Angry SX fans... but why??

Since they just made the timed SX races official and posted about it on SXlive's IG account, I've seen comments of tons of fans who are sad, mad, and even pissed to the point where one guy said "I will not be watching anymore" XD Are these just misinformed/not true fans or am I missing the cons of this change? I think it makes too much sense.
|
GuyB
Posts
35699
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA US
Fantasy
988th
12/14/2016 8:42pm
hillbilly wrote:
Stupid is the new smart.
No, stupid is constant.
Chains
Posts
254
Joined
4/10/2012
Location
Fort Dodge, IA US
12/14/2016 8:46pm
Maybe if we start telling people the brain is an app they will start using it.
12/14/2016 8:46pm Edited Date/Time 12/14/2016 8:48pm
I find it strange that a lot of "FANS" just don't understand the how things are, a lot of the comments I have seen are saying that this will lead to less laps obviously they don't realise most SX races are sub 1 minute lap times.

The Shop

Travis_Hudson
Posts
5011
Joined
12/7/2010
Location
Bentonville, AR US
Fantasy
1089th
12/14/2016 8:55pm
I find it strange that a lot of "FANS" just don't understand the how things are, a lot of the comments I have seen are saying...
I find it strange that a lot of "FANS" just don't understand the how things are, a lot of the comments I have seen are saying that this will lead to less laps obviously they don't realise most SX races are sub 1 minute lap times.
The average supercross fan is not a "real" fan. They know monster truck races wwe and laser shows. Don't take them to serious.
GuyB
Posts
35699
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA US
Fantasy
988th
12/14/2016 9:12pm
In the interest of discussion, here at the times for each of the 2016 main events. In nearly every case, it's going to result in more time on the track for each of the main events.

The shortest 250? Santa Clara, at 11:18.
The shortest 450? Santa Clara, at 14:38.

The longest 250? Las Vegas, at 17:46.
The longest 450? Las Vegas, as 21:00.

250
A1 15:43.670
SD1 12:32.000
A2 14:52.292
Oakland 13:47.059
Glendale 16:06.892
SD2 15:00.575
Arlington 13:07.204
Atlanta 12:03.638
Daytona 17:25.668
Toronto 14:24.917
Detroit 12:11.210
Santa Clara 11:18.491
Indianapolis 12:32.380
St. Louis 14:16.009
Foxborough 15:11.488
East Rutherford 11:42.330
Las Vegas 17:46.707

450
A1 20:57.823
SD1 16:34.006
A2 19:25.414
Oakland 17:59.908
Glendale 21:06.141
SD2 19:37.252
Arlington 17:09.208
Atlanta 15:26.334
Daytona 22:09.070
Toronto 18:32.119
Detroit 15:53.440
Santa Clara 14:38.083
Indianapolis 15:43.653
St. Louis 18:14.137
Foxborough 19:35.153
East Rutherford 15:13.858
Las Vegas 21:00.243
KBOLTZ
Posts
381
Joined
4/24/2016
Location
Tarzana, CA US
12/14/2016 9:16pm
GuyB wrote:
In the interest of discussion, here at the times for each of the 2016 main events. In nearly every case, it's going to result in more...
In the interest of discussion, here at the times for each of the 2016 main events. In nearly every case, it's going to result in more time on the track for each of the main events.

The shortest 250? Santa Clara, at 11:18.
The shortest 450? Santa Clara, at 14:38.

The longest 250? Las Vegas, at 17:46.
The longest 450? Las Vegas, as 21:00.

250
A1 15:43.670
SD1 12:32.000
A2 14:52.292
Oakland 13:47.059
Glendale 16:06.892
SD2 15:00.575
Arlington 13:07.204
Atlanta 12:03.638
Daytona 17:25.668
Toronto 14:24.917
Detroit 12:11.210
Santa Clara 11:18.491
Indianapolis 12:32.380
St. Louis 14:16.009
Foxborough 15:11.488
East Rutherford 11:42.330
Las Vegas 17:46.707

450
A1 20:57.823
SD1 16:34.006
A2 19:25.414
Oakland 17:59.908
Glendale 21:06.141
SD2 19:37.252
Arlington 17:09.208
Atlanta 15:26.334
Daytona 22:09.070
Toronto 18:32.119
Detroit 15:53.440
Santa Clara 14:38.083
Indianapolis 15:43.653
St. Louis 18:14.137
Foxborough 19:35.153
East Rutherford 15:13.858
Las Vegas 21:00.243
Can't argue with facts.
KirkChandler
Posts
1667
Joined
7/31/2015
Location
Oceanside, CA US
Fantasy
385th
12/14/2016 9:42pm
What I don't get is that it's not a new concept. Motocross has always been a timed 30 minute (used to be 45) moto plus 2 laps.

