Never try to argue with idiots; they will only bring you down to their level.....and being more experienced, they will beat you at their own game!
Never try to argue with idiots; they will only bring you down to their level.....and being more experienced, they will beat you at their own game!
There was no "Close call" what so ever.....the dude was completely ff the track.jtomasik wrote: I don't think that's where some of us are going with saying he shouldn't have crossed. Something much worse could've happened. Crossing a track when guys are riding isn't smart.
jeffro503 wrote: Earlier today you had multiple guys putting 100% or MOST of the blame on a guy who crossed the track about 150' of James. Yet he went full throttle into that mess of ruts........yeah it was the other dudes fault. I feel bad if James is hurt or out.....but Christ....people throw the blame at the nearest thing they can think of around here.
I got a good idea......ask the other 39 guys on the gate if that spectator would of distracted them "so much " that it would cause them to wreck. I bet every single one of them would roll their eyes and say " whatever ".jtomasik wrote: Uh, you ever get momentarily distracted and have a get-off because of it? No matter what the cause, did you? I have. I can understand something momentarily pulling my focus slightly, and that MIGHT cause me to make bad decisions. It was a sequence of events. Maybe Stew would've wrecked without that happening, maybe not.
But, whatever you say, crossing the track when the riders are out there is just plain fucking stupid. And, crossing at the base of that jump is even more idiotic. No matter whether or not it was a contributor to Stew going down is irrelevant.
Chuck Norris Rules!
Chuck Norris once kicked a Horse in the chin. It's decedents are known today as Giraffes.
R.I.P. Jim Leroy....Best Aerobatic pilot ever!
Remember the field of view on a GoPro is a lot wider/further back than actual eyesight. So, it would seem farther away with what the GoPro picks up.jtomasik wrote: Not full speed, but you can see the rut split on James right where he goes down.

Quality local to national motocross race coverage...and more!
http://www.mxptv.com/
I agree with what you said man......I really do. I just find it funny that the hard core Stewart fans are so quick to throw the blame at anyone else but James. I myself have been cheering for the dude this year to.....I think he's been doing great! But I'm not blindly in love with the guy and worship the ground he walks on.....like some others in here. In their eyes.....you would swear James was the second coming of Christ......fer Christs sake!Outsider wrote: Anyone saying that it wouldn't mess with your head to come over a huge, blind, downhill jump and have some clown standing in your line, is high, at best. JMO
Oh, and since when is it a good idea to hit the brakes when leaning into a rut?jeffro503 wrote: 1.) the guy wasn't standing in Stewart's line......in fact he was in the middle of the track when James was about 150' away.....completely "off" the track before he passed him.
2.) He was on the gas hard on the landing....for the next....what 100' before he even got to the ruts.......then passed the guy , and wrecked about 100' past him.
That whole section looked like about an 1/8th of a mile long from the jump all the way to the corner. Are you saying he had no chance what so ever so slow down a bit and choose a line he was comfortable with? He "DID" choose a line he was comfortable with......the same line he used the previous 2 laps.....and the same one on the 4th lap when he wrecked.Outsider wrote: I'm saying he was most likely distracted, as in WTF was that guy doing? Like, say, trying to move something off the track? I know I would be wondering what the hell was going on. And you should know with ruts like that, you need to be focused or you'll lose your balance and bad things happen. I'm liking the new James and think we should just take his word for it and move on. Really, who cares, it's fucked we may have lost out on a close series.
Chuck Norris Rules!
Chuck Norris once kicked a Horse in the chin. It's decedents are known today as Giraffes.
R.I.P. Jim Leroy....Best Aerobatic pilot ever!
You just nailed it.jtomasik wrote: Not full speed, but you can see the rut split on James right where he goes down.
Yeah, that would be Kongols. He's a bit of a special case...jeffro503 wrote: I agree with what you said man......I really do. I just find it funny that the hard core Stewart fans are so quick to throw the blame at anyone else but James. I myself have been cheering for the dude this year to.....I think he's been doing great! But I'm not blindly in love with the guy and worship the ground he walks on.....like some others in here. In their eyes.....you would swear James was the second coming of Christ......fer Christs sake!
