Upgrade to enjoy this feature!
Vital MX fantasy is free to play, but paid users have great benefits. Paid member benefits:
- View and download rider stats
- Pick trends
- Create a private league
- And more!
Only $10 for all 2024 SX, MX, and SMX series (regularly $30).
Its more aggresive than the racing we have in the GPs but I cant stand the blind minds racking down on the GPs as a B-League to the US-Nationals.
It is also inconceivable that judging foreign riders in the US against the Americans in their own country may not be the most accurate way to judge who is the best...like they have done with Searle... his GP results mean nothing even though he won more GPs than Rattray in 2008.. Tommy got second in the GPs at 17 and 18.. that is better than Barcia has done at the same age.
You never hear them using the world championship to judge how everyone would do when home country advantage is not a being used constantly. Only America counts....If they all raced the World Championship the US riders would be no better or worse than the top riders from other countries just like Moto GP or whatever.
Would be unfair to compare who was better if an American raced and lived just in Germany against Roczen... or Holland against Herlings?
It is harder for them to race the GPs than their own national series so they have to much to lose.
European/GP riders are more adaptable and well rounded outdoors than US riders that is why they can compete in the America but Americans seem to struggle more in the GPs...when they have to adapt to different countries, and a wide variety of tracks.
The reason those guys where mentioned were because they have rode in the USA, and those are the only foreign riders Americans have respect for because they raced in the USA... you missed the pointn and in doing so proved Jamma's point - well done.
The fact...Two different series... similar quality. Fast is Fast, put them all in a World champions and they are all similar speed.
The Shop
Plenty of Americans "do sport" outside our country. You follow World Cup skiing at all or Tennis? You ever hear of Zach Osborne or Allen Iverson?Some of our Best soccer players are playing abroad. I understand your blind passion for all that is Euro, but MX is just one of many Sports where the premier competition is in the USA. Baseball, Basketball, Football, Hockey..etc If the premier competition is abroad, so are our best Athletes.....
Riders like JMB, Pichon and Albertyn set a precedent and this paved the way for the youngsters like DV, Tortelli & Langston who read about them, watched them on dvd and saw what can be achieved. These riders have since paved the way for the current crop of young riders looking to head stateside which has become a relatively straightforward transition now. Some European riders are more attracted by America than others. Its just a cycle.
(* maybe you do, Im just presuming you don't)
I guess you could say that 2005 is recent enough to be considered fairly current, but also long enough ago to have given the "premier GP riders" of that year time to switch to the US. You wann know how many of that year's top ten in MX1 have raced an AMA series, as opposed to an odd race as an invitational because they had nothing else on that weekend ? Two - Townley and Pichon. In MX2 three - McFarlane, Chiodi, Pourcel.
Not a single one of the 2006 MX1 top 20, let alone top 10, has ever raced a US series, in MX2 again three of the top 10 - Pourcel, Rattray, Searle.
2007 four in MX2 - the same three as the year before plus Swanepoel, and one in MX1 - and that was Mike Brown.
2008 just Rattray.
2009 Swanepoel MX1, Musquin and Roczen MX2, 2010 Musquin, Roczen, Osborne
So in six years that adds up to a dozen top 10 GP riders, two of whom are Americans, who have ridden more than the odd race in the US. Of the other ten, four are Commenwealth riders who were given the chance to race in Europe when no-one in the US would have helped them, which leaves us with three Frenchies, one each from Italy, England and Germany. Not exactly "most".
Of last year's MX1 world top ten I can count Philippaerts, Nagl, Ramon, Leok, Boog, Guarneri, perhaps also Bobryshev, who have/will never have any desire to race US regularly if at all.
But of course I forgot, they're not real top guys if they are too scared to race AMA because they will get beat.
I'll give you Athletics though.
Jamma is right it is partially the media that feeds the odd GP rider to go to the US because it looks cool and glamourous with Supercross etc - eg. in the UK our magazines we get our national championship coverage, GP coverage and US coverage we watch everything.. so have a better perspective... the American magazines that we also get just have their own national championship coverage... you are inspired by what you see... and Americans don't see anything about motocross racing outside their own country not even World Championship racing... hence when they do race the GPs they seem to struggle to adapt due to not realising the the type of track variety or the level of competition... When is a GP rider ever on the cover of a US mag?
Zach is doing well because he had the right mentality and he is very talented... the US riders that represent your country on the World stage should get a lot more respect... what Zach is doing is more impressive than Barcia imo. If the US mags had as much GP coverage as they do the US national coverage, and vice versa more Americans would maybe race GPs. Why Americans can't follow both and have equal respect for both confuses me...it is not a competition, both are fantastic series... watching the GPs with the same interest as your national championship does not disrespect your country... most countries watch their national championship and the World Championship.
Again Europe is not a country.. a guy like Roczen is as foreign to me as he is to you....so get the " Blind passion for all that is Euro" whatever that is out of your head...nationality is more important. than continent.... Cairoli had to leave his own country to race the GPs and live in Belgium and learn a new language too... Canard is probably my favourite rider right now.