Now it's in Supercross.

Allmost all major sports are timed, NFL, NBA, NHL. Heck people don't know it but F1 and MotoGP are timed to, they calculate the average lap time and fit it into the TV window of 45 minutes(MotoGP) or 2 hours(F1).
kiwifan
Posts
9485
Joined
10/31/2009
Location
CA US
12/14/2016 11:15pm
I dont see how a few more laps (or in Vegas's case, equal laps) mean suddenly its not viewable to some ! Pure stupidity.
Cortami79
Posts
1462
Joined
1/11/2016
Location
NL
12/14/2016 11:43pm
GuyB is right.

''The shortest 250? Santa Clara, at 11:18.
The shortest 450? Santa Clara, at 14:38.

The longest 250? Las Vegas, at 17:46.
The longest 450? Las Vegas, as 21:00.''


As KBOLTZ said, can't argue with facts. Plus it could be really cool if some of the top guys came from the back (like Tomac who has bad starts frequently) and the leader crosses the line with 19 minutes and 55 seconds. That means he has 2 more laps to do instead of 1. I always love (and sometimes hateTongue ) this aspect in outdoors racing. So how could this be a bad thing? There is a possibility to have mains of almost 25 minutes when they have bad luck.
JB 19
Posts
4205
Joined
3/8/2009
Location
Marion, OH US
12/15/2016 12:08am
And all this time I thought it would be riders complaining that their training would be all jacked up because they trained for 15 minute races, not 21 minute races. In my opinion, the additional time on the track for the main is pretty substantial, but I haven't saw any mention of it.
jeffro503
Posts
27442
Joined
7/22/2007
Location
St Helens, OR US
12/15/2016 12:08am
I find it strange that a lot of "FANS" just don't understand the how things are, a lot of the comments I have seen are saying...
I find it strange that a lot of "FANS" just don't understand the how things are, a lot of the comments I have seen are saying that this will lead to less laps obviously they don't realise most SX races are sub 1 minute lap times.
The average supercross fan is not a "real" fan. They know monster truck races wwe and laser shows. Don't take them to serious.
Travis summed that up pretty well. carry on.
GuyB
Posts
35699
Joined
7/10/2006
Location
Aliso Viejo, CA US
Fantasy
988th
12/15/2016 4:53pm
250
A1 15:43.670 Baseball
SD1 12:32.000 Baseball
A2 14:52.292 Baseball
Oakland 13:47.059 Baseball/Football
Glendale 16:06.892 Football
SD2 15:00.575 Baseball
Arlington 13:07.204 Football
Atlanta 12:03.638 Football
Daytona 17:25.668 NASCAR
Toronto 14:24.917 Baseball/Football
Detroit 12:11.210 Football
Santa Clara 11:18.491 Football
Indianapolis 12:32.380 Football
St. Louis 14:16.009 Football
Foxborough 15:11.488 Football
East Rutherford 11:42.330 Football
Las Vegas 17:46.707 Football +

450
A1 20:57.823
SD1 16:34.006
A2 19:25.414
Oakland 17:59.908
Glendale 21:06.141
SD2 19:37.252
Arlington 17:09.208
Atlanta 15:26.334
Daytona 22:09.070
Toronto 18:32.119
Detroit 15:53.440
Santa Clara 14:38.083
Indianapolis 15:43.653
St. Louis 18:14.137
Foxborough 19:35.153
East Rutherford 15:13.858
Las Vegas 21:00.243
The Rock
Posts
8763
Joined
3/21/2007
Location
HAIKU, HI US
12/15/2016 5:43pm
That took some effort GuyB. Thanks for doing that.


Zoom
Posts
1106
Joined
10/21/2012
Location
Cypress, TX US
12/15/2016 6:24pm
I know it's only 5 minutes, but a lot of old school motocrossers claim that motocross used to be 45 plus 2. It was 40 plus 2 until 1983 when it went to 30 plus 2.