T Valley has hard soil add a bunch of new top soil and or sand on it and the water will go through the new "soil" and run down the hill and settle at the first low spot...damn that is where the ruts are! Man made ruts.......I long for natural terrain motocross!jtomasik wrote: That's what I love about Thunder Valley. That corner is always a shitter. It's at the base of a relatively long downhill (with that jump prior to it), and it always ruts up big time. It's kinda weird, 'cause you come off that jump and it seems every lap it's like, "oh shit, I'm at this part of the track again".
No baggin' on Stewy for going down there from this guy. That momentary distraction from the guy crossing the track could make anyone fall prey to those ruts. That's one wicked section, and he was hitting it faster than anyone.
Photo was taken at Woodland WA 2008. Bike came from Rik Ballet in Belgium. Rik built it and we did some trading and I ended up with the bike
Gnarly dude.Matt Wozney wrote: Try going through these at a high rate of speed...
Jim Martin
"blame at anyone else but James"jeffro503 wrote: I agree with what you said man......I really do. I just find it funny that the hard core Stewart fans are so quick to throw the blame at anyone else but James. I myself have been cheering for the dude this year to.....I think he's been doing great! But I'm not blindly in love with the guy and worship the ground he walks on.....like some others in here. In their eyes.....you would swear James was the second coming of Christ......fer Christs sake!
Motocross is a contact sport

24 and 0 was some time ago.Outsider wrote: I'm saying he was most likely distracted, as in WTF was that guy doing? Like, say, trying to move something off the track? I know I would be wondering what the hell was going on. And you should know with ruts like that, you need to be focused or you'll lose your balance and bad things happen. I'm liking the new James and think we should just take his word for it and move on. Really, who cares, it's fucked we may have lost out on a close series.
jeffro503 wrote: I agree with what you said man......I really do. I just find it funny that the hard core Stewart fans are so quick to throw the blame at anyone else but James. I myself have been cheering for the dude this year to.....I think he's been doing great! But I'm not blindly in love with the guy and worship the ground he walks on.....like some others in here. In their eyes.....you would swear James was the second coming of Christ......fer Christs sake!
carlosmacho wrote: "blame at anyone else but James"
Do you think anyone on this board would blame a photographer for distracting James if no photographer ran in front of him? No.
It is a legitimate reason, Did he crash there the previous laps? No. No one is in love with him, take all the emotion and fanboism away and what do you have left, someone crossed in front of a rider on an mx track right after a jump and before a highly technical area of the track which requires a lot of concentration, then the rider was distracted and crashed.
Knowing James can do 24-0 season, knowing he had been 4-0 so far, knowing he was in the lead with no pressure, and James said what happened and it did happen that someone crossed the track. I am going to give the benefit of the doubt to James. Any reasonable unemotionally attached person would. Which suggest you are emotional persuaded by your dislike for James.
Jim Martin
Dear Nacho........Outsider wrote: I'm saying he was most likely distracted, as in WTF was that guy doing? Like, say, trying to move something off the track? I know I would be wondering what the hell was going on. And you should know with ruts like that, you need to be focused or you'll lose your balance and bad things happen. I'm liking the new James and think we should just take his word for it and move on. Really, who cares, it's fucked we may have lost out on a close series.
jeffro503 wrote: I agree with what you said man......I really do. I just find it funny that the hard core Stewart fans are so quick to throw the blame at anyone else but James. I myself have been cheering for the dude this year to.....I think he's been doing great! But I'm not blindly in love with the guy and worship the ground he walks on.....like some others in here. In their eyes.....you would swear James was the second coming of Christ......fer Christs sake!
carlosmacho wrote: "blame at anyone else but James"
Do you think anyone on this board would blame a photographer for distracting James if no photographer ran in front of him? No.
It is a legitimate reason, Did he crash there the previous laps? No. No one is in love with him, take all the emotion and fanboism away and what do you have left, someone crossed in front of a rider on an mx track right after a jump and before a highly technical area of the track which requires a lot of concentration, then the rider was distracted and crashed.
