the face of some of the bigger jumps........
flarider
Vital MX member flarider

Posts: 12048

Joined: 4/01/2008

Location:
MERRITT ISLAND, FL

Quote

5/8/2008 9:42 AM

That's where strategy comes in

You're supposed to stop BEFORE you run out of gas
P
Vital MX member P

Posts: 1175

Joined: 11/21/2006

Location:
Greensboro, NC

Quote

5/8/2008 9:42 AM

100 laps with pit stops???


P
Racer92
Vital MX member Racer92

Posts: 3708

Joined: 8/15/2006

Location:
Houston, TX

Quote

5/8/2008 9:43 AM

Edited Date/Time:

5/8/2008 9:43 AM

Stop & dismount for gas? Not for offroad folks.


Dry break.
CR250Rider
Vital MX member CR250Rider

Posts: 2011

Joined: 4/01/2008

Location:
Bellevue, WA.

Quote

5/8/2008 9:44 AM

how about TWO 45 minute motos? just an idea.
twizzler
Vital MX member twizzler

Posts: 376

Joined: 4/01/2008

Location:
DANA POINT, CA

Quote

5/8/2008 9:46 AM

Was this an NPG/Coombs family idea or DMG forced?? My thoughts are that this sport both SX and MX is becoming more and more non-interesting to me.
Shocker
Vital MX member Shocker

Posts: 145

Joined: 4/01/2008

Location:
LAKE ARIEL, PA

Quote

5/8/2008 9:49 AM

G-man wrote: Sheesh I thought the new guys in charge were suppose to make things better, not worse! And yea I remember when the FIM tried it and Everts kicked everyone's ass! W00t

But the thing about the FIM is when they know they screwed up they are not afraid to change it right away. Unlike the AMA who continues to make one bad decision after another & stick with it. The "LITES" name and hackjob of the SX format are prime examples, and now this BS!

I know one thing it will just save me time & money from SPECTATING if they continue down this spiral path of stupidity. I'll just go riding--what a concept!