BTW, I have been suggesting 20 plus 1 and 15 plus 1 in SX for a few years now. Good move for sure.
Skidaddle
Posts
1707
Joined
7/19/2016
Location
Woodland, CA US
12/15/2016 6:30pm
They went 45 minutes with 4" of shit suspension. Might as well have been coil over car shocks. No we have all this good stuff, and 10 minutes guys are pulling off with blisters and at 15 need an IV.

zehn
Posts
7258
Joined
1/15/2013
Location
Anchorage, AK US
12/15/2016 6:45pm Edited Date/Time 12/15/2016 6:45pm
GuyB wrote:
I did ask Eli Tomac about it this afternoon. You can hear some of his comments here. http://www.vitalmx.com/videos/features/Countdown-To-Supercross-Eli-Tomac,14804/GuyB,64
I did ask Eli Tomac about it this afternoon. You can hear some of his comments here.

http://www.vitalmx.com/videos/features/Countdown-To-Supercross-Eli-Toma…
Video isn't playing, just a heads up
12/15/2016 6:45pm
What I don't get is that it's not a new concept. Motocross has always been a timed 30 minute (used to be 45) moto plus 2...
What I don't get is that it's not a new concept. Motocross has always been a timed 30 minute (used to be 45) moto plus 2 laps.

Now it's in Supercross.

Allmost all major sports are timed, NFL, NBA, NHL. Heck people don't know it but F1 and MotoGP are timed to, they calculate the average lap time and fit it into the TV window of 45 minutes(MotoGP) or 2 hours(F1).
F1 races (with the exception of Monaco) are the fewest number of laps that will exceed 305km. That's why Monza is ~75 minutes, and Singapore is ~115 minutes. There is also a maximum time if 2 hours, but this rarely happens.
KirkChandler
Posts
1667
Joined
7/31/2015
Location
Oceanside, CA US
Fantasy
385th
12/15/2016 7:07pm
What I don't get is that it's not a new concept. Motocross has always been a timed 30 minute (used to be 45) moto plus 2...
What I don't get is that it's not a new concept. Motocross has always been a timed 30 minute (used to be 45) moto plus 2 laps.

Now it's in Supercross.

Allmost all major sports are timed, NFL, NBA, NHL. Heck people don't know it but F1 and MotoGP are timed to, they calculate the average lap time and fit it into the TV window of 45 minutes(MotoGP) or 2 hours(F1).
F1 races (with the exception of Monaco) are the fewest number of laps that will exceed 305km. That's why Monza is ~75 minutes, and Singapore is...
F1 races (with the exception of Monaco) are the fewest number of laps that will exceed 305km. That's why Monza is ~75 minutes, and Singapore is ~115 minutes. There is also a maximum time if 2 hours, but this rarely happens.
The 2 hour limit is what I was talking about.
Bearuno
Posts
4141
Joined
6/28/2014
Location
AU
12/15/2016 7:09pm Edited Date/Time 12/15/2016 7:28pm
There's probably a few (spectators / TV viewers) that are upset about this: that now the races will be too long for them.

I've read here, but more so on other sites, where people have regarded the SX mains as too long.................... it seems that limited attention spans are not limited to the youth of today, as most that bitched about races being too long, were not 'youths'.

If so many can sit watching FI / Nascar, any number of piss poor stick and ball games, for near hours at a time, you'd think that something with so much constant action and 'colour', such as SX, would keep their attention.

We are down to 30 +2 in MX, with the US having had that for a long time, and then, sadly the GPs going to it in 2014 (2015?). At least it made the GP Motos the same length as the MXDN Motos - they had been 30 + 2 for a long time.

With bikes being so good, with so many riders training 'scientifically', it's sad that we are ever shortening races. 'TV' is given as a reason for that, but hell, they still carve the race coverage to hell, even in short SX races. So, we will probably see a few 23 /24 / 25 minute long 450 SX Mains - well, perhaps a bit of that time..... Ads need to be scheduled, but you'd think that producers / suppliers would think a bit about the ad structure / placement.

This 20 +2, and the change to 250s, is at least a bit of a reversal of that trend. Good stuff.
Brent
Posts
5302
Joined
8/16/2006
Location
Party in Temecula, CA US
12/15/2016 7:48pm
Skidaddle wrote:
They went 45 minutes with 4" of shit suspension. Might as well have been coil over car shocks. No we have all this good stuff, and...
They went 45 minutes with 4" of shit suspension. Might as well have been coil over car shocks. No we have all this good stuff, and 10 minutes guys are pulling off with blisters and at 15 need an IV.