Knowing James can do 24-0 season, knowing he had been 4-0 so far, knowing he was in the lead with no pressure, and James said what happened and it did happen that someone crossed the track. I am going to give the benefit of the doubt to James. Any reasonable unemotionally attached person would. Which suggest you are emotional persuaded by your dislike for James.
Chuck Norris Rules!
Chuck Norris once kicked a Horse in the chin. It's decedents are known today as Giraffes.
R.I.P. Jim Leroy....Best Aerobatic pilot ever!
"The time to buy is when there's blood in the streets." Baron Rothschild
Are u smoking crack "knowing he was in the lead with no pressure" did u not watch Freestone last weekend Dungey pressured Stewart for and hour +4 laps, if you paid attention James was Timid/Pressured from the moment the gate dropped at Thunder Valley why do u think he made 10 passes in 2 laps.Outsider wrote: I'm saying he was most likely distracted, as in WTF was that guy doing? Like, say, trying to move something off the track? I know I would be wondering what the hell was going on. And you should know with ruts like that, you need to be focused or you'll lose your balance and bad things happen. I'm liking the new James and think we should just take his word for it and move on. Really, who cares, it's fucked we may have lost out on a close series.
jeffro503 wrote: I agree with what you said man......I really do. I just find it funny that the hard core Stewart fans are so quick to throw the blame at anyone else but James. I myself have been cheering for the dude this year to.....I think he's been doing great! But I'm not blindly in love with the guy and worship the ground he walks on.....like some others in here. In their eyes.....you would swear James was the second coming of Christ......fer Christs sake!
carlosmacho wrote: "blame at anyone else but James"
Do you think anyone on this board would blame a photographer for distracting James if no photographer ran in front of him? No.
It is a legitimate reason, Did he crash there the previous laps? No. No one is in love with him, take all the emotion and fanboism away and what do you have left, someone crossed in front of a rider on an mx track right after a jump and before a highly technical area of the track which requires a lot of concentration, then the rider was distracted and crashed.
Knowing James can do 24-0 season, knowing he had been 4-0 so far, knowing he was in the lead with no pressure, and James said what happened and it did happen that someone crossed the track. I am going to give the benefit of the doubt to James. Any reasonable unemotionally attached person would. Which suggest you are emotional persuaded by your dislike for James.
THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS.TY6 wrote: To the vitards thinking that the camera man/mechanic caused the crash, you have to be taking the piss? To say that the anonymous person distracted James is bullshit. If James can go through a 30+2 with Dungey revving right behind him on his tail as opposed to someone on the side of the track nowhere near his line could not possibly distract him and make him crash. He simply cross-rutted and went down, the evidence is overwhelming.
Jeff Emigs Keys to the Race:
1. Get a good start
2. Don't crash
Edited Date/Time:
I think why so many people are unwilling to "give the benefit of doubt" to James is that it seems every other time he blames it on someone else. What makes this time different? IE: when he ran into Milsaps, "I stalled it when davi hit me". but if you watch the gopro and put an alignment line parallel with the centerline stripe on his helmet you see he is not even distracted enough to turn his head even a minutia in the direction of the "distraction". His helmet stays locked onto his line. I also don't see any change in the bikes attitude or body from the camera view from the front where you would expect him to first notice the "distraction". I agree some parts of the track need more attention than others but there are so many distractions all the time. Now Kevin trying to ride over a Yamaha, that's a distraction. I think JS would have gained many fans had he just said, "I always race to win and sometimes you make a mistake".Outsider wrote: I'm saying he was most likely distracted, as in WTF was that guy doing? Like, say, trying to move something off the track? I know I would be wondering what the hell was going on. And you should know with ruts like that, you need to be focused or you'll lose your balance and bad things happen. I'm liking the new James and think we should just take his word for it and move on. Really, who cares, it's fucked we may have lost out on a close series.
jeffro503 wrote: I agree with what you said man......I really do. I just find it funny that the hard core Stewart fans are so quick to throw the blame at anyone else but James. I myself have been cheering for the dude this year to.....I think he's been doing great! But I'm not blindly in love with the guy and worship the ground he walks on.....like some others in here. In their eyes.....you would swear James was the second coming of Christ......fer Christs sake!
carlosmacho wrote: "blame at anyone else but James"
Do you think anyone on this board would blame a photographer for distracting James if no photographer ran in front of him? No.