Nationality doesn't bother me nor the series they race in, the riders style/talent is more important...but obviously you will support people in your own country and want them to win ( ie I want Searle to win the GPs) but not to the detriment of being blind to the qualities of other riders, or whether they race in your national championship or not.
Lets see the most well known international sports that Americans take part in successfully that requires a long time away from their own country...
Tennis...No Americans at the sharp end anymore
Golf.. Europe won the ryder cup, Westwood is World no.1 ( even that sport has a US tour though so Americans only have to briefly leave their country for the Majors)
Rugby... O wait...you don't play that
Cricket... O wait... you don't play that
Football...O wait... you play your own football
F1... er you dont do that either
MotoGP... some good Americans trying there but not winning the last few years...
Rallying.... again not really Americans best sport.
MX GP... Not Americas most successful avenue of motocross in recent times..
The point is Americans like to be in America and watching American sports.. that is fine...but that is the mentality (also in the media) that stops riders racing the GPs... not because the GPs are too easy for American riders or a step down. ( which is you arguement) And it is also why I have huge respect for any American that races the GPs.. because it is hard.
I think Hairy has factually answered your questions about your myth of all the top GP riders going to the US.,.... Your perception is not fact. And the point is, the GP riders that go there run at or near the front.. proving yet again they are as good as the US riders...which is all anyone outside American argues...
Let your national pride go... The World Championship is just as competitive as the AMA Nationals.. and "europeans" as you see them are just as good as American riders. Thats why I watch both and view them as a similar level just diffferent types of series. Which is exactly why Ken is fast over there just like he is in the World Championship...as was Pourcel, DV, Albee, Rattray, etc what is funny is the US media are giving him alot more hype now he has raced in the US compared to when he raced the GPs...as they did with all the other GP riders...which in turn means Americans only know foreign riders who race in the US.. and thus begins the false perception....
Like I said if the Americans did compete in the World Championship I think it would be fairly even.. you couldn't say who would win they are all fast, just like motogp or wherever.
McCread your diatribe against Barcia and the AMA series is old. You are like the cranky old man that keeps telling his story regardless of anyone is listening....No one forced DV, Pourcel, Reed, Townley, Rattray, Musquin, Searle, Anstie, Albee, JMB. Pichone, Tortelli, Langston(how many GP titles is that) or any of the other guys who started their careers in the GP's to come over. They decided on their own to come over and leave the GP's. You want to blame it on the media, hype, etc....go ahead and create that friendly place in your mind so that you are at peace, but the fact does not change. The AMA is the premier series because of that fact.
The AHL is just as "competitive" as the NHL. Doesnt mean the quality of play is as good though. Local C class races are "competitive......
sure those other GP guys are fast but who wins the MXDN every year...the USA! We ARE a lil better, our talent is deeper and our championships are more valuable. Do you see our top guys going over there? Nope.
Jean Bayle, Greg Albertine, David Vuillemin, Sebastien Tortelli, Grant Langston, Chad Reed, Ben Townley, Pourcel, Roczen Musquin all have come over here to try to capture the most valuable championships in the world and when they all come over here the talent over in the GP's looses its depth. No?
Nothing retarted about that. I think Roczen will have a tougher time here than over there, our 250 guys here are on a level above! Hopefull we can see him do some gp's and some Nationals...then well see!
nope.
Just a whole lot of wrong. Guys like you just don't have a grasp on the whole picture.
This thread will be saved to my favourites so you can't lick Musquin's arse when he smokes Barcia.
USA USA USA..........
Pit Row
Might aswell put on the forum banner ,"European riders are inferior" and be done with it.
I have been racer since I was 10 and still race to this day....vet Intermediate. I have also done testing for a factory and a magazine.
Also for the last 10 years my buisness has been involved with 2 factory teams and a sat team. I have been a part of both world championships as well as AMA championships. I am in the factories on a regular basis working on making the bikes better.
I actually do really know motocross very very well. All I said was I beleive Roczen will have a tougher time over here then he would in the GP's...just my opinion but judging by all the others that dominated over there to come over here and had a tought time prove my point. I also said I beleive he and Musquin do stand a chance of winning the AMA championship. Just my opinion...I never said anyone sucks...thay are all great riders but these new american lights riders are some of the most talented I have seen in a long time and I truly beleive their level is above what GP's have this year. Again just my opinion
Roczen was great at the MXDN and so was Townley at the USGP. How did Townley do at the nationals?
its a whole series not just one race. I never said he will have a tough time...just a tougher time winning the AMA championship vs the World championship. Again I also said I beleive he has a chance.
That will never ever happen w/ guys like we have had from Hannah, Bailey and Ward, Mcgrath, Carmichael, Bubba and now Villopoto and Dungey. Never happen!
Post a reply to: Ken Roczen to race on 350 @ Daytona and SLC