Yes on on a much easier track. I'm old enough to remember racing on 6 inches of travel, and racing now is much more difficult than it was back then.

Don't be such a curmudgeon.
mx617
Posts
1399
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
Trail CA
12/15/2016 9:11pm
KBOLTZ wrote:
Can't argue with facts.
You must be new here Woohoo
Johnny Depp
Posts
6438
Joined
10/16/2014
Location
Buda, TX US
12/15/2016 9:22pm Edited Date/Time 12/15/2016 9:23pm
Why Angry SX fans?

If they are on Instagram in a matter of hours it is not casual fans. It is most likely uninformed fans who don't understand what it means and think they are getting less racing for their dollar?

There is some chance that it is informed fans who were hoping for something more in the way of changes rather than a little trim around the edges in an area that will have a minimal impact on the end result and just prolong the inevitable. I doubt that is it, most of those fans have become complacent over the decades like Mitch Payton has.

I still find it curious why in the press release (which was prepared by who?) they felt a need to troll us with a bit of history about '85 with 2 mains being considered the best season ever? Where is that coming from? Do they have something else in the works?
KBOLTZ
Posts
381
Joined
4/24/2016
Location
Tarzana, CA US
12/16/2016 7:40am
KBOLTZ wrote:
Can't argue with facts.
mx617 wrote:
You must be new here Woohoo
Haha you'd think so!
Berm
Posts
647
Joined
4/23/2014
Location
MI US
Fantasy
136th
12/16/2016 8:29am
Taking a look at Heat's and Semi's just for Anaheim 1. Even though Anaheim 1 passes the 20 min and 15 min cutoff, it doesn't take laps away. AND, it actually will add laps for some of the semi/lcq's.

Anaheim 1 (how many more or fewer laps under timed format)

250 heat 1: same
250 heat 2: same
250 lcq: same
250 main: same

450 heat 1: same
450 heat 2: same
450 semi 1: One more with timed
450 semi 2: One more with timed
450 lcq: One more with timed
450 main: same

Keep in mind, the other good thing is that it no longer matters if the first lap is super short (as is often the case, the first lap is shorter than a full lap). I don't think many tracks have an extra long first lap but I could be wrong.

Lastly, I wonder how this rule works out for red-flagged races. If it is red-flagged mid race so that there is not a complete gate restart, when does the clock start and stop?
jeffmc134
Posts
121
Joined
4/1/2008
Location
AL US
12/16/2016 9:02am
GuyB wrote:
In the interest of discussion, here at the times for each of the 2016 main events. In nearly every case, it's going to result in more...
In the interest of discussion, here at the times for each of the 2016 main events. In nearly every case, it's going to result in more time on the track for each of the main events.

The shortest 250? Santa Clara, at 11:18.
The shortest 450? Santa Clara, at 14:38.

The longest 250? Las Vegas, at 17:46.
The longest 450? Las Vegas, as 21:00.

250
A1 15:43.670
SD1 12:32.000
A2 14:52.292
Oakland 13:47.059
Glendale 16:06.892
SD2 15:00.575
Arlington 13:07.204
Atlanta 12:03.638
Daytona 17:25.668
Toronto 14:24.917
Detroit 12:11.210
Santa Clara 11:18.491
Indianapolis 12:32.380
St. Louis 14:16.009
Foxborough 15:11.488
East Rutherford 11:42.330
Las Vegas 17:46.707

450
A1 20:57.823
SD1 16:34.006
A2 19:25.414
Oakland 17:59.908
Glendale 21:06.141
SD2 19:37.252
Arlington 17:09.208
Atlanta 15:26.334
Daytona 22:09.070
Toronto 18:32.119
Detroit 15:53.440
Santa Clara 14:38.083
Indianapolis 15:43.653
St. Louis 18:14.137
Foxborough 19:35.153
East Rutherford 15:13.858
Las Vegas 21:00.243
Why is Vegas listed as the longest 450? Why not Glendale or Daytona?
peelout
Posts
17870
Joined
1/6/2011
Location
Ogden, UT US
12/16/2016 9:11am
hillbilly wrote:
Stupid is the new smart.
GuyB wrote:
No, stupid is constant.
if morans could fly, the internet would be an airport

Post a reply to: Angry SX fans... but why??

The Latest