It is a legitimate reason, Did he crash there the previous laps? No. No one is in love with him, take all the emotion and fanboism away and what do you have left, someone crossed in front of a rider on an mx track right after a jump and before a highly technical area of the track which requires a lot of concentration, then the rider was distracted and crashed.
Knowing James can do 24-0 season, knowing he had been 4-0 so far, knowing he was in the lead with no pressure, and James said what happened and it did happen that someone crossed the track. I am going to give the benefit of the doubt to James. Any reasonable unemotionally attached person would. Which suggest you are emotional persuaded by your dislike for James.
The Counter Sprocket Tool from http://www.sprocketstuff.com
Edited Date/Time:
Fairly said. It seems to me that Stewart said (X) seeing the guy there distracted him, but (Y)the crash is on him.SShaw490 wrote: It's a silly argument. No question the photog was an idiot for crossing right there, right then. No question that it was the match that lit the fuse. No question that Stewart could have avoided the crash in hindsight, but I've never crashed in my life and not known how I could have avoided it in hindsight. And you throw in the type of section he was riding into, and it's highly likely that a momentary distraction or even slight lack of commitment to a certain rut and perfect body positioning would have resulted in at least a big swap and probably a crash for any really fast guy.
At the end of it all, it was a very unfortunate coincidence of bad decision making on the photog's part, maybe not the best reaction to it on James' part, and you have a season of watching Ryan Dungey put 30 seconds on the field every moto. It's a pity for everyone, but that's the way it goes. Stewart said, "That's racing", but it's not racing to have to deal with photographers crossing the race track right in front of the race leader on the blind side of a 4th gear jump leading into a deep, soft rut section.
Very well said FTE and by the couple guys right before you to. I am not sure if the camera guy distracted him or not , and only he knows. I'm thinking it probably did there for a split second when he was in the air , you would think he would of been just fine by the time he landed. That's what I had been trying to say all along....was he landed with the gas on ( not off , or braking slightly when he landed )....but gas on and right through the exact same line he had been taking the previous laps.SShaw490 wrote: It's a silly argument. No question the photog was an idiot for crossing right there, right then. No question that it was the match that lit the fuse. No question that Stewart could have avoided the crash in hindsight, but I've never crashed in my life and not known how I could have avoided it in hindsight. And you throw in the type of section he was riding into, and it's highly likely that a momentary distraction or even slight lack of commitment to a certain rut and perfect body positioning would have resulted in at least a big swap and probably a crash for any really fast guy.
At the end of it all, it was a very unfortunate coincidence of bad decision making on the photog's part, maybe not the best reaction to it on James' part, and you have a season of watching Ryan Dungey put 30 seconds on the field every moto. It's a pity for everyone, but that's the way it goes. Stewart said, "That's racing", but it's not racing to have to deal with photographers crossing the race track right in front of the race leader on the blind side of a 4th gear jump leading into a deep, soft rut section.FreshTopEnd wrote: Fairly said. It seems to me that Stewart said (X) seeing the guy there distracted him, but (Y)the crash is on him.
If he said it distracted him, it did. I suppose you can argue it shouldn't have or call him a liar. It was an unremarkable crash in a demanding rutted up section.
You'd think the way Stewart addressed it would have put an end to it. There wouldn't be any controversy at all without the attitudes and personalities of several people on this board
Chuck Norris Rules!
Chuck Norris once kicked a Horse in the chin. It's decedents are known today as Giraffes.
R.I.P. Jim Leroy....Best Aerobatic pilot ever!
Jesus. Can't you comprehend?jeffro503 wrote: There was no "Close call" what so ever.....the dude was completely ff the track.
"No matter whether or not it was a contributor to Stew going down is irrelevant."......What?
Of course it was stupid.......it would of been even more stupid if the guy actually endangered one of the riders.....which he didn't. And I still don't see how James came into that section full throttle , in "HIS" preferred line ( the one he had been using )......wrecks 100' later......and then you guys blame the dude crossing the track.
Christ.....Even james said himself " That's racing ".......yeah he got distracted..........you dudes think that is the biggest distraction a rider can have during a moto?
What about....
Changing rutted lines every lap because that section was a mess to begin with?
yelling fans?
camera flashes going off in front of you?
different obstacles?
Riders you are battling with?
lappers?
tuff blocks?
And countless other things that could throw your concentration off? Heaven forbid if a fly flew in front of him during a race.....he may freak out and wad his brains out. Or a 4yr old kid waves at him from behind the fence.......think of the carnage!!
And again....for the 10th time!.....I'm bummed James is hurt. I wish it wasn't true....but I aint stupid enough to cast a blame on a dude crossing the track that far away. Fucking ridiculous.
I'm deathly afraid of marriage because statistics suggest 50% of American marriages last forever.
JT....I get it!! We are arguing over the exact same thing. Read my last reply right above yours sheeesh.jtomasik wrote: Uh, you ever get momentarily distracted and have a get-off because of it? No matter what the cause, did you? I have. I can understand something momentarily pulling my focus slightly, and that MIGHT cause me to make bad decisions. It was a sequence of events. Maybe Stew would've wrecked without that happening, maybe not.
But, whatever you say, crossing the track when the riders are out there is just plain fucking stupid. And, crossing at the base of that jump is even more idiotic. No matter whether or not it was a contributor to Stew going down is irrelevant.jeffro503 wrote: There was no "Close call" what so ever.....the dude was completely ff the track.
"No matter whether or not it was a contributor to Stew going down is irrelevant."......What?
Of course it was stupid.......it would of been even more stupid if the guy actually endangered one of the riders.....which he didn't. And I still don't see how James came into that section full throttle , in "HIS" preferred line ( the one he had been using )......wrecks 100' later......and then you guys blame the dude crossing the track.
Christ.....Even james said himself " That's racing ".......yeah he got distracted..........you dudes think that is the biggest distraction a rider can have during a moto?
What about....
Changing rutted lines every lap because that section was a mess to begin with?
yelling fans?
camera flashes going off in front of you?
different obstacles?
Riders you are battling with?
lappers?
tuff blocks?
And countless other things that could throw your concentration off? Heaven forbid if a fly flew in front of him during a race.....he may freak out and wad his brains out. Or a 4yr old kid waves at him from behind the fence.......think of the carnage!!
And again....for the 10th time!.....I'm bummed James is hurt. I wish it wasn't true....but I aint stupid enough to cast a blame on a dude crossing the track that far away. Fucking ridiculous.jtomasik wrote: Jesus. Can't you comprehend?
I said "Maybe Stewart might've wrecked without that happening, maybe not." ...might've....maybe...
It means I AM NOT SURE. And, neither are you. I'm saying it might've had something to do with it, it might not've, but regardless, CROSSING THE TRACK when guys are on their bikes is wrong, stupid, and should not happen.
Chuck Norris Rules!
Chuck Norris once kicked a Horse in the chin. It's decedents are known today as Giraffes.
R.I.P. Jim Leroy....Best Aerobatic pilot ever!
agreed...track was not fun to watch on tv....the first few laps made the 450 riders looked like amateurs...zero flow and those uphill switchbacks sucked....MiSledder wrote: That track looks like a shit hole
It's actually a blast to ride. Very tough track....unless you're one of those guys who won't pull his bike out of the truck until the track gets groomed.wydopen wrote: agreed...track was not fun to watch on tv....the first few laps made the 450 riders looked like amateurs...zero flow and those uphill switchbacks sucked....
i was sooo bummed to see james go down...i didnt even want to finish watching the race..
I'm deathly afraid of marriage because statistics suggest 50% of American marriages last forever.